New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

They continue to evolve. In fact, the only thing I can say with certainty is that the scientific community has failed to convince me either way.

They'd failed to convince you 10, 20, and 30 years ago too, I presume. So, that's not an evolution. As I pointed out, a VAST amount of new information has come in during those three decades -- record high global temps with accelerating warming, piles of new data, research, and analysis, a deepening and broadening consensus among the experts, the debunking of various alternate theories, etc. The question is whether any of that has altered your beliefs. If you'd kept an open mind, it would be pretty much impossible for it not to have altered your beliefs..... maybe it wouldn't yet be enough to convince you, but you'd at least have greatly altered the probability you ascribed to various possibilities. If, instead, you find you're in the same state of complacent agnosticism you were in decades ago, it suggests the information didn't actually make its way into your closed mind.

You appear to be all settled in

No. As you're aware, I do not appear to be settled in, since my views have been changing substantially over the years in light of the major developments in the field. YOU are comfortably settled in to your safe space of insisting it's the scientific community's fault you aren't convinced, and I expect you to be sitting in that exact same safe space the day you die, because you find it a very comfortable place to hang out. So long as you keep your mind closed to new information, nothing can nudge you out of that rut you've dug for yourself.
 
They'd failed to convince you 10, 20, and 30 years ago too, I presume. So, that's not an evolution. As I pointed out, a VAST amount of new information has come in during those three decades -- record high global temps with accelerating warming, piles of new data, research, and analysis, a deepening and broadening consensus among the experts, the debunking of various alternate theories, etc. The question is whether any of that has altered your beliefs. If you'd kept an open mind, it would be pretty much impossible for it not to have altered your beliefs..... maybe it wouldn't yet be enough to convince you, but you'd at least have greatly altered the probability you ascribed to various possibilities. If, instead, you find you're in the same state of complacent agnosticism you were in decades ago, it suggests the information didn't actually make its way into your closed mind.



No. As you're aware, I do not appear to be settled in, since my views have been changing substantially over the years in light of the major developments in the field. YOU are comfortably settled in to your safe space of insisting it's the scientific community's fault you aren't convinced, and I expect you to be sitting in that exact same safe space the day you die, because you find it a very comfortable place to hang out. So long as you keep your mind closed to new information, nothing can nudge you out of that rut you've dug for yourself.

You have a firm position and have drawn a conclusion, and no one is going to talk you out of it. You're convinced, you think everyone else should be likewise convinced, and find it intolerable if they are not.

I'm keeping an open mind.

You have no idea what my thoughts were 10, 20, 0r 30 years ago, but being a closed-minded individual, you've assigned me the position you feel most comfortable believing. Believe what you wish, it doesn't really matter. It's not like you're open to change anyway.
 
Rather than responding to the entire "Gish Gallop" here, I'll focus on just one of the persistent lies that keeps making the rounds:

Two years later, Dr. Hansen told an interviewer that in 20 years, the area below his New York City office would be completely changed, most notably that “the West Side Highway [which runs along the Hudson River] will be under water.”
​
So, did Hansen actually tell an interviewer that in 20 years the West Side Highway would be under water? Check your own link, embedded in the bolded, blue text, for an answer. According to that link, both of those involved in the conversation report that Hansen had been asked to speculate about what would happen in forty years, if CO2 doubled.

So, the prediction is based on what things would look like in 2028 if CO2 reached 560 ppm. Right now CO2 is about 407 ppm and increasing about 2.11 ppm per year. So by 2028, it'll be around 430.21 ppm. If the rate keeps going up by 2.11/year, we'd be at the 560 ppm mark by 2089. Will the West Side Highway be under water by then? No clue. But if you're going to fault Hansen, obviously you should do so based on what he actually said, not some claim you are putting into his mouth.

That could be true except there is no evidence to support your claim. Lots of if's. ...Like If my bank account were a lot bigger I could drive a Ferrari 488 spider although not the car I really want, but IF the CO2 decreases every year this will never happen...Get it?
 
I suppose the solution to the problem of there being such a plethora of of predictions that were wildly inaccurate would be to quit making wildly inaccurate predictions.....:>)

No it's not gonna stop the Global crazies from exposing their true agenda.
 
