New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

In Massachusetts and everywhere else on the planet, that means money out can't exceed money in. If it does, there are three fixes. Decrease money going out. Increase money coming in. Or combine the two. Only blindered right wingers assume there's a single option.

There IS only one option for those who are fiscally responsible.
 
Shit like Solyndra; the muslim Brotherhood; bailing out Unions; foreign car companies; healthcare reform scams; Michelle's vacations and lunches.

And what would you have him stop spending it on ? How about cost + contracts of KBR, Halliburton, and Bechtel, I know a tone of independents and liberals who would like to see that. How about stop construction altogether on that new and unnecessary class of new aircraft carriers the navy is building, not to mention the subs. The navy states that the effective working life for a carrier is 50 years, how about we don't build any replacement until the first of the Nimitz class is at least 40 years old. How about we return the task of maintain base services back to the service folk that used to be responsible for them ? Why pay a civilian worker to do a job a soldier can do. Certainly a man who can repair jet hydraulics can repair plumbing on a stopped up sink. What about the Army Corp of Engineers ? If they can dredge rivers and build levees surely they should be able to build and maintain the infrastructure of an Army, Navy. Marine Corp or Air Force base ? Kust think of the billions we would save by paying active duty soldiers to do their only laundry, instead of contracting it out to KBR for $13.50 per bag.

Isn't it amazing that tasks routinely performed by active duty soldiers for centuries, must now be sub-contracted out to pirates and scalpers at prices that would make your own kids blush. But what the hey ! Its part of the Dick Cheney Legacy, and republicans never make a mistake.

I borrowed this from CatsEye, from a post made on Sept 5th. Perhaps you missed it.

View attachment 2988 If the picture doesn't appear, you can find it here.

https://www.politicaljack.com/forum...LLON-dollars-and-the-Dem-Lib-media-Ignored-It


Yes its easy to say: STOP SPENDING MONEY ! but there sure were a lot of Republican politicians in like to get plenty of it for their states and pet projects. And they got it. You noticed former REPUBLICAN Gov Christ on the podium last knight I hope. Did he not clearly describe to you what Florida faced had there not been a Stimulus Package and a TARP bill ? Did President Obama's barely 1 month in office administration cause these problems. Be honest, I know its hard for a conservative to do that, but give it a try, you might grow to like it. While you are at it check out the status of TARP see how much has been repaid and by whom.

Remember, spending bills constitutionally are the responsibility of the House of Representatives, and remind me, who has the majority there ?
 
Must I cite Fox News to be acceptable to you? If you'd like, I can dig through their archives. There, too, we'll find the Olympia Snowe quote saying Obama should take the public option off the table to get Republican support (and, as you are perfectly well aware, the public option came off the table but Snowe and every other Republican stuck to lock step opposition all the same). If you're HONESTLY ignorant of the bipartisan summit Obama pulled together, and his efforts to strike down attempts by Democrats to get a less right-wing reform package, then you've been embarrassingly lazy. Even within your silly Fox News echo chamber there must have been talk of the public option and "Medicare for All," and how the president pushed back against his own party on those things. He was pathetically desperate to get bipartisan support for health care reform, and pushed a far-right reform package (the Romney package), over the objection of more mainstream Democrats, all with the naive idea it would shame a few Republicans into cooperating. But, as we know, Republicans are shameless, so that was never going to work.
 
Agreed. The only option for the fiscally responsible is the one proven to work in the real world -- the one that actually took us from record budget deficits, at the end of twelve consecutive years of Republicans befouling the Oval Office, to record surpluses, in the second term of the Democrat who replaced them. What worked was a combination of tax hikes, slowed domestic spending growth, and military spending cuts. That's what real fiscal responsibility looks like. The rest is just dishonest posturing by those who don't give a crap about debt, but who pretend they do because they really hate the idea of government helping out the less fortunate.
 
Unsurprisingly, David Stockmann agrees with you.

