New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

People on Disability

Arkady

President
There's been a rise of people on disability in recent years, with some conservatives seeing it as a sign of rising levels of shirking, as opposed to actual disability. I'm not so sure. With the population getting both older and fatter, we'd expect genuine disability to be on the rise. However, it occurred to me we might check that theory by looking for where disability is highest, and seeing if it's consistent with that model -- is it, in fact, most prevalent in areas of high obesity and high median age?

Here's the data by state:

https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/statcomps/ssi_sc/2014/table01.html

If you take the disabled column and divide it by each state's population, here are the states where disability is most common:

West Virginia,
Kentucky
Mississippi,
Louisiana,
Arkansas

At a glance, the way WV and KY top the list suggests coal mining might be driving some of it. The list isn't at all consistent with the age theory, since West Virginia is the only one of those that's got an unusually high median age. However, obesity does seem like a likely explanation. Here's where they rank for obesity:

West Virginia, 2
Kentucky, 7
Mississippi, 1
Louisiana, 4
Arkansas, 8

At the least-disabled end of the list, here are the states and their obesity rankings:

UT, 43
ND, 29
WY, 32
CO, 47
NV, 35

So, that looks like a plausible factor. It's not so much that the culture has shifted to encourage more shirking, as just the fact people are so fat now that they're more likely to suffer the kinds of conditions that prevent working.

Some of the obesity problem is genetic, and some probably has to do with immutable aspects of geography (obesity tends to be less common at altitude, for some reason). But policy can make a difference, as well. If we want to reduce the cost of disability to the taxpayer, we ought to think about ways to get obesity under control.
 
One way to get obesity and other health costs under control: have people pay for the risk factors that have significant control over. I'll rattle off a few:

Riding a motorcycle
Riding a motorcycle without a helmet
smoking and other tobacco use
obesity
risky sports (that definition can be honed at a later discussion, I think you get the point)

Also, the southern diet is HORRIBLE! The American diet overall is bad enough, but southern cooking is the worse of the worse.
 
Thanks for another useless navel gaze. Do you know anyone on SSDI? I do - my tenant who lost her sales job in her mid-50s and got herself certified as too "clinically depressed" to look for work. She sure seems to have no trouble taking care of the 15 acre farm she rents from me, or going on long walks with her dogs, etc.
 
There's been a rise of people on disability in recent years, with some conservatives seeing it as a sign of rising levels of shirking, as opposed to actual disability. I'm not so sure. With the population getting both older and fatter, we'd expect genuine disability to be on the rise. However, it occurred to me we might check that theory by looking for where disability is highest, and seeing if it's consistent with that model -- is it, in fact, most prevalent in areas of high obesity and high median age?

Here's the data by state:

https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/statcomps/ssi_sc/2014/table01.html

If you take the disabled column and divide it by each state's population, here are the states where disability is most common:

West Virginia,
Kentucky
Mississippi,
Louisiana,
Arkansas

At a glance, the way WV and KY top the list suggests coal mining might be driving some of it. The list isn't at all consistent with the age theory, since West Virginia is the only one of those that's got an unusually high median age. However, obesity does seem like a likely explanation. Here's where they rank for obesity:

West Virginia, 2
Kentucky, 7
Mississippi, 1
Louisiana, 4
Arkansas, 8

At the least-disabled end of the list, here are the states and their obesity rankings:

UT, 43
ND, 29
WY, 32
CO, 47
NV, 35

So, that looks like a plausible factor. It's not so much that the culture has shifted to encourage more shirking, as just the fact people are so fat now that they're more likely to suffer the kinds of conditions that prevent working.

Some of the obesity problem is genetic, and some probably has to do with immutable aspects of geography (obesity tends to be less common at altitude, for some reason). But policy can make a difference, as well. If we want to reduce the cost of disability to the taxpayer, we ought to think about ways to get obesity under control.

When Americans couldn't find JOBs in the 'Hope & Change' Θ failure, of course their next option was Disability and they went for it. Perfectly healthy and able bodied people drawing Disability, they are easily seen when out and about.

Hell, appears with all the time you have to do nothing but type, you may be on Disability as well? You sure prove to be one bored human!
 
One way to get obesity and other health costs under control: have people pay for the risk factors that have significant control over. I'll rattle off a few:

Riding a motorcycle
Riding a motorcycle without a helmet
smoking and other tobacco use
obesity
risky sports (that definition can be honed at a later discussion, I think you get the point)

Also, the southern diet is HORRIBLE! The American diet overall is bad enough, but southern cooking is the worse of the worse.