You have a firm position and have drawn a conclusion, and no one is going to talk you out of it

No. As you know, my position hasn't been firm at all. It's not like your long-unchanged insistence that the scientists haven't convinced you one way or the other -- a position I fully expect to remain permanent. My position has evolved over time, in response to the changing science. I expect it to keep doing so. That doesn't mean I'm going to wake up tomorrow transformed into one of those imbeciles who rejects the vast weight of the science simply because it's personally or politically inconvenient. But as the weight of the science shifts, so will my opinions, as has always been true.

Imagine an alternate history, starting back in 1986, when Hansen made the predictions that in 20 years the temperature would be one degree above the pre-industrial level, that warming would be happening fast enough to show up above the "noise" of shorter term variations, and that the warming would be continuing to accelerate. Now, as you know, in our world that all ended up being correct. Within 20 years temps were about a degree above pre-industrial levels, the warming was showing up clearly above the "noise," and the pace of the warming has continued to accelerate since then. But in that alternate history, imagine that's not what happened. Imagine that temperatures had spent years declining right back to the point where they were barely discernible from pre-industrial levels (as had been the case in the years immediately after 1945). Imagine that no easily discernible pattern emerged above the "noise" and that no evidence of accelerating warming had shown up.

In that alternate timeline, your views would presumably be identical to what they are in this timeline -- you'd be saying the scientists have failed to convince you one way or the other. I, on the other hand, would have very different views. Instead of believing the scientists had a pretty solid handle on the big picture of what's happening, I'd be very doubtful about their conclusions.

That's what having an open mind looks like: your views actually respond to stuff that happens in the outside world. You're mistaking an "open mind" for an unwavering refusal to allow events to nudge you out of the non-committal position you find so comfortable.

You have no idea what my thoughts were 10, 20, 0r 30 years ago

Contradict me, then. What were you thoughts at the time? Were you convinced global warming was happening? Were you convinced it wasn't? Or were you in the same position of comfortably complacent agnosticism on the subject? Am I wrong? Did the events of that time meaningfully change your views?
 
That could be true except there is no evidence to support your claim. Lots of if's. ...Like If my bank account were a lot bigger I could drive a Ferrari 488 spider although not the car I really want, but IF the CO2 decreases every year this will never happen...Get it?
No, I don't get it. I don't have the foggiest notion what you're trying to say.
 
No. That's not my position. Again, it's odd you'd think it was. My position is that fossil fuel burning since the start of the industrial revolution raised greenhouse levels in the atmosphere setting off a cycle of global warming that is now occurring at an unprecedented pace .
ooooooooh, okay, now I understand, my bad, cuz, I thought you was trying to say the ice cores proved out the greenhouse gas theory... which would have been terribly wrong.
 
No. As you know, my position hasn't been firm at all. It's not like your long-unchanged insistence that the scientists haven't convinced you one way or the other -- a position I fully expect to remain permanent. My position has evolved over time, in response to the changing science. I expect it to keep doing so. That doesn't mean I'm going to wake up tomorrow transformed into one of those imbeciles who rejects the vast weight of the science simply because it's personally or politically inconvenient. But as the weight of the science shifts, so will my opinions, as has always been true.

Imagine an alternate history, starting back in 1986, when Hansen made the predictions that in 20 years the temperature would be one degree above the pre-industrial level, that warming would be happening fast enough to show up above the "noise" of shorter term variations, and that the warming would be continuing to accelerate. Now, as you know, in our world that all ended up being correct. Within 20 years temps were about a degree above pre-industrial levels, the warming was showing up clearly above the "noise," and the pace of the warming has continued to accelerate since then. But in that alternate history, imagine that's not what happened. Imagine that temperatures had spent years declining right back to the point where they were barely discernible from pre-industrial levels (as had been the case in the years immediately after 1945). Imagine that no easily discernible pattern emerged above the "noise" and that no evidence of accelerating warming had shown up.

In that alternate timeline, your views would presumably be identical to what they are in this timeline -- you'd be saying the scientists have failed to convince you one way or the other. I, on the other hand, would have very different views. Instead of believing the scientists had a pretty solid handle on the big picture of what's happening, I'd be very doubtful about their conclusions.

That's what having an open mind looks like: your views actually respond to stuff that happens in the outside world. You're mistaking an "open mind" for an unwavering refusal to allow events to nudge you out of the non-committal position you find so comfortable.



