New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

I like the idea that we're all on equal ground, when it comes to citizenship, rather than some getting more rights than others based on who their parents are. I'm also uncomfortable with the idea of the government being able to decide who gets citizenship and who doesn't, at birth. If they can say that those with foreign parents don't get citizenship, couldn't they say that those with Jewish parents, or poor parents, or black parents, or parents who are (or are not) veterans, or parents from Texas, etc., aren't citizens?

Nope! If the parents are citizens, then their kids are citizens. Period! Are you sure you're a lawyer???
 
Nope!

Fortunately, we have the highest possible authority on record to answer this question of how the term "jurisdiction" was to be interpreted and applied, the author of the citizenship clause, Sen. Jacob M. Howard (MI) to tell us exactly what it means and its intended scope as he introduced it to the United States Senate in 1866:

Mr. HOWARD: I now move to take up House joint resolution No. 127.

The motion was agreed to; and the Senate, as in Committee of the Whole, resumed the consideration of the joint resolution (H.R. No. 127) proposing an amendment to the Constitution of the United States.

The first amendment is to section one, declaring that all "persons born in the United States and Subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the States wherein they reside. I do not propose to say anything on that subject except that the question of citizenship has been fully discussed in this body as not to need any further elucidation, in my opinion. This amendment which I have offered is simply declaratory of what I regard as the law of the land already, that every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States. This has long been a great desideratum in the jurisprudence and legislation of this country.[1]


http://www.14thamendment.us/articles/anchor_babies_unconstitutionality.html
The language says what it says. If Mr. Howard wanted something that wouldn't apply to those born in the US and subject to the jurisdiction of the US, then he ought to have drafted something else. Legislative history, including dicta by drafters, is only relevant when dealing with something where the language itself is ambiguous and we need guidance about what was intended. In this case, the language is quite clear.

Even if we did have recourse to Howard's statement, though, it doesn't say what you seem to think it does.

This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons.
​
If he meant to exclude all those born to foreigners, there'd be no reason to mention ambassadors or foreign ministers at all. He could just say "This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States to parents who are foreigners." That would include those who are in the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers. His wording is clumsy, but it seems pretty clear that he means that those who are born to families of ambassadors or foreign ministers are foreigners and aliens, not that anyone born to foreigners is a foreigner.
 
Nope! If the parents are citizens, then their kids are citizens. Period! Are you sure you're a lawyer???
You seem to have misunderstood what I wrote. Try harder. I'm not saying that those born to citizens aren't citizens. I'm saying that those born to non-citizens, but within the US and subject to the jurisdiction of the US are citizens.
 
The language says what it says. If Mr. Howard wanted something that wouldn't apply to those born in the US and subject to the jurisdiction of the US, then he ought to have drafted something else. Legislative history, including dicta by drafters, is only relevant when dealing with something where the language itself is ambiguous and we need guidance about what was intended. In this case, the language is quite clear.

Even if we did have recourse to Howard's statement, though, it doesn't say what you seem to think it does.

This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons.
​
If he meant to exclude all those born to foreigners, there'd be no reason to mention ambassadors or foreign ministers at all. He could just say "This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States to parents who are foreigners." That would include those who are in the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers. His wording is clumsy, but it seems pretty clear that he means that those who are born to families of ambassadors or foreign ministers are foreigners and aliens, not that anyone born to foreigners is a foreigner.

The discussion didn't end there:

But what exactly did "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" mean to the framers of the Fourteenth Amendment? Again, we are fortunate to have on record the highest authority to tell us, Sen. Lyman Trumbull, Chairman of the Judiciary Committee, author of the Thirteenth Amendment, and the one who inserted the phrase:
[T]he provision is, that 'all persons born in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens.' That means 'subject to the complete jurisdiction thereof.' What do we mean by 'complete jurisdiction thereof?' Not owing allegiance to anybody else. That is what it means.