Agreed. The only option for the fiscally responsible is the one proven to work in the real world -- the one that actually took us from record budget deficits, at the end of twelve consecutive years of Republicans befouling the Oval Office, to record surpluses, in the second term of the Democrat who replaced them. What worked was a combination of tax hikes, slowed domestic spending growth, and military spending cuts. That's what real fiscal responsibility looks like. The rest is just dishonest posturing by those who don't give a crap about debt, but who pretend they do because they really hate the idea of government helping out the less fortunate.
 
If they're sitting on it now, when we desperately need economic activity, and then they use that money down the road, when the economy is already heated up to the point where any further heating will be actively fought by the Fed with interest rate hikes, to avoid inflation, that's worthless. The whole point is to try to dampen the oscillations of the business cycle a bit, not to increase them. Don't you people even try to think these things through?
 
I link to a wide assortment of mainstream news sources -- sources owned, by the way, by giant for-profit corporations controlled by the super-rich. You just blubber about it because the facts those sources report don't fit with the tidy mythology your cloistered propaganda sources have constructed to keep you stupid.
 
It's what Obama should NOT have done that is the key. First, he should not have spent his fist year and a half ramming a massive bill that called for the takeover of the medical industry and the subsequent unionization of 20 million employees; all this against the wishes of 70% of the American people.

He should not have used the $850B stimulus to reward his cronies and Hollywood pals for helping him get elected. He should not have bailed out the UAW while non-union companies werehaving to close. He should not have rejected the Keystone pipeline. He should not have sued the State of Arizona for trying to rotect their citizens from illegal criminals. He should not have interfered with the states' rights to use voter ID cards to ensure that only American ctizens vote in our elections.

He should not have let Harry Reid table all the Republican jobs blls and refuse to allow them to come up for a floor vote. He should not have given $500 M to his friends to start Solyndra. He should not have given money to the Muslim Brotherhood.

He should not have permitted the NLRB to block Boeing from moving to North Carolina. He should not have allowed Eric Holder to remain in his job after the Fast & Furious scandal. He should not have told lies everytime he opened his mouth.

So, what should he have done? Should he have sat around doing nothing, like Hoover, hoping the biggest financial collapse since the Great Depression didn't give rise to a second a Great Depression? Or do you have recommendations for things he actually should have done (rather than merely demands that he not do things that violate conservative taboos)?
 
Pres. Obama has presided over the slowest growth in guvmint spending, of any American since President Eisenhower (and his wind-down of WWII). Some above, are arguing that even Obama's historically pissant spending growth was WAY TOO MUCH!

The only way to interpret that, is that they feel that our best way out of a worldwide depression, would've been to engender actual negative spending "growth". They "feel" their view most strongly, even as there's is absolutely NO practical nor historic evidence in support of their view - none whatsoever. In fact, virtually all economic/historic evidence available to us, argues decidedly against this angle.

I could be wrong...but time and again, and again, and again....I've practically gotten down on my (virtual) knees and BEGGED the screechers of this angle, to give me just ONE current or recent-historic example of this angle's actually working. As yet....none has come back with one single example. They can't offer even that one example, yet they're convinced they're right. (BTW, that's "radical" in spades, not "conservative").

It's a religious faith for them. Asking for evidence of real-world efficacy is like asking a faith healer to show a double-blind placebo-controlled study indicating his methods are effective. They believe because they believe, period, and real world events are utterly irrelevant.

Come to think of it, the faith-healer analogy sucks, because generally faith healers are just harmless placebos. Republican economic policies aren't harmless. They're more like prescribing a leeching to "balance the humours" of someone with anemia. It's not a harmless placebo. It's something that works in a way that predictably will make the underlying condition dangerously worse.
 
No businessman or woman refuses to expand his or her business out of hatred. That would be both stupid and the equivalent of cutting their own throat. They are holding back because they realized that the nation really did put a capitalism hating socialist into office. They fear that if they begin moving forward again Obama will destroy them, especially if he gets a second term. So fear of Obama's socialistic background and demonstrated tendencies are holding them back, not hatred for Obama.

