New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Net Neutrality is communist plot...

The Federal Communications Commission will allow some cities and towns to set up and expand municipal Internet services, overruling state laws that had been put in place to block such efforts.
The commission granted petitions by Chattanooga, Tenn., and Wilson, N.C., to overturn laws that restricted the ability of communities in those states to offer broadband service. In all about 20 states have passed such laws. The decisions don’t affect the other states, but they do set a precedent for consideration of similar petitions in the future.

now were those states which forbade cities to set up and expand municipal internet services COMMIEs or FASCISTs?

States are sovereign and right or wrong are entitled to set jurisdictional limits. Next, the Federales will tell Chattanooga that no their police department is not limited to enforcing the law in their jurisdiction. They can in fact range from Nashville to Knoxville enforcing the laws of the State.

Progressive liberals never get the full extent of the ramifications of their feel good policies.
 
States are sovereign and right or wrong are entitled to set jurisdictional limits. Next, the Federales will tell Chattanooga that no their police department is not limited to enforcing the law in their jurisdiction. They can in fact range from Nashville to Knoxville enforcing the laws of the State.

Progressive liberals never get the full extent of the ramifications of their feel good policies.

States are sovereign and right or wrong are entitled to set jurisdictional limits.
you might think it was that black and white, but then you'd be wrong.
 
As far as internet service is concerned, we only have one provider, Windstream. It's horrible, cable companies aren't coming out here so we have Directv. We have no contract cell phones, so 3G is hard to get in some areas. With all that, I still do not want the government involved, especially this administration.
 
This bill will allow them to tax the internet and pick winners as to who gets what service, I can just get who that will be.
 
I'm for capitalism and, in case you can't read, the guy who started this ball rolling said it was designed to remove the capitalist control of the internet. It's about reducing the profitability of investing in network infrastructure so it can become a government function. It's about eliminating the market's ability to determine winners and losers, and putting those decisions in the hands of bureaucrats. And it's about increasing government control over what we can see and do on the internet. "Fairness" is a Marxist dog whistle to rally the collectivists in pursuit of statism.
It's about what I said it was about.

Babble away.
 
States are sovereign and right or wrong are entitled to set jurisdictional limits. Next, the Federales will tell Chattanooga that no their police department is not limited to enforcing the law in their jurisdiction. They can in fact range from Nashville to Knoxville enforcing the laws of the State.

Progressive liberals never get the full extent of the ramifications of their feel good policies.

But the internet is not a intrastate network. It crosses state lines so why should it not be the under the jurisdiction of the federal govt ?
 
But the internet is not a intrastate network. I assume most of us are in different states. So you can't have every state having its own rules and expect for the network to function correctly.
A business is located in a state not the internet. A municipality is a entity of the States defining and control. State's rights are being obliterated right and left.
 
Hmmm indeed. That is gross profit margin. It does not include the cost of building out their network. You want to speculate about what that stuff costs? Sheesh!

You can always count on Marxists to distort a company's financial reports in their feverish attempts to stamp out its profits.

Spamature spanked you. This is a great time to slink away. I'll cover your retreat with a funny picture of Bush:

George-Bush-Funny.gif
 
Spamature spanked you. This is a great time to slink away. I'll cover your retreat with a funny picture of Bush:

George-Bush-Funny.gif

That's funny. Leave it to a lefty to completely misunderstand the salient points in a disagreement about corporate finance.

http://dailycaller.com/2013/02/15/does-cable-really-have-a-97-profit-margin/

As I pointed out, that is gross margin and doesn't mean anything even close to what Spamature (pretty appropriate name, btw) suggested. It excludes the capital cost of building their networks, as well as their selling, general and administrative expenses.

http://www.investopedia.com/terms/g/grossmargin.asp

They do NOT make a net profit of 97 cents on each dollar of internet service revenue. He couldn't have BEEN more wrong even if he had completely made up the number. Like I said, it smelled like it came out of Alinsky's ass and I was spot on. Now maybe you should post another funny picture of Bush to distract everyone from noticing what a huge fool you just made of yourself. Have a nice day!

Edit: I wouldn't ordinarily point out how badly you misunderstood the issues here, but since you chose to make the snide comment about me "slinking away" I simply couldn't resist the urge.
 
Last edited:
They do when it comes to the cost of providing that service over their infrastructure.

Yeah, but then they have to pay for the infrastructure out of that. As well as their selling general and administrative cost overhead. They are not putting 97 cents of every dollar in their pocket. I was completely on target - that number came out of Alinsky's ass!

It was thrown out by the Marxist professional left to mislead the fellow travelers and useful idiots who won't understand that the number means absolutely nothing without understanding the cost structure of building out and maintaining a huge telecommunications network. But it sure got your anti-profit juices flowing, didn't it. So mission accomplished!
 
Yeah, but then they have to pay for the infrastructure out of that. As well as their selling general and administrative cost overhead. They are not putting 97 cents of every dollar in their pocket. I was completely on target - that number came out of Alinsky's ass!

It was thrown out by the Marxist professional left to mislead the fellow travelers and useful idiots who won't understand that the number means absolutely nothing without understanding the cost structure of building out and maintaining a huge telecommunications network. But it sure got your anti-profit juices flowing, didn't it. So mission accomplished!

Marxist this, communist that, hey sometimes companies just screw over their customers. Cable companies are notorious for doing that. Unless you live in a cave you know that. The govt gave broadband provider $200 billion in tax breaks to build those networks. Now you're calling people marxist for calling them out on their profit margins after supping at the govt teet to help cover those cost. Also you keep ignoring the fact that those build out cost are for ALL of the services they provide not just internet.

