New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Non-partisan question

Hahahahahaha! You can occasionally be endearing, Boca.

To answer your question, I've been wondering the same thing with the storm coming. I really hope there is a way to enable people in the affected areas to vote. It's a unique situation as far as I know. They've already cancelled early voting in some places. It would seem that cancelling voting would be a more egregious anomaly than extending the date. No one is manipulating the situation, after all. Pugs always assume that anything that suppresses the vote favors them, but I'm not so sure that holds true when the suppression is random.
 
You're absolutely half-correct Leroy.....but it was more a question of economics than slavery. The south was thoroughy agricultural and doing extremely well in exporting and the North had but it's nascent industrial economy.

Besides, it was Northern politicians who demanded that a black man or woman should be counted as 3/5 of a person. Southerners thought they were whole persons...and we still do
 
9 great-grandfathers? You have 4 1/2 grandfathers? How does that work?
 
an interesting one too, not only from a legal point of view but a public perception view.

Let's forget for just a moment who the President is. Let's just say either/or, a conservative or a liberal, a Democrat or a Republican. It doesn't matter.

Actually it's three questions...

1) Short of a nuclear war breaking out, or an approaching meteor, whatever ...under what conditions would you be comfortable with postponing a General Election?

2) Would extreme weather be one reason?

3) Who would you accept as having the authority to do so (.... a court, the Congress, etc.)?


This should be fun...by the way, does anyone know if it's ever happened?

Good question Boca, it will be interesting to hear what people who believe in God might say about an "act of God". Will we hear from Pat Robertson?

Is Mother Nature especially pissed off this year, is she firing warning shots or is it the gales of November again on steroids? (See (or hear) "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald")

Would a joint agreement (gee, something that's become quite rare) be a good authority? All three branches agreeing that all voting at polling places be suspended?

I'd be interested in hearing what the consequences of such would be and to whose advantage it would be, if any?

I would imagine the people in tornado alley would not be pleased to have an election go on right after several towns were flattened, so maybe the same should be a consideration once the storm has passed.
 
My 9 greatgrandfathersw were rebels. My great grandfather and grand uncles fought for a new country. i guess you must be one of the Tea Party nuts -- but if my state voted to leave the union it would have the right to leave.

It's the Tea Party nuts who think that states have the right to secede from the Union. They do not, unless you are advocating overthrowing the Supreme Court.

And I never said "Lincoln was for Negroes." I said he was against slavery.
 
Boca...how did Beauregard know a fleet was coming? Satellite photography or the Confederate Air Recon units?


BTW, quoting the aggressors? I'm sure the Japanese had the same excuses for why THEY had to "strike the first blow".

The Germans attacked Pearl Harbor in self-defense!!!
 
That won't make it any easier to vote for Mittwit. I suspect many will have a couple of stiff ones before they plug their noses and vote for him.
 
an interesting one too, not only from a legal point of view but a public perception view.

Let's forget for just a moment who the President is. Let's just say either/or, a conservative or a liberal, a Democrat or a Republican. It doesn't matter.

Actually it's three questions...

1) Short of a nuclear war breaking out, or an approaching meteor, whatever ...under what conditions would you be comfortable with postponing a General Election?

2) Would extreme weather be one reason?

3) Who would you accept as having the authority to do so (.... a court, the Congress, etc.)?


This should be fun...by the way, does anyone know if it's ever happened?

Very good questions. I don't know what the legal guidance is for this. I assume it would be up to the states, though, with the risk that if they don't do the voting within a certain time, they can't make use of the "safe harbor provision" which forces the US Congress to accept their slate of electors. With the Bush v. Gore decision, though, you never know. That utterly incomprehensible piece of legalish fecal-matter could be read to say basically anything you want, using its super-wide view of equal protection and its inexplicable picking-and-choosing of where equal protection can be enforced.

Setting aside existing legal precedent, if it were entirely my call, I'd have a pre-existing set of rules allowing elections to be extended on a state-by-state basis for as long as a state-of-emergency exists in the state, if a judge has ruled that it remains severe enough to have a likely substantial impact on the outcome of the election.
 
It's the Tea Party nuts who think that states have the right to secede from the Union. They do not, unless you are advocating overthrowing the Supreme Court. And I never said "Lincoln was for Negroes." I said he was against slavery.
Lincoln's opposition to slavery was spotty, at best. Lincoln's top priority was winning the war. He did whatever was necessary to assure that.
 