So that expalins the 4.5 million new jobs since Obama took office?Right! These people are scared to death!

I have posted many times about how Manufacturing is on a roll in my area. GE hooked up with the University of Dayton,(One of the premier Engineering Colleges).GE is building right on the grounds of UD. Caterpillar built a huge plant directly across from the Vocational school less than a mile from me.Industrial Parks are filling up as fast as they can build them. There is a huge lack of skilled trades workers.The Community Colleges are sending them out as quick as they can.

And the whole area of I70 and I75 is being flooded with new plants. Every day they are announcing new ones.You can just bet allt hese companies are scared to death of Obama.I can assure you they were of Bush. The place became a ghost town.
 
So that expalins the 4.5 million new jobs since Obama took office?Right! These people are scared to death!
I have posted many times about how Manufacturing is on a roll in my area. GE hooked up with the University of Dayton,(One of the premier Engineering Colleges).GE is building right on the grounds of UD. Caterpillar built a huge plant directly across from the Vocational school less than a mile from me.Industrial Parks are filling up as fast as they can build them. There is a huge lack of skilled trades workers.The Community Colleges are sending them out as quick as they can.

And the whole area of I70 and I75 is being flooded with new plants. Every day they are announcing new ones.You can just bet allt hese companies are scared to death of Obama.I can assure you they were of Bush. The place became a ghost town.

There ARE no 4.5 million jobs that were created under Obama; that is the lie you people keep blindly repeating.
 
Well, in fact, Sarge made the opposite assertion without providing any substantive reasons other than a faith in the free market. Neither of us is going to be able to prove what would have happened if a "free-market" solution had been tried. You can't prove counterfactuals one way or the other. You can just speculate. The primary source of my skepticism is the failure of Hoover's response to the Stock Market Crash of 1929 and the cascading crises that continued to 1933 when FDR was elected. In my mind, Bush was about a return to the policies of Coolidge and Romney and Ryan are about a return to the policies of Hoover. I am not inclined to go in that direction. But you are certainly free to disagree.

I am not discussing this with Sarge, I am discussing this with you. I do understand where Sarge is coming from, I don't understand where you are coming from.
Coolidge was a small government republican who did not want to get government involve in any aspect of the private market if at all possible. Coolidge even refused disaster assistance to states in times of trouble. When he did that, a remarkable thing happened. States stepped up and took care of their own problems. Bush, on the other hand, was a big government republican who expanded social spending, such as the prescription program, and got us involved in 2 wars, and expanded the powers of the police, the FBI, and the CIA. The assertion that Bush is anything like Coolidge is unfounded.

