New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

If you took the exact same dollar amount and used that for tax cuts on millionaires or billionaires....would they buy the same quantity (given there are far fewer of them) of a given product (ie...a car) or would that amount of money spread to far more people at a lower income level be spent on a greater quantity? If the result was 1,000 Ferraris or Mercedes vs 3,000 Chevys....what would you think the economic differences would be?
That's a good question. The point I was making about a rich person's spending compared to a poor or middle class person is on an individual basis. I guess I should have clarified that.

I think that one individual millionaire's spending on everyday purchases like groceries, meals, services etc would contribute more to the economy and outweigh the spending of say 2, 3 or 4 poor or middle class people. That's just my opinion though there's nothing scientific about it. I can't quote a study that verifies my opinion. It just makes common sense to me. The wealthy simply have more money and disposable income to spread around. And they do. Most of the wealthy people I know spend indiscriminately and without worry on any and everything that suits their fancy. The extremely wealthy people I know spend even more. And that's all good for our economy obviously.

I don't have the brains to extrapolate that to the whole country's population. Because like you said the middle and lower class greatly outnumber the millionaires and billionaires. Maybe there's a study out there somewhere which can answer your question.

I do pretty good income wise for myself and I think most folks would consider me well off or at least comfortable. After reading your posts for almost the last year I feel safe in assuming you do pretty darn good for yourself too and are quite comfortable as well. I only mention that because even though I'm very comfortable I still spend WAY more than I save or invest. That's why I disagree with ETR that only lower income people spending on subsistence has an impact on our economy. I don't understand why he/she thinks wealthy people only hoard their dollars. That simply isn't realistic.
 
That's a good question. The point I was making about a rich person's spending compared to a poor or middle class person is on an individual basis. I guess I should have clarified that.

I think that one individual millionaire's spending on everyday purchases like groceries, meals, services etc would contribute more to the economy and outweigh the spending of say 2, 3 or 4 poor or middle class people. That's just my opinion though there's nothing scientific about it. I can't quote a study that verifies my opinion. It just makes common sense to me. The wealthy simply have more money and disposable income to spread around. And they do. Most of the wealthy people I know spend indiscriminately and without worry on any and everything that suits their fancy. The extremely wealthy people I know spend even more. And that's all good for our economy obviously.

I don't have the brains to extrapolate that to the whole country's population. Because like you said the middle and lower class greatly outnumber the millionaires and billionaires. Maybe there's a study out there somewhere which can answer your question.

I do pretty good income wise for myself and I think most folks would consider me well off or at least comfortable. After reading your posts for almost the last year I feel safe in assuming you do pretty darn good for yourself too and are quite comfortable as well. I only mention that because even though I'm very comfortable I still spend WAY more than I save or invest. That's why I disagree with ETR that only lower income people spending on subsistence has an impact on our economy. I don't understand why he/she thinks wealthy people only hoard their dollars. That simply isn't realistic.

So if you were making $500k, clearing $350k and suddenly got $50k tax cut...what would you spend it on? I'd probably buy a Tesla in the first year....and put money into my 401k...

If you were making $50k and got a $5k tax cut what would you do with it?
 
So if you were making $500k, clearing $350k and suddenly got $50k tax cut...what would you spend it on? I'd probably buy a Tesla in the first year....and put money into my 401k...

If you were making $50k and got a $5k tax cut what would you do with it?
Ahhhh more good questions. You think Tesla..... I'm thinking opposite end of the spectrum like a new Silverado 3500 diesel or maybe upgrade our CLS 550 to the new AMG CLS 63S. 577 horsepower! It"s a street legal German pavement eating monster. With style and luxury as a bonus! Wife says we're not responsible enough to have all that power under our right foot! She"s probably right although I'd never admit it!

If I got a 5k tax stipend I'd probably go for a Barrett model 99 in chambered in .50 BMG. I've lusted for one of those since the first time I saw one. Don't really know what I'd do with it except look at it. It ain't practical or necessary but man is it a blast to pull the trigger on that thing.

The real truth is I have a hard time splurging on myself. IRA or a 401k would contributions would definately be maxed. Opening the statements almost feels like Christmas nowadays. I'd more than likely spend most of the extra money doing and getting things for the family.
 
Not all private money is equally productive. Money spent by poor people for subsistence will immediately increase demand for goods and services, while money given to rich people will be hoarded or gambled in financial speculation if that is more profitable than investing in an industrial sector with a glut of supply relative to demand by consumers who are too poor to afford the prices that can profitably be charged. Part of the problem with Obama's stimulus was that nearly all of it went to big business interests and not to the sorts of spending proven to create the most jobs (food stamps and welfare).