More obesity people in Northern cities than in my South kitchen.........☻
 
Thanks for another useless navel gaze. Do you know anyone on SSDI? I do - my tenant who lost her sales job in her mid-50s and got herself certified as too "clinically depressed" to look for work. She sure seems to have no trouble taking care of the 15 acre farm she rents from me, or going on long walks with her dogs, etc.

Sounds like someone that lives close to me, lost his job and goes for 'bad-back' and gets Disability, he just built himself a small barn.......it's a miracle!
 
There's been a rise of people on disability in recent years, with some conservatives seeing it as a sign of rising levels of shirking, as opposed to actual disability. I'm not so sure. With the population getting both older and fatter, we'd expect genuine disability to be on the rise. However, it occurred to me we might check that theory by looking for where disability is highest, and seeing if it's consistent with that model -- is it, in fact, most prevalent in areas of high obesity and high median age?

Here's the data by state:

https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/statcomps/ssi_sc/2014/table01.html

If you take the disabled column and divide it by each state's population, here are the states where disability is most common:

West Virginia,
Kentucky
Mississippi,
Louisiana,
Arkansas

At a glance, the way WV and KY top the list suggests coal mining might be driving some of it. The list isn't at all consistent with the age theory, since West Virginia is the only one of those that's got an unusually high median age. However, obesity does seem like a likely explanation. Here's where they rank for obesity:

West Virginia, 2
Kentucky, 7
Mississippi, 1
Louisiana, 4
Arkansas, 8

At the least-disabled end of the list, here are the states and their obesity rankings:

UT, 43
ND, 29
WY, 32
CO, 47
NV, 35

So, that looks like a plausible factor. It's not so much that the culture has shifted to encourage more shirking, as just the fact people are so fat now that they're more likely to suffer the kinds of conditions that prevent working.

Some of the obesity problem is genetic, and some probably has to do with immutable aspects of geography (obesity tends to be less common at altitude, for some reason). But policy can make a difference, as well. If we want to reduce the cost of disability to the taxpayer, we ought to think about ways to get obesity under control.

I don't understand why you waste your time on these silly "analyses" just to denigrate Southerners. Especially considering that you're going to vote for one in November...
 
There's been a rise of people on disability in recent years, with some conservatives seeing it as a sign of rising levels of shirking, as opposed to actual disability. I'm not so sure. With the population getting both older and fatter, we'd expect genuine disability to be on the rise. However, it occurred to me we might check that theory by looking for where disability is highest, and seeing if it's consistent with that model -- is it, in fact, most prevalent in areas of high obesity and high median age?

Here's the data by state:

https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/statcomps/ssi_sc/2014/table01.html

If you take the disabled column and divide it by each state's population, here are the states where disability is most common:

West Virginia,
Kentucky
Mississippi,
Louisiana,
Arkansas

At a glance, the way WV and KY top the list suggests coal mining might be driving some of it. The list isn't at all consistent with the age theory, since West Virginia is the only one of those that's got an unusually high median age. However, obesity does seem like a likely explanation. Here's where they rank for obesity:

West Virginia, 2
Kentucky, 7
Mississippi, 1
Louisiana, 4
Arkansas, 8

At the least-disabled end of the list, here are the states and their obesity rankings:

UT, 43
ND, 29
WY, 32
CO, 47
NV, 35

So, that looks like a plausible factor. It's not so much that the culture has shifted to encourage more shirking, as just the fact people are so fat now that they're more likely to suffer the kinds of conditions that prevent working.

Some of the obesity problem is genetic, and some probably has to do with immutable aspects of geography (obesity tends to be less common at altitude, for some reason). But policy can make a difference, as well. If we want to reduce the cost of disability to the taxpayer, we ought to think about ways to get obesity under control.

How about people are obese in the FIRST place BECAUSE they're "shirking"?

I mean... let's imagine they got no jobs, got nothing to do all day but sit on the couch and eat cheap crap... you think THAT might contribute to obesity?

I KNOW it does. There's not a doubt in my mind.
 
How about people are obese in the FIRST place BECAUSE they're "shirking"?

I mean... let's imagine they got no jobs, got nothing to do all day but sit on the couch and eat cheap crap... you think THAT might contribute to obesity?

I KNOW it does. There's not a doubt in my mind.

Food Stamps cause of obesity
 
One way to get obesity and other health costs under control: have people pay for the risk factors that have significant control over. I'll rattle off a few:

Riding a motorcycle
Riding a motorcycle without a helmet
smoking and other tobacco use
obesity
risky sports (that definition can be honed at a later discussion, I think you get the point)

Also, the southern diet is HORRIBLE! The American diet overall is bad enough, but southern cooking is the worse of the worse.
It's an interesting idea.