Hoover was another big government republican in the vain of Bush. Expansion of the power of government, the creation of the FBI, and large spending projects, such as the Hoover Damn, makes Hoover a lot closer to Bush than Coolidge was. The greatest of our problems seem to have always come from large government leaders.
Well, if we talked long enough, we might come up with a decent solution. The problem is that - in my view - the Republicans - with the exception of a few folks like Bob Corker - tried to undermine the efforts of reform of the financial institutions and seem to be intent on going back to the circumstances as they existed in 2006. It sounds to me that you are not in favor of going back to 2006 either. I am very willing to believe that small businesses are still having trouble establishing lines of credit so that they can have working capital. If that is indeed the case, that is a problem and one that I think to which a bi-partisan solution can be found without returning to the wild west of 2006. That said, this is not an area in which I have particular expertise and I recognize that there may be things that I do not know or am not aware of. That said, you have not supplied evidence that new Obama regulations are causing this credit crunch. You have asserted it but you have never backed it up as far as I know (other than possibly with the anecdote about your two friends who own small businesses and blame their problems on Obama.)
http://posttrib.suntimes.com/busine...ill-struggling-to-get-loans-to-grow-jobs.html
http://www.businessweek.com/smallbiz/content/jan2011/sb20110121_157814.htm
http://www.usnews.com/news/washingt...stration-added-95-billion-in-red-tape-in-july
http://www.suntimes.com/news/737237...sh-obama-administrations-new-regulations.html
Obama is not anti-business in any way, shape, or form. (And again you seem to be making an assertion without backing it up.) Being pro-union does not make you either a socialist or a Marxist. It means that you support the right of workers to organize and bargain collectively.
Business leaders would disagree with you, as my links show. The Obama administration is taken a micromanagement style of economic management, and has shown that he favors unions over business, as with his UAW deal with GM and Chrysler. This election cycle, business contributions are going almost exclusively to Romney. This wouldn't happen if Obama was as business friendly as you believe.
First, I did not say "Romney and Ryan bad/Obama good." I was really mimicking what I took you to be saying. Second, I did say "Romney and Ryan (going forward) worse/Obama (going forward) better. I think that Romney and Ryan would just repeat the failures of Bush. You think that Obama has been a failure. We can both put forward substantive reasons to support our beliefs about the past. And we can draw on our view of the past to predict what we think will happen in the future. Given our perspectives, we are not likely to agree. But your calling Obama an idiot is not an invitation to a substantive discussion either. If you want to do some bashing, I don't know why you expect people to engage you in a discussion.
If anyone has repeated Bush's failures, it would be Obama. He has continued, and expanded, Bush's social spending, increased deficit spending, and expanded government. He's piled on new regulations and is strangling business. From everything I am seeing, this is what is keeping our economy from rebounding. From what I have seen, Romney and Ryan would do the exact opposite of Bush, and shrink government intervention in the private market, reduce social spending, and use the private market to manage key social programs. I find all of these things appealing. Right now, the Obama plan adds 8 years to the longevity of SS and Medicare, kicking the problem down the road to another administration. In my opinion, that is the cowardly way of going about a solution. I didn't like it with Bush, I really don't like it with Obama. Romney and Ryan want people collecting their SS and Medicare for decades to come, which means things need to be changed.
 
I repeat CNN busted that 4.5 million jobs myth and lie last week. Obama's only created 400,000 new jobs in total since taking office in 2009. Endlessly repeating the lies of the Obama administration does not turn them into the truth.
 
I repeat CNN busted that 4.5 million jobs myth and lie last week. Obama's only created 400,000 new jobs in total since taking office in 2009. Endlessly repeating the lies of the Obama administration does not turn them into the truth.

Question. If Romney is elected November and in January when he takes office we lose 800,000 jobs who will you blame for that?
If you don't blame Romney when will you start, if ever, start blaming him?
 
False, you can get any type of (legal) treatment if you can pay for it. It's up to you to pay for it, not anyone else.

So if you can't afford to pay for a $150,000 quad by-pass surgery, you should just die? Nice, and very typical of a rightwinger.

I'm quite familiar with economics. The best way to have the best goods and services at the lowest prices is through free market competition, not government monopolies.

Bullshit. You know nothing but what FOX news tells you.
 
Cicero,

Obama has been in office for 42 months approximately. Over the first 12 months, the cratering of the economy that began and accelerated in 2008 continued. There was a full blown economic crisis when Obama entered office. There were 800K jobs being lost per month.

However, jobs - adding up 4.6 million have been created over the last 30 months. That is CONSISTENLY what the Democrats and Obama have said (and you know it.) If you account for the jobs lost because of the momentum from the Bush crash, you get the figure you cite.

The recovery could not be said to have started until jobs began to be added. That was 30 months ago. Since the recovery began 30 months ago, 4.6 million jobs have been added. That is a fact.


I repeat CNN busted that 4.5 million jobs myth and lie last week. Obama's only created 400,000 new jobs in total since taking office in 2009. Endlessly repeating the lies of the Obama administration does not turn them into the truth.
 
I suspect that as soon as Romney gets in office, Cicero will begin plotting how to get Romney out of office and replace him with the sainted Hillary Clinton. That seems to be his schtick.

Question. If Romney is elected November and in January when he takes office we lose 800,000 jobs who will you blame for that?
If you don't blame Romney when will you start, if ever, start blaming him?
 
Back
Top