Trumbull continues, "Can you sue a Navajo Indian in court? Are they in any sense subject to the complete jurisdiction of the United States? By no means. We make treaties with them, and therefore they are not subject to our jurisdiction. If they were, we wouldn't make treaties with them...It is only those persons who come completely within our jurisdiction, who are subject to our laws, that we think of making citizens; and there can be no objection to the proposition that such persons should be citizens.[2]

Sen. Howard concurs with Trumbull's construction:

Mr. HOWARD: I concur entirely with the honorable Senator from Illinois [Trumbull], in holding that the word "jurisdiction," as here employed, ought to be construed so as to imply a full and complete jurisdiction on the part of the United States, whether exercised by Congress, by the executive, or by the judicial department; that is to say, the same jurisdiction in extent and quality as applies to every citizen of the United States now.[3]


It's pretty clear what they meant. And it isn't what you say it is...
 
You seem to have misunderstood what I wrote. Try harder. I'm not saying that those born to citizens aren't citizens. I'm saying that those born to non-citizens, but within the US and subject to the jurisdiction of the US are citizens.

"Subject to the jurisdiction of," as the drafters explained, meant owing allegiance to.

Otherwise the babies of Indians born off the reservation would have been citizens. Please feel free to find me evidence that that was the case.
 
Last edited:
The language says what it says. If Mr. Howard wanted something that wouldn't apply to those born in the US and subject to the jurisdiction of the US, then he ought to have drafted something else. Legislative history, including dicta by drafters, is only relevant when dealing with something where the language itself is ambiguous and we need guidance about what was intended. In this case, the language is quite clear.

Even if we did have recourse to Howard's statement, though, it doesn't say what you seem to think it does.

This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons.
​
If he meant to exclude all those born to foreigners, there'd be no reason to mention ambassadors or foreign ministers at all. He could just say "This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States to parents who are foreigners." That would include those who are in the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers. His wording is clumsy, but it seems pretty clear that he means that those who are born to families of ambassadors or foreign ministers are foreigners and aliens, not that anyone born to foreigners is a foreigner.

And on:

Sen. Johnson, speaking on the Senate floor, offers his comments and understanding of the proposed new amendment to the constitution:
[Now], all this amendment [citizenship clause] provides is, that all persons born in the United States and not subject to some foreign Power--for that, no doubt, is the meaning of the committee who have brought the matter before us--shall be considered as citizens of the United States. That would seem to be not only a wise but a necessary provision. If there are to be citizens of the United States there should be some certain definition of what citizenship is, what has created the character of citizen as between himself and the United States, and the amendment says that citizenship may depend upon birth, and I know of no better way to give rise to citizenship than the fact of birth within the territory of the United States, born to parents who at the time were subject to the authority of the United States.[4]
 
And on:

Sen. Johnson, speaking on the Senate floor, offers his comments and understanding of the proposed new amendment to the constitution:
[Now], all this amendment [citizenship clause] provides is, that all persons born in the United States and not subject to some foreign Power--for that, no doubt, is the meaning of the committee who have brought the matter before us--shall be considered as citizens of the United States. That would seem to be not only a wise but a necessary provision. If there are to be citizens of the United States there should be some certain definition of what citizenship is, what has created the character of citizen as between himself and the United States, and the amendment says that citizenship may depend upon birth, and I know of no better way to give rise to citizenship than the fact of birth within the territory of the United States, born to parents who at the time were subject to the authority of the United States.[4]
Exactly. It's quite clear that it was meant to cover those born in the US to parents who were subject to US authority -- which would be anyone other than those with diplomatic immunity or those living on foreign compounds that functioned effectively as foreign soil.
 
Why don't we ask the drafter:

Fortunately, we have the highest possible authority on record to answer this question of how the term "jurisdiction" was to be interpreted and applied, the author of the citizenship clause, Sen. Jacob M. Howard (MI) to tell us exactly what it means and its intended scope as he introduced it to the United States Senate in 1866:

Mr. HOWARD: I now move to take up House joint resolution No. 127.

The motion was agreed to; and the Senate, as in Committee of the Whole, resumed the consideration of the joint resolution (H.R. No. 127) proposing an amendment to the Constitution of the United States.

