New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Net Neutrality is communist plot...

They aren't misunderstanding anything. When you see the cockeyed lefty doggy pile that you are experiencing, you've kicked their backsides. Hive-dwelling Internet lefty now seeks to pile on and dilute the content of what you've written.

It's like clockwork.

Always the thread vulture ?
 
So I'm not here to defend the oligarchs running cable and telecom companies. Don't know what exactly that $200 billion in "tax breaks" they got but it is either a legitimate business deduction that every business gets or it could be that they required a subsidy to run the lines in uneconomic places. I seriously doubt it was just a blatant give away but if it is, I would certainly oppose that. If it was a subsidy incentive, that would certainly be part of the argument against your suggestion that they are making gajillions in profits, because these networks are incredibly expensive and serving some places doesn't make market based profit sense. So more profitable locations subsidize the uneconomic markets (in, dare I say it, socialist fashion).

So I'm happy to hear you backing off the 97 cents on the dollar profit nonsense. And yes, we don't know what the number is. But the one number we know it isn't is 97%. Now go tell BP he completely misunderstood the issue when he said you "spanked me."

As for monopolies, I'm certainly not here to defend them either but the fact is that most markets have at least two and usually three options (telecom, cable and satellite). And most assuredly, the best way to ensure the net stays open and free is to increase competition, and that's not what government regulation does.

No you're the one who used net profit. I never used that term. Then you post a dailycaller article that tries to mask the point about the infrastructure as if to pretend it means something other than it does. The fact that the network transmits both voice and video in addition to data. Which means the build out cost was not solely for data. Video cost more because they have to pay for the content. One of the primary things that got moment towards codified net neutrality. They get the content for data free. In fact they already get paid to transmit data by the websites that pay for access to the internet just like their customers pay for access. Yet the cable companies wanted to be gatekeepers and get paid a second time by the content providers with fast lanes and by the customers with tiered service.

My point was and is that one of the services it provides (data) is the most profitable and running it over their existing infrastructure returns a 97% (I originally said 94% ) profit margin for providing that service. Who knows what your article includes in it's calculation. For all we know they might be including the cost of bribes, bullying and collusion with other providers to maintain their monopolies. All of that is besides the point. Since a large portion of the infrastructure was subsidized

Now as to the $200 billion (which in actuality is likely much more.) Your article points out that they have spent $200 billion since 1996. But they were that much in tax breaks and incentives to provide high speed broadband to every home and did not do it with the money. Yet your article made no mention of that when it states how much they have spent to build their networks.

http://www.bwianews.com/2006/01/new_book_lays_b.html

So when you talk about how expensive it was to create. You should also talk about how expensive they are to access. If you compare the price Americans pay for that kind of access with what countries

_70699733_cost_broadband_around_the_world_v2.gif

http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-24528383


It is ridiculous to throw around names like marxist while trying to hammer on the side of these companies vs the profits they make over the existing infrastructure that was subsidized by the public.
 
It sucks when your direct lying campaign is suspended...even briefly, eh?

Just about all of you lefties are treading bong water at this point.

It sucks to see a post just dropped into a thread to toss around insults without adding to the discussion. It's as unseemly as having a vulture fly in and the pick at the carcass without ever being part of the hunt.
 
These Internet leftists are failures. When the inevitable happens (their failure), they start with the thread-bombing, jamming, overt lying, doggypiling, whatever it takes. Most of these burned out hippies are pathetic potheads and they project their tendency of easy distraction upon others.
That's why they think they can change what you comitted to writing and assert that you wrote it. They are that stupid...and that lousy as people.

Pathetic, doped up old geezers sitting at keyboards and underachieving even at simple message board participation.
:-/
Cathartic isn't it?

I by and large give them all the benefit of the doubt because they are just being followers. It is the nature of collectivist thinking. More is the pity that they don't follow a Scott Walker or Rand Paul (nobody is perfect including these two). Instead they ingratiate themselves to the collective by accepting the loss of free speech as right and natural when proposed. When it fails they wonder why their kind bothers the American thinkers.
 
No you're the one who used net profit. I never used that term. Then you post a dailycaller article that tries to mask the point about the infrastructure as if to pretend it means something other than it does. The fact that the network transmits both voice and video in addition to data. Which means the build out cost was not solely for data. Video cost more because they have to pay for the content. One of the primary things that got moment towards codified net neutrality. They get the content for data free. In fact they already get paid to transmit data by the websites that pay for access to the internet just like their customers pay for access. Yet the cable companies wanted to be gatekeepers and get paid a second time by the content providers with fast lanes and by the customers with tiered service.