At least with regard to some of those, it wouldn't be so hard to implement even in concert with Affordable Care -- for example, Affordable Care has subsidies for low-income coverage... in theory you could increase or decrease the subsidies based on various risky behaviors.

Diet is probably the biggest factor, but also the toughest to deal with. How do you make people pay for high-risk diets? In theory you could do it by way of some sort of surtax for junk food, but that would be "rough justice" at best. For example, pasta might be junk food for a couch potato and very healthy fuel for a dedicated runner. Chicken might be extremely healthy if boiled, and an absolute artery-buster if deep fried.

I suppose the other way to go about it is to just measure outcomes rather than inputs -- you're either fat or not, and how you got there is your own business. But there, too, there'd be injustices in individual cases. If someone is overweight because of a genetic predisposition, it's rough to essentially fine him for that, when he may eat better and exercise more than an average person.
 
Thanks for another useless navel gaze. Do you know anyone on SSDI? I do - my tenant who lost her sales job in her mid-50s and got herself certified as too "clinically depressed" to look for work. She sure seems to have no trouble taking care of the 15 acre farm she rents from me, or going on long walks with her dogs, etc.
I only know one non-elderly person who doesn't work, due to disability -- a cop who got injured in an on-the-job car accident.

Anyway, obesity is also a risk factor in depression, so if we could bring our obesity epidemic under control, depression-related disability should also become rarer.
 
It's an interesting idea.

At least with regard to some of those, it wouldn't be so hard to implement even in concert with Affordable Care -- for example, Affordable Care has subsidies for low-income coverage... in theory you could increase or decrease the subsidies based on various risky behaviors.

Diet is probably the biggest factor, but also the toughest to deal with. How do you make people pay for high-risk diets? In theory you could do it by way of some sort of surtax for junk food, but that would be "rough justice" at best. For example, pasta might be junk food for a couch potato and very healthy fuel for a dedicated runner. Chicken might be extremely healthy if boiled, and an absolute artery-buster if deep fried.

I suppose the other way to go about it is to just measure outcomes rather than inputs -- you're either fat or not, and how you got there is your own business. But there, too, there'd be injustices in individual cases. If someone is overweight because of a genetic predisposition, it's rough to essentially fine him for that, when he may eat better and exercise more than an average person.

It's like any of the other social problems you navel gazers like to think you are "fixing" with all your social policy efforts - you can't make people make the right choices. Which is why subsidizing those who make the wrong choices so tragically disastrous...
 
I only know one non-elderly person who doesn't work, due to disability -- a cop who got injured in an on-the-job car accident.

Anyway, obesity is also a risk factor in depression, so if we could bring our obesity epidemic under control, depression-related disability should also become rarer.

My tenant is thin as a rail...
 
Thanks for another useless navel gaze. Do you know anyone on SSDI? I do - my tenant who lost her sales job in her mid-50s and got herself certified as too "clinically depressed" to look for work. She sure seems to have no trouble taking care of the 15 acre farm she rents from me, or going on long walks with her dogs, etc.

Indeed our old daycare lady is on the three year plan to get disability. You know.. the three years you have to go without working in order for them to eventually say, fine your "illness" is enough for us to give you disability.

She manages to go sell her stuff for cash at flea-markets every weekend... but.. oddly enough... she has vertigo and is unable to drive or get out of bed for days at a time.. during the regular work week.....

connie
 
you know, the EXACT same thing happened during the Vietnam war. Perfectly healthy young men starting showing up at the induction centers claiming "4F" - everything from tennis elbow to surfers knee to flat feet made them completely unfit to serve their nation.

Here's what NPR has to say about the epidemic of disability claims:

"The federal government spends more money each year on cash payments for disabled former workers than it spends on food stamps and welfare combined. Yet people relying on disability payments are often overlooked in discussions of the social safety net. The vast majority of people on federal disability do not work.[1] Yet because they are not technically part of the labor force, they are not counted among the unemployed.

In other words, people on disability don't show up in any of the places we usually look to see how the economy is doing. But the story of these programs -- who goes on them, and why, and what happens after that -- is, to a large extent, the story of the U.S. economy. It's the story not only of an aging workforce, but also of a hidden, increasingly expensive safety net.

For the past six months, I've been reporting on the growth of federal disability programs. I've been trying to understand what disability means for American workers, and, more broadly, what it means for poor people in America nearly 20 years after we ended welfare as we knew it. Here's what I found.

In Hale County, Alabama, nearly 1 in 4 working-age adults is on disability.[2] On the day government checks come in every month, banks stay open late, Main Street fills up with cars, and anybody looking to unload an old TV or armchair has a yard sale.