Boca, as someone noted...we had a Presidential election....DURING THE CIVIL WAR.

So "short of nuclear war or a meteor approaching"....what scenario COULD be bad enough to call for a postponment?

I wouldn't advocate postponing an election for a war or any other lengthy scenario. But I would advocate extending voting for a few days in the face of some acute problem that would make the election extremely unrepresentative for some short period of time. For example, picture a massive black-out during normal voting hours, with mostly electronic voting machines. Not so long ago, we had a black-out that stretched from Ohio to Massachusetts, which would have made a joke of any election held on that day. Picture, for example, if a blackout took out only a portion of a state (e.g., only New York City and its surroundings, suddenly making New York a red state, thanks to the conservative upstate portion having vastly greater turnout; or, similarly, what if only the DC suburbs of Virginia had power, while the grid of rural parts was down, making Virginia an easy blue state for a few hours?) Better to extend voting for a day or two than get a result nobody could see as representative.
 
Congress should have taken steps to modernize our election laws after the debacle in 2000. This storm scenario is one of many issues that should have been addressed. Instead, we got nothing from Congress and a plethora of state level laws designed to restrict voter turnout.
 
Lincoln's opposition to slavery was spotty, at best. Lincoln's top priority was winning the war. He did whatever was necessary to assure that.

It is true that Lincoln would have been willing to allow the continuation of slavery in the old slave states of the Confederacy. The preservation of the Union was his overarching goal, no doubt. What tore the country apart, and led directly to the Civil War, was the insistence by Southern politicians on extending slavery into the new territories in the West. That, Lincoln could simply not tolerate. And he was right.
 
Very good questions. I don't know what the legal guidance is for this. I assume it would be up to the states, though, with the risk that if they don't do the voting within a certain time, they can't make use of the "safe harbor provision" which forces the US Congress to accept their slate of electors. With the Bush v. Gore decision, though, you never know. That utterly incomprehensible piece of legalish fecal-matter could be read to say basically anything you want, using its super-wide view of equal protection and its inexplicable picking-and-choosing of where equal protection can be enforced.

Setting aside existing legal precedent, if it were entirely my call, I'd have a pre-existing set of rules allowing elections to be extended on a state-by-state basis for as long as a state-of-emergency exists in the state, if a judge has ruled that it remains severe enough to have a likely substantial impact on the outcome of the election.

This seems reasonable to me, as we already allow judges to extend the voting hours in polling places that are overwhelmed by long lines of people waiting to vote.
 
True, but doesn't matter. They were still fighting to preserve slavery. Or are you arguing that they didn't know what they were fighting for?

I highly doubt any of the confederate soldiers believed in their hearts that they were fighting to preserve slavery. IMO, simplifying the Civil War to platitudes about good vs evil is nothing more than a convenient excuse for one's own bigotry and hatred, no offense.
 
Very good questions. I don't know what the legal guidance is for this. I assume it would be up to the states, though, with the risk that if they don't do the voting within a certain time, they can't make use of the "safe harbor provision" which forces the US Congress to accept their slate of electors. With the Bush v. Gore decision, though, you never know. That utterly incomprehensible piece of legalish fecal-matter could be read to say basically anything you want, using its super-wide view of equal protection and its inexplicable picking-and-choosing of where equal protection can be enforced.

Setting aside existing legal precedent, if it were entirely my call, I'd have a pre-existing set of rules allowing elections to be extended on a state-by-state basis for as long as a state-of-emergency exists in the state, if a judge has ruled that it remains severe enough to have a likely substantial impact on the outcome of the election.

My concern there Arkady, would be any reporting of election results where voting still took place and what that impact is believed to have upon subsequent voting/voter turnout. I there were a moratorium on disclosure of any results of voting before all were cast, I would have fewer problems with your thought to continue on in some states, postpone in storm affected states.
 
I highly doubt any of the confederate soldiers believed in their hearts that they were fighting to preserve slavery. IMO, simplifying the Civil War to platitudes about good vs evil is nothing more than a convenient excuse for one's own bigotry and hatred, no offense.

For your information, professional historians are in agreement with me that slavery was the PRIMARY cause of the Civil War.
 
For your information, professional historians are in agreement with me that slavery was the PRIMARY cause of the Civil War.


Slavery may well have been the primary political motivator for the occurrence of the war, but what does that have to do with the motivation of the soldiers? The people who start the wars almost never fight in the wars. Do you believe that we fought in Vietnam to secure the freedom of the South Vietnamese peasants?
 
Back
Top