New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

That makes no sense. Even US citizens can be extradited to other countries. And we will often refuse to extradite non-citizens to their country of origin.

AND, would we ever refuse to extradite an illegal alien accused of a crime in their nation of origin? Maybe, but only in really really specific circumstances. It would be the exception that proves the rule.
 
I'm willing to evaluate any comments of theirs you find where they state their intent to alter the interpretation from the drafters'. All I've seen is comments from Senators during the discussion before it passed that agree with Howard's interpretation.

Regardless, full jurisdiction is pretty effing clear. If a person can be extradited (or recalled) from America by their country of origin, then they are NOT subject to the FULL jurisdiction of America. And that would include their minor children.
So, would that mean that dual citizens are also not subject to the full jurisdiction of America, and that their kids aren't citizens? For example, if I my wife and I both have US and Israeli citizenship, and we have a child here in the US, should that child be denied birthright citizenship, on the grounds that Israel could theoretically "recall" my wife and I, and therefore we aren't under the "full" jurisdiction of the US?
 
I'm in favor of increasing legal immigration. That is, in fact, one of the very best ways to decrease illegal immigration, since legal immigrants will tend to fill the same employment niches that attract illegal immigrants here. With those niches filled, the attraction will be diminished. I agree that illegal immigration is a bad thing, if only because it's bad to countenance illegal activity, since it erodes respect for the law. I've repeatedly advocated a demand-side approach to decreasing illegal immigration (since the supply-side approach has obvious problems that render it nearly completely ineffectual). Focus on drying up the employment opportunities that draw undocumented immigrants here, whether by filling those niches with more legal immigrants, or by punishing the illegal employers (who have a lot more to lose and so can be more realistically deterred by the risk of prosecution).

So, I'm not saying illegal immigration is a good thing or that we ought to ignore it. I'm just asking what evidence there is that it's unstable. It doesn't seem to be a particularly bad problem nor a growing one, right now.

Well the evidence that it is unstable is that the progressives give it their full throated support. It's a prima facie case that it is then unstable, as the entire progressive agenda is unstable.
 
Yes, we decide if our citizens are extradited abroad (or not), because they are under our FULL jurisdiction. And we would never refuse to extradite non-citizens if they are clearly chargeable with a legitimate offense to a country with which we have a treaty, because they are NOT under the FULL jurisdiction of the USA.

Nonsense. All people in this country, with rare exceptions like diplomats, are fully under the jurisdiction of this country. And whether or not citizens, this country and its courts decide whether someone will be extradited.
 
So, would that mean that dual citizens are also not subject to the full jurisdiction of America, and that their kids aren't citizens? For example, if I my wife and I both have US and Israeli citizenship, and we have a child here in the US, should that child be denied birthright citizenship, on the grounds that Israel could theoretically "recall" my wife and I, and therefore we aren't under the "full" jurisdiction of the US?

No, the child would also have dual citizenship. It's based on blood, not territory.
 
That's because it was the intended meaning at the time, as discussed during its passage in Congress. If it meant to imply that anyone born here regardless of their parents' status was a US citizen, why even include it?

Because certain people were not then, and are not now, subject to the jurisdiction of this country, diplomats being the most prominent examples. And, back then, Indian reservations were considered sovereign nations, and some of that concept of sovereignty persists to this day.

That's why.

Do you actually agree with Levin that jurisdiction actually means allegiance?
 
Nonsense. All people in this country, with rare exceptions like diplomats, are fully under the jurisdiction of this country. And whether or not citizens, this country and its courts decide whether someone will be extradited.

Over a century ago, the Supreme Court correctly confirmed this restricted interpretation of citizenship in the so-called 'Slaughter-House cases' [83 US 36 (1873)] and in [112 US 94 (1884)]. In Elk v.Wilkins, the phrase 'subject to its jurisdiction' excluded from its operation 'children of ministers, consuls, and citizens of foreign states born within the United States.' In Elk, the American Indian claimant was considered not an American citizen because the law required him to be 'not merely subject in some respect or degree to the jurisdiction of the United States, but completely subject to their political jurisdiction and owing them direct and immediate allegiance.'

http://www.cairco.org/issues/anchor-babies
 
Because certain people were not then, and are not now, subject to the jurisdiction of this country, diplomats being the most prominent examples. And, back then, Indian reservations were considered sovereign nations, and some of that concept of sovereignty persists to this day.