Contradict me, then. What were you thoughts at the time? Were you convinced global warming was happening? Were you convinced it wasn't? Or were you in the same position of comfortably complacent agnosticism on the subject? Am I wrong? Did the events of that time meaningfully change your views?

Notice how you utilize the word "convinced" - It betrays the flaw in your thinking process. It implies a destination, rather than a journey. Once you have arrived at your destination, the journey is complete. For you, your journey is complete- you've arrived, and your journeying is over.

I'm still on the journey, still with an open mind, still exploring new possibilities. Sadly, your mind is made up, and now your only interest is "convincing" others. You're done thinking, you're in the agenda mode.

I have no interest in "convincing" you about what I thought 30 years ago - You can conjure up whatever fantasy about that you wish to.
 
The darkly humorous things about the least educated denialists, like you, is that they're utterly incapable of thinking through the implications of their own points. If we didn't have ice core data showing how higher global temps can boost CO2, we'd actually be at liberty to be a lot less worried about global warming. After all, in that situation we could expect that once things start to get unacceptably warm, we can reign in our greenhouse gas emissions, and things will just stop there. One of the reasons the stakes are so high is that we have plenty of evidence, including that ice core data, telling us that isn't true: that higher temps can result in more greenhouse gas emissions, independent from direct human causes. That means there's a likelihood that the feedback loops will tend to amplify, rather than muffle, the impacts of our actions. Even after we put on the brakes, we may well see CO2 levels in the atmosphere continuing to rise, as a result of the heat we caused, and that will mean even more heat. It's a vicious cycle, and it's all the more reason to apply the brakes early, rather than waiting until things are already to an unacceptable level. But, of course, that never occurs to the least educated of the denialists.



That's not how it works. More life doesn't mean more carbon. What happens with warming is that CO2 gets less soluble in water at higher temperatures, meaning the oceans hold less of it, putting more of it in the atmosphere. Warming also melts permafrost, which currently holds a huge amount of carbon.



They do nothing of the sort. There's a reason that nearly all leading experts on this topic believe higher carbon levels produce higher temps, and it's not because they don't know about the ice core data. It's because they understand the data better than you do.



Wrong. They're doing something to global temperatures right now.
CO2 is an integral part of the circle of life. Without it, there would be no life on earth. With it, oxygen makes the cycle between plants and animals. We are carbon based creatures, carbon is not a "pollutant", neither is it a "heat pollutant", neither is heat a pollutant; global warming has always resulted in more life, not less. Carbon Dioxide has never produced global warming, there is no greenhouse effect in our atmosphere because there is no barrier to heat rising in our atmosphere... this is the most unscientific idiotic spew of nonsense ever to come from "scientists"... even worse than the "space time wrinkles in matter" ... at least the physical theorists weren't proposing taxes to pay for their nonsense.

The Greenhouse theory was a complete swing and a miss at explaining why the ice cap was melting in the Arctic circle. It turned out, the heat was coming from the water, not the air. The heat in the air was also coming from the water. The real source of the heat? volcanic activity on the floor of the Arctic ocean. We now know the theory is wrong, we always knew it made no sense, but now we know it was wrong and made no sense. Nothing stops heat from rising in the atmosphere; the atmosphere cools the earth's surface, adding carbon dioxide to the atmosphere doesn't change how that works; it is all about this wonderful program of water evaporating, rising into the atmosphere, cooling, and coming back as rain, it's a great program, it cools the earth, and as long as there is still water in the oceans, it still works.
 
Notice how you utilize the word "convinced" - It betrays the flaw in your thinking process. It implies a destination, rather than a journey. Once you have arrived at your destination, the journey is complete. For you, your journey is complete- you've arrived, and your journeying is over.

I'm still on the journey, still with an open mind, still exploring new possibilities. Sadly, your mind is made up, and now your only interest is "convincing" others. You're done thinking, you're in the agenda mode.

I have no interest in "convincing" you about what I thought 30 years ago - You can conjure up whatever fantasy about that you wish to.

That's always the goal of a scam, a hoax, a false prophet, a cult, a con. To convince others to join.
 
You have a firm position and have drawn a conclusion, and no one is going to talk you out of it. You're convinced, you think everyone else should be likewise convinced, and find it intolerable if they are not.

I'm keeping an open mind.