Sonny Ryan, a retired judge in town, didn't hear disability cases in his courtroom. But the subject came up often. He described one exchange he had with a man who was on disability but looked healthy.

"Just out of curiosity, what is your disability?" the judge asked from the bench.

"I have high blood pressure," the man said.
"So do I," the judge said. "What else?"
"I have diabetes."
"So do I."

There's no diagnosis called disability. You don't go to the doctor and the doctor says, "We've run the tests and it looks like you have disability." It's squishy enough that you can end up with one person with high blood pressure who is labeled disabled and another who is not.

read the entire article here:
http://apps.npr.org/unfit-for-work/
 
It's an interesting idea.

At least with regard to some of those, it wouldn't be so hard to implement even in concert with Affordable Care -- for example, Affordable Care has subsidies for low-income coverage... in theory you could increase or decrease the subsidies based on various risky behaviors.

Diet is probably the biggest factor, but also the toughest to deal with. How do you make people pay for high-risk diets? In theory you could do it by way of some sort of surtax for junk food, but that would be "rough justice" at best. For example, pasta might be junk food for a couch potato and very healthy fuel for a dedicated runner. Chicken might be extremely healthy if boiled, and an absolute artery-buster if deep fried.

I suppose the other way to go about it is to just measure outcomes rather than inputs -- you're either fat or not, and how you got there is your own business. But there, too, there'd be injustices in individual cases. If someone is overweight because of a genetic predisposition, it's rough to essentially fine him for that, when he may eat better and exercise more than an average person.

Ban junk food and pop bought with Food Stamps a great place to start.
 
It's like any of the other social problems you navel gazers like to think you are "fixing" with all your social policy efforts - you can't make people make the right choices. Which is why subsidizing those who make the wrong choices so tragically disastrous...

Exactly. It is human nature to take the easy way out. It simply is.

So, if one way out - is arduous, annoying, stressful and difficult - and one involves taking substantially less - but having to do nothing... then they will chose the latter. At least those without any self respect and integrity. Which is many many people.
 
Thanks for another useless navel gaze. Do you know anyone on SSDI? I do - my tenant who lost her sales job in her mid-50s and got herself certified as too "clinically depressed" to look for work. She sure seems to have no trouble taking care of the 15 acre farm she rents from me, or going on long walks with her dogs, etc.
my sister has COPD, is on oxygen, obese, and takes anti-depressents.

She works 40 hours a week as a cashier at "Big Lots"
 
my sister has COPD, is on oxygen, obese, and takes anti-depressents.

She works 40 hours a week as a cashier at "Big Lots"

Someone posted this on facebook a while ago with the caption.. "tell me again why you can't work"......
QoXGd.jpg


If working meant the difference between starving or eating.. we would have a lot less "disabled" people.......
 
It's an interesting idea.

At least with regard to some of those, it wouldn't be so hard to implement even in concert with Affordable Care -- for example, Affordable Care has subsidies for low-income coverage... in theory you could increase or decrease the subsidies based on various risky behaviors.

Diet is probably the biggest factor, but also the toughest to deal with. How do you make people pay for high-risk diets? In theory you could do it by way of some sort of surtax for junk food, but that would be "rough justice" at best. For example, pasta might be junk food for a couch potato and very healthy fuel for a dedicated runner. Chicken might be extremely healthy if boiled, and an absolute artery-buster if deep fried.

I suppose the other way to go about it is to just measure outcomes rather than inputs -- you're either fat or not, and how you got there is your own business. But there, too, there'd be injustices in individual cases. If someone is overweight because of a genetic predisposition, it's rough to essentially fine him for that, when he may eat better and exercise more than an average person.

I agree, it's tough to get someone to pay for their food choices. And your analogy on couch potato versus runner makes sense. Prior to a minor back injury, I was training for a half marathon. I had already decided on a big pasta dinner the night before and a quart or two of OJ the morning of the run. As you pointed out, depending on the person that may or may not be a bad idea.

This is why I would gravitate towards having the individual pay for their risk. We do a similar thing with auto insurance. Some cars get stolen more. If you get caught speeding, you're a higher risk for an accident and thus a claim.

It is definitely a difficult issue to deal with and no easy solutions- well, none that fit the notions of freedom in this country. I doubt anyone at either political extreme would want to ban foods. Such an idea would be met with appropriate laughter.

I do have to admit I've liked seeing more restaurants list their calories on their menu choices. A restaurant is hard work, so I'd never own one. But if I did, I'd list calories, protein, carbs and fat.
 
Back
Top