New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

One down....

Interesting. I see numbers broken down by racial groups, not as a whole. How were you able to diving "family income" for the entire country from that spreadsheet?
The very first chart is "All Races." In Excel, rows 7 through 73 have the data for all races. Column D has the median data in inflation-adjusted numbers. The subsequent tables then break it down by race. Starting on row 77 you have "white alone" on 92 starts "white, alone or in combination," on 165 starts non-hispanic whites, alone, 213 starts "black alone or in combination," etc.
 
The very first chart is "All Races." In Excel, rows 7 through 73 have the data for all races. Column D has the median data in inflation-adjusted numbers. The subsequent tables then break it down by race. Starting on row 77 you have "white alone" on 92 starts "white, alone or in combination," on 165 starts non-hispanic whites, alone, 213 starts "black alone or in combination," etc.

I see... it's a government chart and them putting "Race, Hispanic Origin and Year" over every section had me confused. Thanks.

Oh I am using Excel 2007 so it might not be displaying properly either.
 
If by "estimate" you mean "pull a number out of your butt without having to document the methodology," sure. But that's not how it works. They responded to criticisms about the failure to properly account for IP by coming up with an methodology for calculating it better, similar to the way they have methods for estimating other kinds of production, then they applied that method in the past and present to get their revised numbers. If you think their method is poor, feel free to offer a better one.



The case for official inflation being overestimated is much stronger, and is based on the official calculation comparing un-like products, by not even attempting to account for product improvements. Thus, even if it would have cost you millions of dollars to buy the equivalent of today's desktop computer just twenty years ago, in terms of equivalent capabilities, the official rate doesn't reflect that massive deflation. Instead, it pretends that today's desktop computer and yesterday's are equivalent products and compares their prices, just as if people were actually buying the same thing.



I know your right-wing websites have programmed you to regurgitate that "double seasonal adjustment" trope, and you're powerless to resist, but you look like an idiot when you do it in this context, because seasonal adjustments, whatever they might be, wash out in ANNUAL calculations. They merely result in seasonal numbers being higher or lower. If they artificially boost this Spring's numbers, they'll boost next Spring's numbers similarly, resulting in no net increase in annual growth.



You haven't even begun to grapple with the concept here. The question isn't whether those in the over-65 age group have higher or lower participation than those in the over-65 age group in some prior era. The question is one of population distribution. The Baby Boom demographic was in traditionally peak working years in the 1990s, and now they're in years where workforce participation traditionally declines fast.

That does not, of course, explain away all the issues with the workforce. We are genuinely under capacity right now, even after accounting for the demographic shift. And we could change that with some stimulus. But even with stimulus, we'd be foolish to expect we'd be getting up to the employment/population ratios we had in 2000, since the demographics have changed. We'd move in that direction, but would not get all the way there.



What makes you think I believe it will all stay within this continent? I"m sure some of the benefit will leak abroad, just as I'm sure some of their stimulus will benefit us. But the question is merely whether we'll be better off with the stimulus. Obviously, we will.


Trickle-down economics has failed every time it's been tried, most recently in the Bush years. I know that using your bizarre personal definitions of "supply-side," the demand-side policies of the Clinton years (which included big upper-class tax hikes) are supposed to be called "supply side," while the classic supply-side policies of Bush (which included big upper-class tax cuts) are not supposed to count as supply-side, but that's only because inventing a whole new eccentric lexicon is the only way for you to shelter your religious faith from the facts that supply-side failed miserably, whereas demand-side policies succeeded well.

Actually that is kind of how it works, but with a "methodology." No one I know of was complaining about a failure to adequately value the contribution of IP - it was captured the same way everything else is as cost of production. So adding an extra "adjustment" for the value of IP is arguably double counting it. And the "methodology" for their adjustments is looking at long term trends and extending them, even when the current data appears to suggest a change. And when the original adjustment isn't producing desired results, then they just assume the need to super adjust it to meet expectations, instead of evaluating if the trend makes sense any more. And there may not be any good way to measure economic output in a massive modern economy, which is why no one should rely to a great extent on just GDP and the "unemployment" rate like you do while ignoring other measures that indicate the optimistic measures of GDP and "unemployment" are likely not telling the whole economic story.

