New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

To be fair, I'm sure you get get people cheaper. But, ultimately, you get what you pay for. These aren't draftees. They have choices. If you worsen the deal for them, you'll get worse quality people willing to fill those roles. If you better the deal for them, you'll get better quality people. People who think teachers currently get paid too much are basically people who think that our current teachers are too high in quality -- that education of our young people is an area where we can afford to cut some more corners.

Here's what the hardly liberal McCkinsey HR firm found:
http://www.mckinseyonsociety.com/downloads/reports/Education/Closing_the_talent_gap.pdf
 
That's simply not true... the Jobs REcovery act worked. We needed a second one. The GOP filbustered any attempt to pass one precisely because it would have worked and then the GOP would have had nothing to run on against Obama.


No we do not. While the majority of the economic activity is indivudual non-governmental transactions, that's not the same as what the driving force for the economic TRENDS are. In a Liquidity/Demand Trap which is what we are in now - eventually you CAN crawl out of it without government intervention. Its how the economy operated through about 1890. The problem is that this approach increases the duration of the recovery BY A FACTOR OF EIGHT on average (and yes this is not an "average" crash). And it makes for a much much much more fragile recovery.

And no it is not "regulations" that make this more difficult. Not when the "regulatory burden" (remember that contract enforcement and private property protections are PART of "regulations") in total adds up to less than 11% of GDP.


And this simply is not true. For example. the Fiscal Multiplier (economic efficiency) of private sector infrastructure construction is 1.5.. and the FM for Public sector infrastructure construction IS ALSO 1.5... That's The Government "touching" something and being EQUALLY EFFICIENT.


[quiote] When that balance is lost, when politics gets involved we see teachers in Chicago, the highest paid in the nation, go on strike to get even more than a mere $80,000 per year plus unbelievable benefits and pensions.
Hmm how much would it cost you to hire an employee with the following resume:

  • Masters degree or better
  • 15+ years industry experience
  • Independent worker
  • Self-starter, works well in ambiguous circumstances
  • Strong communications skills
  • strong conflict negotiator
  • consistently delivers under-budget
  • independently takes responsibility to take work home as necessary

I suspect it would cost you more than $80k.[/QUOTE]

The jobs recovery act did not work and is still not working. We have 23 million people out of work and 8% unemployment with a true number being closer to 14% counting those who have quit looking for work. Those are bottom line facts and your pretzel logic figures don't amount to anything. GM is not working and unless bailed out again in the near future will go back to the bankruptcy drawing board to fix what they should have in the beginning.

I have hired many with a Masters for half the price because people do what they need to to survive, government workers think they are insulated from hard times but they are finding out different. By the way it appeared that most of those teachers did not have a masters.
 
To be fair, I'm sure you get get people cheaper. But, ultimately, you get what you pay for. These aren't draftees. They have choices. If you worsen the deal for them, you'll get worse quality people willing to fill those roles. If you better the deal for them, you'll get better quality people. People who think teachers currently get paid too much are basically people who think that our current teachers are too high in quality -- that education of our young people is an area where we can afford to cut some more corners.

Nonsense, a teachers work is the equivalent to maybe a secretary or a bank teller, that they have to have a degree is neither here nor there. Public schools through grade 12 are a total failure even though we have invested billions while they keep asking for more as if money is the fix it all. Today in most schools teachers are given a step by step syllabus to follow, they don't even have to think, much less be creative, anyone could do it. Charter schools in the same areas are far advanced of public ones. If teachers really cared about the kids why didn't they work out there grievances before school started.

I get really tired of hearing "but it's for the kids"??? when we all know it's for the unions and the amount of money they contribute to a political party. By far, teacher's Unions are the strongest lobby group in California and one of the main reasons for the State becoming financially insolvent while having some of the worst drop out rates, especially among minorities, and the lowest test scores in the nation.

I suspect it's the same in Chicago.
 
Did you see the link I gave elsewhere in this thread just this AM where Canada saw a DROP in corporate reinvestment rates when it reduced corporate tax rates?

Well Jack, I guess that says what several people here have been saying all along, there is not benefit to be reaped from all of these Bush tax cuts for the top after all. Let's cut the bullshit and focus on what we want to have happen. Elimination of the Bush tax cuts for corporation. Instead offer a tax cut for bone fide re-investment in the AMERICAN economy. High taxes on profits made outside the US. Repeal of the so-called depletion allowances. Pull that money and invest it in the Social Security Trust fund, and Medicare & Medicaid, or Obamacare if you must. Depletion allowances permit corporations to extract oil & gas and other minerals belonging to the people of the United States, and take credits for doing so. Do they own those things they extracting, hell no. The are the rightful property of the people of this country, (specifically on public lands and offshore) why shouldn't John Q Public get the benefit ?

