New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Recession?

By your own admisssion they just come around.. the economy is "due" for one, so what is to say that that is nothing more than a coincidence and the market needed a correction?
The historical record shows a big difference between, on the one hand long and strong growth cycles (the Clinton boom being the longest in history, and the FDR boom being the strongest in history), and short and shallow growth cycles (like the ridiculously short 12-month growth cycle that ended in Reagan's recession). The thing that happens to Republicans, again and again, isn't that their economies are simply over-due for a shrinkage cycle. It's that they just can't keep growth cycles going for anywhere close as long as Democrats typically do. Republican growth cycles tend to die premature deaths.

In all of history, there was only a single growth cycle that made it to a ripe old age under Republican presidents -- the 92-monther under Reagan/Bush -- and that one was fueled largely by enormous reductions in interest rates and ever larger deficits year after year. Aside from that, only one growth cycle even made it to six years under Republicans, and all the others in history were dead before they reached their fourth year. By comparison, we're on our sixth growth cycle that has surpassed the four-year mark under a Democrat.... and we've surpassed it by a large margin.
 
business-cycle-graph.png

What are the odds prospective voters will be looking at an economy next September similar to the one they saw in 2008?
Tough to say for sure, but as I mentioned, the last few recessions, including the one we were in back in 2008, were preceded by periods of labor market weakness. The second of Bush's two recessions started in December 2007. Job creation had already gone negative twice in July and August of that year, and hadn't cracked 115,000 since May of 2007. So, the weakness was clear for half a year before the recession officially started and for over a year by the time the election rolled around. That's just not how things are going this time. We've had job creation over 115,000 every single month since the start of 2014, except a single bad month last march -- and even that came nowhere close to going negative, with 84,000 jobs created. If we were following a track similar to the one leading up to the 2008 election, we'd already be in our third month of recession, and we'd already have three quarters of a year of weak job creation behind us. If voters end up facing something similar this year to what they saw in 2008, it'll take a much more sudden decline, without advance warning, than we had back in 2008.
 
LMAO...........as you've ben saying, now that is funny as hell, especially since we're already in a recession


According to what definition, exactly? There are two main definitions the press uses. The lay-person's definition is generally two consecutive quarters of GDP shrinkage. The last two quarters of GDP growth were positive, so even if this quarter ended up being negative (and the Fed is predicting we'll have more than twice as much growth as last quarter), that wouldn't satisfy that definition. If the Fed is anything close to right, and first quarter growth is up again, we can't be in a recession until third quarter, at the earliest -- in other words, not until October at the earliest.

The other definition is the determination of the NBER's business cycle dating committee. They make the determination by month, instead of quarter, and look to factors like job creation, instead of GDP growth. They haven't declared a recession. However, it's true that when they make the call they typically back-date it, so in theory they could later look back and say we were in recession right now. But given the importance their committee puts on job creation and other measurable signs of economic activity, that's highly unlikely, since growth is still clear in most areas, including robust payroll job creation and rising wages.

So, what definition were you relying on, exactly?
 
This is a great example of the Lukey Method, which I discussed earlier. If all the normally quoted economic stats are telling you something you don't want to believe, you'll hunt for increasingly obscure ones, usually spoon-fed to you by a right-wing propaganda outlet, until you find one that says what you want to believe. I did a search of the forum for "Kansas City Fed Composite Index" and can find no indication that anyone here has EVER mentioned it before just now. It's about as obscure as indicators go. But, at the moment, it's telling you what you want to believe, and so you'll cite it. Then, when it starts telling you something you don't want to believe, like it did in 2014, you'll stop being spoon-fed it by Tyler Durden, and you won't mention it again. If you lack any more common stats pointing the way of your prejudices, you'll just move onto some new obscure one, like the obscure stats you used to insist the economy was in deep trouble in 2014, when the KC Fed Composite was up. Have you honestly failed to detect the pattern in your own behavior?
 