So maybe they're putting 87% or 77% or 67% or 57 % or 47% in their pockets out of the broadband portion of their profits. It still some of the most expensive broadband service in the developed world. Yet somehow commenting on the profits monopolies make because of the lack of competition they've engineered in the marketplace make someone a communist.
 
Last edited:
Marxist this, communist that, hey sometimes companies just screw over their customers. Cable companies are notorious for doing that. Unless you live in a cave you know that. The govt gave broadband provider $200 billion in tax breaks to build those networks. Now you're calling people marxist for calling them out on their profit margins after supping at the govt teet to help cover those cost. Also you keep ignoring the fact that those build out cost are for ALL of the services they provide not just internet.

So maybe they're putting 87% or 77% or 67% or 57 % or 47% in their pockets out of the broadband portion of their profits. It still some of the most expensive broadband service in the developed world. Yet somehow commenting on the profits monopolies make because of the lack of competition they've engineered in the marketplace make someone a communist.

So I'm not here to defend the oligarchs running cable and telecom companies. Don't know what exactly that $200 billion in "tax breaks" they got but it is either a legitimate business deduction that every business gets or it could be that they required a subsidy to run the lines in uneconomic places. I seriously doubt it was just a blatant give away but if it is, I would certainly oppose that. If it was a subsidy incentive, that would certainly be part of the argument against your suggestion that they are making gajillions in profits, because these networks are incredibly expensive and serving some places doesn't make market based profit sense. So more profitable locations subsidize the uneconomic markets (in, dare I say it, socialist fashion).

So I'm happy to hear you backing off the 97 cents on the dollar profit nonsense. And yes, we don't know what the number is. But the one number we know it isn't is 97%. Now go tell BP he completely misunderstood the issue when he said you "spanked me."

As for monopolies, I'm certainly not here to defend them either but the fact is that most markets have at least two and usually three options (telecom, cable and satellite). And most assuredly, the best way to ensure the net stays open and free is to increase competition, and that's not what government regulation does.
 
Last edited:
What? I see net neutrality as a roadblock against total control of online propaganda by right wing fascists.

The internet is already owned by a few right wing oligarchs. They could, and would, throttle down the speed of liberal leaning, if not disallowing any access, websites while allowing right wing sites complete speed and access.
The internet is already owned by a few right wing oligarchs. They could, and would, throttle down the speed of liberal leaning, if not disallowing any access, websites while allowing right wing sites complete speed and access.

Right, that's why there are sites such as Move On.Org, and The Daly Koz. And that's why Obama raised a record amount of campaign cash on the internet.

How the hell dumb can you get? Pretty damn dumb it looks like. Remember this, every time government grows, freedom shrinks. Before Net Neutrality you were free to pick your provider, pick your speed, pick the services you want. Now the government will do all of that. More regulations, to add to the millions already on the books, more expense to enforce those regulations and more expense to comply with those regulations.

Dumb Ass Liberals don't have a damn clue.
 
That's funny. Leave it to a lefty to completely misunderstand the salient points in a disagreement about corporate finance.

http://dailycaller.com/2013/02/15/does-cable-really-have-a-97-profit-margin/

As I pointed out, that is gross margin and doesn't mean anything even close to what Spamature (pretty appropriate name, btw) suggested. It excludes the capital cost of building their networks, as well as their selling, general and administrative expenses.

http://www.investopedia.com/terms/g/grossmargin.asp

They do NOT make a net profit of 97 cents on each dollar of internet service revenue. He couldn't have BEEN more wrong even if he had completely made up the number. Like I said, it smelled like it came out of Alinsky's ass and I was spot on. Now maybe you should post another funny picture of Bush to distract everyone from noticing what a huge fool you just made of yourself. Have a nice day!

Edit: I wouldn't ordinarily point out how badly you misunderstood the issues here, but since you chose to make the snide comment about me "slinking away" I simply couldn't resist the urge.
They aren't misunderstanding anything. When you see the cockeyed lefty doggy pile that you are experiencing, you've kicked their backsides. Hive-dwelling Internet lefty now seeks to pile on and dilute the content of what you've written.

It's like clockwork.
 
So I'm not here to defend the oligarchs running cable and telecom companies. Don't know what exactly that $200 billion in "tax breaks" they got but it is either a legitimate business deduction that every business gets or it could be that they required a subsidy to run the lines in uneconomic places. I seriously doubt it was just a blatant give away but if it is, I would certainly oppose that. If it was a subsidy incentive, that would certainly be part of the argument against your suggestion that they are making gajillions in profits, because these networks are incredibly expensive and serving some places doesn't make market based profit sense. So more profitable locations subsidize the uneconomic markets (in, dare I say it, socialist fashion).

So I'm happy to hear you backing off the 97 cents on the dollar profit nonsense. And yes, we don't know what the number is. But the one number we know it isn't is 97%. Now go tell BP he completely misunderstood the issue when he said you "spanked me."

As for monopolies, I'm certainly not here to defend them either but the fact is that most markets have at least two and usually three options (telecom, cable and satellite). And most assuredly, the best way to ensure the net stays open and free is to increase competition, and that's not what government regulation does.
First lefty ridicules the capitalist for opposing all these private industry bailouts and subsidies...then lefty invokes these bailouts and subsidies as a "claim" on private industry interventionism.

Shocking, eh?
 
Back
Top