New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Net Neutrality is communist plot...

Trying to pass laws and regulations stemming free speech is not free speech when coming from politicians, they are threats. It is what you do to people who propose such things: tar and feather.

To the Bitter end you don't get it. lol

You want to dispense with laws altogether and instead purge people who aren't wingers like yourself.

You are antithetical to our system, yet I still think you should be able to practice free speech. Your words will make a fine cautionary tale if nothing else.
 
This whole question harkens back to the Clinton day, when Bill approved legislation to deregulate our American media. Subsequently, many of us from right to left, are wishing he hadn't done that.

Pres. Obama's view on this question has shifted over time. It's said that he's been influenced by the millions of Americans - libruls AND conservatives - who reached out to him, calling upon him to preserve net-neutrality. If that ain't "democracy", what is?

Anyway...check out the attacks herein, on net neutrality. Our forum's rightsters are having one helluva time coming up with a valid reason for hating on it, but for the fact that Obama done it.
 
This whole question harkens back to the Clinton day, when Bill approved legislation to deregulate our American media. Subsequently, many of us from right to left, are wishing he hadn't done that.

Pres. Obama's view on this question has shifted over time. It's said that he's been influenced by the millions of Americans - libruls AND conservatives - who reached out to him, calling upon him to preserve net-neutrality. If that ain't "democracy", what is?

Anyway...check out the attacks herein, on net neutrality. Our forum's rightsters are having one helluva time coming up with a valid reason for hating on it, but for the fact that Obama done it.

I don't believe a f*cking word that comes outta that commie's mouth...
 
You want to dispense with laws altogether and instead purge people who aren't wingers like yourself.

You are antithetical to our system, yet I still think you should be able to practice free speech. Your words will make a fine cautionary tale if nothing else.

Literalism is your autistic demise.
 
This whole question harkens back to the Clinton day, when Bill approved legislation to deregulate our American media. Subsequently, many of us from right to left, are wishing he hadn't done that.

Pres. Obama's view on this question has shifted over time. It's said that he's been influenced by the millions of Americans - libruls AND conservatives - who reached out to him, calling upon him to preserve net-neutrality. If that ain't "democracy", what is?

Anyway...check out the attacks herein, on net neutrality. Our forum's rightsters are having one helluva time coming up with a valid reason for hating on it, but for the fact that Obama done it.
Really? "no valid reason"? Did you actually read the concerns posted? Those which note that there does necessarily involve state scrutiny of content posted online in assessment of "neutrality"?

Are concerns about our federal government assessing and scrutinizing free speech online with the intent of governing access rates/bandwidth "invalid"? Is that what has become of our dialog?
 
Really? "no valid reason"? Did you actually read the concerns posted? Those which note that there does necessarily involve state scrutiny of content posted online in assessment of "neutrality"?

Are concerns about our federal government assessing and scrutinizing free speech online with the intent of governing access rates/bandwidth "invalid"? Is that what has become of our dialog?

The history of this will be written by the winners.
 
So what? There is almost no direct cost in moving data - it is all indirect costs. All your obsessing over that financial reports is wasted effort as it tells you nothing about the relative cost of providing that service. But it does make for a great anti-capitalist rant though, doesn't it?

I only pointed out the huge profit in that particular endeavor. After all their primary business is providing video service. So the cost of building that network is the cost of providing their video services. Data is an add on service for them not their primary business. It just so happened to turn out there was a large market for that add on service with a high rate of return. So it is fair to look at it separately because the cost of the network is the cost of providing their primary service and may have little do with cost of providing data.
 
Really? "no valid reason"? Did you actually read the concerns posted? Those which note that there does necessarily involve state scrutiny of content posted online in assessment of "neutrality"?

Are concerns about our federal government assessing and scrutinizing free speech online with the intent of governing access rates/bandwidth "invalid"? Is that what has become of our dialog?

How ? It call for treating all data equally from a human standpoint. From a computer standpoint data is prioritized by the system which has nothing to do with the content in that respect. Even that cat video vs remote surgery red herring is not true. Because the two would not be treated the same by the network as they are designed because they are two different kinds of transmissions as far it is concerned.
 
How ? It call for treating all data equally from a human standpoint. From a computer standpoint data is prioritized by the system which has nothing to do with the content in that respect. Even that cat video vs remote surgery red herring is not true. Because the two would not be treated the same by the network as they are designed because they are two different kinds of transmissions as far it is concerned.
What comprises the messaging and content of comparative customers is necessarily assessed. This is how conclusions will be arrived at. There are no external meters mounted that your local bureaucrat can come and read.

What exactly do you think is contained in several hundred pages of policy? Just a lot of "heretofores" and "whereases"?

You grant the federal government gating and valving ownership of Internet and it's all out the window.
 
Really? "no valid reason"? Did you actually read the concerns posted? Those which note that there does necessarily involve state scrutiny of content posted online in assessment of "neutrality"?

Are concerns about our federal government assessing and scrutinizing free speech online with the intent of governing access rates/bandwidth "invalid"? Is that what has become of our dialog?
Perhaps you missed my gist that I don't give a rat's ass. I realize that those of you who feel especially special about one another, see this differently. Alas, I don't feel that special about myself, nor the rest of you. Seriously...you guys put me to sleep, much less someone who's paid (by whom?), to parse your nonsense.
 