Arkady has already stated he is preemptively absolving Obama from any economic consequences of his administration.
The only reason I'd want to do that is if I were a mindless Obama basher, since overall --as you well know-- the economic consequences have been positive. Real GDP per capita is way up on his watch, unemployment is way down, we've had a record-long run of job creation, we've had one of the longest growth cycles in American history, inflation is very low, consumer debt levels have plummeted, budget deficits are down by half, etc. I can understand why your side might wish to "absolve" him of the economic successes of his administration, the same way you wanted to absolve Bush's failure. But I think Obama's economic run has been decent --and an enormous improvement over his predecessor-- whether or not we end up going into recession sometime soon.
 
And you give Obama credit for the record breaking streak of 81 consecutive months of economic growth coming out of the epic GWB near-depression, no?

;-)
Just as a nit: it's been a record-long run of job-creation, but it's still got a ways to go to be a record long run of economic growth. That record belongs to the Clinton Boom, and it'll be a while, still, before that's in danger of being broken.
 
Bullshit.

Are you saying that it's bullshit that I mentioned before that we're overdue for a recession? Well, then, you're demonstrably wrong (as you usually are about everything, so I suppose you're used to it). I first mentioned that we were overdue for a correction way back in July of 2014, when we were 61 months into a growth cycle, where the average cycle was 38.7 month and post-WWII cycles have averaged 58.4 months:

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/reagan-and-obama-unemployment.72523/#post-1129900

I brought it up again later, as we became increasingly overdue:

https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...at-odds-with-actual-polls.89093/#post-1531104

The numbers are what they are. We know how long growth cycles tend to be. Only three out of 33 in history have ever run longer than the current one. In sporting terms we're the 2007-2008 Houston Rockets, riding a 22-game winning streak, the fourth-longest in NBA history. We've got a ways to go to match the 71-72 Lakers (in this case, the boom of 1991-2001), but it's pretty impressive already.
 

According to what definition, exactly? There are two main definitions the press uses. The lay-person's definition is generally two consecutive quarters of GDP shrinkage. The last two quarters of GDP growth were positive, so even if this quarter ended up being negative (and the Fed is predicting we'll have more than twice as much growth as last quarter), that wouldn't satisfy that definition. If the Fed is anything close to right, and first quarter growth is up again, we can't be in a recession until third quarter, at the earliest -- in other words, not until October at the earliest.

The other definition is the determination of the NBER's business cycle dating committee. They make the determination by month, instead of quarter, and look to factors like job creation, instead of GDP growth. They haven't declared a recession. However, it's true that when they make the call they typically back-date it, so in theory they could later look back and say we were in recession right now. But given the importance their committee puts on job creation and other measurable signs of economic activity, that's highly unlikely, since growth is still clear in most areas, including robust payroll job creation and rising wages.

So, what definition were you relying on, exactly?

http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2016...rates-still-linger-above-prerecession-levels/

c
 
This is a great example of the Lukey Method, which I discussed earlier. If all the normally quoted economic stats are telling you something you don't want to believe, you'll hunt for increasingly obscure ones, usually spoon-fed to you by a right-wing propaganda outlet, until you find one that says what you want to believe. I did a search of the forum for "Kansas City Fed Composite Index" and can find no indication that anyone here has EVER mentioned it before just now. It's about as obscure as indicators go. But, at the moment, it's telling you what you want to believe, and so you'll cite it. Then, when it starts telling you something you don't want to believe, like it did in 2014, you'll stop being spoon-fed it by Tyler Durden, and you won't mention it again. If you lack any more common stats pointing the way of your prejudices, you'll just move onto some new obscure one, like the obscure stats you used to insist the economy was in deep trouble in 2014, when the KC Fed Composite was up. Have you honestly failed to detect the pattern in your own behavior?

Yeah, it's just our imagination...

