New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Non-partisan question

LeRoy, what you say may have been true the first few years of the Vietnam conflict (war was never declared), but by the mid-sixties that just wasn't the facts anymore. I served two tours and the average grunt was there because that's where he was told to go. The shine on the "We're defending freedom" halo was pretty tarnished by '66 when we all saw the corruption of the government we were "defending". The least honorable conflict the US has ever engaged in until we invaded Iraq.

I agree with you. When I said 'early on', I was thinking of the period from ~1961 to ~1965. As you know, things were really changing in America by the time you get to the mid-1960s. The counter-culture was flourishing. Hippies were running amok. People started to "Question Authority". High time, too.
 
That's what we told we were fighting for, to keep South Vietnam free from communism. Of course it was a lie, just like the average southern soldier was told that he was fighting for "state's rights" when in reality they were fighting for the rich plantation owners rights to keep cheap labor.

If we go back to the Vietnam conflict's roots - late 40's early 50's - we find of course, that it had nothing to do with "freedom for the 'S. Vietnamese' ", but neither was it about preventing the spread of communism in S.E. Asia. What it was REALLY about, was stopping the spread of communism in Europe - France, specifically.
 
how could it have been a moral struggle on the part of the usa if they refused to get involved until hitler declared war on them? where was the morality beforehand??

As you know, America was a very isolationist country in the 1930s. [Especially the Republicans, who were very different back then from what they are today!] FDR knew that the threat of Nazi Germany would eventually have to be faced. I reject the idea that there was any kind of 'moral equivalence' between Nazi Germany and 1940s America. Yes, we unconstitutionally interned our Japanese-American citizens, and that was (wildly) wrong. But we did not stuff them into gas chambers.
 
Well of course they were. I've never denied that. That is exactly why slavery was relevant to the Civil War. I'm only arguing that the war didn't occur simply because the morally superior folks who lived North of some arbitrary dividing line suddenly decided that they just had to take up arms and seek freedom for those poor, innocent slaves. That's John Wayne movie bullshit. There was slavery in America long before the South was even settled. Neither side was possessed of absolute moral purity leading up to the war, but the winners always get to write the fable after the fact. It's just another spoil, I guess.

Have you ever read Uncle Tom's Cabin? It's the book that caused the war, you know.
 
No they weren't. We still rely upon slave labor to manufacture cheap goods. We simply offshore the slavery so we don't have to witness it firsthand.

Don't confuse slavery with 'wage slavery'. It is nothing less than offensive to label Chinese workers as being slaves. Those 'slaves' are buying refrigerators, DVD players, big-screen TVs, and some of them are moving up from bicycles to automobiles. Slaves don't buy refrigerators. Slaves don't buy DVD players. Slaves don't buy big-screen TVs. Slaves don't buy automobiles. Slaves don't buy anything, in fact, because they are not paid. They are merely kept alive, by providing them with food, shelter, and clothing, and preferably a minimal amount of all three.
 
What a friggin whiner. Coelho was ripping on Reagan long before republicans ever attacked Oneill.
There is always partisan campaigning. The issue with ONeill is that Gingrich attacked him for the very thing that Gingrich went on to be himself censured for.

Nor did Coelho ever distribute a memo to the Dems telling them to frame republicans as anti-american, facist, dangerous etc. Schumer's comment about labeling everything extreme is 16 years AFTER the Gingrich GOPAC memo - a case of Turnabout is Fair play more than anything - because the question is WHERE DID IT ORIGINATE.

The GOP is not "getting back".

They started the filibuster, obstructionism game.
They started the name calling game
They started the road to lying and race baiting with Nixon and then the open arm welcome of everyone from Jesse Helms to Reagan to Strom thrumond.


So explain why the Dems should not sink Romney EXACTLY the same way that the GOP has sought to sink Obama? One good reason. Because if you cannot - then you basically need to vote for Obama if you want to see the goverance of the nation improved.

Why? Becuase you need to not reward and encourage politics that are destructively obstructionist.
 
