New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

"Which is why the whole thing amounts to taking water from one end of the pool and dumping it in the other end - and, of course, why it never works"

The most absolutely brilliant summarization of Keynesian economics as I've ever heard.

Agreed! It sums it up rather nicely. The whole Keynesian scam is based in Bastiat's concept of "what is seen and what is not seen:"

http://bastiat.org/en/twisatwins.html

The lefty Keynesians focus attention on what is seen (the act of pouring the bucket of water in the pool) and completely (and purposefully) ignore the fact that you are getting the water from the other end of the pool. The whole concept of the "fiscal multiplier" (upon which standard Keynesian theory is based) is simply mathematical sleight of hand, where you measure only the effects to the economy as a result of the "stimulus" and pretend there are no negative effects that offset some, or all, or even, in some cases, more than the entire value of the "stimulus." When you do that, you are either clueless about economics or you are lying. Either way it is astonishing that this sort of fiscal shamanism passes for accepted "conventional wisdom" by the majority of Americans. It really illustrates the effect of "fake news" - the mainstream media prints story after story after story about the pouring of water into the pool, and you never see one reference to what might be happening at the other end. That is what passes for "factual" coverage, and when an outlet (such as ZeroHedge) points us to what is happening behind the Wizard's screen, it is vilified as being "unfactual." The good news is that the fracturing of the information dissemination as a result of the internet is giving those who have a clue, and know the truth, the facts to counteract the lefty fake news media machine. I think that's why there is such a widespread acceptance of the fact that the Obama "stimulus" failed. In the old days, 99% of Americans would never see a single fact that supports that conclusion.
 
Reagan was sworn in January 1981. From then until 1986 the recovery that you think so superior was nonexistent. You think that recovery was great and this one sucks...well, not if you were looking for a job.

Nobody but extreme left wing ideologues believe that Reagan's economic policies resulted in some sort of failure. The simple fact that so many people were able to enter the workforce, as illustrated by the increasing LFPR in the chart YOU POSTED during the Reagan years, disputes your argument here. I would simply reiterate my appreciation for your refuting your own argument with that chart.
 
If FDR hadn't destroyed the economic recovery, producing what we now refer to as the "Great Depression," there wouldn't have been a war.

http://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/FDR-s-Policies-Prolonged-Depression-5409

One of your funnier assertions, although I'm sure you didn't mean it to be. History reduces your logic to comedy. Your UCLA professors assert that the depression, which by 1933 had produced an official 25% unemployment rate, actually got going because of pro-labor actions by FDR in mid 1933.

World War II had a lot less to do with the depression in the US than you seem to think. Were you thinking Hitler would not have invaded Poland in 1939 if not for FDR?
 
Nobody but extreme left wing ideologues believe that Reagan's economic policies resulted in some sort of failure. The simple fact that so many people were able to enter the workforce, as illustrated by the increasing LFPR in the chart YOU POSTED during the Reagan years, disputes your argument here. I would simply reiterate my appreciation for your refuting your own argument with that chart.

That increase in the LFPR did not happen until 1986...look into the number of tax increases that had been pushed through by then as Reagan realized his tax cuts were creating a huge deficit and weren't accomplishing what he wanted.

The increase in the LFPR had to do with the baby boom and not Reagan. The decrease in the LFPR has to do with the boomers retiring and not Obama. To pretend that the decrease in unemployment is all about the LFPR is to ignore job creation numbers.

If you wish to compare job numbers...tell me one 30 period during Reagan's years in which we lost 750,000 jobs....The fact is that Bush handed Obama the worst economy since 1929.

econ_charts2.png


cbpp-chart-recession-joblosses.jpg


chart2_JOBS_monthlygainloss.png
 
Agreed! It sums it up rather nicely. The whole Keynesian scam is based in Bastiat's concept of "what is seen and what is not seen:"

http://bastiat.org/en/twisatwins.html

The lefty Keynesians focus attention on what is seen (the act of pouring the bucket of water in the pool) and completely (and purposefully) ignore the fact that you are getting the water from the other end of the pool. The whole concept of the "fiscal multiplier" (upon which standard Keynesian theory is based) is simply mathematical sleight of hand, where you measure only the effects to the economy as a result of the "stimulus" and pretend there are no negative effects that offset some, or all, or even, in some cases, more than the entire value of the "stimulus." When you do that, you are either clueless about economics or you are lying. Either way it is astonishing that this sort of fiscal shamanism passes for accepted "conventional wisdom" by the majority of Americans. It really illustrates the effect of "fake news" - the mainstream media prints story after story after story about the pouring of water into the pool, and you never see one reference to what might be happening at the other end. That is what passes for "factual" coverage, and when an outlet (such as ZeroHedge) points us to what is happening behind the Wizard's screen, it is vilified as being "unfactual." The good news is that the fracturing of the information dissemination as a result of the internet is giving those who have a clue, and know the truth, the facts to counteract the lefty fake news media machine. I think that's why there is such a widespread acceptance of the fact that the Obama "stimulus" failed. In the old days, 99% of Americans would never see a single fact that supports that conclusion.
BOOM!