That's why.

Do you actually agree with Levin that jurisdiction actually means allegiance?

I agree with the USSC:

Over a century ago, the Supreme Court correctly confirmed this restricted interpretation of citizenship in the so-called 'Slaughter-House cases' [83 US 36 (1873)] and in [112 US 94 (1884)]. In Elk v.Wilkins, the phrase 'subject to its jurisdiction' excluded from its operation 'children of ministers, consuls, and citizens of foreign states born within the United States.' In Elk, the American Indian claimant was considered not an American citizen because the law required him to be 'not merely subject in some respect or degree to the jurisdiction of the United States, but completely subject to their political jurisdiction and owing them direct and immediate allegiance.'

http://www.cairco.org/issues/anchor-babies
 
My argument doesn't need "weight." I'd be happy to see any reference you have to the USSC ruling specifically on what "subject to the full jurisdiction of the US" means. Or any legislation that was passed that defines it.

My understanding is neither has ever happened. Until then it's easy enough to pass a bill (or even issue an executive order) defining it as not being subject to any other national authority. When that amendment passed there weren't strong international laws (read - extradition treaties) and many immigrants had no (traceable) citizenship when they arrived. That made them ours by default. That is no longer the case, is it? It's pretty easy to trace where immigrants (legal and otherwise) are citizens (and it ain't the USA). If you are the citizen of a foreign country you (and your progeny) are subject to your home nation's jurisdiction as well as the US'. That's the simple difference.
Could we then strip citizenship from the children of any business people who owned property abroad at the time of the birth of the child? For example, if Donald Trump's father had owned property in Canada when Donald was born, then he was subject to another nation's authority. He could, for example, have been sued in Canada if someone got hurt on that Canadian property, and he could be subject to Canadian criminal law and civil forfeiture if he failed to pay taxes there. So, since he was subject to another nation's authority, does this mean that Donald isn't a US citizen, having been born to someone who wasn't under the "full jurisdiction of the US"?

I'm betting that using this theory, we could deprive most wealthy people of their citizenship, since the wealthy tend to be a cosmopolitan class, and their parents mostly had foreign interests that subjected them at least in some manner to foreign jurisdiction, which, using the strained reading of "full jurisdiction" that you're going for (i.e., meaning no other country has any claim on the person), would mean no citizenship by birth for the children of those people.
 
Here's a simple test of your theory. If a foreign national runs her car into the rear end of the auto of another foreign national in their nation's capital, and then flees to America - is she or isn't she subject to the judgement and/or criminal charges as assessed under that foreign nation's laws?
If a foreign national runs her car into another car abroad, whether that was a crime or not would be based on the laws of that foreign nation. If the foreign national then fled to America, he or she would still be subject to judgment or criminal charges assessed abroad.... the same as a US citizen who'd had that kind of accident abroad. I'm not clear on how you see that as a test on the theory.
 
If a foreign national runs her car into another car abroad, whether that was a crime or not would be based on the laws of that foreign nation. If the foreign national then fled to America, he or she would still be subject to judgment or criminal charges assessed abroad.... the same as a US citizen who'd had that kind of accident abroad. I'm not clear on how you see that as a test on the theory.

There are differences in how extraditions are handled depending on if the person is a US citizen or not:

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/3181

Are you suggesting that we use the same extradition process whether the person is a US citizen or an illegal alien?
 
I agree with the USSC:

Over a century ago, the Supreme Court correctly confirmed this restricted interpretation of citizenship in the so-called 'Slaughter-House cases' [83 US 36 (1873)] and in [112 US 94 (1884)]. In Elk v.Wilkins, the phrase 'subject to its jurisdiction' excluded from its operation 'children of ministers, consuls, and citizens of foreign states born within the United States.' In Elk, the American Indian claimant was considered not an American citizen because the law required him to be 'not merely subject in some respect or degree to the jurisdiction of the United States, but completely subject to their political jurisdiction and owing them direct and immediate allegiance.'

http://www.cairco.org/issues/anchor-babies
That's dicta.
 
