New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

sit down, let me explain to you just how much heat came up from the Arctic Ocean floor.

way more than 81 Mt St Helens explosions every day for 40 years.

A frickin' mountain range 1100 miles long pushed up on the ocean floor. And yes, that's geo thermal activity every day for 40 years, it is still kicking out a massive amount of heat. Did you read anything I linked?

how many Mt St Helens mountains can we fit into a mountain range 1100 miles long?

how about 1100 miles divide by 5 miles = 220 Mt St Helens.

Meanwhile, air temps were averaging at least 30 degrees (F) below freezing, so air temps were adding to the ice cap, even with the heat from the volcanic activity warming the air.

If the geo-thermal heat didn't have to melt so much ice before it escaped into the atmosphere, north pole temps would have become tropical over the past 40 years.

carbon dioxide is not going to produce heat in the air at the North pole anyway; the angle of the sun's rays are so extreme, there's nothing there for the carbon dioxide to work with.

Does carbon dioxide increase air temps? sure. Did carbon dioxide melt any ice in the Arctic Circle? Hell no.

Actually, warming from the greenhouse effect is most pronounced at the highest latitudes. What the CO2 (and other greenhouse gasses like H2O, the concentration of which is increased by warming which causes more evaporation) actually does is prevent the heat from escaping. And this effect is most pronounced when it doesn't flow to colder areas around the earth's surface but can only go upward.
 
Actually, a firm consensus of qualified scientists (you and I are not) think the same. The air heats the water and the water melts the ice.
I know, but they need to break the laws of thermodynamics to pull it off. Subfreezing air does not melt ice, it freezes water.
 
Actually, warming from the greenhouse effect is most pronounced at the highest latitudes. What the CO2 (and other greenhouse gasses like H2O, the concentration of which is increased by warming which causes more evaporation) actually does is prevent the heat from escaping. And this effect is most pronounced when it doesn't flow to colder areas around the earth's surface but can only go upward.
All that heat at the North pole, eh? Nothing like trapping 10 below zero air temps for melting ice... what could go wrong?
 
I know, but they need to break the laws of thermodynamics to pull it off. Subfreezing air does not melt ice, it freezes water.

And if all the air in the troposphere (no matter where on the globe and no matter what time of year) were sub-freezing, all the water would freeze. Instead, warmer air heats water which then ends up in areas where the air is colder. Warm air and water warm the Arctic air, meaning it is sub-freezing for less of the year.
 
Actually, a firm consensus of qualified scientists (you and I are not) think the same. The air heats the water and the water melts the ice.
I don't believe that. Real scientists may be in on the hoax, but no real scientists believe it's anything but a hoax.
 
And if all the air in the troposphere (no matter where on the globe and no matter what time of year) were sub-freezing, all the water would freeze. Instead, warmer air heats water which then ends up in areas where the air is colder. Warm air and water warm the Arctic air, meaning it is sub-freezing for less of the year.
Warm water heats the air... this is exactly what I've been saying. Heat rises.

So can we end this? Greenhouse gases did not warm the air in the Arctic Circle enough to melt the ice cap... because in the first place, the air in the Arctic circle never melted any ice, it added to the ice, but it didn't melt any ice. Cause and effect. If the average air temp is below freezing, even one degree below freezing, then air temps are adding ice, not depleting it. That's absolutely positively how it works, you can't get around that. You can't pretend that Greenhouse gases were melting the ice cap if air temps were not warm enough to melt the ice cap. If air temps got so warm that they averaged above freezing... then you could argue for your theory; it would still be wrong because the air temps were warmed by the water, but at least you would have an opening to try and pull it off; but if air temps didn't melt any ice to begin with, the idea that greenhouse gases could be responsible for melting ice - that the air temps were not warm enough to melt - it is a total non-starter.
 
Warm water heats the air... this is exactly what I've been saying. Heat rises.

So can we end this? Greenhouse gases did not warm the air in the Arctic Circle enough to melt the ice cap... because in the first place, the air in the Arctic circle never melted any ice, it added to the ice, but it didn't melt any ice. Cause and effect. If the average air temp is below freezing, even one degree below freezing, then air temps are adding ice, not depleting it. That's absolutely positively how it works, you can't get around that. You can't pretend that Greenhouse gases were melting the ice cap if air temps were not warm enough to melt the ice cap. If air temps got so warm that they averaged above freezing... then you could argue for your theory; it would still be wrong because the air temps were warmed by the water, but at least you would have an opening to try and pull it off; but if air temps didn't melt any ice to begin with, the idea that greenhouse gases could be responsible for melting ice - that the air temps were not warm enough to melt - it is a total non-starter.

Air temperatures in the Arctic do get that warm, every year.
 
With those little, tiny hands? Not a chance...
My hands are average size but unusually strong. Even when I haven't been training, I can do a few reps on a Captains of Crush 2 (195 lbs). I used to work a 2.5, trying to get up to a 3, but never got to the point that I could close a 3.
 
sit down, let me explain to you just how much heat came up from the Arctic Ocean floor.

way more than 81 Mt St Helens explosions every day for 40 years.

