Arkady
President
There's been a rise of people on disability in recent years, with some conservatives seeing it as a sign of rising levels of shirking, as opposed to actual disability. I'm not so sure. With the population getting both older and fatter, we'd expect genuine disability to be on the rise. However, it occurred to me we might check that theory by looking for where disability is highest, and seeing if it's consistent with that model -- is it, in fact, most prevalent in areas of high obesity and high median age?
Here's the data by state:
https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/statcomps/ssi_sc/2014/table01.html
If you take the disabled column and divide it by each state's population, here are the states where disability is most common:
West Virginia,
Kentucky
Mississippi,
Louisiana,
Arkansas
At a glance, the way WV and KY top the list suggests coal mining might be driving some of it. The list isn't at all consistent with the age theory, since West Virginia is the only one of those that's got an unusually high median age. However, obesity does seem like a likely explanation. Here's where they rank for obesity:
West Virginia, 2
Kentucky, 7
Mississippi, 1
Louisiana, 4
Arkansas, 8
At the least-disabled end of the list, here are the states and their obesity rankings:
UT, 43
ND, 29
WY, 32
CO, 47
NV, 35
So, that looks like a plausible factor. It's not so much that the culture has shifted to encourage more shirking, as just the fact people are so fat now that they're more likely to suffer the kinds of conditions that prevent working.
Some of the obesity problem is genetic, and some probably has to do with immutable aspects of geography (obesity tends to be less common at altitude, for some reason). But policy can make a difference, as well. If we want to reduce the cost of disability to the taxpayer, we ought to think about ways to get obesity under control.
Here's the data by state:
https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/statcomps/ssi_sc/2014/table01.html
If you take the disabled column and divide it by each state's population, here are the states where disability is most common:
West Virginia,
Kentucky
Mississippi,
Louisiana,
Arkansas
At a glance, the way WV and KY top the list suggests coal mining might be driving some of it. The list isn't at all consistent with the age theory, since West Virginia is the only one of those that's got an unusually high median age. However, obesity does seem like a likely explanation. Here's where they rank for obesity:
West Virginia, 2
Kentucky, 7
Mississippi, 1
Louisiana, 4
Arkansas, 8
At the least-disabled end of the list, here are the states and their obesity rankings:
UT, 43
ND, 29
WY, 32
CO, 47
NV, 35
So, that looks like a plausible factor. It's not so much that the culture has shifted to encourage more shirking, as just the fact people are so fat now that they're more likely to suffer the kinds of conditions that prevent working.
Some of the obesity problem is genetic, and some probably has to do with immutable aspects of geography (obesity tends to be less common at altitude, for some reason). But policy can make a difference, as well. If we want to reduce the cost of disability to the taxpayer, we ought to think about ways to get obesity under control.