As for inflation, it's rather a simple argument - the old way of accounting for inflation was making the bureaucrats look bad so they came up with a new way of calculating it that produces a lower CPI:

http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/inflation-charts

Kind of like how they count "unemployment" and GDP (which have both undergone "alterations" in "methodology" to produce more bureaucratic friendly numbers).

I understand population distribution. I taught college level statistics back in the 80s. So yes, a lot of what's going on in the LFPR is unclear. Certainly there is some decrease in the overall LFPR that can be attributed to some baby boomers leaving the work force. But despite your attempts to suggest otherwise, that's not what is affecting the 25 to 54 year old cohort. It's declined and if baby boomers "retiring" was really involved in this cohort, the younger workers would be increasing their LFPR as they move into the jobs the baby boomers vacate and this LFPR would look more like it did before the recession (and it does not). And the reason we know this is stories like this:

http://www.theatlantic.com/business...der-to-get-started-than-it-used-to-be/395609/

Which, as usual, you claim "stimulus" would help, despite all the evidence that it has actually done more harm than good. What we need is reduced regulation and normalized interest rates, which will help with small business creation:

http://www.kauffman.org/what-we-do/...importance-of-young-firms-for-economic-growth

"(T)he question is merely whether we'll be better off with the stimulus. Obviously, we will."

We've added something like $60 trillion in debt worldwide since the financial crisis, and the global economy is still mired in near recession. So clearly it isn't working. So it's not really all that "obvious" that we would be better off with more of it. A good case has been made that all that debt has only pulled demand forward and keeps leading to lower levels of demand once the "stimulus" runs its course and we in fact would be much better off if we'd stop with all the "central planning" and just let the markets clear so we can get the economy growing organically again.

And "trickle down" is not the same as "supply side" as I have repeatedly shown you. Clinton's economic policies were definitely "supply side" without being "trickle down." Bush's economic policies were Keynesian and "trickle down" as are the Fed's attempts to create economic lift off through the "Wealth Effect" of elevated asset prices. "Supply side" economics is merely understanding that government central planning doesn't work, nor does a generous attitude toward entitlements (many studies have documented workers waiting until their unemployment runs out to begin in earnest to look for work). It also focuses on creating an economic environment that is conducive to new business creation, which no amount of "stimulus" (either fiscal or monetary) is going to overcome. We need a stable currency, less regulation and more streamlined tax policies. Cutting the size of government is clearly a part of a lower tax, more (productive) investment friendly economic environment. Why you keep arguing for the opposite in spite of all the evidence I provide that disputes your arguments quite frankly calls into question your analytical and logical abilities.
 
I see... it's a government chart and them putting "Race, Hispanic Origin and Year" over every section had me confused. Thanks.

Oh I am using Excel 2007 so it might not be displaying properly either.
There are a whole bunch of spreadsheets,some of which provide breakdowns by age, or family type, etc., which is why that confusing heading is there. I just happened to pull up the one that includes the breakdowns by race, but since it starts with all races combined, it serves.
 
No one I know of was complaining about a failure to adequately value the contribution of IP

Understood. I'm assuming Tyler Durden was obsessed with other questions. What you need to do is branch out beyond those who see economics as merely a field for playing the game of partisan politics, and read those who see it more as a science where we're trying to get the best possible understanding of what is actually happening, instead of merely churning out propaganda. Tyler's not going to get you there.

http://www.quora.com/Is-GDP-a-good-measure-of-economic-growth-Why-or-why-not

I taught college level statistics back in the 80s. So yes, a lot of what's going on in the LFPR is unclear.

Did you suffer some sort of blow to the head or debilitating cerebral disease since then?

But despite your attempts to suggest otherwise, that's not what is affecting the 25 to 54 year old cohort.

Obviously, a 25-54 age cohort is much too broad to be useful in assessing that question, since traditional LFPR rates vary dramatically across that age range. Because of that variation, if the bulk of those in the age range used to be in the middle of the range (with traditionally high LFPR), and now they're at the top end (where LFPR traditionally starts to decline), then they'd drive down the LFPR of the group as a whole.

We've added something like $60 trillion in debt worldwide since the financial crisis

Debt merely moves money from one place to another. It should only be expected to stimulate to the extent it moves money from those who'd be less likely to spend it to those who would be more likely to spend it. That's what happens at a time when the private sector is too skittish to get on the sidelines and the government increases its borrowing in order to finance increased public sector spending. But measuring total global debt tells you nothing about that.=

Clinton's economic policies were definitely "supply side" without being "trickle down."

