Well, in fact, Sarge made the opposite assertion without providing any substantive reasons other than a faith in the free market. Neither of us is going to be able to prove what would have happened if a "free-market" solution had been tried. You can't prove counterfactuals one way or the other. You can just speculate. The primary source of my skepticism is the failure of Hoover's response to the Stock Market Crash of 1929 and the cascading crises that continued to 1933 when FDR was elected. In my mind, Bush was about a return to the policies of Coolidge and Romney and Ryan are about a return to the policies of Hoover. I am not inclined to go in that direction. But you are certainly free to disagree.
I am not discussing this with Sarge, I am discussing this with you. I do understand where Sarge is coming from, I don't understand where you are coming from.
Coolidge was a small government republican who did not want to get government involve in any aspect of the private market if at all possible. Coolidge even refused disaster assistance to states in times of trouble. When he did that, a remarkable thing happened. States stepped up and took care of their own problems. Bush, on the other hand, was a big government republican who expanded social spending, such as the prescription program, and got us involved in 2 wars, and expanded the powers of the police, the FBI, and the CIA. The assertion that Bush is anything like Coolidge is unfounded.
Hoover was another big government republican in the vain of Bush. Expansion of the power of government, the creation of the FBI, and large spending projects, such as the Hoover Damn, makes Hoover a lot closer to Bush than Coolidge was. The greatest of our problems seem to have always come from large government leaders.
Well, if we talked long enough, we might come up with a decent solution. The problem is that - in my view - the Republicans - with the exception of a few folks like Bob Corker - tried to undermine the efforts of reform of the financial institutions and seem to be intent on going back to the circumstances as they existed in 2006. It sounds to me that you are not in favor of going back to 2006 either. I am very willing to believe that small businesses are still having trouble establishing lines of credit so that they can have working capital. If that is indeed the case, that is a problem and one that I think to which a bi-partisan solution can be found without returning to the wild west of 2006. That said, this is not an area in which I have particular expertise and I recognize that there may be things that I do not know or am not aware of. That said, you have not supplied evidence that new Obama regulations are causing this credit crunch. You have asserted it but you have never backed it up as far as I know (other than possibly with the anecdote about your two friends who own small businesses and blame their problems on Obama.)
http://posttrib.suntimes.com/busine...ill-struggling-to-get-loans-to-grow-jobs.html
http://www.businessweek.com/smallbiz/content/jan2011/sb20110121_157814.htm
http://www.usnews.com/news/washingt...stration-added-95-billion-in-red-tape-in-july
http://www.suntimes.com/news/737237...sh-obama-administrations-new-regulations.html
Obama is not anti-business in any way, shape, or form. (And again you seem to be making an assertion without backing it up.) Being pro-union does not make you either a socialist or a Marxist. It means that you support the right of workers to organize and bargain collectively.
Business leaders would disagree with you, as my links show. The Obama administration is taken a micromanagement style of economic management, and has shown that he favors unions over business, as with his UAW deal with GM and Chrysler. This election cycle, business contributions are going almost exclusively to Romney. This wouldn't happen if Obama was as business friendly as you believe.
First, I did not say "Romney and Ryan bad/Obama good." I was really mimicking what I took you to be saying. Second, I did say "Romney and Ryan (going forward) worse/Obama (going forward) better. I think that Romney and Ryan would just repeat the failures of Bush. You think that Obama has been a failure. We can both put forward substantive reasons to support our beliefs about the past. And we can draw on our view of the past to predict what we think will happen in the future. Given our perspectives, we are not likely to agree. But your calling Obama an idiot is not an invitation to a substantive discussion either. If you want to do some bashing, I don't know why you expect people to engage you in a discussion.
If anyone has repeated Bush's failures, it would be Obama. He has continued, and expanded, Bush's social spending, increased deficit spending, and expanded government. He's piled on new regulations and is strangling business. From everything I am seeing, this is what is keeping our economy from rebounding. From what I have seen, Romney and Ryan would do the exact opposite of Bush, and shrink government intervention in the private market, reduce social spending, and use the private market to manage key social programs. I find all of these things appealing. Right now, the Obama plan adds 8 years to the longevity of SS and Medicare, kicking the problem down the road to another administration. In my opinion, that is the cowardly way of going about a solution. I didn't like it with Bush, I really don't like it with Obama. Romney and Ryan want people collecting their SS and Medicare for decades to come, which means things need to be changed.