Haha! Thanks a million for helping me out with one of the most important points I make around here - that the Democrats' current platform stems from a Marxist mindset. And here we have it folks, an admitted communist using the exact same argument the modern Democrats do to justify their wealth redistribution schemes. Birds of a feather...
 
So if you were making $500k, clearing $350k and suddenly got $50k tax cut...what would you spend it on? I'd probably buy a Tesla in the first year....and put money into my 401k...

If you were making $50k and got a $5k tax cut what would you do with it?

LOL! Other than the tacit admission that buying a Tesla is a waste of money, what is your point? What is the difference to the economy between buying a Tesla and buying five Kia's? What do you suppose happens to the money you put in your 401k - does it fall into a black hole? You really don't understand economics so I suggest you stick with coding. It doesn't matter who spends a dollar, or whether they spend it or they save it (and the bank lends it to someone else to spend). The idea that putting money into investments is somehow bad for the economy is just flat out stupid.
 
Haha! Thanks a million for helping me out with one of the most important points I make around here - that the Democrats' current platform stems from a Marxist mindset. And here we have it folks, an admitted communist using the exact same argument the modern Democrats do to justify their wealth redistribution schemes. Birds of a feather...

Wow ... how do you meet those Democrats?

Seriously, what Democrats used that argument "to justify their wealth redistribution schemes"?
 
LOL! Other than the tacit admission that buying a Tesla is a waste of money, what is your point? What is the difference to the economy between buying a Tesla and buying five Kia's? What do you suppose happens to the money you put in your 401k - does it fall into a black hole? You really don't understand economics so I suggest you stick with coding. It doesn't matter who spends a dollar, or whether they spend it or they save it (and the bank lends it to someone else to spend). The idea that putting money into investments is somehow bad for the economy is just flat out stupid.

There are investments that boost the economy (industry) and investments that store value (e.g., gold and real estate). When industry becomes unprofitable due to irrational competition leading to a glutted market, the financiers flee toward the latter and market signals are sent out for wealth to be destroyed by waste and war.
 
There are investments that boost the economy (industry) and investments that store value (e.g., gold and real estate). When industry becomes unprofitable due to irrational competition leading to a glutted market, the financiers flee toward the latter and market signals are sent out for wealth to be destroyed by waste and war.

You are partially correct. But what drives money into "unproductive" investments isn't the evilness in the capitalist making it, it's the perception that productive investment is being punished by government. You don't need "stimulus" when the government is rewarding productive investment (by reducing taxation/spending and regulation). The best "public investment" is in reducing the size and scope of government.
 
You are partially correct. But what drives money into "unproductive" investments isn't the evilness in the capitalist making it, it's the perception that productive investment is being punished by government. You don't need "stimulus" when the government is rewarding productive investment (by reducing taxation/spending and regulation). The best "public investment" is in reducing the size and scope of government.

The boom-and-bust cycle is a built-in feature of production driven by competition for investment. The general business failure or depression is a periodic occurrence under every state strategy for managing capitalism, especially the laissez-faire strategy. The government can reward productive investment, sometimes more efficiently, by buying the products of industry, or it can, again sometimes more efficiently, allocate those resources itself.
 
One of your funnier assertions, although I'm sure you didn't mean it to be. History reduces your logic to comedy. Your UCLA professors assert that the depression, which by 1933 had produced an official 25% unemployment rate, actually got going because of pro-labor actions by FDR in mid 1933.

World War II had a lot less to do with the depression in the US than you seem to think. Were you thinking Hitler would not have invaded Poland in 1939 if not for FDR?

History, is a bitch:

Hitler's drive for political power began in 1919 when he joined a small party, later known as the Nazis. This party demanded that all Jews be deprived of German citizenship, and that all German-speakers be united into a single country. A brilliant propagandist, organizer, and orator, Hitler gave the Nazi movement a potent symbol: the swastika; raised party membership to 15,000 by 1923; and formed a private army, the storm troopers, to attack his political opponents. In the fall of 1923, Hitler engineered a revolt, the Beer Hall Putsch, to overthrow Germany's five year old republic. The uprising was quickly suppressed; the Nazi party was ordered dissolved, and Hitler was imprisoned for nine months.

While in jail, Hitler wrote a book, Mein Kampf (My Struggle), which laid out his beliefs and vision for Germany. He called on Germans to repudiate the Versailles Treaty ending World War I; rearm; conquer countries with large German populations like Austria and Czechoslovakia; and seize lebensraum (living space) for Germans in Russia.

