Arkady
President
I found the following calculations of internal rate of return on Social Security contributions, as part of a discussion we were having elsewhere on the topic:
https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/NOTES/ran5/an2012-5.html
As you can see, your expected rate of return on Social Security depends on a lot of factors. One of them is gender. Since women live longer, they tend to get more value back. Another is when you were born -- Social Security paid out VASTLY in excess of contributions in the past, whereas these days retirement age has been raised and SS taxes are higher, so the return isn't as sweet. Where a medium earner born in 1920 could have had an effective return of 6.49% (based on a single-earner couple), at the same medium earning level today, the same couple would earn 4.51%. Keep in mind that's already factoring in longer lives in retirement today -- even with that, the return has gotten almost two points worse because of the later retirement age and the higher contribution rates.
That's why I reacted so harshly to Obama's attempts to appease Republicans with a move to chained-CPI COLAs. Politically, those made sense, since it allowed old people to get away with almost no sacrifices, while those hard-hit would be young folks who are too far from retirement to realize how hard Obama was screwing them. Since the decrease in the effective COLA rate compounded over time, it would be a tiny downward adjustment in lifetime benefits for the old, and a gigantic one for the young. Yet, as these tables show, the old already have been getting a tremendous deal from Social Security (a 6.49% return on a rock-solid safe investment), whereas the young were already getting something of questionable value (a mere 4.51% return). Making the deal even worse for those who already were getting a questionable deal was cynical as hell.
Anyway, the other thing to note about the system is the way that effective returns fall by income. Even for a middle-income person born in a given year, like 1973, the rate of return is much better if you're lower income (6.49%), than if you're at the high end of earnings (2.81%). I'm fine with that, since I think part of what Social Security was always intended to be is a form of wealth redistribution. If you're lucky in life and earn tons of money, you wind up supplementing the retirements of those who are less lucky. But what I don't approve of is how that re-distribution caps out. As you move up the income scale, you move from the category of being subsidized to the category of doing the subsidizing. Then you keep moving up and are expected to subsidize more and more. And that general rule holds true consistently through a certain point, where suddenly you reach the SS tax cap, and then things go flat. Although someone earning $120,000/year is expected to subsidize less fortunate retirees more than someone earning $100,000/year, someone earning $140,000/year (or $100 million, for that matter), doesn't subsidize the less fortunate retirees even one penny more than someone earning $120,000 per year. Why that special exception, just for the rich, that eliminates the normal rule of rising assistance for the less fortunate as you move up the ladder?
I could see insisting on an SS system with no re-distributive aspect -- where what you get out is strictly proportional to what you pay in. But what I don't get is a system that is smoothly re-distributive all the way up the income distribution until you get to $118,500 in individual earnings, then suddenly re-distribution is declared illegitimate and the rich are allowed to stop paying above the cap. A special rule like that, just for the rich, strikes me as intellectually inconsistent -- either make the SS system non-redistributive, or subject the rich to the same rules as everyone else by removing the cap, but don't keep it as redistributive while giving them a special exception.
https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/NOTES/ran5/an2012-5.html
As you can see, your expected rate of return on Social Security depends on a lot of factors. One of them is gender. Since women live longer, they tend to get more value back. Another is when you were born -- Social Security paid out VASTLY in excess of contributions in the past, whereas these days retirement age has been raised and SS taxes are higher, so the return isn't as sweet. Where a medium earner born in 1920 could have had an effective return of 6.49% (based on a single-earner couple), at the same medium earning level today, the same couple would earn 4.51%. Keep in mind that's already factoring in longer lives in retirement today -- even with that, the return has gotten almost two points worse because of the later retirement age and the higher contribution rates.
That's why I reacted so harshly to Obama's attempts to appease Republicans with a move to chained-CPI COLAs. Politically, those made sense, since it allowed old people to get away with almost no sacrifices, while those hard-hit would be young folks who are too far from retirement to realize how hard Obama was screwing them. Since the decrease in the effective COLA rate compounded over time, it would be a tiny downward adjustment in lifetime benefits for the old, and a gigantic one for the young. Yet, as these tables show, the old already have been getting a tremendous deal from Social Security (a 6.49% return on a rock-solid safe investment), whereas the young were already getting something of questionable value (a mere 4.51% return). Making the deal even worse for those who already were getting a questionable deal was cynical as hell.
Anyway, the other thing to note about the system is the way that effective returns fall by income. Even for a middle-income person born in a given year, like 1973, the rate of return is much better if you're lower income (6.49%), than if you're at the high end of earnings (2.81%). I'm fine with that, since I think part of what Social Security was always intended to be is a form of wealth redistribution. If you're lucky in life and earn tons of money, you wind up supplementing the retirements of those who are less lucky. But what I don't approve of is how that re-distribution caps out. As you move up the income scale, you move from the category of being subsidized to the category of doing the subsidizing. Then you keep moving up and are expected to subsidize more and more. And that general rule holds true consistently through a certain point, where suddenly you reach the SS tax cap, and then things go flat. Although someone earning $120,000/year is expected to subsidize less fortunate retirees more than someone earning $100,000/year, someone earning $140,000/year (or $100 million, for that matter), doesn't subsidize the less fortunate retirees even one penny more than someone earning $120,000 per year. Why that special exception, just for the rich, that eliminates the normal rule of rising assistance for the less fortunate as you move up the ladder?
I could see insisting on an SS system with no re-distributive aspect -- where what you get out is strictly proportional to what you pay in. But what I don't get is a system that is smoothly re-distributive all the way up the income distribution until you get to $118,500 in individual earnings, then suddenly re-distribution is declared illegitimate and the rich are allowed to stop paying above the cap. A special rule like that, just for the rich, strikes me as intellectually inconsistent -- either make the SS system non-redistributive, or subject the rich to the same rules as everyone else by removing the cap, but don't keep it as redistributive while giving them a special exception.
Last edited: