New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Obama to Close Gitmo

Why was the UN supervision wrong? Would it have been better to let Stalin supervise elections in the North and the US supervise elections in the South?

Stalin had agreed to the split between South and North, with the US.

The UN supervise what? All they do is white wash.
 
They weren't told to pull back. The Chinese Army forced a retreat with about a million "volunteers".

No they didn't --- I have given you links before middleview --- It had been agreed between Russia and the US that each would control a part of Korea, without the consent of the people of course. The US went in to occupy their side and when the Military pushed further than they should they were told to pull back ---

It s a chess game.
 
We'll never know the answer to that question since the US disbanded the PRK and refused to allow any elections to take place long before "hundreds of thousands of Koreans fled to the part of the peninsula controlled (occupied) by the US." Why do you suppose Americans thought they had the right to deny self-determination to millions of Koreans in 1945?

Of course we know the answer. The North was clearly going to be a communist country and the South a capitalist one. 400,000 people voted with their feet.
 
The answer hasn't changed.
Because the US military prevented free elections in 1945.

Not having been there we can guess that the communists were far better organized and in a position to win a national election. The US arrived in the country at the end of 1945 and long after Soviet troops had arrived in the North. Negotiations between the occupying powers fell apart as it became clear that the Russians had no intention of surrendering control of countries they occupied in Europe.

I realize you'd like to paint the communist side as the good guys, but the dictatorship in the North shows no sign of becoming any more democratic...face it, it is a failed state and must maintain a constant state of war to keep from having an outright rebellion.
 
No they didn't --- I have given you links before middleview --- It had been agreed between Russia and the US that each would control a part of Korea, without the consent of the people of course. The US went in to occupy their side and when the Military pushed further than they should they were told to pull back ---

It s a chess game.

Your version of history is more a comedy act than anything else. Do you know anything about the Korean war? It was in all the news.
 
Your version of history is more a comedy act than anything else. Do you know anything about the Korean war? It was in all the news.

I don't have a version of History - I try to find the truth of it all.

'Tis you with a version - The Victors Version. Never moving always the same, no matter what new info comes to light - stuck, riveted to the spot.
 
I don't have a version of History - I try to find the truth of it all.

'Tis you with a version - The Victors Version. Never moving always the same, no matter what new info comes to light - stuck, riveted to the spot.

The North Korean army invaded South Korea in June of 1950 with the blessings of Mao and Stalin...and with significant help from Rusisan officers in planning the attack.
By September the US and ROK forces were confined to a small perimeter at Pusan, the southern most point of the peninsula...The US landed troops in Inchon, far behind the North Korean lines. The North Koreans retreated all the way back to the border with China by October. The Chinese army crossed the border into North Korea, surprising the UN forces and causing a retreat to the 38th parallel.

Feel free to rethink your earlier opinion on how the two sides ended up where they are today.
 
I don't understand why you don't see that the 400,000 people were exercising their right to self determination by fleeing to the South.
That's because you are talking about an exodus in 1948-'49 that would never have taken place if the US military had not prevented unification elections in Korea in 1945.
 
The North must have really sucked. Good thing the US was there.
Easy for you to say; however, things looked much better in North Korea in 1945:
"After the surrender of the Empire of Japan to the Allies, division at the 38th parallel marked the beginning of Soviet and American command over the North and South, respectively.

"U.S. forces landed at Incheon on September 8, 1945, and established a military government shortly thereafter.[9]

"The forces landing at Incheon were of the XXIV Corps of the U.S. Tenth Army.[10]

"They were commanded by Lt. General John R. Hodge, who then took charge of the government.[11] Four days before he arrived in Korea, Hodge told his officers that Korea 'was an enemy of the United States'.[2]

"On September 9, at a surrender ceremony, Hodge announced that the Japanese colonial government would remain intact, including its personnel and its governor-general. After a major outcry, Hodge replaced the governor-general with an American and removed all the Japanese bureau chiefs, though he, in turn, enlisted the former Japanese bureaucrats as advisors.[3]"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Military_Government_in_Korea#Background
At the same time in the north, Japanese bureaucrats were sent home, and all Koreans who collaborated with Japan's occupation were murdered. In the south, collaborators were welcomed into the police and military units being set up by US occupiers whose officers viewed Korea as "the enemy."
 
That's because you are talking about an exodus in 1948-'49 that would never have taken place if the US military had not prevented unification elections in Korea in 1945.

Because there would have been no point. There were a handful of American soldiers in Korea in 1945. There was a Russian army in the north. The exodus actually took place before the end of 1946.

With communists in charge of the north and a Russian army there....a well organized communist party in the south. You think that would have been a fair election. I do not.
People fled because they preferred the form of government they saw in the south...not the one with Kim Il Sung at the top. To this day North Korea has not had a free election and is still a family run business. It survives by force. The proof is in the pudding. People defect to the south all the time...to the north, not so much.
 
