New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Putin eats Ukraine.

If Stockman actually has a point...it is the patriotism of the Ukrainian people that is hard to explain...if they were as uninterested in fighting as the Russian troops are...there would be no war.

If you read his piece, his main point is that Ukraine is essentially a bifurcated country with the east being made up of primarily Russian speaking people, and the west a hodgepodge of ethnicity. It really doesn't have a longstanding national identity.

Basically it is the western "Ukrainians" fighting the Russian invaders, and before that the separatists in the east. It complicates matters for those who don't share your (rather simplistic) "black vs. white" viewpoint.

If you accept Stockman's facts as, well, factual, you can start to see a possible negotiated end to the war. But first we need to convince the neocons that their dream of "regime change" in Russia is not worth the deaths of a hundred thousand people.
 
If you read his piece, his main point is that Ukraine is essentially a bifurcated country with the east being made up of primarily Russian speaking people, and the west a hodgepodge of ethnicity. It really doesn't have a longstanding national identity.

Basically it is the western "Ukrainians" fighting the Russian invaders, and before that the separatists in the east. It complicates matters for those who don't share your (rather simplistic) "black vs. white" viewpoint.

If you accept Stockman's facts as, well, factual, you can start to see a possible negotiated end to the war. But first we need to convince the neocons that their dream of "regime change" in Russia is not worth the deaths of a hundred thousand people.


Riiight... So, the Hispanic population in America approaches 20%...it would be within their right ..let's say Mexico....to claim those areas of America most densely populated by Hispanics as theirs....after all.. Americans really don't have a very long standing national identity. Meh, only a couple hundred years..

Eh?
 
Riiight... So, the Hispanic population in America approaches 20%...it would be within their right ..let's say Mexico....to claim those areas of America most densely populated by Hispanics as theirs....after all.. Americans really don't have a very long standing national identity. Meh, only a couple hundred years..

Eh?

You mean they aren't?

migrants waving mexican flags - Bing images

We aren't exactly persecuting them, are we? It would seem Zalensky is doing so to the ethnic Russians:

Zelenskyy Gov't Bans Ukraine's Opposition Party, Seizes Rivals' Assets - Headline USA

Zelensky: Only the Elderly Need the Russian Language – Сталкер Zone (stalkerzone.org)
 
No no, let's simply follow the simplistic rationale outlined above. Hispanics would be well within their rights to simply claim a chunk of the United States based on census. No? Surely everyone that says Ukraine should simply negotiate and cede territory would be perfectly fine with that occurring here.
 
No no, let's simply follow the simplistic rationale outlined above. Hispanics would be well within their rights to simply claim a chunk of the United States based on census. No? Surely everyone that says Ukraine should simply negotiate and cede territory would be perfectly fine with that occurring here.

Lets hold a referendum in the southwest to see if they want to secede. I'm okay with them joining Mexico if the majority decide that's how they want to proceed.
 
If you read his piece, his main point is that Ukraine is essentially a bifurcated country with the east being made up of primarily Russian speaking people, and the west a hodgepodge of ethnicity. It really doesn't have a longstanding national identity.

Basically it is the western "Ukrainians" fighting the Russian invaders, and before that the separatists in the east. It complicates matters for those who don't share your (rather simplistic) "black vs. white" viewpoint.

If you accept Stockman's facts as, well, factual, you can start to see a possible negotiated end to the war. But first we need to convince the neocons that their dream of "regime change" in Russia is not worth the deaths of a hundred thousand people.
I've posted polls that showed the people of Donbas preferred to remain part of Ukraine, not to join Russia. That was before the fighting started.

A poll released by the Kiev Institute of Sociology, with data gathered from 8–16 April, 41.1% of people in Donetsk were for decentralisation of Ukraine with powers transferred to regions, while letting it remain a unified state, 38.4% for changing Ukraine into federation, 27.5% were in favour of secession from Ukraine to join the Russian Federation, and only 10.6% supported current unitary structure without changes.[18]

Another poll, taken by the Donetsk Institute for Social Research and Political Analysis, found that 18.6% of those polled in the region opposed changes to the government structure, 47% favoured federalisation, or at least more economic independence from Kyiv, 27% wanted to join Russia in some form, and 5% wanted to become an independent state




The negotiated end would be for Russia to withdraw to within their own borders and all residence of those areas return to their homes, followed by a vote on the matter with only legal voters taking part....and without Russian interference.

Other issues, reparations to rebuild what Russia destroyed, war crimes for the murders and rapes that took place, the return of the Ukrainian citizens kidnapped and held in Russia.
 
Lets hold a referendum in the southwest to see if they want to secede. I'm okay with them joining Mexico if the majority decide that's how they want to proceed.
Uh huh. Ok

So, you're ok with ceding one fifth of America..on someone else's declarative?

Sure you are.
 
Uh huh. Ok

So, you're ok with ceding one fifth of America..on someone else's declarative?

Sure you are.

You don't know me then. I'm pretty sure I've posted before on how I believe running the US government has become too big a job for one person, which is why we have had a succession of failed presidencies. I advocate breaking it up into smaller units that are more manageable in size. If one of those chunks decides to become part of Canada or Mexico, what do I care?
 
