New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Non-partisan question

and slaves were a route to economic power

Well of course they were. I've never denied that. That is exactly why slavery was relevant to the Civil War. I'm only arguing that the war didn't occur simply because the morally superior folks who lived North of some arbitrary dividing line suddenly decided that they just had to take up arms and seek freedom for those poor, innocent slaves. That's John Wayne movie bullshit. There was slavery in America long before the South was even settled. Neither side was possessed of absolute moral purity leading up to the war, but the winners always get to write the fable after the fact. It's just another spoil, I guess.
 
I think you're right on track...which means you're jusr as confused I am.

Thanks for jumping in.
 
Thanks LeRoy...I was wondering about that and didn't bother taking the time to look it up. So....is there a scenario that you'd be comfortable with?

After I posted the question, I was wondering what would have happened had the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor on Nov 7, 1940 in instead of a month later?

(I didn't bother looking up the first Tuesday of November in 1940 either.)


Boca, maybe you should invest some time in learning some American history. Japan attacked Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, not December 7, 1940. For someone who is always posting about how things are not right in America, you seem to be awful stupid about its history.

As for your questions, I have always thought that the voting should take place on a weekend or that the day of voting should be a national holiday with everyone having the day off work to go vote. Making people vote on a work day seems a little unfair.
 
Thank you Jammer for coming in to fart...I think PJ has some award or something for "thread closers".
 
Boca, the "hostile fleet" was a supply ship sent by then President Buchanan, not Lincoln, which was fired on by the Confederate forces in Charlotte. Several months later the southerns demanded the withdrawal of Union forces from Sumter, which its commander refused. The batteries in Charlotte opened fired and after a battle of 34 hours, the Union agreed to withdraw. What I find amazing was that during the entire 34 hours of trading cannon fire, neither side lost a single man. It was when they were leaving and two Union soldiers attempted to destroy a cannon and were killed by the expolsion that the only lives in the battle were lost.
 
You'll have to simplify all that for me Sheet...sorry.

I did simplify it. There IS no Constitutionally dispositive law, on the subject. If we're to put the issue into its most current context, there's no law preventing Pres. Obama from postponing the election at his whim. The only thing from "preventing" him from doing so, is the fact that it'd probably piss people off royally, and cause them to "vote him out of office", when the election actually does go down.
 
Paper ballots. Ex-patriots and overseas military voters get 2 weeks to get their votes in...past the election day.
 
I'd still rather have served two tours there than one in Iraq. What a hell hole.

Viet Nam is a beautiful country with some of the kindest, friendliest and most industrious people I've ever met. I thought it would turn into North Korea when we left. Instead, they forgave us and got back to work. Amazing.
 
I'd still rather have served two tours there than one in Iraq. What a hell hole.

Viet Nam is a beautiful country with some of the kindest, friendliest and most industrious people I've ever met. I thought it would turn into North Korea when we left. Instead, they forgave us and got back to work. Amazing.

they really are incredible folks arent they! meanwhile we hold grudges for centuries!!
 
oh come on, slavery was like taxes; without slavery there was no civilization; civilization was founded upon the labor of slaves... surely you know that.
 
oh come on, slavery was like taxes; without slavery there was no civilization; civilization was founded upon the labor of slaves... surely you know that.

bullcrap. other western nations were doing just fine without it.
 
meanwhile we hold grudges for centuries!!

Not really. We forgave Japan and Germany pretty quickly and helped them rejoin the world community. We bombed them into submission first, of course.
 
What a friggin whiner. Coelho was ripping on Reagan long before republicans ever attacked Oneill.

And you're forgetting Shumer's famous "label everything as extreme" call to democrats during the 2008 campaign.

You can make up whatever sh1t you want about recounts and whatever else, it's what you liberals do, but democrats started abusing the filibuster, and now they're reaping what they sowed. Get over it. You were cheering democrats on when they were doing it to Bush. "Power of the minority".

Now you're getting it back and I applaud the republicans for doing it.
 
You're absolutely half-correct Leroy.....but it was more a question of economics than slavery. The south was thoroughy agricultural and doing extremely well in exporting and the North had but it's nascent industrial economy.

Besides, it was Northern politicians who demanded that a black man or woman should be counted as 3/5 of a person. Southerners thought they were whole persons...and we still do

Factually that's true Boca, but the reasoning behind it tells a different story. The southerns wanted to count the slaves, who had no rights and could not vote, as whole people because it would give the southern states more reprentatives in the House. The more populous northern states said that they could only be counted as whole people if they were given their freedom and allowed to vote. The issue threatened to wreck the newly founded United States. To preserve the counrty, James Madison came up with the 3/5's compromise and after long debates it was finally agreed upon by all states.

Not one of America's prouder moments.
 
meanwhile we hold grudges for centuries!!

Not really. We forgave Japan and Germany pretty quickly and helped them rejoin the world community. We bombed them into submission first, of course.

ireland, dixie, armenia, palestine, serbia,
 
Slavery may well have been the primary political motivator for the occurrence of the war, but what does that have to do with the motivation of the soldiers? The people who start the wars almost never fight in the wars. Do you believe that we fought in Vietnam to secure the freedom of the South Vietnamese peasants?

That's what we told we were fighting for, to keep South Vietnam free from communism. Of course it was a lie, just like the average southern soldier was told that he was fighting for "state's rights" when in reality they were fighting for the rich plantation owners rights to keep cheap labor.
 
I hope you're not one of the people that drive around with a Confederate flag in the back of your pickup truck, NS. Our soldiers in Vietnam BELIEVED they were fighting to save those South Vietnamese peasants from falling under a terrible Communist tyranny. Which, of course, is exactly what happened after we declared victory and got the hell out. But it was still all wrong, because those soldiers were misinformed by our leadership of that era. Ho Chi Minh was never a committed Marxist. He was a nationalist, who simply wanted nothing more than for Vietnam to be united. In that sense, he was sort of like Lincoln! We drove him into the arms of the Communists.

I hope you don't try to give me any lectures on Vietnam. I did not speak with my father, and he did not speak with me, for the last six months of his life, because we strenuously disagreed on the Vietnam War. I had told him that I would be a conscientious objector, or would even flee to Canada. He was the old-fashioned sort who thought our government could do no wrong. Except for Spiro Agnew, whom my father loathed. To this day, I regret that my father and I parted on such very poor terms, that we could not even speak to each other.

LeRoy, what you say may have been true the first few years of the Vietnam conflict (war was never declared), but by the mid-sixties that just wasn't the facts anymore. I served two tours and the average grunt was there because that's where he was told to go. The shine on the "We're defending freedom" halo was pretty tarnished by '66 when we all saw the corruption of the government we were "defending". The least honorable conflict the US has ever engaged in until we invaded Iraq.
 
Back
Top