You have no idea what my thoughts were 10, 20, 0r 30 years ago, but being a closed-minded individual, you've assigned me the position you feel most comfortable believing. Believe what you wish, it doesn't really matter. It's not like you're open to change anyway.
if ark was a gambler, this would be called "throwing good money after bad"

examples of people clinging to a discredited position out of faith abound.

  • 99% of blacks still voted for Obama in 2012, despite a dismal first term
  • ISIS convinced allah is going to deliver victory and world domination to them
  • Christians convinced the next supreme court justice is going to overturn roe, and allow creationism and prayer back into the classroom
  • state social workers and judges convincing themselves that juveniles with multiple "priors" for auto theft, grand larceny, assault, narcotics, etc should be spared incarceration for the current arrest.
  • women convincing themselves "he only beats me because I make him mad"
  • Hillary's belief that she's not responsible for her own results
  • Trump's belief that anyone can be a big success, if her or she works hard enough
  • the left's belief that suppression of opposing views will bring a more harmonious, fairer world.
 
Notice how you utilize the word "convinced" - It betrays the flaw in your thinking process. It implies a destination, rather than a journey. Once you have arrived at your destination, the journey is complete. For you, your journey is complete- you've arrived, and your journeying is over
No. With all science, the journey is never complete. But at some point along the journey, you're convinced enough that it starts driving behaviors.

For example, I try to keep my weight within what scientists currently regard as a healthy range. I understand that guidance may change. I understand it's even possible that some day the very idea of there being a healthy range will be considered bunk, and I'll find I wasted a lot of effort over the years on calorie control and exercise that wasn't doing a thing for my health. But, I'm convinced enough, right now, to act based on the mainstream medical science.

That's the same thing I'm doing with climate science. At some point in the early 90s, the science became convincing enough, for me, to serve as the basis for my actions, including my decisions about which political policies to support. Perhaps someday I'll find the mainstream science was wrong. Maybe I'll find that global warming had nothing to do with human activities, and I wasted my time pushing to alter those activities. Or maybe I'll find global warming was far more serious than the mainstream science thought, and that I should have been pushing for far more radical action, and making that activism a much bigger part of my life (or going into serious "prepper" mode ahead of the imminent catastrophe). You never know how it'll go. But a person would be a great fool to hold out for a 100% certainty that will never come, before allowing science to inform his choices.

I'm still on the journey

Where has that journey taken you? What did you think about climate change 10, 20, or 30 years ago? As I've pointed out, the scene today is VASTLY different than 30 years ago, in terms of what we know, the effort that's gone into learning it, and just in terms of average global temperatures. With your "open mind" what journey did that vast change in the facts take you on? I've described my journey up to this point.
 
No. With all science, the journey is never complete. But at some point along the journey, you're convinced enough that it starts driving behaviors.

For example, I try to keep my weight within what scientists currently regard as a healthy range. I understand that guidance may change. I understand it's even possible that some day the very idea of there being a healthy range will be considered bunk, and I'll find I wasted a lot of effort over the years on calorie control and exercise that wasn't doing a thing for my health. But, I'm convinced enough, right now, to act based on the mainstream medical science.

That's the same thing I'm doing with climate science. At some point in the early 90s, the science became convincing enough, for me, to serve as the basis for my actions, including my decisions about which political policies to support. Perhaps someday I'll find the mainstream science was wrong. Maybe I'll find that global warming had nothing to do with human activities, and I wasted my time pushing to alter those activities. Or maybe I'll find global warming was far more serious than the mainstream science thought, and that I should have been pushing for far more radical action, and making that activism a much bigger part of my life (or going into serious "prepper" mode ahead of the imminent catastrophe). You never know how it'll go. But a person would be a great fool to hold out for a 100% certainty that will never come, before allowing science to inform his choices.



Where has that journey taken you? What did you think about climate change 10, 20, or 30 years ago? As I've pointed out, the scene today is VASTLY different than 30 years ago, in terms of what we know, the effort that's gone into learning it, and just in terms of average global temperatures. With your "open mind" what journey did that vast change in the facts take you on? I've described my journey up to this point.

Your journey is complete - You're convinced. You prefer the settled science.

As I eluded to earlier, I'm not interested in trying to prove to you anything about what I thought 30 years ago. You can continue to insist if you like, however, I'm well aware your interest is likely not genuine and more about attempting to control the narrative.