I've posted polls that showed the people of Donbas preferred to remain part of Ukraine, not to join Russia. That was before the fighting started.

A poll released by the Kiev Institute of Sociology, with data gathered from 8–16 April, 41.1% of people in Donetsk were for decentralisation of Ukraine with powers transferred to regions, while letting it remain a unified state, 38.4% for changing Ukraine into federation, 27.5% were in favour of secession from Ukraine to join the Russian Federation, and only 10.6% supported current unitary structure without changes.[18]

Another poll, taken by the Donetsk Institute for Social Research and Political Analysis, found that 18.6% of those polled in the region opposed changes to the government structure, 47% favoured federalisation, or at least more economic independence from Kyiv, 27% wanted to join Russia in some form, and 5% wanted to become an independent state




The negotiated end would be for Russia to withdraw to within their own borders and all residence of those areas return to their homes, followed by a vote on the matter with only legal voters taking part....and without Russian interference.

Other issues, reparations to rebuild what Russia destroyed, war crimes for the murders and rapes that took place, the return of the Ukrainian citizens kidnapped and held in Russia.

Yeah I don't trust polls here, so why would I trust them in one of the most corrupt countries on the planet?

But yeah, if the vote could be overseen by the UN, with peacekeepers in place while it is sorted out, I think that is a fair proposition. But we would still have the matter of security for Russia and their (legitimate) concern about NATO encroachment. I think a treaty that says Ukraine is free to join NATO but that NATO would never put troops or weaponry into Ukraine unless it was attacked would be fair as well.
 
Yeah I don't trust polls here, so why would I trust them in one of the most corrupt countries on the planet?

But yeah, if the vote could be overseen by the UN, with peacekeepers in place while it is sorted out, I think that is a fair proposition. But we would still have the matter of security for Russia and their (legitimate) concern about NATO encroachment. I think a treaty that says Ukraine is free to join NATO but that NATO would never put troops or weaponry into Ukraine unless it was attacked would be fair as well.

You give Putin the benefit of the doubt. He isn't afraid of Ukraine joining Nato. He is motivated by theft of Ukrainian agriculture and resources.

He will not agree to paying reparations to Ukraine to repair the damage. He will never surrender Russian troops who had committed war crimes.
 
You give Putin the benefit of the doubt. He isn't afraid of Ukraine joining Nato. He is motivated by theft of Ukrainian agriculture and resources.

He will not agree to paying reparations to Ukraine to repair the damage. He will never surrender Russian troops who had committed war crimes.

So that's not negotiable? Then release the nukes...am I right?
 
So that's not negotiable? Then release the nukes...am I right?

Anything the elected leaders of Ukraine want to negotiate is on the table. I'm telling you my opinion of what Putin wants and what I think he will agree to.

He will not withdraw from the territory that he has declared part of Russia. He already stated that. Do you think he would pay a penny to rebuild what his army has destroyed? Will he surrender members of the Russian military who have committed war crimes?
 
Riiight... So, the Hispanic population in America approaches 20%...it would be within their right ..let's say Mexico....to claim those areas of America most densely populated by Hispanics as theirs....after all.. Americans really don't have a very long standing national identity. Meh, only a couple hundred years..

Eh?
Lets concede california to them, and call it a day?
 
You don't know me then. I'm pretty sure I've posted before on how I believe running the US government has become too big a job for one person, which is why we have had a succession of failed presidencies. I advocate breaking it up into smaller units that are more manageable in size. If one of those chunks decides to become part of Canada or Mexico, what do I care?
Yeah, im not signing up to be governed by unelected agency heads, or a tripartite coalition of non majority single issue political parties.
 
Yeah, im not signing up to be governed by unelected agency heads, or a tripartite coalition of non majority single issue political parties.

Yes, that is exactly what happens - ever larger portions of the federal behemoth go on "autopilot" directed by career bureaucrats. Anyone who thinks that is a good idea has sh*t for brains.
 
Yes, that is exactly what happens - ever larger portions of the federal behemoth go on "autopilot" directed by career bureaucrats. Anyone who thinks that is a good idea has sh*t for brains.

Anyone advocating for a breakup of our country ignores our history or the sacrifice of countless thousands of men and women who gave their lives to preserve the Unite States has shit where their heart should be.

Do you even think before posting such crap? I invite you to find the country that more suits your wish to have the president control every aspect of government...Luxembourg comes to mind.
 
Ukrainian troops continue to move forward. Moving towards Luhansk.

I read they have turned their personal cars into War Machines....
Russians are deserting and back home leaving so they don't have to serve
 
Anyone advocating for a breakup of our country ignores our history or the sacrifice of countless thousands of men and women who gave their lives to preserve the Unite States has shit where their heart should be.

Do you even think before posting such crap? I invite you to find the country that more suits your wish to have the president control every aspect of government...Luxembourg comes to mind.

You think an Ex- Air Force Officer doesn't know that!
Petty Officer Admiral :)
 
Back
Top