New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Solid jobs report.

Yeah - that's why we have all those PhD baristas...

Do you actually know any? I do not. I suspect that there are FAR FEWER of these than most people think. Such stories, and stories of New York City taxi-drivers with Ph.D. degrees in Astrophysics, are simply apocryphal. In this case, the statistics on unemployment levels by level of education do not lie. Fairsheet did not even give all the statistics. The unemployment rate in America for people with at least a bachelor's degree in a STEM field [STEM = Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics] is less than 2.8%.
 
People seem to sense that, and are reacting accordingly, by educating themselves to ever greater levels, even though it means taking on a gruesome level of debt. I'd like to see the government simultaneously put more money into education, but create incentives for colleges to keep costs down. For example, offer government student loans at the government's own cost of borrowing, but make those loans available only at universities that charge no more than X% more than the median tuition for a college in their bracket, and that have tuition rise no more than Y points above CPI per year. That would mean universities would need to find ways to lower costs, or lose out on a huge chunk of potential students. I suspect the corner cutting would come in areas that US News rewards in their rankings and that prospective freshmen are drawn to, but that have no logical relationship with quality of education (elaborate fitness and dining facilities, manicured campuses, etc.)

The problem is, what they choose to educate themselves as. We don't have many STEM graduates, and lots of law and finance grads.
 
Because there is no "welfare state"

That should come as a surprise to the millions on the various programs that make up our welfare state, from actual welfare, to the food stamp program, to Medicaid, Social Security survivors benefits, etc.

If these are not welfare programs that are part of welfare state operations, what are they?
 
That should come as a surprise to the millions on the various programs that make up our welfare state, from actual welfare, to the food stamp program, to Medicaid, Social Security survivors benefits, etc.

If these are not welfare programs that are part of welfare state operations, what are they?

Just speaking for myself, I have no problem with calling this a 'welfare state', though I prefer the term 'social safety net'. Are you arguing that we should have no social safety net? Are you a social Darwinist? Would you let people starve if they cannot find a job?
 
That should come as a surprise to the millions on the various programs that make up our welfare state, from actual welfare, to the food stamp program, to Medicaid, Social Security survivors benefits, etc.

If these are not welfare programs that are part of welfare state operations, what are they?

What types of things do you believe should be done to promote the general welfare of America and the American people?
 
Do you actually know any? I do not. I suspect that there are FAR FEWER of these than most people think. Such stories, and stories of New York City taxi-drivers with Ph.D. degrees in Astrophysics, are simply apocryphal. In this case, the statistics on unemployment levels by level of education do not lie. Fairsheet did not even give all the statistics. The unemployment rate in America for people with at least a bachelor's degree in a STEM field [STEM = Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics] is less than 2.8%.

"Funny" thing about that 2.8% figure you cite, is that it's probably LESS than optimal. In other words, our wish should be to see that number go to 2.9% (maxing out at around 4%), rather than 2.7%. But..that little problem is easy for us to address...simply by graduating more "STEMs".
 
It means high structural unemployment, growing entitlements and negligible GDP growth.

We don't have high structural unemployment. We have high unemployment based on weak GDP growth, in the wake of a financial meltdown. We're actually recovering from it a bit faster than Europe, and faster than the average trends for post-financial-collapse recoveries historically, around the world. As for the growth of entitlements, that's partly due to the weak GDP growth and partly just due to demographics -- the aging of the Baby Boomer population. Sadly, we didn't prep for the latter eventuality as well as we should have, because the Reagan and Bush tax cuts pissed away so much revenue that the Social Security surplus was diverted from its proper purpose for years. But, notwithstanding their best efforts to bankrupt Social Security, its funding issues remain quite manageable. Just remove the SS tax cap, the same way we removed the Medicare tax cap during the Clinton years.
 
With companies still laying off right and left.....how the hell is the unemployment number going up a "good thing" to the idiot left? The real number is, of course, much, MUCH higher than 7.9%. Obama is a dismal failure.....in every area except the one where he brings America to its' knees.

Unemployment is up, it's a GOOD THING! Wow, admitting that the discouraged coming back to finally look for jobs is a GOOD thing.

There isn't a Democrat in the White House is there?

"Desperado"


Desperado, why don't you come to your senses?
You been out ridin' fences for so long now
Oh, you're a hard one
I know that you got your reasons
These things that are pleasin' you
Can hurt you somehow
 
With companies still laying off right and left.....how the hell is the unemployment number going up a "good thing" to the idiot left? The real number is, of course, much, MUCH higher than 7.9%. Obama is a dismal failure.....in every area except the one where he brings America to its' knees.

Lapcat, you've confronted Dino with an interesting question...but I'm not sure he'd appreciate your assigning him to "the idiot left".
 
With companies still laying off right and left.....how the hell is the unemployment number going up a "good thing" to the idiot left? The real number is, of course, much, MUCH higher than 7.9%. Obama is a dismal failure.....in every area except the one where he brings America to its' knees.

More companies are hiring than are laying off, obviously. That is why we have had 29 consecutive months of private sector job creation. [Unless, of course, you are one of the whacked-out conspiracy theorists claiming that the Bureau of Labor Statistics is LYING about all this.] Consumer confidence is at its highest level in almost five years. Smart businessfolk know that means consumers will be more willing to spend money, and so are expecting the level of demand for their products to be rising. Meaning they will need to hire more workers. And home prices are now rising again, which helps to explain why consumers are becoming more confident.

Try to keep up with the business news, will you? Most good daily newspapers have a 'Business Section'. Try starting there.
 
I heard a fascinating coupla factoids this morning.

