New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

Good job. You are now in the camp of holocaust deniers and Hitler lovers. World War II wasn't Hitler's fault for invading Poland...it was FDR's fault. Dude...you are now one of the weaker minds on PJ. Congratulations.

Hey -------------- keep it real or and apologize to Lukey.

We are talking about what led us to war ---- nothing else.
 

I find it pretty amusing to hear Hitler complain about FDR refusing to recognize "new governments"....since what he is actually saying is that the countries Germany has conquered now have governments installed by Hitler and he thinks they are legitimate governments and it pisses him off that FDR says no they are not. We will not recognize them, we will not trade with them and we will support the governments in exile.

FDR froze the assets of those countries and made them available to governments in exile. That must have really driven Adolph nuts.
 
Hitler armed Germany, but feel free to claim that he was actually calling for disarmament as he did so.


You makers and insister of war disgust me ----------- lying bastards just to be on the wining side of a war long won and lost- despicable blockers of man kinds truths.

On May 17, 1933, a few months after his appointment to the office of Reichskanzler, he delivered a speech in the German Reichstag, from which we extract the following passages:




  • "Germany will be perfectly ready to disband her entire military establishment and destroy the small amount of arms remaining to her, if the neighboring countries will do the same thing with equal thoroughness.
    ... Germany is entirely ready to renounce aggressive weapons of every sort if the armed nations, on their part, will destroy their aggressive weapons within a specified period, and if their use is forbidden by an international convention.

    ... Germany is at all times prepared to renounce offensive weapons if the rest of the world does the same. Germany is prepared to agree to any solemn pact of non-aggression because she does not think of attacking anybody but only of acquiring security."
No answer was received.

https://www.wintersonnenwende.com/scriptorium/english/archives/nothanks/wwr00.html


You are the denialist - the denier of the truth, from which the people of this planet can learn.
 
I find it pretty amusing to hear Hitler complain about FDR refusing to recognize "new governments"....since what he is actually saying is that the countries Germany has conquered now have governments installed by Hitler and he thinks they are legitimate governments and it pisses him off that FDR says no they are not. We will not recognize them, we will not trade with them and we will support the governments in exile.

FDR froze the assets of those countries and made them available to governments in exile. That must have really driven Adolph nuts.

You do not even realise that your very words condemn you.
 
Hey -------------- keep it real or and apologize to Lukey.

We are talking about what led us to war ---- nothing else.

Lukey claimed it was FDRs economic policies that put Hitler in power. Hitler was in power before FDR was.

Hitler claimed he was declaring war on the US because FDR was not nice to him....and refused to recognize governments that the Nazis had installed in Norway, Denmark, Belgium, Luxembourg, France, Poland and Czechoslovakia....He justified declaring war because FDR had no right to have an opinion about Germany's invasions of those countries.

War was not forced on Germany. Hitler started his military buildup in 1934. He sent troops, planes and equipment to Spain to fight on the side of Franco in 1936. He threatened war if he didn't get the Czechs to give up their western frontier...and then invaded Poland pretending that the Poles were mistreating ethnic Germans and had invaded Germany and killed German soldiers.

Your version of history is entertaining...but false.
 
You makers and insister of war disgust me ----------- lying bastards just to be on the wining side of a war long won and lost- despicable blockers of man kinds truths.

On May 17, 1933, a few months after his appointment to the office of Reichskanzler, he delivered a speech in the German Reichstag, from which we extract the following passages:




  • "Germany will be perfectly ready to disband her entire military establishment and destroy the small amount of arms remaining to her, if the neighboring countries will do the same thing with equal thoroughness.
    ... Germany is entirely ready to renounce aggressive weapons of every sort if the armed nations, on their part, will destroy their aggressive weapons within a specified period, and if their use is forbidden by an international convention.

