Bush inherited 9-11, the banking crisis, and an economy that had just experienced the dot com bust.
Actually, 9/11 didn't happen until Bush's ninth month in office, after an August he spent vacationing at his Texas mansion even as his security people were "running around with their hair on fire," the Hart-Rudman commission was calling for urgent security restructuring, and a PDB was telling Bush that Bin Laden was determined to strike in America. That's not something he inherited. Nor did he inherit a banking crisis. That crisis came in his seventh and eighth years in office. As for the dot-com bust, it's true that the NASDAQ had readjusted downward starting in March 2000, but the economy just kept on growing despite that. The unemployment rate ended 2000 at 3.9%, which was lower than it was before the dotcom bust, and the economy kept on growing, not hitting its peak until Bush's third month in office.
Reagan’s economy roared at times (including growth rates like 6.8% in 1984)
Yes, and at other times it shrunk faster than at any point since the Great Depression. If you want to give Reagan credit for stomach-churning economic volatility, so be it. But I'm not going to allow-you to cherry-pick just the stats you like. Taken as a whole, Reagan's economic growth rates were decent, but not great, and that was despite unprecedented peace-time stimulus in the form of the Fed vastly loosening money supply and the government indulging in massive deficit spending increases.
unemployment dropped from 10.8% at the height of the recession he inherited to 5.9% in 1989.
Reagan inherited a GROWING economy. You need to brush up on your economic history. The recession didn't start until his watch. And the 10.8% unemployment is something we didn't get until his third year in office.
During his Presidency, labor force participation rose.
Yes, just as it did under EVERY president between the 1950s and 2000, thanks to the influx of women into the work-force and the Baby Boomers moving into their peak working years.
en route to winning the Cold War
The Cold War outlasted the Reagan presidency by years. By the time it ended, Reagan was pooping in his diaper in California.
In doing that, Reagan unified the U.S. and won over Democrats.
Reagan bought political popularity in the traditional way: with handouts. He handed out big tax cuts to the rich, and increased government spending to everyone else, and left the bill for those who came later. Never before in history had that kind of massive deficit expansion happened in peacetime, and the results are just what you'd expect when a politician tells people they can have their cake and eat it too: he became fairly popular (not as popular, upon leaving office, as Clinton was, but still, pretty well liked).
(1) to be militarily reckless
I've never seen it argued that he was militarily reckless. Obviously, he pushed gigantic spending increases for the military, but he was militarily very cautious. In his eight years, the military highlights included a small action in a micro-country nobody had ever even heard of (Grenada), and a half-assed bombing run on Libya. You could argue he was the LEAST aggressive president, militarily, of the last five. We had more substantial engagements under Bush, Clinton, Bush, and Obama. In fact, Reagan's defining military moment was responding to the bombing of the Marine barracks in Lebanon not with the kind of escalation we'd expect to see today, but by pulling out entirely.
Overall, his was a mediocre presidency. But, one thing he was masterful at was self promotion. His Hollywood training gave him that. And, to this day, there are people who see not the facts of his years in office, but the fictional narrative he wanted them to see.