Tai Pan

That's not redistributing the wealth, that is paying the owners their rightful due.
 
Nonsense, a teachers work is the equivalent to maybe a secretary or a bank teller, that they have to have a degree is neither here nor there. Public schools through grade 12 are a total failure even though we have invested billions while they keep asking for more as if money is the fix it all. Today in most schools teachers are given a step by step syllabus to follow, they don't even have to think, much less be creative, anyone could do it. Charter schools in the same areas are far advanced of public ones. If teachers really cared about the kids why didn't they work out there grievances before school started.

I get really tired of hearing "but it's for the kids"??? when we all know it's for the unions and the amount of money they contribute to a political party. By far, teacher's Unions are the strongest lobby group in California and one of the main reasons for the State becoming financially insolvent while having some of the worst drop out rates, especially among minorities, and the lowest test scores in the nation.

I suspect it's the same in Chicago.


Are you out of your lunatic mind ? A teacher is the equivalent of a bank teller or secretary ? See if you have balls enough to step into an inner city class room for 1 year, and then write this kind of tripe.

Tai Pan
 
Nonsense, a teachers work is the equivalent to maybe a secretary or a bank teller, that they have to have a degree is neither here nor there. Public schools through grade 12 are a total failure even though we have invested billions while they keep asking for more as if money is the fix it all. Today in most schools teachers are given a step by step syllabus to follow, they don't even have to think, much less be creative, anyone could do it. Charter schools in the same areas are far advanced of public ones. If teachers really cared about the kids why didn't they work out there grievances before school started.

I get really tired of hearing "but it's for the kids"??? when we all know it's for the unions and the amount of money they contribute to a political party. By far, teacher's Unions are the strongest lobby group in California and one of the main reasons for the State becoming financially insolvent while having some of the worst drop out rates, especially among minorities, and the lowest test scores in the nation.

I suspect it's the same in Chicago.

Baloney. ONE teacher, in just ONE classroom, over the course of just ONE year, has the potential -via the lifetime prospects of the 25 kids in her classroom - to create more than $1 Million in societal wealth. And...we're just talking one year. If she's a great teacher and teaches for 40 years?...we're talkin' $40 Million in today's dollar (hey, I had a great math teacher!).

And hey...no DOUBT..not every teacher will be so excpetional as to create that wealth. But..every classroom has the potential - given the right teacher. How much is a professional who's capable of creating $40 Million worth of wealth for society, worth?
 
That, fairsheet, is exactly why I want to hike teacher pay greatly (in exchange for tougher standards on teachers). The improvement in teacher quality would pay for the increased up-front cost many, many times over, during the course of the student careers.

I'm sympathetic to those who criticize the unions, because they are blocking teacher accountability. But the union exists to protect the teachers, so you can't expect to somehow browbeat them into abandoning that mission. You're not going to shame teachers into accepting worse working conditions. You need to make a fair trade of value. Link substantially increased teacher pay to substantial increases in teacher accountability and you can get union buy-in. It just needs to look like a CLEAR net improvement for the majority of members, and they'll vote for it.
 
The taxes themselves do not, typically, grow the economy (though, in theory, they can, by convincing businesses to reinvest rather than to pay out higher executive salaries or dividends). Instead, it's what the taxes pay for that grows the economy. Take the Interstate Highway System, as an example. That was paid for by taxes -- at a time when the top bracket paid as much as 92%! It grew the economy by interconnecting America more efficiently, allowing greater economies of scale and specialization across regions.

Regulations can grow the economy in lots of ways. Just to take one regulation, consider child labor laws. By preventing children from working in factories, it freed them up to go to school, instead, which resulted in a more educated workforce, and ultimately far more economic growth than if they'd just been doing repetitive, mindless duties in death-trap factories.
 
Nonsense, a teachers work is the equivalent to maybe a secretary or a bank teller, that they have to have a degree is neither here nor there.

Dave,

Well, I have to see that I flat out disagree with you here as well. I think most responsible business people would disagree as well.

I'd love to see Romney and Ryan run with an opinion like yours. (They won't.) I suspect that 90% of the American public (at a minimum) would disagree with you about the skill level of teachers.
 
Nonsense, a teachers work is the equivalent to maybe a secretary or a bank teller, that they have to have a degree is neither here nor there.