Clinton raised taxes, especially on the rich, which is exactly the opposite of what the supply-siders were calling for. Bush cut taxes, especially on the rich, which is what the supply-siders were calling for. You're attempting to substitute your own eccentric definition for the term in place of the way it's generally used. But, if you want to emulate Clinton's "supply side" policy, I'm up for it: we should then raise taxes, especially on the rich, while returning government spending to a more positive level, where real growth is about twice population growth. We can also refocus on worker protections, with more innovations like FMLA.
 
Did you know that the average unemployment rate under every single Republican presidency, going at least back to Hoover, has been higher than the baseline rate that president inherited? Did you know that eras of Democratic presidential leadership fair better, in average economic terms, than Republican ones when it comes to nearly every single major economic indicator?

As I've mentioned, I'm a high-information guy. I draw my political beliefs from a study of what happens in the real world. From that perspective, the world looks very different than it does for someone who starts with a quasi-religious embrace of right-wing economics and cherry picks facts that happen to line up with that dogma.
Oh, c'mon now. Obama has a close to 11% unemployment rate; he keeps on shrinking the workforce to achieve the lie that it's 5% for low information voters such as yourself. Hoover was a tax and spend liberal, the fact that he was a Republican not withstanding. Bush had close to 5% for most of his presidency, even in the face of 9-11. Then disastrous liberal (even the poor should own a home) democrat policies crashed the market. Too many sub prime loans (which came out of the Clinton administration.)

Reagan was the greatest president of the modern era, once he converted to conservatism, from Democrat communism. Inherited a much crappier economy and the foreign policy weakness of Carter who wouldn't back the Shah of Iran. Our idiot in chief caused many of the problems there now using the same crappy foreign policy.


The US has the highest corporate tax rate in the industrialized world at 35%. If you were a CEO and had a fiduciary agreement to you shareholders what would you do? Hell Obama even wants to double tax corporations, something that no other country does.
Left wing socialism does not prosperity make, and communism is even worse. Right now the difference between Democrats and socialists is that the Democrat party is to the left of socialism, drawing ever closer to Marxism.

Vote Democrat if you want washed up old Democrats cow towing to the worst aspects of Society, by balkanizing it.
 
Ok, I did so. I don't see.



What makes you think that? We've had a shrinking of government spending in the Obama years -- the first such shrinkage over a period this long in a few generations, at least. Are the results what you expected?
Common sense makes me know that. A dollar taken from the private sector is one less dollar to invest, expand, start a business, and hire. Taxes under Obama are the highest ever once you consider the hidden taxes and fees in his policies and regulations plus obamacare. And the Democrats want to raise them even more. That's why we have the largest amount of people living in poverty ever. And especially blacks are getting the shaft.

If it wasn't for the media sniffing his throne, people might get an accurate picture. Oh yeah, and Obama has spent more than any other president to date
 
Oh, c'mon now. Obama has a close to 11% unemployment rate

Incorrect. If you'd like to discuss this in an intelligent manner, it would be good if you first familiarized yourself with the basic facts. The unemployment rate is 5.1%, which is lower than it ever was in the Reagan years.

Bush had close to 5% for most of his presidency, even in the face of 9-11.

Bush inherited an unemployment rate of 3.9% (if you use December 2000 as the baseline). We never saw that rate again, even once, in his presidency. The rate was up over the 5% threshold in September of 2001, didn't come back down below it under December 2005, and was back up over it again starting in December 2007. And that's despite the plummeting of LFPR on his watch (a phenomenon the mindless right-wingers never noticed until their media handlers programmed them to repeat it endlessly once Obama took office).

Reagan was the greatest president of the modern era

He was a scrub. He couldn't even manage the job creation rate of Carter, and despite mountains of artificial stimulus, in the form of an unprecedented increase in peace-time deficits and a huge Fed cut in interest rates, median incomes barely improved and the poverty rate ended his time in office right where it started it. And, as I mentioned, his average unemployment rate was higher than the rate he inherited).

The US has the highest corporate tax rate in the industrialized world at 35%.