Post of the day!
 
Nobody but extreme left wing ideologues believe that Reagan's economic policies resulted in some sort of failure.

Why do you feel the need to twist what I write into something completely different?
Where did I say that Reagans' policies failed? I compared his recovery to Obama's.
His recovery really did not happen until 1986....and the recession he dealt with was not as bad as what Bush handed to Obama.
 
One of your funnier assertions, although I'm sure you didn't mean it to be. History reduces your logic to comedy. Your UCLA professors assert that the depression, which by 1933 had produced an official 25% unemployment rate, actually got going because of pro-labor actions by FDR in mid 1933.

World War II had a lot less to do with the depression in the US than you seem to think. Were you thinking Hitler would not have invaded Poland in 1939 if not for FDR?

Again, you know little to nothing about economics. If you don't understand the effect of economic repression and war reparations in the rise of Hitler's political movement, you simply have an excessively superficial knowledge of history.
 
Why do you feel the need to twist what I write into something completely different?
Where did I say that Reagans' policies failed? I compared his recovery to Obama's.
His recovery really did not happen until 1986....and the recession he dealt with was not as bad as what Bush handed to Obama.

It's not twisting what you say - it's deconstructing your logic. The fact is that Reagan at least HAD a recovery (and by most measures a pretty good one) while Obama did not (thanks to his disastrous anti-capitalist policy agenda):

Screen Shot 2017-09-02 at 5.31.06 PM.png

It really is as simple as that...
 
It's not twisting what you say - it's deconstructing your logic. The fact is that Reagan at least HAD a recovery (and by most measures a pretty good one) while Obama did not (thanks to his disastrous anti-capitalist policy agenda):

View attachment 37295

It really is as simple as that...

Only if you ignore the numbers. One recession does not equal another. The Bush recession was worse than Reagan's...just in terms of how extremes the job losses were alone. You want to bitch about how long the recovery is taking from Bush's recession, but pretend Reagan's recovery was instantaneous....it wasn't.

It is as simple as that.
 
Again, you know little to nothing about economics. If you don't understand the effect of economic repression and war reparations in the rise of Hitler's political movement, you simply have an excessively superficial knowledge of history.

Got it...so the Japanese invasion of China in 1931 was all about German war reparations...Italian fascism and the invasion of Ethiopia and the Spanish civil war were all FDR's fault...Mussolini took power in 1922.

You are truly lost in this absolutely amazing attempt to try to blame FDR for shit....By the way...when did Hitler gain power? Was it before or after FDR did? Since Hitler became chancellor in 1932, you'll have to explain how it is that FDRs policies helped him accomplish that.
 
Agreed! It sums it up rather nicely. The whole Keynesian scam is based in Bastiat's concept of "what is seen and what is not seen:"

http://bastiat.org/en/twisatwins.html

The lefty Keynesians focus attention on what is seen (the act of pouring the bucket of water in the pool) and completely (and purposefully) ignore the fact that you are getting the water from the other end of the pool. The whole concept of the "fiscal multiplier" (upon which standard Keynesian theory is based) is simply mathematical sleight of hand, where you measure only the effects to the economy as a result of the "stimulus" and pretend there are no negative effects that offset some, or all, or even, in some cases, more than the entire value of the "stimulus." When you do that, you are either clueless about economics or you are lying. Either way it is astonishing that this sort of fiscal shamanism passes for accepted "conventional wisdom" by the majority of Americans. It really illustrates the effect of "fake news" - the mainstream media prints story after story after story about the pouring of water into the pool, and you never see one reference to what might be happening at the other end. That is what passes for "factual" coverage, and when an outlet (such as ZeroHedge) points us to what is happening behind the Wizard's screen, it is vilified as being "unfactual." The good news is that the fracturing of the information dissemination as a result of the internet is giving those who have a clue, and know the truth, the facts to counteract the lefty fake news media machine. I think that's why there is such a widespread acceptance of the fact that the Obama "stimulus" failed. In the old days, 99% of Americans would never see a single fact that supports that conclusion.

Not all private money is equally productive. Money spent by poor people for subsistence will immediately increase demand for goods and services, while money given to rich people will be hoarded or gambled in financial speculation if that is more profitable than investing in an industrial sector with a glut of supply relative to demand by consumers who are too poor to afford the prices that can profitably be charged. Part of the problem with Obama's stimulus was that nearly all of it went to big business interests and not to the sorts of spending proven to create the most jobs (food stamps and welfare).
 