You poor man who was passed over by our educational system. and has troubled relationship with facts
 
Dave,
Well, I have to see that I flat out disagree with you here as well. I think most responsible business people would disagree as well.
I'd love to see Romney and Ryan run with an opinion like yours. (They won't.) I suspect that 90% of the American public (at a minimum) would disagree with you about the skill level of teachers.

Teachers are highly overrated.
 
The jobs may not have been filled -- that is different from saying they didn't exist. Being laid off is not the same thing as being fired.
The ONLY difference is that if you are fired, it is "for cause" and you cannot collect unemployment. If you are laid off, the job ceases to exist. It is not counted as "unfilled positions".

"New jobs," are what's created after all the pre-existing jobs have been filled.
No that's a redefinition. a job is a "new job" if it was not previously an "unfilled position". a "new job" is one in which there was no employment opportunity in the period immediately preceding the person being hired into it.

Consider this, when that company laid off employees, it did not reduce the number of jobs.
That's simply newspeak. Because using that logic, when someone gets laid off, the "number of unfilled jobs" would increase. AND IT DOES NOT. Sorry wrong.

But the delta in the example doesn't reflect a company's growth
yes it does. For the purposes of calculating ROI, Profits, Growth. For the purposes of invesstors investing capital, for banks lending capital it qualifies as growth. You are simply engaged in politically expedient redefinition. IOW you are making Sh!t up that has no actual economic basis.

If a company cuts 100 jobs and re-fills 25 of them, it is not experiencing an increase in jobs, Degs
If it happens the next day? No.

but if a company cuts 100 jobs... it is now a smaller company. It has a smaller workforce that perhaps operates more efficiently but odds are it produces less.

At SOME LATER POINT IN TIME.. when the company starts to grow. IT INCREASES THE NUMBER OF JOBS IT HAS... and it does so by hiring NEW EMPLOYEES.

The logic you're using is the logic of someone who says they saved $5 by buying shoes for $50 when they were on a $5 off sale. No, that person has not "saved" five dollars -- they've spent $50.
The irony here is that the simile you describe IS YOURS.

Someone who has spent $50 instead of $55 HAS SPENT LESS. The retailer EARNED LESS.

If next week those shoes cost $55... then the person who buys them then SPENDS MORE. the Retailer EARNS MORE...ie the Retailer's EARNINGS GROW.

Under YOUR reasoning... the Retailer somehow did not earn less during the $5 sale week... because he later charged $55 somehow according to you, that's the same as charging $50..... Frankly BIZZARRE.










"New jobs," are what's created after all the pre-existing jobs have been filled. In other words, full recovery precedes creating new jobs.



Consider this, when that company laid off employees, it did not reduce the number of jobs. Any re-hires are not going into new positions, but re-filling pre-existing positions.


But the delta in the example doesn't reflect a company's growth, but a partial recovery toward the level it was at when it laid off employees. Growth is another thing.



If a company cuts 100 jobs and re-fills 25 of them, it is not experiencing an increase in jobs, Degs. It has experienced a decrease of 75 jobs. No "new" jobs have been created, but some of the old ones have been filled. The logic you're using is the logic of someone who says they saved $5 by buying shoes for $50 when they were on a $5 off sale. No, that person has not "saved" five dollars -- they've spent $50. The company has not created 25 new jobs, it's lost 75.[/QUOTE]
 
Keep that delusion that you know Dominoes better than Dominoes. Or that this regulation affects ONLY Dominoes.

Where does Dominoes claim that this is NET NEW Spend?
Where does Dominoes claim that this prevents hiring?
Where does Dominoes claim that this adversely impacted staffing?

You cannot point to anywhere where they make that claim. WHY NOT? Well perhaps because as I point out - IT HAD NO EFFECT ON HIRING by Dominoes... In which case the whining is exactly what I called it to be.

And yes it does affect other businesses. So why would it affect other businesses MORE than it affects Dominoes? In Dominoes' case it cost them AT MOST 0.3% of revenue. Why would it cost another food purveyor more?

I'll go on to have rational conversations with more rational people.
Hmm ad hominem. You cannot address the ACTUAL FACTS so you name call

Well done.
 
That some representatives have ignored their responsibility to represent that people that elected them is immaterial. [/qote]
except that in the VAST MAJORITY of cases, representatives have made decisions and choices based on THEIR DELIBRATIONS and not just their proxy voting for PART of their constituency.

And it is only as we have gotten more direct feedback on these actions has deliberation been REDUCED.

Well today - the rabble - who don't understand about liquidity traps and Sovereign vs. personal debt and international monetary economics.. are demanding "balanced budgets" and punishing representatives, who upon learning the facts - decide to do something different.
Yes they are... and its hurting the nation.