Our effective corporate tax rates are lower than the OECD average. We have a high nominal rate, but we make it very easy for corporations to avoid paying.

Right now the difference between Democrats and socialists is that the Democrat party is to the left of socialism, drawing ever closer to Marxism.

Democrats remain a center-right party, but viewed from the extreme angle of your own far-right perspective, I guess it must look very different.
 
Taxes under Obama are the highest ever once you consider the hidden taxes and fees in his policies and regulations plus obamacare.

Do you know what federal revenues as a share of GDP were in 2000? Do you know what they are today? Educate yourself if you want to discuss these topics intelligently.
 
The right-wing kooks have been accusing her of crimes since 1992 -- as they ALWAYS accuse every prominent Democrat of crimes. But, so far, despite spending tends of millions of dollars on trying to make one of their charges stick, and despite a full-scale witch-hunt under a crazed prosecutor named Starr, they've yet to back up anything they've claimed. Then they act surprised that nobody serious listens to them any more.
That's because she and most prominent Democrats are criminals. The reason Clinton has not been prosecuted is that the Obama administration does not prosecute Liberal criminals.
 
Last edited:
Incorrect. If you'd like to discuss this in an intelligent manner, it would be good if you first familiarized yourself with the basic facts. The unemployment rate is 5.1%, which is lower than it ever was in the Reagan years.



Bush inherited an unemployment rate of 3.9% (if you use December 2000 as the baseline). We never saw that rate again, even once, in his presidency. The rate was up over the 5% threshold in September of 2001, didn't come back down below it under December 2005, and was back up over it again starting in December 2007. And that's despite the plummeting of LFPR on his watch (a phenomenon the mindless right-wingers never noticed until their media handlers programmed them to repeat it endlessly once Obama took office).



He was a scrub. He couldn't even manage the job creation rate of Carter, and despite mountains of artificial stimulus, in the form of an unprecedented increase in peace-time deficits and a huge Fed cut in interest rates, median incomes barely improved and the poverty rate ended his time in office right where it started it. And, as I mentioned, his average unemployment rate was higher than the rate he inherited).



Our effective corporate tax rates are lower than the OECD average. We have a high nominal rate, but we make it very easy for corporations to avoid paying.



Democrats remain a center-right party, but viewed from the extreme angle of your own far-right perspective, I guess it must look very different.
You are full of shit on all counts. if yours is not a case of cognitive dissonance and you truly believe what you have posted here then you are seriously mentally disturbed and deficient. What you have posted is bald-faced lies.
 
Really? What, specifically was wrong in what I said? Deficits have fallen by half, as I said. The stock market surged ahead, as I said. Unemployment is way down, as I said. The incarceration rate has started to decline for the first time in decades, as I said. The share of Americans covered by health insurance has risen sharply, as I said.

The only arguably wrong item is the claim that we're out of Iraq, since we still have some presence there. But there's a gigantic difference between our current minor presence there (three GIs killed in all of 2015), and what was going on in the Bush years (as many as 904 GIs killed in a single year).
Do you even understand what the deficit is? Here is an analogy of how Obama has lowered the deficit: Ie: A crook is stealing a thousand dollars a month and spending 2 thousand dollars a month. He has a thousand dollar deficit. So he starts stealing fifteen hundred dollars a month and lowers his deficit by half. That's how Obama has lowered the deficit, by stealing more money from the American taxpayer, not by lowering spending as is the proper way but by stealing more money.
 
Do you even understand what the deficit is? Here is an analogy of how Obama has lowered the deficit: Ie: A crook is stealing a thousand dollars a month and spending 2 thousand dollars a month. He has a thousand dollar deficit. So he starts stealing fifteen hundred dollars a month and lowers his deficit by half. That's how Obama has lowered the deficit, by stealing more money from the American taxpayer, not by lowering spending as is the proper way but by stealing more money.
The way the deficit was lowered was the same way it's always lowered: by tilting the revenues/expenses ratio more in the direction of revenues. When Bush left office, we were collective vastly insufficient revenues to cover our expenses. Now revenues are still less than expenses, but they're close enough that we're in a position to grow our way out of debt (along the lines of what we did every year between 1946 and 1981, before Reagan screwed that up with his idiotic tax cuts for the rich).
 