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...se-dallas-fed-respondents-us-economy-freefall
 
The historical record shows a big difference between, on the one hand long and strong growth cycles (the Clinton boom being the longest in history, and the FDR boom being the strongest in history), and short and shallow growth cycles (like the ridiculously short 12-month growth cycle that ended in Reagan's recession). The thing that happens to Republicans, again and again, isn't that their economies are simply over-due for a shrinkage cycle. It's that they just can't keep growth cycles going for anywhere close as long as Democrats typically do. Republican growth cycles tend to die premature deaths.

In all of history, there was only a single growth cycle that made it to a ripe old age under Republican presidents -- the 92-monther under Reagan/Bush -- and that one was fueled largely by enormous reductions in interest rates and ever larger deficits year after year. Aside from that, only one growth cycle even made it to six years under Republicans, and all the others in history were dead before they reached their fourth year. By comparison, we're on our sixth growth cycle that has surpassed the four-year mark under a Democrat.... and we've surpassed it by a large margin.

So, what you are saying then is democrats leave a pending economic disaster - such as this looming recession that will likely end up "starting" under the next president, potentially a Republican. But, they instead - what we do is blame Republicans when they have to clean up the messes of Democratic policies and allow them to take the credit for the growing economies they lay the groundwork for.
 
The Lukey Method is predictable as can be. I'm sure you'd love to be able to go back to the well of one of your previous obscure stats, so that it could seem like a principled preference for that indicator, rather than an opportunistic hunt for confirmation by someone who, in Tyler Durden's unintentionally revealing turn of phrase, is "interested in hearing some horror stories." So, I'm sure, you'd love to be able to point to the Atlanta Fed's GDP forecast, as you did in the past when it looked bad. But, right now, the Atlanta Fed GDPnow forecast is solidly in positive territory, and over twice what last quarter's GDP came in at, so you need to go hunting for some anecdotes rather than going back to that well, at least until it returns to telling you what you want to believe.

I think it's helpful to revisit that GDPNow stat, and your past use of it, because it's so revealing about how the Lukey Method works. Back in April 2015, Tyler Durden pointed you to the GDP Now stat, because a very early forecast for second quarter 2015 (91 days ahead of the official first announcement) had said that GDP growth that quarter would be just 0.9%.

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/u-s-commerce-department-must-be-racist.81664/#post-1329816

I pointed out that the Fed's forecasts were basically useless that early in the cycle, and I showed it to you statistically -- you't have been a lot more accurate just blindly guessing 2.1% every quarter than relying on the Fed's prediction 91 days out. Sure enough, the 0.9% prediction you and Tyler Durden were so aroused by ended up being wildly off base. Actual GDP growth that quarter was 3.9%. But the point wasn't that you thought a prediction by the Fed 90+ days out had value. It's just that they were telling you what you wanted to believe, and so you'd quote them. Right now, they're not telling you what you want to believe, so you won't quote them. If never month they go back to telling you what you want to believe, Tyler Durden will inform you of that and you'll cut-and-paste them again. And if next months Dallas fed respondents are bullish, you'll forget they exist until the next time they're confirming your biases. With literally thousands of potential indicators to choose from, you'll always be able to find some that tell you what you want to believe, with the help of Tyler Durden to bring them to your attention.
 
So, what you are saying then is democrats leave a pending economic disaster

No. We can test for this easily enough by looking only at Democrats who inherit from Democrats and Republicans who inherit from Republicans. When Democrats inherit their economies from Democrats (Truman and Johnson), we tend to get strong economic performance. When Republicans inherit from Republicans (Hoover, Ford, and the first Bush), we tend to get horrible economic performance.

Facts matter. Learn some.
 