-Unemployment among people 25-years or older and holding college degrees, is at 3.9% (effective zero)

-Unemployment among people lacking high school diplomas, is at 12.2%


These factoids seem to offer us a pretty godamned obvious blueprint.

People seem to sense that, and are reacting accordingly, by educating themselves to ever greater levels, even though it means taking on a gruesome level of debt. I'd like to see the government simultaneously put more money into education, but create incentives for colleges to keep costs down. For example, offer government student loans at the government's own cost of borrowing, but make those loans available only at universities that charge no more than X% more than the median tuition for a college in their bracket, and that have tuition rise no more than Y points above CPI per year. That would mean universities would need to find ways to lower costs, or lose out on a huge chunk of potential students. I suspect the corner cutting would come in areas that US News rewards in their rankings and that prospective freshmen are drawn to, but that have no logical relationship with quality of education (elaborate fitness and dining facilities, manicured campuses, etc.)
 
One of my bigger concerns - with ALL due respect for my man, Leroy - is that we risk tipping too far in the direction of the STEM subjects. I'm definitely not suggesting that the student who chooses to major in "Ancient Philosphies of Babylonian Basketweaving", has some sort of God-given "right" to a wonderous, lucrative, and life-long career in her field. But, if those sorts of fields become no longer viable, we'll all be the poorer for it.

I had a global economics professor who was E. Indian. Someone asked him to comment on what's wrong with we Americans? Only 15% of American college students are in STEM-type programs but in India, 95% are?

The E. Indian dude raised to important points. First, we Americans have way more Universities and University students, than the Indians do. SO...in gross numbers, our 15% is actually equal to their 95%. But perhaps more importantly, he said the reason 95% of Indians are in the STEM programs, is because in India, those are the only fields in which they can expect to find employment. Here in the U.S. we have may more, and may more varied opportunities. We don't want to lose that.
 
We don't have high structural unemployment. We have high unemployment based on weak GDP growth, in the wake of a financial meltdown. We're actually recovering from it a bit faster than Europe, and faster than the average trends for post-financial-collapse recoveries historically, around the world. As for the growth of entitlements, that's partly due to the weak GDP growth and partly just due to demographics -- the aging of the Baby Boomer population. Sadly, we didn't prep for the latter eventuality as well as we should have, because the Reagan and Bush tax cuts pissed away so much revenue that the Social Security surplus was diverted from its proper purpose for years. But, notwithstanding their best efforts to bankrupt Social Security, its funding issues remain quite manageable. Just remove the SS tax cap, the same way we removed the Medicare tax cap during the Clinton years.

Okay, we have high unemployment based on structural weak economic growth (if that sounds better to you). The "financial meltdown" is over. Banks are flush with lendable cash but there's no economic growth to finance. We're recovering faster than Europe because they are further down the road to socialist ruin than we are but Obama is trying his best to catch us up. This excuse making is absurd. Obamunism is the worst economic policy we've had in my lifetime. Tax tax tax, spend spend spend. We'll be growing slower than Europe in no time...
 
One of my bigger concerns - with ALL due respect for my man, Leroy - is that we risk tipping too far in the direction of the STEM subjects. I'm definitely not suggesting that the student who chooses to major in "Ancient Philosphies of Babylonian Basketweaving", has some sort of God-given "right" to a wonderous, lucrative, and life-long career in her field. But, if those sorts of fields become no longer viable, we'll all be the poorer for it.

I had a global economics professor who was E. Indian. Someone asked him to comment on what's wrong with we Americans? Only 15% of American college students are in STEM-type programs but in India, 95% are?

The E. Indian dude raised to important points. First, we Americans have way more Universities and University students, than the Indians do. SO...in gross numbers, our 15% is actually equal to their 95%. But perhaps more importantly, he said the reason 95% of Indians are in the STEM programs, is because in India, those are the only fields in which they can expect to find employment. Here in the U.S. we have may more, and may more varied opportunities. We don't want to lose that.

I certainly believe in a well-rounded education. I worry about engineers and scientists who know nothing of the humanities. [On the other hand, I worry even more about people who are well-educated in the humanities but know nothing of math and science.] Our school excels in math and science, yes, but we are not a math-and-science school. If anything, there is a false and pernicious stereotype of our school that we FOCUS on art, music, history, and literature.

But, in terms of sheer numbers, absolute numbers, China is graduating ten times as many engineers and scientists as we are, each and every year. Now, you can make an argument that the QUALITY of their engineers and scientists is not up to our standards, but.....the hand-writing is on the wall. China will become the dominant scientific and technological nation in the world, by mid-century, unless we do something to arrest this trend. I think we do indeed need a massive Sputnik shock.
 
Okay, we have high unemployment based on structural weak economic growth (if that sounds better to you). The "financial meltdown" is over. Banks are flush with lendable cash but there's no economic growth to finance. We're recovering faster than Europe because they are further down the road to socialist ruin than we are but Obama is trying his best to catch us up. This excuse making is absurd. Obamunism is the worst economic policy we've had in my lifetime. Tax tax tax, spend spend spend. We'll be growing slower than Europe in no time...

We are recovering faster than Europe because most of the European nations dangerously chose the path of austerity. And as for your 'tax, tax, tax, spend spend spend' comment, our overall level of taxation is the lowest it has been since the early 1950s. Uh, that's why we have such large budget deficits, Lukey.
 
We are recovering faster than Europe because most of the European nations dangerously chose the path of austerity. And as for your 'tax, tax, tax, spend spend spend' comment, our overall level of taxation is the lowest it has been since the early 1950s. Uh, that's why we have such large budget deficits, Lukey.

They have no choice! They have run out of other people's money. We can't tax enough to pay for all this spending. This economic policy you endorse is insane!
 
Back
Top