New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

Incorrect. Here's a simple test for your theory. You're driving down the street when someone runs a red light and runs into your car, totaling it. You find out the other driver is a foreign national. Does this mean you have no ability to collect damages against him, even though the accident was clearly his fault? Could he simply make a 12(b)(2) civil procedure motion, claiming that any US court lacks personal jurisdiction against him?

https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_12

Of course not. It's well-established that when foreigners come into our borders, they submit to the jurisdiction of US law (federal law and the law of the state they're in). There are partial exceptions for diplomats and a few others:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diplomatic_immunity

However, assuming he wasn't a diplomat, he's subject to the jurisdiction of the US, notwithstanding being a foreign national. A court can enforce both civil and criminal judgments against him.

The jurisdiction you are referencing is not the one mentioned in the constitution.

If two illegal aliens parents crossed the border to have a child in a border hospital and then turned around to leave back to Mexico with said newborn citizen of the U.S. the government would not be able to kick the parents out and keep the child while using the excuse of the better interest of the child.
 
The jurisdiction you are referencing is not the one mentioned in the constitution.

If two illegal aliens parents crossed the border to have a child in a border hospital and then turned around to leave back to Mexico with said newborn citizen of the U.S. the government would not be able to kick the parents out and keep the child while using the excuse of the better interest of the child.
What evidence do you see that the amendment was supposed to refer to some other concept of jurisdiction than ordinary legal jurisdiction? And what is this other kind of jurisdiction you mean? Are there any other situations where the government rules it doesn't have jurisdiction over non-diplomatic foreigners within our borders? Or is this a special kind of jurisdiction that only exists (or rather fails to exist), in this one context? And, if so, shouldn't the amendment have spelled out that it was using a unique concept of "jurisdiction" that it had just invented, and explain what that new concept meant, rather than just speaking of jurisdiction and thus inviting the natural assumption they meant what is meant by jurisdiction in all the other legal contexts?

As for the scenario you speak of, it's not a lack of jurisdiction that governs that consideration, it's deference to parental rights. Remember the Elian Gonzales case? As a reminder, the relatives of a Cuban boy petitioned the government to keep that boy in Cuba against the wishes of his father. The court case that ruled on it was not decided on the idea that the government lacked jurisdiction in the matter. Rather, it was decided on the issue of who had standing to make an asylum petition on the boy's behalf: his father, or less direct relatives. The ruling couldn't have proceeded to that question if the court had looked at it and decided they didn't even have jurisdiction in the matter. Every immigration case that has ever been decided has been based on the idea that the government has jurisdiction over people in our borders. If it didn't, deportation proceedings wouldn't even be possible, because the government would lack jurisdiction to enforce against immigrants.
 
What evidence do you see that the amendment was supposed to refer to some other concept of jurisdiction than ordinary legal jurisdiction? And what is this other kind of jurisdiction you mean? Are there any other situations where the government rules it doesn't have jurisdiction over non-diplomatic foreigners within our borders? Or is this a special kind of jurisdiction that only exists (or rather fails to exist), in this one context? And, if so, shouldn't the amendment have spelled out that it was using a unique concept of "jurisdiction" that it had just invented, and explain what that new concept meant, rather than just speaking of jurisdiction and thus inviting the natural assumption they meant what is meant by jurisdiction in all the other legal contexts?

As for the scenario you speak of, it's not a lack of jurisdiction that governs that consideration, it's deference to parental rights. Remember the Elian Gonzales case? As a reminder, the relatives of a Cuban boy petitioned the government to keep that boy in Cuba against the wishes of his father. The court case that ruled on it was not decided on the idea that the government lacked jurisdiction in the matter. Rather, it was decided on the issue of who had standing to make an asylum petition on the boy's behalf: his father, or less direct relatives. The ruling couldn't have proceeded to that question if the court had looked at it and decided they didn't even have jurisdiction in the matter. Every immigration case that has ever been decided has been based on the idea that the government has jurisdiction over people in our borders. If it didn't, deportation proceedings wouldn't even be possible, because the government would lack jurisdiction to enforce against immigrants.

I gave you the example. At some point you have to start using your common sense.

The elements of the Elian case have nothing to do with the case given since Elian was not born in the U.S. to illegal parents.

It is clear that prog libs take the kids from parents all the time regardless of parental rights.


No point in putting the word jurisdiction in the body of the text unless they were making allowances for the Indian NATIONS. lol

YOU lose Arky.
 
I gave you the example.

Here's what you said: "If two illegal aliens parents crossed the border to have a child in a border hospital and then turned around to leave back to Mexico with said newborn citizen of the U.S. the government would not be able to kick the parents out and keep the child while using the excuse of the better interest of the child."

What, specifically, makes you think that? Is there some specific case you can cite, of that sort, that was decided on the grounds of a lack of jurisdiction? Or is it something you just feel must be true, for some reason?