Are you saying that it's bullshit that I mentioned before that we're overdue for a recession? Well, then, you're demonstrably wrong (as you usually are about everything, so I suppose you're used to it). I first mentioned that we were overdue for a correction way back in July of 2014, when we were 61 months into a growth cycle, where the average cycle was 38.7 month and post-WWII cycles have averaged 58.4 months:

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/reagan-and-obama-unemployment.72523/#post-1129900

I brought it up again later, as we became increasingly overdue:

https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...at-odds-with-actual-polls.89093/#post-1531104

The numbers are what they are. We know how long growth cycles tend to be. Only three out of 33 in history have ever run longer than the current one. In sporting terms we're the 2007-2008 Houston Rockets, riding a 22-game winning streak, the fourth-longest in NBA history. We've got a ways to go to match the 71-72 Lakers (in this case, the boom of 1991-2001), but it's pretty impressive already.
Oh please, you're the gullible monger who asserts the recession cycles match the president in power cycle and now you want pretend that isn't your belief system because you're divining that Obama is about to have one recession of his own.
 
The Lukey Method is predictable as can be. I'm sure you'd love to be able to go back to the well of one of your previous obscure stats, so that it could seem like a principled preference for that indicator, rather than an opportunistic hunt for confirmation by someone who, in Tyler Durden's unintentionally revealing turn of phrase, is "interested in hearing some horror stories." So, I'm sure, you'd love to be able to point to the Atlanta Fed's GDP forecast, as you did in the past when it looked bad. But, right now, the Atlanta Fed GDPnow forecast is solidly in positive territory, and over twice what last quarter's GDP came in at, so you need to go hunting for some anecdotes rather than going back to that well, at least until it returns to telling you what you want to believe.

I think it's helpful to revisit that GDPNow stat, and your past use of it, because it's so revealing about how the Lukey Method works. Back in April 2015, Tyler Durden pointed you to the GDP Now stat, because a very early forecast for second quarter 2015 (91 days ahead of the official first announcement) had said that GDP growth that quarter would be just 0.9%.

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/u-s-commerce-department-must-be-racist.81664/#post-1329816

I pointed out that the Fed's forecasts were basically useless that early in the cycle, and I showed it to you statistically -- you't have been a lot more accurate just blindly guessing 2.1% every quarter than relying on the Fed's prediction 91 days out. Sure enough, the 0.9% prediction you and Tyler Durden were so aroused by ended up being wildly off base. Actual GDP growth that quarter was 3.9%. But the point wasn't that you thought a prediction by the Fed 90+ days out had value. It's just that they were telling you what you wanted to believe, and so you'd quote them. Right now, they're not telling you what you want to believe, so you won't quote them. If never month they go back to telling you what you want to believe, Tyler Durden will inform you of that and you'll cut-and-paste them again. And if next months Dallas fed respondents are bullish, you'll forget they exist until the next time they're confirming your biases. With literally thousands of potential indicators to choose from, you'll always be able to find some that tell you what you want to believe, with the help of Tyler Durden to bring them to your attention.

The cycle? You talkin' 'bout the CYCLE? You kiddin' me?

Screen Shot 2016-02-29 at 6.40.29 AM.png
You like to focus on the "cycle" (or short run) because it gives you the utmost political leeway to propagandize on behalf of the Democrats' pitiful economic record.

In the long run, our economy is dying...regardless of which party held the White House. You can pretend that the decline only happens when the other team has the ball but you can't keep shooting yourself in the foot and expect to win! That's the picture of your economy on progressivism - oh, and don't forget to enjoy the decline...
 
Oh please, you're the gullible monger who asserts the recession cycles match the president in power cycle and now you want pretend that isn't your belief system because you're divining that Obama is about to have one recession of his own.
Could you please specifically cite one of those supposed assertions about recession cycles matching the president? Once you do, I can explain to you what I was actually saying, and we can work to identify how you went so badly wrong.
 
The cycle? You talkin' 'bout the CYCLE? You kiddin' me?

View attachment 30139
You like to focus on the "cycle" (or short run) because it gives you the utmost political leeway to propagandize on behalf of the Democrats' pitiful economic record.

In the long run, our economy is dying...regardless of which party held the White House. You can pretend that the decline only happens when the other team has the ball but you can't keep shooting yourself in the foot and expect to win! That's the picture of your economy on progressivism - oh, and don't forget to enjoy the decline...
Do you know what average real per capita GDP growth was before the progressive era?
 
Back
Top