KnotaFrayed
Mayor
Unlike a lot of Obama supporters, I'll admit that this economic recovery had been weaker than was necessary, even in light of the absolute mess Bush left. I do, of course, let Obama off the hook for 2009, because I think there was almost nothing he could have done to stop the hemorrhaging faster than he did, given the nature of the crisis (it wasn't a standard business-cycle contraction, like most modern recessions, it was a financial meltdown, like the recession that caused the Great Depression, and like some of the economy-obliterating panics of the 1800s). 2009 was a lost cause, even with the best of policies. But, I believe it was possible to have us restored to robust economic growth and normal job creation before now, and so I fault Obama for not having done so. I'll grant he had very limited options after the Republicans took over Congress and dedicated themselves completely to gridlock. But there are things Obama could have done in '09 and '10 that would have had us much farther along the recovery road today.
If people are interested, I'm happy to provide my thoughts, in detail, about what he could have done differently. But that's not the point of this post. Instead, I'm curious what the conservatives, who are his fiercest critics, think he should have done differently.
Should he have pushed through even more tax cuts than he already did? If so, wouldn't that have resulted in even bigger deficits? And, given the fact that the corporations and the rich are already sitting on piles of money they don't care to invest, due to poor demand growth, how would handing them even more cash have helped? Moreover, doesn't the fact that we had some of the lowest taxes in our modern history, for the eight sub-par economic years leading up to the economic catastrophe, give you pause about the economic efficacy of that method?
The other frequent go-to policy for Republicans is deregulation, but that one's also hard to understand in the current context. We just suffered an economic collapse triggered by the "shadow banking system" -- a system of unregulated and under-regulated financial relationships, using exotic instruments that multiplied and spread economic risk throughout the global system. At best, pushing through more deregulation is like telling an alcoholic to take another drink to calm his hangover.
So, what else should Obama have done, from the conservative perspective?
I have to admit Arkady, as much as I agree with a whole lot of what you offer and I'm most certain lots of people disagree with my imperfect opinions here there and maybe everywhere at times or all the time, I'm wondering by what standard you measure or present your assured assertion that "this economic recovery has been weaker than was necessary"?
I have to also admit, while I could offer all sorts of additional opinion and speculation about how we might be in a different place right now, I have no absolute example to anchor to be able to offer any assuredness that done differently, we would necessarily be better off or that any specific leadership could or would be the deciding factor for where a recovery would, should or could be at this point in time. That seems critical to the debate all around. Who can offer some irrefutable divine evidence that they know for a certainty where the economic recovery should be right now relative to the depth of the recession? Do we even fully understand and agree to the depth of the recession or even what caused it? Without that, how does anyone know where we should be right now, even if they were top career professionals in the field of economics and economic analysis?
In some ways it makes "it's the economy stupid" kinda moot, especially coming from the party who had the keys to the White House and the economy (if we are comparing White House accountability to White House accountability) when the second greatest financial crisis this nation has recorded hit the fan. Just how did the party who oversaw that, only 4 short years ago, suddenly become economic geniuses in less than 2 years following it, based on the beginning of their assuredness that Obama was making things worse and causing more damage than the damage that had occurred on their watch.
If one assumes that expending money to fix a big hole one caused in one's roof is in fact, ruining the roof or hurting the house worse than the hole in the roof did, then perhaps that which appears as an absurdity to me, makes sense to someone else.
Additional absurdities I feel, based on what my eyes and mind observe, perhaps illusion or maybe even delusion coming from me in the perspective of others, is the failure of a lot of Americans, maybe even all of us, first to commonly identify and agree to recognize and acknowledge that which is closer to the absolute causes of what has been characterized as the second worst financial crisis this nation has known since tracking such things, then to make statements which have no basis for them.
That unemployment is high is not news, how and why it is high is perhaps more important news or useful information. One of the biggest absurdities I see in the "it's the economy stupid" argument with regard to unemployment is that what really appears to be more "stupid" is to shed jobs for the purpose of improving the economy, improving profit margins for business and lowering government expenditures, THEN complain about the unemployment rate.
It's kinda like saying my left leg needs blood and energy the rest of my body could be using more efficiently if it didn't have the left leg to feed, cutting off my left leg, then afterwards complaining that I don't function as well as I did with the leg.
The other absurdity I see is to stump for less government, less goverment spending, more jobs and more job opportunities from a position of those looking to be elected to positions in goverment and promising action on the former from a position of government.
On top of that, believing the government should not be in the "business" of creating jobs, but then campaigning on the failure of government to create them.
Have we as a nation lost our ability and capacity to listen, absorb, comprehend and try to make sense out of what we hear or do or have we become so self righteous and so focused on some short term and instant gratification and advantage for ourselves we fail to consider and contemplate or perhaps care about larger pictures, longer terms, sustainability, avoiding self contradictions, self-defeating actions and whether our 2 plus 2's actually add up to 4?
Do we really balance our own equations or do we delude ourselves that what might be our huge self-contradictions or invented contrivances or shell games somehow make sense or offer a balanced and correct equation?
Do we purposefully try to obfuscate and confuse, hoping if we move the shells around fast enough most people won't be able to follow the pea and we, not them, our fellow citizens, come out ahead as a result or do we not even recognize how being one who calls for shedding jobs for "fiscal responsibility" while at the same time complaining about the unemployment rate, is an absurdity?
The same for being one who calls for less government, less regulation, while at the same time blaming government for not healing the economy and creating jobs and fast enough, bailing out the private sector (and ignoring the reasons for doing so), not doing enough to put preventative measures in place against another financial meltdown and punish those in the private sector for their role in the financial meltdown one is blaming government for not recovering from or even for causing.
The same with calling blaming the government for out of control spending after contributing to that uncontrolled spending while at the same time reducing revenue needed to pay for the spending, much less calling for further reduction of revenue to pay for increased government spending on private sector/government contracts. Yes, defense spending indirectly creates jobs, but it does so with MORE, not less government spending. An absurdity by those who claim government should not be spending taxpayer dollars to create jobs or suggesting government debt does not create jobs.
An absurdity UNLESS one feed from both troughs or both ends of the trough, by getting a reduction in taxes, while at the same time profiting from additional government debt via government defense contracts.
My question is, does most of America have the capacity to contemplate what are either absurdities in all ways or absurdities only if one is not in the position to profit from having people not recognize them as absurdities?
What does add up in the secret "code" of the "absurdity" of cutting tax rates for the wealthy, cutting revenue, raising defense spending all while complaining about too much government spending, the size of the debt, the failure of goverment to create jobs is that if people do not see the absurdities, they will be "electing" those who will bring even more profit to the few, less employment for the many, MORE, not less government debt, MORE, not less interest to pay on debt.
If I were CEO of a corporation which enormously profited from government contracts, defense especially, why would I not want to feed from a deeper taxpayer funded trough? One, by paying less of my government (taxpayer) funded income. Two, by calling to increase more taxpayer spending in my direction. Three, by insisting the bill go on the taxpayer of America's credit card.
All I would need to do would be to confuse some people so much that they believe they are voting in their own interest or convincing them, falsely, that someone else is going to take their money and simply transfer it gratis to an entire opposition political party, none of who have a job or want a job.
Perhaps there is so much to sort out and in many ways difficult to sort out, whether some intend to make it that way or not, that our circuits are frazzled and we can't or don't take enough time to work out the presented equations to see if they balance or make sense.