Could we then strip citizenship from the children of any business people who owned property abroad at the time of the birth of the child? For example, if Donald Trump's father had owned property in Canada when Donald was born, then he was subject to another nation's authority. He could, for example, have been sued in Canada if someone got hurt on that Canadian property, and he could be subject to Canadian criminal law and civil forfeiture if he failed to pay taxes there. So, since he was subject to another nation's authority, does this mean that Donald isn't a US citizen, having been born to someone who wasn't under the "full jurisdiction of the US"?

I'm betting that using this theory, we could deprive most wealthy people of their citizenship, since the wealthy tend to be a cosmopolitan class, and their parents mostly had foreign interests that subjected them at least in some manner to foreign jurisdiction, which, using the strained reading of "full jurisdiction" that you're going for (i.e., meaning no other country has any claim on the person), would mean no citizenship by birth for the children of those people.

That is an absurd interpretation of this matter. The USSC was clear on it:

Over a century ago, the Supreme Court correctly confirmed this restricted interpretation of citizenship in the so-called 'Slaughter-House cases' [83 US 36 (1873)] and in [112 US 94 (1884)]. In Elk v.Wilkins, the phrase 'subject to its jurisdiction' excluded from its operation 'children of ministers, consuls, and citizens of foreign states born within the United States.' In Elk, the American Indian claimant was considered not an American citizen because the law required him to be 'not merely subject in some respect or degree to the jurisdiction of the United States, but completely subject to their political jurisdiction and owing them direct and immediate allegiance.'

http://www.cairco.org/issues/anchor-babies

It's been re-interpreted wrongly and we need to go back to the original intent, in accordance with every other developed nation (save Canada).
 
Are you suggesting that we use the same extradition process whether the person is a US citizen or an illegal alien?
Why would I be suggesting that? It's utterly irrelevant to this question. So, how do you see this as a test of the reasoning?
 
That is an absurd interpretation of this matter. The USSC was clear on it:

Over a century ago, the Supreme Court correctly confirmed this restricted interpretation of citizenship in the so-called 'Slaughter-House cases' [83 US 36 (1873)] and in [112 US 94 (1884)]. In Elk v.Wilkins, the phrase 'subject to its jurisdiction' excluded from its operation 'children of ministers, consuls, and citizens of foreign states born within the United States.' In Elk, the American Indian claimant was considered not an American citizen because the law required him to be 'not merely subject in some respect or degree to the jurisdiction of the United States, but completely subject to their political jurisdiction and owing them direct and immediate allegiance.'

http://www.cairco.org/issues/anchor-babies

It's been re-interpreted wrongly and we need to go back to the original intent, in accordance with every other developed nation (save Canada).
That was never the law. You're pointing to something that was a dictum, at the time.
http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Dicta
That was not part of the holding of the case, and was irrelevant to reaching the conclusion (since the case didn't deal with someone whose citizenship was being challenged on the grounds of having parents who were citizens of foreign states.) Judges toss in asides like that, and although they're interesting for determining how the particular judge writing the opinion would decide on the issue if he came before him, it has no force of law, and there's no reason to assume it was even agreed by the others signing onto the judgment (whose vote only indicates support for the holding, not all the verbiage prefacing it).
 
Why would I be suggesting that? It's utterly irrelevant to this question. So, how do you see this as a test of the reasoning?

That they aren't handled the same, as deference to the foreign power is given when the person being sought is a guest in our country.
 
And clearly in accordance with the comments of the drafter, and the language of the Amendment.
Actually, it not in accordance with the comments of the drafter, and it's directly against the wording of the amendment itself.
 
That they aren't handled the same, as deference to the foreign power is given when the person being sought is a guest in our country.
And? I'm not clear on how that changes the fact we have full jurisdiction over those here (other than diplomats). We can have different procedures for different classes of defendants, without that meaning they're not under our jurisdiction.
 
That was never the law. You're pointing to something that was a dictum, at the time.
http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Dicta
That was not part of the holding of the case, and was irrelevant to reaching the conclusion (since the case didn't deal with someone whose citizenship was being challenged on the grounds of having parents who were citizens of foreign states.) Judges toss in asides like that, and although they're interesting for determining how the particular judge writing the opinion would decide on the issue if he came before him, it has no force of law, and there's no reason to assume it was even agreed by the others signing onto the judgment (whose vote only indicates support for the holding, not all the verbiage prefacing it).

It shows there is room for that interpretation. And should the US President decide to go back to using that interpretation, is there any federal statute that prevents it?
 
Back
Top