Additionally, output at the fairy dust factory is up 30%, and the unicorn population has risen by 20%. Yay!
I'm citing the actual unemployment rate, as confirmed by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. You're making up numbers to try to distract from facts you find uncomfortable.
 
I'm citing the actual unemployment rate, as confirmed by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. You're making up numbers to try to distract from facts you find uncomfortable.

And if the BLS told you that wolverines make good house pets, undoubtedly you would believe that, too. At least as long as a Democrat is in the White House, of course.
 
Understood. I'm assuming Tyler Durden was obsessed with other questions. What you need to do is branch out beyond those who see economics as merely a field for playing the game of partisan politics, and read those who see it more as a science where we're trying to get the best possible understanding of what is actually happening, instead of merely churning out propaganda. Tyler's not going to get you there.

http://www.quora.com/Is-GDP-a-good-measure-of-economic-growth-Why-or-why-not



Did you suffer some sort of blow to the head or debilitating cerebral disease since then?



Obviously, a 25-54 age cohort is much too broad to be useful in assessing that question, since traditional LFPR rates vary dramatically across that age range. Because of that variation, if the bulk of those in the age range used to be in the middle of the range (with traditionally high LFPR), and now they're at the top end (where LFPR traditionally starts to decline), then they'd drive down the LFPR of the group as a whole.



Debt merely moves money from one place to another. It should only be expected to stimulate to the extent it moves money from those who'd be less likely to spend it to those who would be more likely to spend it. That's what happens at a time when the private sector is too skittish to get on the sidelines and the government increases its borrowing in order to finance increased public sector spending. But measuring total global debt tells you nothing about that.=



Clinton raised taxes, especially on the rich, which is exactly the opposite of what the supply-siders were calling for. Bush cut taxes, especially on the rich, which is what the supply-siders were calling for. You're attempting to substitute your own eccentric definition for the term in place of the way it's generally used. But, if you want to emulate Clinton's "supply side" policy, I'm up for it: we should then raise taxes, especially on the rich, while returning government spending to a more positive level, where real growth is about twice population growth. We can also refocus on worker protections, with more innovations like FMLA.

I don't only use "Durden" (which by the way includes dozens of other writers who aren't hiding behind the pseudonym) the way you only use Krugman. And it's NOT "science" it's sociology coupled with math. I understand way more about it than your myopia will allow you to admit. You keep preaching in favor of an economic approach that has totally failed throughout the past decade. Some people would be embarrassed to do so, but you apparently do not understand economics to know how big a fool you are making of yourself (don't feel bad - Krugman does understand economics and yet doesn't know how big a fool he is making of himself).

Yeah, thanks for the elucidation, but like I said, I get the LFPR nuance. I notice you sidestepped the issue about if it was really older workers in their 50s "retiring early" then there would be no employment crisis in the millenial generation, as they'd be snapping up those jobs rather than sitting around the house and telling researchers they can't find jobs. Oh well, whatever you can't explain away with a Krugman quote you must feel the need to avoid.

"Debt merely moves money from one place to another."

Wrong! Apparently you do not understand that debt creates money. It also creates a liability, but what it doesn't always do is create an asset. Sometimes it just inflates the price of an existing asset. This is how bubbles are born and why more debt isn't the answer to a debt problem. Learn how the economy works and maybe you will be able to fare better in our exchanges.

It's not and "eccentric definition" it is a fact! Government Spending = Taxes (current + deferred). When I challenged you to disprove it all you came up with is the notion that the government could sell assets or default. No one buying the debt of the USA is under the impression that either of those options is in the mix for repayment. No one is suggesting government can spend all it wants because we can simply default on the debt. These are the ravings of a mad man (or a Keynesian, but what's the difference, eh?).

And as usual you completely misread the policy adjustments needed to return to Clinton style "supply sidism." You think growing the government from it's largest ever real per capita levels is part of the equation:

Screen Shot 2015-09-15 at 1.24.43 PM.png
It's got a long way to go (down) before we're in the same area of tax burden per capita as we had when Clinton was in office. And then there's the regulations:

Screen Shot 2015-09-15 at 1.27.01 PM.png
 
I notice you sidestepped the issue about if it was really older workers in their 50s "retiring early" then there would be no employment crisis in the millenial generation, as they'd be snapping up those jobs rather than sitting around the house and telling researchers they can't find jobs.