At some point you have to start using your common sense.

My common sense tells me that when an amendment references jurisdiction, without any indication that the term is being given a special, unusual meaning, it ought to be read simply to refer to legal jurisdiction, which is a well-understood concept. In no other case that I know of has a foreign national in the US, other than someone with diplomatic immunity, been able to argue successfully that the US government does not have jurisdiction over him while he's in the US. If you know of some such case, I'm simply asking that you share it.

YOU lose Arky.

You'll have to try harder than that, little one.
 
If you are a visitor in Mexico and have a kid, your kid is still a US citizen, right? Why shouldn't the same apply in the case of Mexican visitors in the US?

You mean why are the laws in other countries not the same laws as we have in the US.

You don't need to have that explained to you.
 
It doesn't seem to be unstable -- I mean, it's not like the problems of illegal immigration are growing out of control, or our population is surging at a dangerous rate, or anything like that. Illegal immigration is down and our population growth is about as low as it has been in our history -- low enough, in fact, that some of our long-term problems are based around having too few young citizens to support the large generation of older citizens who are retiring. So, I don't see any pressing need to change the rule right now. You apparently do, so what do you see that convinces you that this is no longer a workable idea?

Then increase LEGAL immigration. And open it up to all nationalities, including easter europeans, asians, etc. The problem with "illegal" immigration is that it's illegal. Are you really effing sure you are a lawyer???
 
Why don't we ask the drafter:

Fortunately, we have the highest possible authority on record to answer this question of how the term "jurisdiction" was to be interpreted and applied, the author of the citizenship clause, Sen. Jacob M. Howard (MI) to tell us exactly what it means and its intended scope as he introduced it to the United States Senate in 1866:

Mr. HOWARD: I now move to take up House joint resolution No. 127.

The motion was agreed to; and the Senate, as in Committee of the Whole, resumed the consideration of the joint resolution (H.R. No. 127) proposing an amendment to the Constitution of the United States.

The first amendment is to section one, declaring that all "persons born in the United States and Subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the States wherein they reside. I do not propose to say anything on that subject except that the question of citizenship has been fully discussed in this body as not to need any further elucidation, in my opinion. This amendment which I have offered is simply declaratory of what I regard as the law of the land already, that every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States. This has long been a great desideratum in the jurisprudence and legislation of this country.[1]


http://www.14thamendment.us/articles/anchor_babies_unconstitutionality.html
You are confusing the intent of the drafter and the intent of the Congressmen and states that ratified the final amendment.
 
You are confusing the intent of the drafter and the intent of the Congressmen and states that ratified the final amendment.

I'm willing to evaluate any comments of theirs you find where they state their intent to alter the interpretation from the drafters'. All I've seen is comments from Senators during the discussion before it passed that agree with Howard's interpretation.

Regardless, full jurisdiction is pretty effing clear. If a person can be extradited (or recalled) from America by their country of origin, then they are NOT subject to the FULL jurisdiction of America. And that would include their minor children.
 
I'm willing to evaluate any comments of theirs you find where they state their intent to alter the interpretation from the drafters'. .....
So now we go from "the drafter" to "the drafters'". Is that to add artificial weight to your argument?

As it is, I'll let a century and a half US government legislation and jurisprudence speak for itself.

That said, I favor amending the 14th Amendment's anchor baby clause to born of legal US citizens or residents.
 
So now we go from "the drafter" to "the drafters'". Is that to add artificial weight to your argument?

As it is, I'll let a century and a half US government legislation and jurisprudence speak for itself.

That said, I favor amending the 14th Amendment's anchor baby clause to born of legal US citizens or residents.

My argument doesn't need "weight." I'd be happy to see any reference you have to the USSC ruling specifically on what "subject to the full jurisdiction of the US" means. Or any legislation that was passed that defines it.

My understanding is neither has ever happened. Until then it's easy enough to pass a bill (or even issue an executive order) defining it as not being subject to any other national authority. When that amendment passed there weren't strong international laws (read - extradition treaties) and many immigrants had no (traceable) citizenship when they arrived. That made them ours by default. That is no longer the case, is it? It's pretty easy to trace where immigrants (legal and otherwise) are citizens (and it ain't the USA). If you are the citizen of a foreign country you (and your progeny) are subject to your home nation's jurisdiction as well as the US'. That's the simple difference.
 
It passed in 1868 and until 1924 (when Congress passed the Indian Citizenship Act) no Indians were citizens of the US, including all those born after 1868. How is it that now the 14th Amendment is accepted to cover people born in America of non-citizens when as soon as it was passed that was not the case?

Notwithstanding the arguments in this thread it seems to me there is a simple answer to your simple question.

The 14th Amendment allows for kidnapping.