What, specifically, makes you think that? What's the output of that range, exactly? You seem to think that because a bunch of Mt. St. Helens can fit along the range, it must be putting out the amount of energy of that many of them. But, obviously, when a mountain puts out that kind of energy, it blows itself apart:

ed595f0b6bf25a9933d6224e328bb33c.jpg

What do you think would happen if that kind of energy were being put out under water?

If the geo-thermal heat didn't have to melt so much ice before it escaped into the atmosphere, north pole temps would have become tropical over the past 40 years.

By all means, link to the evidence supporting that.

carbon dioxide is not going to produce heat in the air at the North pole anyway; the angle of the sun's rays are so extreme, there's nothing there for the carbon dioxide to work with.

You seem not to have understood even the most basic concept of air and water circulation. The global warming theory isn't based on the idea of a lot of direct warming at the poles. After all, they have very high albedo -- much of the light that hits them just bounces back into space immediately, and, as you suggest, the angle is extreme enough they aren't getting much of it to begin with. But heat moves around the globe. The rising heat at the equator doesn't just stay there. It moves around by way of air and water currents. And both those things help to melt the Arctic.
 
Well, the phony chart did it for me, I'm convinced now that I need to buy me a cabin, in Colorado on Pikes Peak, up above the Timberline, so when the water rises up to my front porch, I can fish from my rocking chair.
Maybe I need to buy a tree from Al Gore so I can do my part to stave off this man-made disaster. I really feel sorry for all those poor dumb shits who still think that God is in charge of this world, and refuse to bow to the throne of Bill Nye, THE science guy and Al Gore the presidential wannabe.
Crass sarcasm aside, the question remains. What makes you think the global temp hasn't risen for 20 years? You could check NASAs numbers, or NOAAs, or the Met Office's, or the Japan meteorological agency's, or Berkeley Earth's. Do any of those show a 20-year hiatus in warming?
 
Air temperatures in the Arctic do get that warm, every year.
Dumb dumb probably can't figure out why the undersea mountain range has a volcanic cycle of exactly a year, coincidentally lining up with the seasons, to cause a big melt off of ice every summer and refreezing every winter.
 
Crass sarcasm aside, the question remains. What makes you think the global temp hasn't risen for 20 years? You could check NASAs numbers, or NOAAs, or the Met Office's, or the Japan meteorological agency's, or Berkeley Earth's. Do any of those show a 20-year hiatus in warming?
the NOAA climate reference site monitoring - stations located outside of urban "heat islands" shows a gradual decline in US temps. See links below.

Foreign sites don't show a decline. But they include a heavy mix of urban sites subject to local intereference, and are subject to "adjustment". The NOAA reference sites are the 'gold standard' for terrestrial monitoring.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamest...show-u-s-in-decade-long-cooling/#54c641ce1a18

2000.jpg

uscrn-trend-plot-from-ncdc-data1.png
 
the NOAA climate reference site monitoring - stations located outside of urban "heat islands" shows a gradual decline in US temps.

You seem to have responded to the wrong post. The post you responded to is asking about global temperatures, not regional ones. No doubt there are regions where temperature declined during those 20 years. And likewise there were regions where it rose much more than the global average in those 20 years. That's consistent with mainstream scientific expectations, which expressly didn't anticipate uniform changes across the face of the globe.

Anyway, take a look at the graph you posted:

2000.jpg

As you can see, the "gold standard" reference network tracks the historical network almost exactly. In other words, when they ran the numbers using only the very best sites, they got a result that was essentially the same as they'd gotten when they ran the numbers using the whole historical network. What does this tell you?

Here, I'll help you: it tells you the "heat island" effect didn't end up making any significant difference. The denialists had been hanging a lot of hope on the idea that global warming was just a data quirk resulting from growing heat islands around cities, and that once you controlled for that, the results would be very different. That theory was tested in the US and proved wrong. After you control for it, the results are nearly identical. What that did was to boost confidence in the historical networks globally -- if the heat island effect made no real difference in the US, then it would be expected to have made no real difference elsewhere, too. Thus, the global data showing rising temperatures is more convincing than ever, now that the main denialist idea has been eliminated as a plausible explanation for the apparent warming.

That's what's so funny about the dumb end of the denialist bell curve being so eager to cite that "pristine site" data. They imagine that somehow it undermines the mainstream science, when in fact it undermines the denialist counter-narrative. The smarter denialists get that, and tend to avoid that data because of it -- they rightly see it as being the thing that killed the best theory the denialists ever came up with to try to invalidate the data. But the vast majority of denialists haven't the foggiest notion about science, and still haven't managed to grasp the implications of that study.
 
