Lukey
Senator
Actually, it not in accordance with the comments of the drafter, and it's directly against the wording of the amendment itself.
Why didn't it apply to Indians born off the reservation prior to 1924?
Actually, it not in accordance with the comments of the drafter, and it's directly against the wording of the amendment itself.
The US Constitution prevents it. If a US President tried to overrule the Constitution with an executive order that purported to strip millions of American citizens of their citizenship, based on who their parents were, they'd challenge in court and the order would be struck down.It shows there is room for that interpretation. And should the US President decide to go back to using that interpretation, is there any federal statute that prevents it?
And? I'm not clear on how that changes the fact we have full jurisdiction over those here (other than diplomats). We can have different procedures for different classes of defendants, without that meaning they're not under our jurisdiction.
Because Indians were seen as a special case, who had a unique status even off of reservations, which excluded them from certain aspects of jurisdiction.Why didn't it apply to Indians born off the reservation prior to 1924?
The US Constitution prevents it. If a US President tried to overrule the Constitution with an executive order that purported to strip millions of American citizens of their citizenship, based on who their parents were, they'd challenge in court and the order would be struck down.
That's not correct. A executive order is to Federal agencies, not "writing law".Obama has set a precedent as far as writing law via executive order.
Now you want to prevent such action simply because you disagree with the outcome?
That's not very intellectually honest or consistent...
If you think he has made an unconstitutional order, by all means challenge it in court.Obama has set a precedent as far as writing law via executive order.
Now you want to prevent such action simply because you disagree with the outcome?
That's not very intellectually honest or consistent...
The criticism about Obama and executive orders strikes me as similar to those who complain about how much he golfs or vacations, when, in fact, he's been remarkably restrained in all those things relative to recent presidents generally.That's not correct. A executive order is to Federal agencies, not "writing law".
Obama has to work harder to catch up to previous Presidents who wrote more executive orders: http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/data/orders.php
The next President is free to write new EOs.
http://www.thisnation.com/question/040.html
Executive Orders (EOs) are legally binding orders given by the President, acting as the head of the Executive Branch, to Federal Administrative Agencies. Executive Orders are generally used to direct federal agencies and officials in their execution of congressionally established laws or policies. However, in many instances they have been used to guide agencies in directions contrary to congressional intent.
The criticism about Obama and executive orders strikes me as similar to those who complain about how much he golfs or vacations, when, in fact, he's been remarkably restrained in all those things relative to recent presidents generally.
Anyway, I don't know all of his executive orders, and there may be some that cross a line. If so, by all means they ought to be challenged. But the ones I've been aware of have generally been the typical variety where he is guiding executive branch policy in fairly well-worn ways.
Are you suggesting that the POTUS should have the power to rule our economy by decree? That's a very bad idea IMO.I'd be thrilled if you could point me to just one that made the economy stronger...
It's hard to draw one-to-one lines between executive orders and their economic consequences. For example, order 13505 removed arbitrary Bush-era rules that dictated that only certain stem cell lines were eligible for federal research funding. The Bush-era rules guaranteed that funding went not to whatever projects looked most promising from a scientific perspective, but instead to whichever ones looked most promising after you had eliminated any projects that used stem cell lines that politically powerful religious people wanted excluded for reasons of faith. One would fully expect the transition to funding the most promising projects, after removal of that religious rule, to result in the taxpayer getting more bang for his research buck. But can we prove that a particular breakthrough wouldn't have occurred using other stem cell lines? I don't think so. So, although it was clearly a wise order, rationally designed to make the economy stronger, I can't prove it actually made the economy stronger.I'd be thrilled if you could point me to just one that made the economy stronger...
Exactly. An executive order can only be given to pre-existing law. As far as the immigration executive order, there was no pre-existing law in regards to legalizing illegal immigrants.That's not correct. A executive order is to Federal agencies, not "writing law".
I'm not concerned with the quantity of Executive orders at all. I'm concerned with whether or not they apply to existing law or swerve around Congress, as Obama did.Obama has to work harder to catch up to previous Presidents who wrote more executive orders: http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/data/orders.php
If you think he has made an unconstitutional order, by all means challenge it in court.
It's hard to draw one-to-one lines between executive orders and their economic consequences. For example, order 13505 removed arbitrary Bush-era rules that dictated that only certain stem cell lines were eligible for federal research funding. The Bush-era rules guaranteed that funding went not to whatever projects looked most promising from a scientific perspective, but instead to whichever ones looked most promising after you had eliminated any projects that used stem cell lines that politically powerful religious people wanted excluded for reasons of faith. One would fully expect the transition to funding the most promising projects, after removal of that religious rule, to result in the taxpayer getting more bang for his research buck. But can we prove that a particular breakthrough wouldn't have occurred using other stem cell lines? I don't think so. So, although it was clearly a wise order, rationally designed to make the economy stronger, I can't prove it actually made the economy stronger.
That's not the only case. Lots of executive orders are rationally designed to bring about certain positive economic results (e.g,. setting up a group that will focus on opportunities to improve veterans' job opportunities, to lower unemployment among veterans), but that doesn't mean you can prove they necessarily worked. For example, would unemployment have dropped as quickly as it did if not for those various employment-related executive orders? Impossible to say for sure. As you know, we can say that unemployment has dropped a great deal since Obama took office (and that the deficit has, and that real GDP per capita has risen, and that the stock market is up, etc.), but since Obama was throwing a whole bunch of levers and switches at the same time, and so were a bunch of other people, how do we figure out exactly what brought about the improvement?


Are you suggesting that the POTUS should have the power to rule our economy by decree? That's a very bad idea IMO.
Government shouldn't be creating jobs or ruling the economy.
The US Constitution prevents it. If a US President tried to overrule the Constitution with an executive order that purported to strip millions of American citizens of their citizenship, based on who their parents were, they'd challenge in court and the order would be struck down.
Here's a simple test of your theory. If a foreign national runs her car into the rear end of the auto of another foreign national in their nation's capital, and then flees to America - is she or isn't she subject to the judgement and/or criminal charges as assessed under that foreign nation's laws?
I couldn't find Darkady's post and for the time being I've quit talking with him anyway.
I just wanted to say he's not an idiot for the benefit of newcomers who might think so. This one in particular. I lived in Europe for a number of years and when I drove into another country I had to show my passport which indentified me as a "foreign national" and I also had to show my international insurance card. When I flew somewhere and rented a car I also had to show it.
The action is subject to challenge in the courts. Perhaps it will be struck down. So far, no.Ah yes, the ol' "Might makes right" logic.
Something you cry afoul when it's against your agenda.
But if it's Obama? It's "F you, do something about it punk"...
Meanwhile, District judges have called it unconstitutional, and common sense clearly dictates that it is, as EO's can only be given to pre-existing law.
There was no law on the books about legalizing illegal immigrants.
Why is it that the Democrats just want to suddenly choose to ignore the law? They aren't even trying to change it, through Congress?
Nope. Gold-bug right-wingers have been giving me that same advice since Obama was sworn in, and I routinely ignore it. Sometimes that means that I ride the market down for a while. But more often it means I ride it up, and it has averaged out to excellent returns overall. The last time I moved most of my investments out of US securities was in the Bush era, when I was betting that bad leadership in this country would result in US stocks being outperformed by other investment classes.I hope you took my advice about getting your investments into cash...