There's no honest question that older workers in their 50s will be moving away from the labor force, relative to the ratios in their 40s. It has always been that way, and it would be very strange, indeed, if these days a 55-year-old were just as likely to be in the labor force as a 45-year-old, contrary to all precedent. So there's no point in framing this as an "if." It's simply a fact -- some of the fall of LFPR is attributable to a demographic bulge that's moving into older age categories, including those in their early 50s.

But, as to your point, yes, it's true that if the economy were at full capacity, we'd expect lower unemployment rates among Millenials, as departing Boomers created an 'updraft' in the job market, ultimately leaving more spaces at the bottom for Millenials. I've never denied that part of what is going on is that the economy is depressed. In fact, that is absolutely critical for my point. If we were at full-employment, my idea that we need more government stimulus would make no sense. All that would do is set the government to competing with the private sector in a zero-sum game, and the only way we could push down unemployment at all would be by triggering run-away inflation. My whole policy recommendation relies on the idea that some of what is going on is more than just the demographics of Boomers retiring from the job market -- it relies on the idea that we are stuck well under capacity and can be brought up close to capacity if government will get the ball rolling.

That said, two quick points:

(1) We shouldn't expect every departing Boomer to be replaced instantly. There's always a gap in replacing skilled workers, and the Boomers will tend to be the most skilled and experienced workers in the workforce. If there's a mass exodus of them from the work force, it should be expected to overwhelm the market for a time, leaving a persistent gap between supply of workers and demand. That'll hit Millenials particularly hard, since they're effectively at the end of a long chain of career steps away from the Boomers. Picture trying to get out of your driveway when there's a back-up of cars on the road in front of it. There's going to be a delay between when that first car in the line moves and when there's space for you to come in, because there's a delay at each step, which add together. When you're at the far end of a long chain, the delay can take a long time-- the front of the line of cars can be moving for quite a while while the back sits motionless. But, again, I don't think that's all that's going on here (if I did, I wouldn't recommend stimulus, since it won't make the conveyor belt move any faster).

(2) We need to consider the impact on the economy not only of Boomers stepping out of the labor force, but also of them stepping back their role in consumption. Retirees typically spend less than workers. If we have more people who are retirees, that represents less demand for goods and services, and that'll make it harder to get unemployment down, since it'll mean it's easier than before to meet demand with existing workers, rather than staffing up.

Wrong! Apparently you do not understand that debt creates money.

You misunderstand, as always. Let's say you and I each have $1000. You agree to mow my lawn, in exchange for a $20 IOU from me. How much money do we collectively have now? Still $2000. The debt didn't create any money. It increased your worth relative to mine, by the value of that $20 IOU, but there was an exactly offsetting $20 of decline in my worth.

It's not and "eccentric definition" it is a fact!

It's Lukey-language: your own invented set of terminology that calls demand-side economics supply-side, because that's the only way to square what you know worked with what your faith tells you ought to have worked.

Government Spending = Taxes (current + deferred)

As you know, we've debunked that false equation repeatedly.
 
There's no honest question that older workers in their 50s will be moving away from the labor force, relative to the ratios in their 40s. It has always been that way, and it would be very strange, indeed, if these days a 55-year-old were just as likely to be in the labor force as a 45-year-old, contrary to all precedent. So there's no point in framing this as an "if." It's simply a fact -- some of the fall of LFPR is attributable to a demographic bulge that's moving into older age categories, including those in their early 50s.

But, as to your point, yes, it's true that if the economy were at full capacity, we'd expect lower unemployment rates among Millenials, as departing Boomers created an 'updraft' in the job market, ultimately leaving more spaces at the bottom for Millenials. I've never denied that part of what is going on is that the economy is depressed. In fact, that is absolutely critical for my point. If we were at full-employment, my idea that we need more government stimulus would make no sense. All that would do is set the government to competing with the private sector in a zero-sum game, and the only way we could push down unemployment at all would be by triggering run-away inflation. My whole policy recommendation relies on the idea that some of what is going on is more than just the demographics of Boomers retiring from the job market -- it relies on the idea that we are stuck well under capacity and can be brought up close to capacity if government will get the ball rolling.