A Swedish couple, subject to the jurisdiction of Sweden, has a child in the United States who by common law and natural circumstance is subject to the jurisdiction of Sweden by parentage.
 
Last edited:
Notwithstanding the arguments in this thread it seems to me there is a simple answer to your simple question. The 14th Amendment allows for kidnapping.

A Swedish couple, subject to the jurisdiction of Sweden, has a child in the United States who by common law is subject to the jurisdiction of Sweden by parentage.

Exactly. If a pregnant woman who murdered her husband comes across the border and has the baby, is then found and her home country sends an extradition request, do we send her back and keep the baby? The husband's family has no claim on the child? What?
 
Hate radio host Mark Levin and Sean Hannity have been beating this drum lately, along with many other GOP pols and hate merchants.

Levin's argument is that the word "jurisdiction" in the 14th Amendment really means "allegiance."

That's goofy, of course. He cannot simply "rewrite" the Amendment, changing one word to another. And it makes no sense in any event - newborn babies have no "allegiance" to any country, and allegiance is a subjective concept, to boot.

But, the GOP's new platform, which seems to have one plank, is hating on Mexicans. So, they toss common sense out the window and try to "rewrite" the 14th Amendment.
 
Incorrect. Here's a simple test for your theory. You're driving down the street when someone runs a red light and runs into your car, totaling it. You find out the other driver is a foreign national. Does this mean you have no ability to collect damages against him, even though the accident was clearly his fault? Could he simply make a 12(b)(2) civil procedure motion, claiming that any US court lacks personal jurisdiction against him?

https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_12

Of course not. It's well-established that when foreigners come into our borders, they submit to the jurisdiction of US law (federal law and the law of the state they're in). There are partial exceptions for diplomats and a few others:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diplomatic_immunity

However, assuming he wasn't a diplomat, he's subject to the jurisdiction of the US, notwithstanding being a foreign national. A court can enforce both civil and criminal judgments against him.

Here's a simple test of your theory. If a foreign national runs her car into the rear end of the auto of another foreign national in their nation's capital, and then flees to America - is she or isn't she subject to the judgement and/or criminal charges as assessed under that foreign nation's laws?
 
I'm willing to evaluate any comments of theirs you find where they state their intent to alter the interpretation from the drafters'. All I've seen is comments from Senators during the discussion before it passed that agree with Howard's interpretation.

Regardless, full jurisdiction is pretty effing clear. If a person can be extradited (or recalled) from America by their country of origin, then they are NOT subject to the FULL jurisdiction of America. And that would include their minor children.

That makes no sense. Even US citizens can be extradited to other countries. And we will often refuse to extradite non-citizens to their country of origin.
 
That makes no sense. Even US citizens can be extradited to other countries. And we will often refuse to extradite non-citizens to their country of origin.

Yes, we decide if our citizens are extradited abroad (or not), because they are under our FULL jurisdiction. And we would never refuse to extradite non-citizens if they are clearly chargeable with a legitimate offense to a country with which we have a treaty, because they are NOT under the FULL jurisdiction of the USA.
 
Hate radio host Mark Levin and Sean Hannity have been beating this drum lately, along with many other GOP pols and hate merchants.

Levin's argument is that the word "jurisdiction" in the 14th Amendment really means "allegiance."

That's goofy, of course. He cannot simply "rewrite" the Amendment, changing one word to another. And it makes no sense in any event - newborn babies have no "allegiance" to any country, and allegiance is a subjective concept, to boot.

But, the GOP's new platform, which seems to have one plank, is hating on Mexicans. So, they toss common sense out the window and try to "rewrite" the 14th Amendment.

That's because it was the intended meaning at the time, as discussed during its passage in Congress. If it meant to imply that anyone born here regardless of their parents' status was a US citizen, why even include it?
 
Then increase LEGAL immigration. And open it up to all nationalities, including easter europeans, asians, etc. The problem with "illegal" immigration is that it's illegal. Are you really effing sure you are a lawyer???
I'm in favor of increasing legal immigration. That is, in fact, one of the very best ways to decrease illegal immigration, since legal immigrants will tend to fill the same employment niches that attract illegal immigrants here. With those niches filled, the attraction will be diminished. I agree that illegal immigration is a bad thing, if only because it's bad to countenance illegal activity, since it erodes respect for the law. I've repeatedly advocated a demand-side approach to decreasing illegal immigration (since the supply-side approach has obvious problems that render it nearly completely ineffectual). Focus on drying up the employment opportunities that draw undocumented immigrants here, whether by filling those niches with more legal immigrants, or by punishing the illegal employers (who have a lot more to lose and so can be more realistically deterred by the risk of prosecution).

So, I'm not saying illegal immigration is a good thing or that we ought to ignore it. I'm just asking what evidence there is that it's unstable. It doesn't seem to be a particularly bad problem nor a growing one, right now.
 
Back
Top