My point was and is that one of the services it provides (data) is the most profitable and running it over their existing infrastructure returns a 97% (I originally said 94% ) profit margin for providing that service. Who knows what your article includes in it's calculation. For all we know they might be including the cost of bribes, bullying and collusion with other providers to maintain their monopolies. All of that is besides the point. Since a large portion of the infrastructure was subsidized

Now as to the $200 billion (which in actuality is likely much more.) Your article points out that they have spent $200 billion since 1996. But they were that much in tax breaks and incentives to provide high speed broadband to every home and did not do it with the money. Yet your article made no mention of that when it states how much they have spent to build their networks.

http://www.bwianews.com/2006/01/new_book_lays_b.html

So when you talk about how expensive it was to create. You should also talk about how expensive they are to access. If you compare the price Americans pay for that kind of access with what countries

_70699733_cost_broadband_around_the_world_v2.gif

http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-24528383


It is ridiculous to throw around names like marxist while trying to hammer on the side of these companies vs the profits they make over the existing infrastructure that was subsidized by the public.

Well, to begin with, only a Marxist would rail about businesses being "too profitable." Secondly, regardless of the gross margins in this one aspect of their business (because there is no direct costs to moving other people bits and bytes around) their overall net profit is about 10%, which is pretty standard (and reasonable) for a business that employs tens of thousands. Why you would deem to demonize them for making money again just illustrates your Marxist underpinnings.
 
Well, to begin with, only a Marxist would rail about businesses being "too profitable." Secondly, regardless of the gross margins in this one aspect of their business (because there is no direct costs to moving other people bits and bytes around) their overall net profit is about 10%, which is pretty standard (and reasonable) for a business that employs tens of thousands. Why you would deem to demonize them for making money again just illustrates your Marxist underpinnings.

Where do you get the 10% number ? And since when is it Marxist to point out that a company has high profits. If so then your defense of makes you a Monopolist who supports these profit margins in spite of the fact that they come at the expense public investment in their infrastructure and collusion that prevents these companies from competing against each other.
 
Yeah, the really funny part is, after BP said Spamature "spanked" me, Spamature posts a post admitting that I was, in fact, correct - they do not pocket 97 cents of every dollar. All that means is that there's not a lot of direct cost in moving bits and bytes around a network. Which is a good thing because the indirect costs are enormous!

Yet the difference in the prices for their tiers of service is higher than the direct cost in moving the data itself.
 
Yet the difference in the prices for their tiers of service is higher than the direct cost in moving the data itself.

So what? There is almost no direct cost in moving data - it is all indirect costs. All your obsessing over that financial reports is wasted effort as it tells you nothing about the relative cost of providing that service. But it does make for a great anti-capitalist rant though, doesn't it?
 
Cathartic isn't it?

I by and large give them all the benefit of the doubt because they are just being followers. It is the nature of collectivist thinking. More is the pity that they don't follow a Scott Walker or Rand Paul (nobody is perfect including these two). Instead they ingratiate themselves to the collective by accepting the loss of free speech as right and natural when proposed. When it fails they wonder why their kind bothers the American thinkers.
Understand. It's not just philosophical or value disagreement. I was referencing the consistent bad faith posting that they offer by bombing threads, specifically lying about what you write in an effort to distract and waste time, etc.
This is an employed strategy.
 
Understand. It's not just philosophical or value disagreement. I was referencing the consistent bad faith posting that they offer by bombing threads, specifically lying about what you write in an effort to distract and waste time, etc.
This is an employed strategy.

The ends justifies the means...
 
The ends justifies the means...
That's part of it for them. The other part is that most of them aren't terribly bright. What else can they do...other than lie, distract, start with constant references to some radio blowhards, etc.

It's all slogans, bumper stickers, distraction, and source-dismissal. Very little substantive subject treatment. And in the very rare instance when the latter occurs it is shamelessly selective.
 
That's part of it for them. The other part is that most of them aren't terribly bright. What else can they do...other than lie, distract, start with constant references to some radio blowhards, etc.

It's all slogans, bumper stickers, distraction, and source-dismissal. Very little substantive subject treatment. And in the very rare instance when the latter occurs it is shamelessly selective.