I wasn't aware that I was supposed to be holding a grudge against any of those....if that was the point. To me, it's a list of countries that deserve pity rather than contempt. Who do you think holds a grudge against them? Israel vs Palestine is a no brainer, but I'm of the opinion that Israel should try being less provocative with their settlement building endeavor and Palestine should try following leaders who aren't leading them into hell.
 
BS Degs, the tone we are experiencing now is all democrat created and fostered. It doesn't matter if the democrats only obstructed Bush half as much as republicans are restricting Obama. The point is, they did it and republicans are doing exactly what democrats defended doing for 8 years.

You get what you pay for, Degs, and democrats specifically took out this line of credit, "power of the minority" and all.

CF, that is the biggest stake of bullshit you have ever posted. The tone in DC as well as in most of the states is all republicon driven and has been since November, 2008. To claim anything else is just a lie, but since you support the biggest liar since GWB, it comes as no surprise.

Which Mittens are you voting for?

The pro-choice mittens or the "I'll overturn Roe V Wade" Mittens?

The "I'll leave FEMA alone" Mittens or the "FEMA should be privitized" Mittens?

The "Let Detroit fail" Mittens or the "I supported the bailout" Mittens?

The "First day in office, I'll repeal Obamacare" or the "I'll keep parts of Obamacare" Mittens

The "I'll get tough with China" Mittens or the "Cutting trade with China is wrong" Mittens

The "JEEP is sending its production to China" or oh wait that's just the lying mittens, you don't have a choice on that one.

Take your pick from the filp-floppingest persons (well at least multiple personalities) that ever ran for office. me i'll stick with the president that has almost gotten the mess you republicons left him with cleaned up. Four more years and he'll get the job done.
 
The negative impact on turnout would be problematic, but, I think, less problematic than the alternative. If I have the choice of relatively unmotivated voters not voting because they've already heard outcome elsewhere, or even the most motivated voters not voting because they're stranded by a storm or other disaster, I'll go with the former.
 
actually ho was a communist long before america came onto the scene.

What's Ironic is that it was while he was living in France that he was introduced to communism. Do you know he petitoned the US as early as 1920 to help him declare Vietnam a free nation and have France give up its colonial claims? Do you know his Viet Minh was supported by the OSS during WWII in its fight against Japan and the Vichy French? He petitoned President Harry Truman to recognize the elected government of Vietnam after WWII, but Truman never responded, nor did any other nation recognize his government.
 
My bad, sorry I got the town wrong, here's a read for you....

Battle of Fort Sumter


From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


The Battle of Fort Sumter (April 12–14, 1861) was the bombardment and surrender of Fort Sumter, near Charleston, South Carolina, that started the American Civil War. Following declarations of secession by seven Southern states, South Carolina demanded that the U.S. Army abandon its facilities in Charleston Harbor. On December 26, 1860, U.S. Major Robert Anderson surreptitiously moved his small command from the indefensible Fort Moultrie on Sullivan's Island to Fort Sumter, a substantial fortress controlling the entrance of Charleston Harbor. An attempt by U.S. President James Buchanan to reinforce and resupply Anderson, using the unarmed merchant ship Star of the West, failed when it was fired upon by shore batteries on January 9, 1861. South Carolina authorities then seized all Federal property in the Charleston area, except for Fort Sumter.

During the early months of 1861, the situation around Fort Sumter increasingly began to resemble a siege. In March, Brig. Gen. P. G. T. Beauregard, the first general officer of the newly formed Confederate States of America, was placed in command of Confederate forces in Charleston. Beauregard energetically directed the strengthening of batteries around Charleston harbor aimed at Fort Sumter. Conditions in the fort grew dire as the Federals rushed to complete the installation of additional guns. Anderson was short of men, food, and supplies.