    ... Germany is at all times prepared to renounce offensive weapons if the rest of the world does the same. Germany is prepared to agree to any solemn pact of non-aggression because she does not think of attacking anybody but only of acquiring security."
No answer was received.

https://www.wintersonnenwende.com/scriptorium/english/archives/nothanks/wwr00.html


You are the denialist - the denier of the truth, from which the people of this planet can learn.

Whether or not Hitler would have actually disarmed the small German Army of 1933 is pretty much debatable...since what he actually did was secretly expanded the army and air force to be the most modern and powerful in the world by 1939. He claimed to want peace, but then sent Germans to fight in Spain in 1936....
 
Lukey claimed it was FDRs economic policies that put Hitler in power. Hitler was in power before FDR was.

Hitler claimed he was declaring war on the US because FDR was not nice to him....and refused to recognize governments that the Nazis had installed in Norway, Denmark, Belgium, Luxembourg, France, Poland and Czechoslovakia....He justified declaring war because FDR had no right to have an opinion about Germany's invasions of those countries.

War was not forced on Germany. Hitler started his military buildup in 1934. He sent troops, planes and equipment to Spain to fight on the side of Franco in 1936. He threatened war if he didn't get the Czechs to give up their western frontier...and then invaded Poland pretending that the Poles were mistreating ethnic Germans and had invaded Germany and killed German soldiers.

Your version of history is entertaining...but false.

Lukey was correct, as was Hitler.

You though just called Lukey a Holocaust denier and a Nazi ( in other words) - I think you should apologize.

My stance is not Lukey's nor has he ever even insinuated that his was.
 
Lukey was correct, as was Hitler.

You though just called Lukey a Holocaust denier and a Nazi ( in other words) - I think you should apologize.

My stance is not Lukey's nor has he ever even insinuated that his was.

If Hitler was in power before FDR...how in hell did FDR's economic policies put him there?
 
Whether or not Hitler would have actually disarmed the small German Army of 1933 is pretty much debatable...since what he actually did was secretly expanded the army and air force to be the most modern and powerful in the world by 1939. He claimed to want peace, but then sent Germans to fight in Spain in 1936....

None of America's business.
 
1. You've proven my point. Hitler gained power before FDR became president.
2. You've failed and failed miserably to make the point that FDR is to blame for anything Hitler did.

Hitler used government spending to bring Germany out of the depression. They were probably the first major nation to recover. The autobahn as well as major weapons programs put people back to work much more quickly than in the US.

I never said that. I said he was responsible for producing the conditions that brought about WWII. Yes, Hitler became a political player before FDR was elected, but the account I posted CLEARLY STATES that his support soared as the depression wore on. Yes, it was Hoover who set the depression in motion (through his "Bushian" big government interventionism) but FDR didn't do enough to reverse Hoover's mistakes (like repealing Smoot Hawley), and, in fact, made things worse (as the UCLA Professors documented).

In retrospect, Smoot-Hawley was reflective not only of the era’s economic nationalism, but of the political isolationism that was to prove so useful to Hitler.

https://newrepublic.com/article/88394/peddling-protectionism-smoot-hawley-depression-douglas-irwin

If FDR had never stood in the way of the economy recovering, as the UCLA study documents, the improving world economy would have taken the wind out from under Hitler's wings, and the developed nations would have been too busy re-establishing economic ties to rattle their sabers at each other.
 
Good job. You are now in the camp of holocaust deniers and Hitler lovers. World War II wasn't Hitler's fault for invading Poland...it was FDR's fault. Dude...you are now one of the weaker minds on PJ. Congratulations.

That, of course, is bullshit (and frankly indicative of the weakness of your position that you have to concoct a bullshit argument to deflect from my actual argument). I'm not "pro-Hitler" - that would imply I am (also) pro-WWII, which I clearly am not. Nor am I excusing anything Hitler did. I'm simply peeling off the fake recounting of history that the war was somehow righteous (or inevitable). WWII (indeed, ALL war) is a failure of geopolitical (and almost always economic) policy. In WWII's case, the (failed) FDR policy agenda is arguably responsible for making the global depression last longer than it needed to. And it is clearly not "holocaust denial" out of the mainstream (as my links would support) to suggest that the economic conditions were what led to WWII. The fact that you are trying to make it into that says more about you than it does about me.