Well, the phony chart did it for me, I'm convinced now that I need to buy me a cabin, in Colorado on Pikes Peak, up above the Timberline, so when the water rises up to my front porch, I can fish from my rocking chair.
Maybe I need to buy a tree from Al Gore so I can do my part to stave off this man-made disaster. I really feel sorry for all those poor dumb shits who still think that God is in charge of this world, and refuse to bow to the throne of Bill Nye, THE science guy and Al Gore the presidential wannabe.

See, that's part of the problem. The people who push those phony charts typically don't do a thing to reduce their own footprint. In fact, the goal of the whole thing for most of them is to make money, so they can buy bigger homes, bigger cars, and bigger boats.
 
See, that's part of the problem. The people who push those phony charts typically don't do a thing to reduce their own footprint. In fact, the goal of the whole thing for most of them is to make money, so they can buy bigger homes, bigger cars, and bigger boats.
Exactly, Al Gore and his airplane that spews more gunk into the air than Mount St Helens, and lives in a house with a footprint the size of some small towns. And Leonardo de Cappuccino, who has a yacht bigger than the QE-2.
 
My hands are average size but unusually strong. Even when I haven't been training, I can do a few reps on a Captains of Crush 2 (195 lbs). I used to work a 2.5, trying to get up to a 3, but never got to the point that I could close a 3.
Did you mean to say Captain Crunch.
http://www.capncrunch.com/
My guess is you do more reps on Captain Crunch than on anything else.
 
What, specifically, makes you think that? What's the output of that range, exactly? You seem to think that because a bunch of Mt. St. Helens can fit along the range, it must be putting out the amount of energy of that many of them. But, obviously, when a mountain puts out that kind of energy, it blows itself apart:

ed595f0b6bf25a9933d6224e328bb33c.jpg

What do you think would happen if that kind of energy were being put out under water?



By all means, link to the evidence supporting that.
You lazy son-of-a-gun. I did Link the evidence, I even copy pasted it into posts, I asked you three or four times if you had read any of it, you keep repeating the same mistakes, you haven't acknowledged any of the links or having clicked on a single one, and then you have the unmitigated gall to ask me to ""By all means, link to the evidence supporting that." I explained the event to you also and after all that, you post a representation of total ignorance of any of it. What it does ... it shows me why you refuse to learn anything on this subject ... either you are not reading our posts or you just don't care about the truth, you are stuck in your religion; as far as you are concerned, the earth is flat and all the evidence of all mankind proves it is flat and the rest of us are hopelessly stupid.

You seem not to have understood even the most basic concept of air and water circulation. The global warming theory isn't based on the idea of a lot of direct warming at the poles. After all, they have very high albedo -- much of the light that hits them just bounces back into space immediately, and, as you suggest, the angle is extreme enough they aren't getting much of it to begin with. But heat moves around the globe. The rising heat at the equator doesn't just stay there. It moves around by way of air and water currents. And both those things help to melt the Arctic.
I don't seem to understand basic concepts of air and water circulation but I guess I stumbled onto the severe angle of reflection of the sun's rays at the North Pole... interesting, seeing as I stumbled onto that point many years ago and you resisted it all these years until this post.

What you just explained is why warm water currents are heating the water on the edge of the Arctic Circle. More reason the increase in air temps in the Arctic Circle is coming from the water. But you guys are claiming the ice cap melted from the heat in the air. As ignorant as I am of global air circulation, I still know that both poles have polar vortex winds that wall out outside intervention from oceanic currents.

Regardless of whatever influence the Arctic air temps received from ocean currents, the fact remains that the average air temp for the years in question (and for as long as the North pole sat on top of a spinning earth tilted to the sun) is 35-45 degrees (F) below freezing. Explain all you want where the heat came from... you still don't have enough heat in the air to melt any ice. The ice cap melt was a direct result of geo-thermal heat that rose through the water when an entire mountain ridge rose up on the ocean floor. The ridge is still very active, as all my links pointed out, and they point it out in the headlines, God, just read the headlines!
 
Last edited:
Ah yes, thanks for the reminder. They aren't all just right wing websites. The denialist dummies also like to pull from an infamous British tabloid that, when it's not publishing juicy stories about celebrity affairs, likes to host climate change denialist garbage.
you are saying, that all evidence of an 1100 mountain ridge - that now has a name - is false? ... there is no mountain ridge on the Arctic floor? You already acknowledged it exists, so why are you claiming the websites are all right wing? What are you refuting?

How much volcanic activity does it require to raise up that 1100 mile long ridge?????

We are talking about a 1100 mile long split in the ocean floor spewing magma and 3000 degree (F) gas into the Arctic ocean directly below the ice cap.

You seem to think that 3000 degrees (F) rising directly below the ice cap could not possibly melt the ice, while you maintain that heat in the air - which doesn't exist - the average air temp at the North pole is still 35 degrees (F) below freezing - yeah, the freezing cold air at the North Pole is what you think melted the ice.

stupid
 
Last edited:
Back
Top