The resupply of Fort Sumter became the first crisis of the administration of President Abraham Lincoln. He notified the Governor of South Carolina, Francis W. Pickens, that he was sending supply ships, which resulted in an ultimatum from the Confederate government: evacuate Fort Sumter immediately. Major Anderson refused to surrender. Beginning at 4:30 a.m. on April 12, the Confederates bombarded the fort from artillery batteries surrounding the harbor. Although the Union garrison returned fire, they were significantly outgunned and, after 34 hours, Major Anderson agreed to evacuate. There was no loss of life on either side as a direct result of this engagement, although a gun explosion during the surrender ceremonies on April 14 caused two Union deaths.

Following the battle, there was widespread support from both North and South for further military action. Lincoln's immediate call for 75,000 volunteers to suppress the rebellion resulted in an additional four states also declaring their secession and joining the Confederacy. The Civil War had begun.
 
What's Ironic is that it was while he was living in France that he was introduced to communism. Do you know he petitoned the US as early as 1920 to help him declare Vietnam a free nation and have France give up its colonial claims? Do you know his Viet Minh was supported by the OSS during WWII in its fight against Japan and the Vichy French? He petitoned President Harry Truman to recognize the elected government of Vietnam after WWII, but Truman never responded, nor did any other nation recognize his government.

The reason Truman/Eisenhower rebuffed Ho, had little to do with Ho and everything to do with the French. Ho was France's adversary and France was our ally.
 
BS whiner. Your side fought for the ability to filibuster whatever you didn't like, and now republicans are doing it back. Good for them. Democrats broke this government, I fear beyond repair, and again the Obama apologists are desperate to blame the opposition.

You broke it, so quit whining about it.
 
The reason Truman/Eisenhower rebuffed Ho, had little to do with Ho and everything to do with the French. Ho was France's adversary and France was our ally.

France might have been our ally, but apparently not enough to be supported in the battle of Dien Bien Phu. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Dien_Bien_Phu. President Eisenhour refused to support France in that battle which resulted in the defeat of the French forces and ushered in the end of colonial control by France in the area. Only later did the "domino effect" policy come into being and our involvement in a long war. General Giap whipped the French, us and our allies. He did this without the aid of an Air Force, a Navy, or a large standing army.
 
When history doesn't serve you, just make shit up.

Who is the last Republican President who left the country in better shape than he found it in? Eisenhower?

The current President is bound to do that whether he gets a second term or not. Clinton did it. Carter did it. Johnson did it. Kennedy did it.

No Republican President in over 60 years has accomplished that one basic task. They do what you do. Blame their incompetence on Democrats and lie a lot. Why? To perpetuate the dominance of the 1%. If you can name a Republican who has ever had another policy agenda, spill it.

Maybe a rich guy with a familiar name isn't the best criteria to qualify one as President. Ya think?
 
I wasn't aware that I was supposed to be holding a grudge against any of those....if that was the point. To me, it's a list of countries that deserve pity rather than contempt. Who do you think holds a grudge against them? Israel vs Palestine is a no brainer, but I'm of the opinion that Israel should try being less provocative with their settlement building endeavor and Palestine should try following leaders who aren't leading them into hell.

the grudge holders live in those countries. they cant let go of what happened to them.
 
France might have been our ally, but apparently not enough to be supported in the battle of Dien Bien Phu. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Dien_Bien_Phu. President Eisenhour refused to support France in that battle which resulted in the defeat of the French forces and ushered in the end of colonial control by France in the area. Only later did the "domino effect" policy come into being and our involvement in a long war. General Giap whipped the French, us and our allies. He did this without the aid of an Air Force, a Navy, or a large standing army.

Dien Bien Phu is dispositive in that rather than walk away from Indochina, the U.S. rushed in to fill the gap. That goes to the fact that the U.S. was concerned that the French were going "weak kneed", and that France itself, might succumb to Soviet-communist entreaties.
 
Dien Bien Phu is dispositive in that rather than walk away from Indochina, the U.S. rushed in to fill the gap. That goes to the fact that the U.S. was concerned that the French were going "weak kneed", and that France itself, might succumb to Soviet-communist entreaties.

not to forget that in their attempts to get american help, the french had done a fine job of convincing the mcarthyist americans that ho chi minh was a chinese pawn and that the domino theory was a real fact.
 
Back
Top