Of course we know the answer. The North was clearly going to be a communist country and the South a capitalist one. 400,000 people voted with their feet.
Actually, it had more to do with religion than with economics by 1949. In 1945 a majority of Koreans would likely have supported PRK communists because communists fought against Japan's brutal occupation while rich capitalists collaborated with the Japanese. Are you of the opinion the US had the right to prevent all Koreans from exercising self-determination in 1945, or does your support for freedom extend only to those who adopt a capitalist economy?
"The program of the PRK was presented in its September 14 twenty-seven point program. The program included: 'the confiscation without compensation of lands held by the Japanese and collaborators; free distribution of that land to the peasants; rent limits on the non redistributed land; nationalization of such major industries as mining, transportation, banking, and communication; state supervision of small and mid-sized companies; …guaranteed basic human rights and freedoms, including those of speech, press, assembly, and faith; universal suffrage to adults over the age of eighteen; equality for women; labor law reforms including an eight-hour day, a minimum wage, and prohibition of child labor; and establishment of close relations with the United States, USSR, England (ed. should be the United Kingdom), and China, and positive opposition to any foreign influences interfering with the domestic affairs of the state.'"[
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People's_Republic_of_Korea#Program
 
With communists in charge of the north and a Russian army there....a well organized communist party in the south. You think that would have been a fair election. I do not.
Millions of Koreans across the length and breadth of the peninsula disagreed with your opinion. What right did the US have in 1945 to deny all Koreans the right to self-determination?
"Lyuh Woon-hyung or Yo Un-hyung (May 25, 1886 – July 19, 1947) was a Korean politician who argued that Korean independence was essential to world peace,:eek: and a reunification activist who struggled for the independent reunification of Korea since its national division in 1945."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyuh_Woon-hyung
 
Easy for you to say; however, things looked much better in North Korea in 1945:
"After the surrender of the Empire of Japan to the Allies, division at the 38th parallel marked the beginning of Soviet and American command over the North and South, respectively.

"U.S. forces landed at Incheon on September 8, 1945, and established a military government shortly thereafter.[9]

"The forces landing at Incheon were of the XXIV Corps of the U.S. Tenth Army.[10]

"They were commanded by Lt. General John R. Hodge, who then took charge of the government.[11] Four days before he arrived in Korea, Hodge told his officers that Korea 'was an enemy of the United States'.[2]

"On September 9, at a surrender ceremony, Hodge announced that the Japanese colonial government would remain intact, including its personnel and its governor-general. After a major outcry, Hodge replaced the governor-general with an American and removed all the Japanese bureau chiefs, though he, in turn, enlisted the former Japanese bureaucrats as advisors.[3]"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Military_Government_in_Korea#Background
At the same time in the north, Japanese bureaucrats were sent home, and all Koreans who collaborated with Japan's occupation were murdered. In the south, collaborators were welcomed into the police and military units being set up by US occupiers whose officers viewed Korea as "the enemy."

The comment attributed to General Hodge is not sourced....so it amounts to hearsay.

The fact was that Hodge arrived with a handful of Americans. We were completely unprepared for the number of refugees flowing south or the chaos as a result of the Japanese surrender. He used the Japanese to maintain the civil government and police forces...until his own division had moved into Korea.

In any case...it doesn't help you make your assertion that the US was to blame for the invasion in 1950.
 
Actually, it had more to do with religion than with economics by 1949. In 1945 a majority of Koreans would likely have supported PRK communists because communists fought against Japan's brutal occupation while rich capitalists collaborated with the Japanese. Are you of the opinion the US had the right to prevent all Koreans from exercising self-determination in 1945, or does your support for freedom extend only to those who adopt a capitalist economy?
"The program of the PRK was presented in its September 14 twenty-seven point program. The program included: 'the confiscation without compensation of lands held by the Japanese and collaborators; free distribution of that land to the peasants; rent limits on the non redistributed land; nationalization of such major industries as mining, transportation, banking, and communication; state supervision of small and mid-sized companies; …guaranteed basic human rights and freedoms, including those of speech, press, assembly, and faith; universal suffrage to adults over the age of eighteen; equality for women; labor law reforms including an eight-hour day, a minimum wage, and prohibition of child labor; and establishment of close relations with the United States, USSR, England (ed. should be the United Kingdom), and China, and positive opposition to any foreign influences interfering with the domestic affairs of the state.'"[
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People's_Republic_of_Korea#Program

Is it your opinion that the Soviets were right to keep the North Koreans from participating in the UN election in 1948? Do you think that there is freedom of speech today in North Korea? How about freedom of the press?
 
Congress not falling for Θ and GITMO

TOPIC
"A group of 19 retired U.S. generals and admirals on Thursday backed Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton's position on the U.S. military prison in Guantanamo and torture and called for an end to the 'dangerous rhetoric' from her Republican opponents.
http://www.newsweek.com/gitmo-isis-...o-bay-retired-generals-hillary-clinton-430558
"'The Republican candidates have turned this into a game to see who can seem toughest. Yet, how we combat our enemies and defeat ISIS is not a game, and these proposals would only make us weaker,' the retired officers said in a statement, using an acronym for Islamic State, the militant group active in Syria, Iraq and elsewhere."
The prison at Guantanamo should be closed and the land the base sits on returned to its rightful owners.
 
The fact was that Hodge arrived with a handful of Americans. We were completely unprepared for the number of refugees flowing south or the chaos as a result of the Japanese surrender. He used the Japanese to maintain the civil government and police forces...until his own division had moved into Korea.
Are you capable of grasping the concept the Koreans needed no help from the US in 1945 when it came to dealing with refugees or holding free election which would have likely been won by communists? That chaos began when the US military occupied South Korea in spite of the resistance of an overwhelming majority of Koreans.
 
Millions of Koreans across the length and breadth of the peninsula disagreed with your opinion. What right did the US have in 1945 to deny all Koreans the right to self-determination?
"Lyuh Woon-hyung or Yo Un-hyung (May 25, 1886 – July 19, 1947) was a Korean politician who argued that Korean independence was essential to world peace,:eek: and a reunification activist who struggled for the independent reunification of Korea since its national division in 1945."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyuh_Woon-hyung

The UN held elections in 1948. The Russians would not allow millions of Koreans to take part....that is the bottom line.
 
Back
Top