New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Support for redistribution?

I blame the majority of the "dumbing down of education" on No Child Left Behind. My daughter was in grade school when this legislation was implemented and my son had not yet started grade school. I watched the requirements and expectations of the students slowly diminish...when my son started school, there was an accelerated program for the smarter kids, of which my son was a member. The "gifted" program quickly disappeared and those smarter kids were put back into classrooms where the pace of study was slowed at a tremendous rate so that the slower learners could achieve the grades necessary for the schools to receive funding....the result; the average student was dragged down to below average and the above average students were dragged down to average.
 
Well, I actually AGREE.

Wow. Did the Earth just suddenly stop rotating for a second, there?

But the problems in the American educational system go much further back in time than the No Child Left A Dime Act.
 
In some classes, yes, GPAs are merit based and objective...however, that is not so when you take classes with solid right and wrong answers...tell me, how can history, math, science, or anatomy classes, for example, be objective? The answer is right or it is wrong...there is no in between. If you went to a university that made those grades and answers objective, you went to a pathetic university.
 
How was Paris Hilton "lucky"? She inherited the fortune her family built. That has nothing to do with luck...unless you are saying there was a way that Paris Hilton could have been born into another family.
 
Nope...the earth didn't stop rotating...I don't ascribe to a party line...I call a spade a spade. If you've never met a conservative that calls out wrongs on both sides...that's unfortunate for you.
 
Well, not when it effects them directly. Most of these 4.0 GPA students support raising taxes on the top 10%, but view it as different when asked to give some of their GPA points to the students with lower GPAs. Which leads to the question...is it different and if so, why?

[video=youtube;lOyaJ2UI7Ss]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOyaJ2UI7Ss[/video]


Hmm, I remember those young republicans who were all for the Iraq war, but no way would they actually go serve in it.
As far as they were concerned, others had to go serve, not them. So why would you be surprised when the right set that example during the BushCo days?
 
Nope...the earth didn't stop rotating...I don't ascribe to a party line...I call a spade a spade. If you've never met a conservative that calls out wrongs on both sides...that's unfortunate for you.

Well I've never met one here in PJ.

The real world, yes I have met a few, in PJ, nope not a single one.
 
Uh, I think you are confusing the two words 'objective' and 'subjective'. Math quiz scores can be very OBJECTIVE. As you say, the answer is either right or wrong. A grade on an essay on 'the meaning of life' is going to be at least somewhat SUBJECTIVE; the views of the grader may make it hard to grade such an essay OBJECTIVELY.
 
By definition, you are lucky to be born into the aristocratic class. If you inherit a billion dollars, you are LUCKY, just as you would be lucky to win a half-billion dollar Powerball lottery.
 
In some classes, yes, GPAs are merit based and objective...however, that is not so when you take classes with solid right and wrong answers...tell me, how can history, math, science, or anatomy classes, for example, be objective? The answer is right or it is wrong...there is no in between. If you went to a university that made those grades and answers objective, you went to a pathetic university.

There are no such things as essays in physics or anatomy?

"learning" doesn't really melt your eyeballs like maw said k?

Thx
 
The same sorts of decisions have been made at the state and local level for years. I was in gifted and honor classes for most of my time in school, after several years at a subpar parochial school. In 1982, we started the school year with a classroom full of supplemental material obtained by the teacher; she had also placed most of us on the level 15 reading textbook, though several of us were well past it. Before the first month had passed, all of the supplemental material was gone, and we were forbidden from using anything higher than the level 13 reading textbook. This was due entirely to decisions made by the state and local school boards.
 
Uh, I think you are confusing the two words 'objective' and 'subjective'. Math quiz scores can be very OBJECTIVE. As you say, the answer is either right or wrong. A grade on an essay on 'the meaning of life' is going to be at least somewhat SUBJECTIVE; the views of the grader may make it hard to grade such an essay OBJECTIVELY.

He is confusing the two...
 
First a question.

Is it possible to have a GPA greater than 4.0 ?

If not then the redistribution of income vs grade point average are not compatible measurements and the premise is flawed.
 
Spamature: Is it possible to have a GPA greater than 4.0?

LeRoy: Actually, yes, it is. I often hear of high school valedictorians with a GPA of, say, 4.235. The reason is because many high schools have adopted the practice of giving 'extra' GPA points for AP-level courses, which are, for all practical purposes, college-level courses. Indeed, most of the students who take AP classes take an AP test at the end of the school year. and if they get a passing score, can get college credit for those courses. AP tests are always graded on a five-point scale; you get a score of 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5. [No scores of 0.] A score of 3 or above is considered passing, though some colleges will only accept higher scores. [There are a few colleges, such as the service academies and some of the Ivy League schools, who don't accept AP scores at all.]

There is a reasonable justification for adjusting GPA's upward for taking these tougher college-level courses. If you didn't do that, students would have an incentive to load up on easy courses, to maximize their GPA, and a much smaller number of students would be signing up for AP courses.
 
Obviously, you haven't read many of my posts. I've displayed my animus regarding Bush, Boehner, Cheney, ect. many times on PJ
 
Inheriting fortunes built by your family is not lucky...winning a lottery is. There's a difference. When my kids inherit what I will leave them, they are by no means lucky, because luck had nothing to do with the money I made and the wisdom of my investment decisions and, luck had nothing to do with them becoming my children.
 
Bull. I wrote essays in some of my physics classes...don't know if they are required in anatomy or not...never took the class.

Regarding "learning"...What's your degree in? And, how many do you have?
 
Back
Top