Some of them are actually quite smart. But they can't use actual facts to support their policies because they always lead to failure, so, as with Krugman when he used "potential GDP" as the denominator (rather than, you know, the actual GDP) to suggest that the ARRA "stimulus" wasn't "big enough." Of course it is an absurd argument, but the guy is no dummy. That's why I feel they believe the ends justify the means - so they can lie, cheat, prevaricate, whatever they need to do to advance the progressive policies because they are just so darned convinced that markets and capitalism are bad.
 
To "spread the bits around" - I'm not the least bit shocked, are any of you?

But such voices have been drowned out by left-wing activists who want to manage the Internet to achieve their political objectives. The most influential of these congregate around the deceptively named Free Press, a liberal lobby co-founded in 2002 by Robert McChesney, a University of Illinois communications professor. His goals have always been clear. “At the moment, the battle over network neutrality is not to completely eliminate the telephone and cable companies,” he told the website SocialistProject in 2009. “But the ultimate goal is to get rid of the media capitalists in the phone and cable companies and to divest them from control.” Earlier in 2000, he told the Marxist magazine Monthly Review: “Our job is to make media reform part of our broader struggle for democracy, social justice, and, dare we say it, socialism.” When I interviewed him in 2010, he admitted he is a socialist and said he was “hesitant to say I’m not a Marxist.”

Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/414483/comrades-net-neutrality-john-fund

Hahaha! No, you Obama supporters aren't Marxists. Why would we think that???
Net neutrality is simply a reaction to the fact that a robust competitive market doesn't exist in the area of broadband service in most localities, such that market dynamics don't function efficiently, and quasi-monopolistic abuses can happen.

If most people had a choice of ten independent broadband providers, net neutrality wouldn't be needed. Then, if we didn't like the way a particular provider was restricting our access to make money on the side, we'd just move to a different provider, and either the more restrictive providers would need to charge a lot less than the less restrictive ones, or they'd go out of business. But that kind of market functioning doesn't tend to happen when most people have one, or at most just a few choices for broadband. Then, the risk of losing some customers in a few areas where there is real choice is less of a consideration for the providers than all the profits they can make turning the screws on customers in other areas where they are a captive audience.

You don't have to be a socialist to support net neutrality. Some big for-profit tech companies are in favor of it. But among libertarians, whose cultish economic views do not allow even the possibility of the existence of market failings, the argument for neutrality is incomprehensible -- or, at least, it became so once the Obama administration came out in favor of it.
 
YOUR people want to purge free speech. They are a danger to this country. They should be run out of town tarred and feathered.

I want to purge free speech, yet you're the one calling for people to be tarred, feathered and run out of the country.

Are you wingers conducting a hypocrisy contest?

I wouldn't be proud of your Communist logic stream. It doesn't look good on anybody.

You gave it to me, so perhaps you're the one who shouldn't be proud.
 
Net neutrality is simply a reaction to the fact that a robust competitive market doesn't exist in the area of broadband service in most localities, such that market dynamics don't function efficiently, and quasi-monopolistic abuses can happen.

If most people had a choice of ten independent broadband providers, net neutrality wouldn't be needed. Then, if we didn't like the way a particular provider was restricting our access to make money on the side, we'd just move to a different provider, and either the more restrictive providers would need to charge a lot less than the less restrictive ones, or they'd go out of business. But that kind of market functioning doesn't tend to happen when most people have one, or at most just a few choices for broadband. Then, the risk of losing some customers in a few areas where there is real choice is less of a consideration for the providers than all the profits they can make turning the screws on customers in other areas where they are a captive audience.

You don't have to be a socialist to support net neutrality. Some big for-profit tech companies are in favor of it. But among libertarians, whose cultish economic views do not allow even the possibility of the existence of market failings, the argument for neutrality is incomprehensible -- or, at least, it became so once the Obama administration came out in favor of it.

So it's just a "coincidence" that the guy behind it designed it to get the "capitalist" companies out of a position of controlling the internet? I don't think so. You've backed ever socialistic policy proposal ever put on this board so pardon me if I take your position on this with a grain of salt. If a lack of competition is the problem, regulation isn't the solution - because it just makes the barriers to entry higher.
 
I want to purge free speech, yet you're the one calling for people to be tarred, feathered and run out of the country.

Trying to pass laws and regulations stemming free speech is not free speech when coming from politicians, they are threats. It is what you do to people who propose such things: tar and feather.

To the Bitter end you don't get it. lol
 
Back
Top