The first amendment is to section one, declaring that all "persons born in the United States and Subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the States wherein they reside. I do not propose to say anything on that subject except that the question of citizenship has been fully discussed in this body as not to need any further elucidation, in my opinion. This amendment which I have offered is simply declaratory of what I regard as the law of the land already, that every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States. This has long been a great desideratum in the jurisprudence and legislation of this country.[1]


http://www.14thamendment.us/articles/anchor_babies_unconstitutionality.html
Yes, it was a well debated subject. Speaking of Supreme Court activism, what that Heller decision, eh?

http://teachingamericanhistory.org/library/document/veto-of-the-civil-rights-bill/
By the first section of the bill, all persons born in the United States, and not subject to any foreign power, excluding Indians not taxed, are declared to be citizens of the United States.
Andrew Johnson
Washington, D.C., March 27, 1866.



http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llcg&fileName=073/llcg073.db&recNum=11

http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llcg&fileName=070/llcg070.db&recNum=702
 
It passed in 1868 and until 1924 (when Congress passed the Indian Citizenship Act) no Indians were citizens of the US, including all those born after 1868. How is it that now the 14th Amendment is accepted to cover people born in America of non-citizens when as soon as it was passed that was not the case?

Because the country was run by a bunch of racist. Why else do you think ? Now the racist of today want to strip citizenship from other people born in this country just like the racist of old denied it.
 
Yet they excluded Native Americans ? Why ?
Sovereign nations by treaty. Does a state have jurisdiction on Indian land?

I like your dancing, Spam. You claimed the US government was racist yet deny they passed the 14th Amendment. Why?
 
Because the country was run by a bunch of racist. Why else do you think ? Now the racist of today want to strip citizenship from other people born in this country just like the racist of old denied it.

If you are a visitor in Mexico and have a kid, your kid is still a US citizen, right? Why shouldn't the same apply in the case of Mexican visitors in the US?
 
Yet they excluded Native Americans ? Why ?

Because they never intended it to mean simply being born on US soil to automatically convey citizenship. That is why they said "and subject to the jurisdiction of." It meant FULL jurisdiction - i.e. no allegiance to a foreign government.
 
Yes, it was a well debated subject. Speaking of Supreme Court activism, what that Heller decision, eh?

http://teachingamericanhistory.org/library/document/veto-of-the-civil-rights-bill/
By the first section of the bill, all persons born in the United States, and not subject to any foreign power, excluding Indians not taxed, are declared to be citizens of the United States.
Andrew Johnson
Washington, D.C., March 27, 1866.



http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llcg&fileName=073/llcg073.db&recNum=11

http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llcg&fileName=070/llcg070.db&recNum=702

Immigration has long been regulated by the federal government. It began with the The Naturalization Act of 1790. The purpose was to control who and how foreigners were permitted to become citizens. The act you are referring to here doesn't appear to me to unconditionally grant citizenship to anyone born here of non-citizen parents. The part I highlighted appears to me to specifically exclude babies born here to non-citizen parents. I would assume that if the parents are here as legal immigrants, once they are naturalized, and the child reaches 18, the child could then also become naturalized, via whatever process is in place at the time.

Any immigrant here whether legally or illegally is not subject to the "full jurisdiction" of the US. They cannot be compelled to serve in the military in the event of a draft, or to serve on a jury, pay taxes on income earned in their home country, etc. They can't get social security numbers, qualify for most entitlement programs, etc. This is because they are still considered to be foreign subjects. There's really no strong argument for the conferring of citizenship to babies born here of non-citizens, because, like their parents, they are not going to be subject to the full jurisdiction of the US. If that weren't the intention of the drafters and those who approved the 14th Amendment, then there was simply no reason to include that language. The idea that it was specifically directed at foreign diplomats (cited as an example) and not other temporary foreign visitors (either admitted legally or illegally) is a superfluous argument, as all such children would also be automatically citizens of their home countries and therefor not subject to the "full jurisdiction" of the United states.
 
Exactly. It's quite clear that it was meant to cover those born in the US to parents who were subject to US authority -- which would be anyone other than those with diplomatic immunity or those living on foreign compounds that functioned effectively as foreign soil.

No, it isn't. They could not be compelled to serve in the military, serve on juries, etc. FULL jurisdiction - not merely "subject to US authority."
 
Agreed. It's just not what you thought.

No, it's not what YOU thought. They were referring to people having "allegiance" to a foreign power, which would include ALL those not yet naturalized or born of naturalized citizens. FULL jurisdiction includes the requirement to serve in the military, serve on juries, etc. It really is quite clear and your effort to legally water it down despite clear evidence to the contrary is an example of why attorneys are held in such low esteem.
 
Back
Top