Not all private money is equally productive. Money spent by poor people for subsistence will immediately increase demand for goods and services, while money given to rich people will be hoarded or gambled in financial speculation if that is more profitable than investing in an industrial sector with a glut of supply relative to demand by consumers who are too poor to afford the prices that can profitably be charged. Part of the problem with Obama's stimulus was that nearly all of it went to big business interests and not to the sorts of spending proven to create the most jobs (food stamps and welfare).
Soooo.....money spent by rich people on subsistence doesn't immediately increase demand for goods and services just the same as poor people?

Really?

And rich people, being rich or course, have a whole lot more money to spend on subsistence don't they? More than say.......poor people?
 
Not all private money is equally productive. Money spent by poor people for subsistence will immediately increase demand for goods and services, while money given to rich people will be hoarded or gambled in financial speculation if that is more profitable than investing in an industrial sector with a glut of supply relative to demand by consumers who are too poor to afford the prices that can profitably be charged. Part of the problem with Obama's stimulus was that nearly all of it went to big business interests and not to the sorts of spending proven to create the most jobs (food stamps and welfare).
Do you never look at a composition, re-read it, before hitting the Post Reply button, and say to yourself: This is the dumbest shit I've ever come up with. I'll look like a moron if I actually post this? No? Well you should try it.
 
Soooo.....money spent by rich people on subsistence doesn't immediately increase demand for goods and services just the same as poor people?

Really?

And rich people, being rich or course, have a whole lot more money to spend on subsistence don't they? More than say.......poor people?

The point, in my opinion, is that if someone who is fairly wealthy gets a large tax cut they are unlikely to spend that money on consumer goods. While they may take a vacation to Bora Bora or buy a new painting at Southeby's....those expenses have less to do with the American economy than tax cuts for those who live payday to payday.
 
The point, in my opinion, is that if someone who is fairly wealthy gets a large tax cut they are unlikely to spend that money on consumer goods. While they may take a vacation to Bora Bora or buy a new painting at Southeby's....those expenses have less to do with the American economy than tax cuts for those who live payday to payday.
I agree with your points that those scenarios quite probably play out that way along with others similar.

But to say that rich people don't spend more than poor people do on subsistence is comical at best. Or that the money rich people spend doesn't have the same impact on the economy as a poor person's money is silly. They surely do have more than enough money to purchase anything they desire at any time and do so every day. Whether its shopping on Rodeo Dr. or the mall, eating at Ruth's Chris or MacD's or buying an F-350 diesel vs. a Yugo. Whereas a poor person on a budget doesn't have the freedom to spent as much or as frequently.

That's the point I was trying to make.
 
Last edited:
Soooo.....money spent by rich people on subsistence doesn't immediately increase demand for goods and services just the same as poor people?

Really?

And rich people, being rich or course, have a whole lot more money to spend on subsistence don't they? More than say.......poor people?

The point is that poor people necessarily spend all their money on subsistence. Rich people often do not spend their money buying goods and services at all, as opposed to turning it into capital, and when they do it is often for conspicuous - consumption items that don't create permanent jobs.
 
The point is that poor people necessarily spend all their money on subsistence. Rich people often do not spend their money buying goods and services at all, as opposed to turning it into capital, and when they do it is often for conspicuous - consumption items that don't create permanent jobs.
Your point is ridiculous.

So rich people don't buy groceries? Cars? Dinner? Shoes? Services? ........Anything? Are you under the erroneous impression they only save their money for investment and capital gains? Seriously?

No. As a matter of fact, on an individual basis, a rich person will spend greatly, hugely, excessively more than a poor person for all of those things I listed above and millions of others. And they don't even have to think twice about it.

A rich person may have 40 pairs of shoes, a pantry closet full to overflowing with goods and food or a 6 car garage full of new vehicles. A poor person may only have one pair of shoes (maybe with holes in them) and empty shelves devoid of any goods or food and ride the bus. Now you tell me honestly.......which one of those people is the bigger contibutor to the economy?

Be honest
 
I agree with your points that those scenarios quite probably play out that way along with others similar.

But to say that rich people don't spend more than poor people do on subsistence is comical at best. Or that the money rich people spend doesn't have the same impact on the economy as a poor person's money is silly. They surely do have more than enough money to purchase anything they desire at any time and do so every day. Whether its shopping on Rodeo Dr. or the mall, eating at Ruth's Chris or MacD's or buying an F-350 diesel vs. a Yugo. Whereas a poor person on a budget doesn't have the freedom to spent as much or as frequently.

That's the point I was trying to make.

If you took the exact same dollar amount and used that for tax cuts on millionaires or billionaires....would they buy the same quantity (given there are far fewer of them) of a given product (ie...a car) or would that amount of money spread to far more people at a lower income level be spent on a greater quantity? If the result was 1,000 Ferraris or Mercedes vs 3,000 Chevys....what would you think the economic differences would be?
 
Back
Top