Following his release from prison, Hitler persuaded the German government to lift its ban on the Nazi party. In 1928, the Nazis polled just 810,000 votes in German elections; however, in 1930 after the Depression began, they polled 6 ½ million votes. Two years later, Hitler ran for president; he lost, but received 13 ½ million votes--37 percent of all votes cast. The Nazis had suddenly become the single largest party in the German parliament. In January 1933, Germany's president named Hitler chancellor. A year and a half later Hitler was Germany's dictator.


http://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtid=2&psid=3484

The German economy was already struggling under the weight of the WWI reparations during the "roaring 20s." Once the depression set in, the strain on the Germans became immeasurable. And the UCLA professors are correct. If FDR hadn't put his anti-capitalist, big government, interventionist agenda smack dab in the way of the economy's natural tendency to recover, the Nazi movement would have either petered out, or at least have been marginalized (by a recovering economy). The Nazis' zeal for war was intensified by the ongoing FDR depression. FDR was only too happy to join them in that endeavor in an effort to keep from going down in history as the economic failure he most definitely was. Like I always say, war is the last refuge of failed Keyensians...
 
OK, but how does unemployment insurance amount to wealth redistribution? You work, you pay the premiums, you become unemployed, you collect the benefits. Wealth redistribution would be taking that away from people to give it to the rich.

Not the "extended benefits" Pelosi was making an argument for.
 
The boom-and-bust cycle is a built-in feature of production driven by competition for investment. The general business failure or depression is a periodic occurrence under every state strategy for managing capitalism, especially the laissez-faire strategy. The government can reward productive investment, sometimes more efficiently, by buying the products of industry, or it can, again sometimes more efficiently, allocate those resources itself.

Precisely! It's the "creative destruction" that keeps an economy vital (and growing). As long, that is, as you allow the markets to clear. When you start government interventions that prevent the markets from clearing, you begin stifling the creative destruction necessary to restart economic growth, and you get what we had in the 1930s and the past decade - economic stagnation. The reason for that is that productive investment is punished by the government propping up zombie companies, or bestowing competitive advantage on crony capitalists (like Elon Musk), or simply running up huge deficits (deferred taxation) that implies tax rates in the future will be higher.
 
History, is a bitch:

Hitler's drive for political power began in 1919 when he joined a small party, later known as the Nazis. This party demanded that all Jews be deprived of German citizenship, and that all German-speakers be united into a single country. A brilliant propagandist, organizer, and orator, Hitler gave the Nazi movement a potent symbol: the swastika; raised party membership to 15,000 by 1923; and formed a private army, the storm troopers, to attack his political opponents. In the fall of 1923, Hitler engineered a revolt, the Beer Hall Putsch, to overthrow Germany's five year old republic. The uprising was quickly suppressed; the Nazi party was ordered dissolved, and Hitler was imprisoned for nine months.

While in jail, Hitler wrote a book, Mein Kampf (My Struggle), which laid out his beliefs and vision for Germany. He called on Germans to repudiate the Versailles Treaty ending World War I; rearm; conquer countries with large German populations like Austria and Czechoslovakia; and seize lebensraum (living space) for Germans in Russia.

Following his release from prison, Hitler persuaded the German government to lift its ban on the Nazi party. In 1928, the Nazis polled just 810,000 votes in German elections; however, in 1930 after the Depression began, they polled 6 ½ million votes. Two years later, Hitler ran for president; he lost, but received 13 ½ million votes--37 percent of all votes cast. The Nazis had suddenly become the single largest party in the German parliament. In January 1933, Germany's president named Hitler chancellor. A year and a half later Hitler was Germany's dictator.


http://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtid=2&psid=3484

The German economy was already struggling under the weight of the WWI reparations during the "roaring 20s." Once the depression set in, the strain on the Germans became immeasurable. And the UCLA professors are correct. If FDR hadn't put his anti-capitalist, big government, interventionist agenda smack dab in the way of the economy's natural tendency to recover, the Nazi movement would have either petered out, or at least have been marginalized (by a recovering economy). The Nazis' zeal for war was intensified by the ongoing FDR depression. FDR was only too happy to join them in that endeavor in an effort to keep from going down in history as the economic failure he most definitely was. Like I always say, war is the last refuge of failed Keyensians...


