New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

Key in on the red highlighted text. The words "subject to jurisdiction thereof" are there to make an exception of Indians who belonged to Indian nations. Illegal aliens are not subject to the jurisdiction being spoken of much like Indians at the time were not.

So your position is that illegal aliens and their offspring born here can do whatever they want because they are not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States?
 
So your position is that illegal aliens and their offspring born here can do whatever they want because they are not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States?

Well, that is not how it worked when an Indian killed a U.S. citizen. So evidently 'jurisdiction' implies assertion of citizenship by a foreign nation on the children of their nationals who may happen to be abroad when born.
 
This is not a matter of "international norms" - this is a matter of what the 14th Amendment says.
Well, actually international norms do apply because you see these anchor babies all have Mexican citizenship. Go ask Mexico about it and they'll tell you that yes those anchor babies are Mexican citizens.
 
Well, actually international norms do apply because you see these anchor babies all have Mexican citizenship. Go ask Mexico about it and they'll tell you that yes those anchor babies are Mexican citizens.

Ridiculous - the so-called anchor babies are from many different countries.

And it's not up to Mexico to tell us we can't enforce the actual words of our 14th Amendment. Not that they seek to do so, despite what you say.
 
Well, that is not how it worked when an Indian killed a U.S. citizen. So evidently 'jurisdiction' implies assertion of citizenship by a foreign nation on the children of their nationals who may happen to be abroad when born.

Your dodge is noted. You know that my question squarely refutes your absurd position, so you dodge and dissemble.

Answer it if you work up the stones.
 
The international norm is that your citizens who have children abroad are of your nationality. So Mexican kids born to illegal aliens in this country are Mexican citizens.
Again you act like a Lib Winger: They use that same argument for gun control "The international norm is..."

These are reasons why more and more Americans are becoming so disgusted with authoritarian [Unwelcome language removed].

gitmorazorwireFlag.jpg
 
Again you act like a Lib Winger: They use that same argument for gun control "The international norm is..."

These are reasons why more and more Americans are becoming so disgusted with authoritarian [Unwelcome language removed].

gitmorazorwireFlag.jpg
Again, whether you like it or not, international norms do apply when it comes to citizenship and dual citizenship. It's how we all get along.
 
Again, whether you like it or not, international norms do apply when it comes to citizenship and dual citizenship. It's how we all get along.

Wingers are so desperate to sell their hooey on the anchor baby stuff that they actually claim that Mexico has a say in whether we can enforce the words of our 14th Amendment.

How about Iran? North Korea? Can they do that too?

;-)
 
Show me that you have a clue. Answer my question instead of dodging it:

Is it your position is that illegal aliens and their offspring born here can do whatever they want because they are not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States?

I answered it before:

Well, that is not how it worked when an Indian killed a U.S. citizen. So evidently 'jurisdiction' implies assertion of citizenship by a foreign nation on the children of their nationals who may happen to be abroad when born.

Now if you say I dodged your question one more time then you can go fvck yourself.
 
Again, whether you like it or not, international norms do apply when it comes to citizenship and dual citizenship. It's how we all get along.
One again you are wrong. International law applies, not "norms". The fact soccer (the international norm is "football") is the world's most popular sport doesn't mean it has to be our most popular sport too. Only the law matters in this case.
 
I answered it before:

Well, that is not how it worked when an Indian killed a U.S. citizen. So evidently 'jurisdiction' implies assertion of citizenship by a foreign nation on the children of their nationals who may happen to be abroad when born.

Now if you say I dodged your question one more time then you can go fvck yourself.

Nope.

Permissible answers are:

A. Yes.
B. No.
C. I don't know.

Care to choose one, or dodge again?
 
One again you are wrong. International law applies, not "norms". The fact soccer (the international norm is "football") is the world's most popular sport doesn't mean it has to be our most popular sport too. Only the law matters in this case.

"Norm" speaks to how most all countries treat a matter. Mexico could say, "those anchor babies aren't ours." Who'd stop them? You and your international laws?
 
Back
Top