Which, of course, you're not going to...:>) Feel free to keep trying though.
 
CO2 is an integral part of the circle of life. Without it, there would be no life on earth. With it, oxygen makes the cycle between plants and animals. We are carbon based creatures, carbon is not a "pollutant", neither is it a "heat pollutant", neither is heat a pollutant; global warming has always resulted in more life, not less.

A little parable for you. Picture a ship at sea, with the water in the bilge rising fast. The ship's engineers tell the captain that he needs to have a hole in the hull patched, or find a way to pump the water out faster, or the ship will founder soon. The captain, being an utter imbecile, responds:

Water is an integral part of the circle of life. Without it, there would be no life on earth. It is part of the cycle between plants and animals. We are water based creatures; water is not a "pollutant", neither is sea water a pollutant; water has always resulted in more life, not less.​

Carbon Dioxide has never produced global warming

Incorrect. Carbon dioxide has been producing global warming for many decades now.

there is no greenhouse effect in our atmosphere because there is no barrier to heat rising in our atmosphere

There is a greenhouse effect in our atmosphere, and in the atmosphere of other planets we've studied. If it didn't exist, we'd all freeze solid every night, as the heat escaped directly into space. The physics of this are easy to understand and easy to demonstrate in experiments. CO2 (and some other gases) have a structure that causes resonating at infrared wavelengths. That means some of the infrared light that would have radiated directly into space instead gets transformed into kinetic molecular motion in the molecules of the atmosphere. The more greenhouse gases, the fewer photons of infrared radiation make it to space and the more of that energy goes to warm the atmosphere. The same thing keeps that heat, in the form of kinetic molecular motion, from exiting our atmosphere that keeps the air itself from doing so: gravity. Gravity holds those excited molecules around the Earth. Eventually that energy gets transformed back into infrared light and radiates out into space, but it's like a situation where you have a faucet emptying into a tub and a drain draining away from it. Restrict the flow of water out of the tub through the drain, and the water level will rise, even though eventually every bit of water that goes into it will leave it. Similarly, restrict the flow of infrared radiation way from the Earth, while the radiation coming in stays fairly constant, and the heat rises, even though eventually all that energy will leave into space. This isn't hard to understand. It's bizarre some people can't think their way through it.

The Greenhouse theory was a complete swing and a miss at explaining why the ice cap was melting in the Arctic circle. It turned out, the heat was coming from the water, not the air.

You missed the point badly. Why is the water warmer? It's not volcanic activity on the Arctic ocean floor. No such activity has been observed, the pattern within the water column is inconsistent with the idea that the heat is radiating from the depths (there's less warming deep down than above), and we aren't measuring the changes in atmospheric chemistry or water chemistry that would show up with a big uptick in volcanic activity (e.g., CO2 isotopes associated with volcanoes as opposed to fossil fuels, plus other elements that are associated with volcanic outgassing). This is how science works. You're welcome to guess at alternative explanations for what we're seeing. But those hypotheses can be tested, by measuring various things. There's a particular pattern of data we'd expect to see if the polar ice was melting from global warming, and another pattern we'd expect to see if it was being melted geothermally. Turns out, the pattern of data is consistent with the AGW theory, not the geothermal one. It was worth looking into, but like all the other desperate attempts by the denialists, it was killed by the data. But, of course, mere real-world facts won't cause the know-nothing brigades to abandon their silly petty theory, even as the more serious climate change skeptics left it by the wayside long ago.
 
I thought differently about it as I do now.
I don't know what you're saying. Does that mean you thought differently about it than you do now? In what ways were your thoughts then different from your thoughts now.

For me, the last few decades were a big deal. As a reminder:

upload_2017-4-25_11-19-53-png.35957


The way things looked in the mid-1980s, the global warming record just wasn't that clear -- the recent periods of cooling had been almost as many and frequent as the periods of warming, such that 1984 and 1944 had almost the same global temperature anomaly. But then things really changed. There were no more significant periods of cooling after that. Things oscillated from very rapid warming to a few years of fairly steady temps, to very rapid warming again. And the slope of the trend-line from the mid-80s onward was clearly much greater than it had been for the prior portion of the temperature record. That had a big impact on my beliefs. Did it have an impact on yours?
 
Back
Top