I'm anti-war, and quite simply, pro-truth! And the truth is that FDR mismanaged the economy and, in doing so, created the geopolitical petrie dish upon which WWII incubated.
 
Hitler armed Germany, but feel free to claim that he was actually calling for disarmament as he did so.

He didn't do so immediately. It was an economic "stimulus" program as much as a re-arming. Hitler was a Keynesian:

In the 1930s, Hitler was widely viewed as just another protectionist central planner who recognized the supposed failure of the free market and the need for nationally guided economic development. Proto-Keynesian socialist economist Joan Robinson wrote that "Hitler found a cure against unemployment before Keynes was finished explaining it."

https://mises.org/library/hitlers-economics

And, as I always say, war is the last refuge of failed Keynesians.
 
I never said that. I said he was responsible for producing the conditions that brought about WWII. Yes, Hitler became a political player before FDR was elected, but the account I posted CLEARLY STATES that his support soared as the depression wore on. Yes, it was Hoover who set the depression in motion (through his "Bushian" big government interventionism) but FDR didn't do enough to reverse Hoover's mistakes (like repealing Smoot Hawley), and, in fact, made things worse (as the UCLA Professors documented).

In retrospect, Smoot-Hawley was reflective not only of the era’s economic nationalism, but of the political isolationism that was to prove so useful to Hitler.

https://newrepublic.com/article/88394/peddling-protectionism-smoot-hawley-depression-douglas-irwin

If FDR had never stood in the way of the economy recovering, as the UCLA study documents, the improving world economy would have taken the wind out from under Hitler's wings, and the developed nations would have been too busy re-establishing economic ties to rattle their sabers at each other.

I can't agree entirely, because my understanding of how WWI and WWII came about and of Hitler and the Reich, as well, is other but of FDR indeed, as Hitler stated - I paraphrase, 'why didn't he help his own poor people living in misery, poverty and on the streets rather than making war on Germany' .

Why don't 'they' ever want their own people happy, content, independent and in work? Outside as cannon fodder for another of their wars?
 
Lukey claimed it was FDRs economic policies that put Hitler in power. Hitler was in power before FDR was.

Hitler claimed he was declaring war on the US because FDR was not nice to him....and refused to recognize governments that the Nazis had installed in Norway, Denmark, Belgium, Luxembourg, France, Poland and Czechoslovakia....He justified declaring war because FDR had no right to have an opinion about Germany's invasions of those countries.

War was not forced on Germany. Hitler started his military buildup in 1934. He sent troops, planes and equipment to Spain to fight on the side of Franco in 1936. He threatened war if he didn't get the Czechs to give up their western frontier...and then invaded Poland pretending that the Poles were mistreating ethnic Germans and had invaded Germany and killed German soldiers.

Your version of history is entertaining...but false.

Provide the quote or STFU! I never said that and you know it. You are just trying to hide from the fact that you are losing the argument.

All Hitler did was start "re-arming" Germany, as it had been forced to disarm after WWII. So yea, you can characterize it as a "military build-up," but you can't definitively state that his aim in doing so was to eventually start invading his neighbors.
 
I can't agree entirely, because my understanding of how WWI and WWII came about and of Hitler and the Reich, as well, is other but of FDR indeed, as Hitler stated - I paraphrase, 'why didn't he help his own poor people living in misery, poverty and on the streets rather than making war on Germany' .

Why don't 'they' ever want their own people happy, content, independent and in work? Outside as cannon fodder for another of their wars?

I guess I'm not really clear on what you are disagreeing with.
 
Back
Top