 

Indeed! The left has always embraced war mongers when it furthers their one world communist government agenda. They did it with Teddy Roosevelt, they did it with Woodrow Wilson, they did it with FDR, LBJ, and on and on and on. The latest example is how they are all slobbering over John McCain, who has never seen a geopolitical situation that he didn't think called for war, simply because he is blocking the Republicans from repealing Obamacare. He is a despicable person who is sticking a shove in his loyal servant's back in the process. Lindsey "light in the loafers" Graham has had a man-crush on McCain for two decades and it appears McCain has manipulated and used him the way Bill Clinton did to Monica Lewinski. And the left applauds them both as heroes of their movement, that is ostensibly based on NOT bullying and abusing the weaker minds among us. It's a real low down dirty movement that will happily throw their own grannies under the bus to move socialism along...
 
History, is a bitch:

Hitler's drive for political power began in 1919 when he joined a small party, later known as the Nazis. This party demanded that all Jews be deprived of German citizenship, and that all German-speakers be united into a single country. A brilliant propagandist, organizer, and orator, Hitler gave the Nazi movement a potent symbol: the swastika; raised party membership to 15,000 by 1923; and formed a private army, the storm troopers, to attack his political opponents. In the fall of 1923, Hitler engineered a revolt, the Beer Hall Putsch, to overthrow Germany's five year old republic. The uprising was quickly suppressed; the Nazi party was ordered dissolved, and Hitler was imprisoned for nine months.

While in jail, Hitler wrote a book, Mein Kampf (My Struggle), which laid out his beliefs and vision for Germany. He called on Germans to repudiate the Versailles Treaty ending World War I; rearm; conquer countries with large German populations like Austria and Czechoslovakia; and seize lebensraum (living space) for Germans in Russia.

Following his release from prison, Hitler persuaded the German government to lift its ban on the Nazi party. In 1928, the Nazis polled just 810,000 votes in German elections; however, in 1930 after the Depression began, they polled 6 ½ million votes. Two years later, Hitler ran for president; he lost, but received 13 ½ million votes--37 percent of all votes cast. The Nazis had suddenly become the single largest party in the German parliament. In January 1933, Germany's president named Hitler chancellor. A year and a half later Hitler was Germany's dictator.


http://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtid=2&psid=3484

The German economy was already struggling under the weight of the WWI reparations during the "roaring 20s." Once the depression set in, the strain on the Germans became immeasurable. And the UCLA professors are correct. If FDR hadn't put his anti-capitalist, big government, interventionist agenda smack dab in the way of the economy's natural tendency to recover, the Nazi movement would have either petered out, or at least have been marginalized (by a recovering economy). The Nazis' zeal for war was intensified by the ongoing FDR depression. FDR was only too happy to join them in that endeavor in an effort to keep from going down in history as the economic failure he most definitely was. Like I always say, war is the last refuge of failed Keyensians...

1. You've proven my point. Hitler gained power before FDR became president.
2. You've failed and failed miserably to make the point that FDR is to blame for anything Hitler did.

Hitler used government spending to bring Germany out of the depression. They were probably the first major nation to recover. The autobahn as well as major weapons programs put people back to work much more quickly than in the US.
 
1. You've proven my point. Hitler gained power before FDR became president.
2. You've failed and failed miserably to make the point that FDR is to blame for anything Hitler did.

Hitler used government spending to bring Germany out of the depression. They were probably the first major nation to recover. The autobahn as well as major weapons programs put people back to work much more quickly than in the US.

When Hitler gained power there was no threat of war ........... Hitler was calling for disarmament and peace.
 
Indeed! The left has always embraced war mongers when it furthers their one world communist government agenda. They did it with Teddy Roosevelt, they did it with Woodrow Wilson, they did it with FDR, LBJ, and on and on and on. The latest example is how they are all slobbering over John McCain, who has never seen a geopolitical situation that he didn't think called for war, simply because he is blocking the Republicans from repealing Obamacare. He is a despicable person who is sticking a shove in his loyal servant's back in the process. Lindsey "light in the loafers" Graham has had a man-crush on McCain for two decades and it appears McCain has manipulated and used him the way Bill Clinton did to Monica Lewinski. And the left applauds them both as heroes of their movement, that is ostensibly based on NOT bullying and abusing the weaker minds among us. It's a real low down dirty movement that will happily throw their own grannies under the bus to move socialism along...

Good job. You are now in the camp of holocaust deniers and Hitler lovers. World War II wasn't Hitler's fault for invading Poland...it was FDR's fault. Dude...you are now one of the weaker minds on PJ. Congratulations.
 
Back
Top