That said, two quick points:

(1) We shouldn't expect every departing Boomer to be replaced instantly. There's always a gap in replacing skilled workers, and the Boomers will tend to be the most skilled and experienced workers in the workforce. If there's a mass exodus of them from the work force, it should be expected to overwhelm the market for a time, leaving a persistent gap between supply of workers and demand. That'll hit Millenials particularly hard, since they're effectively at the end of a long chain of career steps away from the Boomers. Picture trying to get out of your driveway when there's a back-up of cars on the road in front of it. There's going to be a delay between when that first car in the line moves and when there's space for you to come in, because there's a delay at each step, which add together. When you're at the far end of a long chain, the delay can take a long time-- the front of the line of cars can be moving for quite a while while the back sits motionless. But, again, I don't think that's all that's going on here (if I did, I wouldn't recommend stimulus, since it won't make the conveyor belt move any faster).

(2) We need to consider the impact on the economy not only of Boomers stepping out of the labor force, but also of them stepping back their role in consumption. Retirees typically spend less than workers. If we have more people who are retirees, that represents less demand for goods and services, and that'll make it harder to get unemployment down, since it'll mean it's easier than before to meet demand with existing workers, rather than staffing up.



You misunderstand, as always. Let's say you and I each have $1000. You agree to mow my lawn, in exchange for a $20 IOU from me. How much money do we collectively have now? Still $2000. The debt didn't create any money. It increased your worth relative to mine, by the value of that $20 IOU, but there was an exactly offsetting $20 of decline in my worth.



It's Lukey-language: your own invented set of terminology that calls demand-side economics supply-side, because that's the only way to square what you know worked with what your faith tells you ought to have worked.



As you know, we've debunked that false equation repeatedly.

Baby boomers are reported to be holding onto their jobs longer than previous generations, so while they may have some effect on LFPR it isn't as much as you claim it is. In fact, it is widely reported only a little over half of baby boomers even have any retirement savings, and only about 25% claim they have "enough." And a third plan to work to 70 (at least). So your scenario where hundreds of thousands of baby boomers in their early 50s are voluntarily walking away from the workforce is just not comporting with the facts.

Also, the vast majority of jobs do not require 30 years of experience to do (maybe 10% do) and those are the best jobs (like mine) and I'm not leaving until I'm well over seventy (or dead) so no one is walking away from those. So your "conveyor belt" analogy, while imaginative, is complete crap. And, as usual, you want it both ways, claiming that the LFPR declining is "just baby boomers retiring" so it's no "big deal" and then turn around and agree that too many young people can't find jobs but then claim it is because "government just isn't spending enough" when, in fact, it is spending more now than it ever did (on average during Obama's Administration). Your math doesn't work! I showed you why they aren't finding jobs plentiful:

http://www.kauffman.org/what-we-do/...importance-of-young-firms-for-economic-growth

You claim to love research but the Kauffman Foundation's is of no interest to you. Interesting, since you suggest I'm the one who has the "closed loop" source of information. It's clear that the economy needs more PRIVATE SECTOR growth with respect to new firm creation, as we are well below historical levels in that respect. Bigger government isn't going to help with that or we'd see the effects from all the government spending we have going on now. Your logic is flawed.

As is your debt example. I'm not talking about IOUs - I'm talking about commercial and investment bank created loans (which is, lets face it, the bulk of borrowing). And when banks loan money in a fractional reserve system they are typically creating new money. It's just how it works:

http://www.investopedia.com/ask/ans...al-banks-us-money-multiplier-create-money.asp

https://rwer.wordpress.com/2015/01/...bly-shows-banks-create-money-out-of-thin-air/

And it isn't "Lukey language" it's logic - unless the government is seriously considering default when they issue the debt, their intention is to (eventually) repay it via taxation. And even if the intention is to just keep rolling it over and never repay it, there is still, as long as the debt is growing, a perception that taxes will need to be raised in response to a rising debt service component of the federal budget. It is "rational expectations," which is a widely acknowledged economic principle. It may not be universal, or work the same way in every instance, but rational economically successful people are usually bright enough to put two and two together and get four (unlike Keynesians). So no, you have not "debunked" that equation...at all.
 
Baby boomers are reported to be holding onto their jobs longer than previous generations, so while they may have some effect on LFPR it isn't as much as you claim it is.

How much do I claim it is, exactly? Be specific, please.
 
Back
Top