What comprises the messaging and content of comparative customers is necessarily assessed. This is how conclusions will be arrived at. There are no external meters mounted that your local bureaucrat can come and read.

What exactly do you think is contained in several hundred pages of policy? Just a lot of "heretofores" and "whereases"?

You grant the federal government gating and valving ownership of Internet and it's all out the window.

How is content even part of it ? It would be a violation of the first amendment to regulate the content of communications in the way your are describing it.
 
Perhaps you missed my gist that I don't give a rat's ass. I realize that those of you who feel especially special about one another, see this differently. Alas, I don't feel that special about myself, nor the rest of you. Seriously...you guys put me to sleep, much less someone who's paid (by whom?), to parse your nonsense.
Now I understand. It is your personal interest that bestows "validity" as to folks' concerns. It necessarily follows that you do feel "special about yourself". :)

Thanks for the clarification.
 
To "spread the bits around" - I'm not the least bit shocked, are any of you?

But such voices have been drowned out by left-wing activists who want to manage the Internet to achieve their political objectives. The most influential of these congregate around the deceptively named Free Press, a liberal lobby co-founded in 2002 by Robert McChesney, a University of Illinois communications professor. His goals have always been clear. “At the moment, the battle over network neutrality is not to completely eliminate the telephone and cable companies,” he told the website SocialistProject in 2009. “But the ultimate goal is to get rid of the media capitalists in the phone and cable companies and to divest them from control.” Earlier in 2000, he told the Marxist magazine Monthly Review: “Our job is to make media reform part of our broader struggle for democracy, social justice, and, dare we say it, socialism.” When I interviewed him in 2010, he admitted he is a socialist and said he was “hesitant to say I’m not a Marxist.”

Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/414483/comrades-net-neutrality-john-fund

Hahaha! No, you Obama supporters aren't Marxists. Why would we think that???
Liberals just do not like a level playing field. It makes them feel sooo vulnerable.
 
I only pointed out the huge profit in that particular endeavor. After all their primary business is providing video service. So the cost of building that network is the cost of providing their video services. Data is an add on service for them not their primary business. It just so happened to turn out there was a large market for that add on service with a high rate of return. So it is fair to look at it separately because the cost of the network is the cost of providing their primary service and may have little do with cost of providing data.

That does NOT include the cost of "providing video" content. That is a separate line of business. This is just for providing a data connection to their network. But like I said, why let the facts get in the way of a good anti-capitalist rant.
 
That does NOT include the cost of "providing video" content. That is a separate line of business. This is just for providing a data connection to their network. But like I said, why let the facts get in the way of a good anti-capitalist rant.

I didn't say "content" I said "service". They are a cable company. Their primary service is providing video. The expensive infrastructure that makes up the network exists to provide video to homes. It would exist if they did not even provide data services.

Look at it this way. McDonald's most profitable product is not a food item. It's their gift cards (This is because people rarely use them so they get to keep the money spent on them without providing a product.) But you wouldn't count the building of restaurants as part of the cost of providing gift cards. The restaurants weren't built to provide gift cards. It is just an add on item they sell.

Data to your home is an add on item to your video service. The video service is why they built the networks. The infrastructure cost for data is the cost of connecting the other way to the internet backbone. That is no where near the infrastructure cost of building out to neighborhoods and homes. So that why it is honest to say that they have the high profits on data as stated before.
 
I didn't say "content" I said "service". They are a cable company. Their primary service is providing video. The expensive infrastructure that makes up the network exists to provide video to homes. It would exist if they did not even provide data services.

Look at it this way. McDonald's most profitable product is not a food item. It's their gift cards (This is because people rarely use them so they get to keep the money spent on them without providing a product.) But you wouldn't count the building of restaurants as part of the cost of providing gift cards. The restaurants weren't built to provide gift cards. It is just an add on item they sell.

Data to your home is an add on item to your video service. The video service is why they built the networks. The infrastructure cost for data is the cost of connecting the other way to the internet backbone. That is no where near the infrastructure cost of building out to neighborhoods and homes. So that why it is honest to say that they have the high profits on data as stated before.

Yet again, as I have already pointed out, their overall net income is only about 10%, so wtf difference does it make? The high profits on this line of business subsidize the costs of other less profitable business lines. The only person who would get their nose out of joint over this is an anti-capitalist. They are not now, nor have they ever, pocketed 97 cents of any dollar that they charged any customer. It is a fiction you are going on about here, so no, it's not "honest."
 
Yet again, as I have already pointed out, their overall net income is only about 10%, so wtf difference does it make? The high profits on this line of business subsidize the costs of other less profitable business lines. The only person who would get their nose out of joint over this is an anti-capitalist. They are not now, nor have they ever, pocketed 97 cents of any dollar that they charged any customer. It is a fiction you are going on about here, so no, it's not "honest."

Or someone who uses that service and believes they overcharge for it. Because they have colluded with other providers to stake out monopolies where there is no competition and have bribed and bullied legislatures to block municipalities from building there own networks.

You can't defend that an still claim you are defending capitalism or that you even really support capitalism.
 
Back
Top