Neither -- they're supposed to represent the POLITICAL VIEWS of the constituency.
No. They are supposed to represent the Best Interests of the constituency.
 
Teachers are highly overrated.

Here you go again Jack........ criticizing that of which you have no knowledge and less understanding.

I did go to private school, then public college, thence private university. The people who educated me were scholars, not just teachers. They loved learning and knowledge for its own sake and imparted the same to me and most of my friends who were similarly educated. A gifted educator is a precious gem, who deserves fair pay and the respect to his/her accomplishments. Some of these people spoke multiple languages, had traveled all over the work, and had accomplished jobs in the private or governmental sector as well. I remember one History professor, who was US Embassy Attache in Franco's Spain, prior to and during World War II. He lived diplomacy on the front lines during that period of time. When he spoke of that period, it wasn't someone who learned about it in books, he was actually there. He experienced it first hand. You don't get that kind of an opportunity every day. How about studying under a professor like Stephen Ambrose? Founder of the D-Day museum and author of a number of books including a biography of Eisenhower that is still recognized today as authoritative, except perhaps by revanchist historians who are so busy rewriting history, they only know what they have invented.

To quote John Boehner: "No, No,No, No, NO........."

You have to be in a classroom to understand the dynamics: social, educational, emotional, and physical. You have to be there to see the joy on a kid's face and the pride on his teacher's, when some who has been labeled a poor student takes those steps to the front of the class to receive maybe the first prize for academic achievement he has ever known. And you have to be there when a kid who was considered hopeless, walks across a stage to get his diploma. If you haven't been there, you don't know, and you never will.

You won't understand teachers who take money out of their own pockets to pay for supplies for kids whose parents can't afford them and whose state doesn't feel are worth supplying in sufficient quantity.

It's the 150th anniversary of the beginning of the Civil War and I live in a city whose history is alive with it. I ask why are students here aren't being taken to battle sites, historic homes, and the Battery where it all began, and exposed and taught about the events and the individuals and the roles they played. Not all of it's "nice" some of it is downright disgusting, but it is real, it is alive. It vibrates along King Street, Meeting Street. at the plantations that ring the city, on the Battery, and in the museums. Ask any history or civics teacher if he or she would love to give this opportunity to his students, and then ask them why they can't.

Most teachers are a national treasure, and they desire respect, fair pay, good working conditions and the tool they need in the classroom to do the job they are capable of doing. They shouldn't have to be out of the streets striking for wages of benefits we should be more than happy to give them. I despise those who pay lip service to this profession, all the while plotting to pile on more work and responsibility without incumbent compensation.

I've said all I want to say about this subject, and I fully realize that there is no convincing some people that education is the key to success no matter the chosen life path. But its ok with me if you want change over to the idea that everything is practice until you get it right. Hell if doctors and lawyers can get away with it, they are the only two professions I know of that refer to their professions as practices, I guess everyone can, at least in the Republican world of owners and serfs.

Tai Pan

ps: I will write no more on this thread. It has deteriorated into ignorant pronouncements, followed by reasoned responses that have no more chance of making a dent in antediluvian thinking than an iron nail has of surviving a sulfuric acid bath.
 
Are you out of your lunatic mind ? A teacher is the equivalent of a bank teller or secretary ? See if you have balls enough to step into an inner city class room for 1 year, and then write this kind of tripe.

Tai Pan

I'd do it in an instant. Take one of those teachers, have them quit their job and start a business, any kind, using their own money. Who would you think has the better chance of success?
 
Baloney. ONE teacher, in just ONE classroom, over the course of just ONE year, has the potential -via the lifetime prospects of the 25 kids in her classroom - to create more than $1 Million in societal wealth. And...we're just talking one year. If she's a great teacher and teaches for 40 years?...we're talkin' $40 Million in today's dollar (hey, I had a great math teacher!).

And hey...no DOUBT..not every teacher will be so excpetional as to create that wealth. But..every classroom has the potential - given the right teacher. How much is a professional who's capable of creating $40 Million worth of wealth for society, worth?

Talk about baloney, what delusional factoid magazine did you pick that up from? as if the child were a blob of clay coming out of a mold and each teacher were a sculpture. People do what they do regardless of formal education, we live we learn period. Formal education is a good thing but rated by the educators to be the cure all and some lemmings believe it.

I would say you would have to pick one child, follow him through the end of his life and document each day to even come close to proving your ridiculous statement as any kind of accuracy.
 
Back
Top