New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Surreal....

No it did not. F&F involved Dealers selling to Strawman buyers who then sold to the smugglers. The problem was that the Strawman to Smuggler sale interdiction got screwed up.

The key word there is "dealers."

The way it is done in NY State - all private sales must be transacted THROUGH a registered broker (ie dealer). The dealers are required to do this for a nominal transaction fee and as part of it they are required to run background checks and register the transaction.

And the way to best enforce it is nationwide. Then the transaction gets registered and any gun that is used in a crime that did not go through a registered transaction and is not reported as stolen, means the seller gets hit with a felony gun selling charge.

So, at least you're showing the true colors. The goals is not better background checks or putting more liability on gun owners, the goal is gun registration.
 
No worries - we have truly draconian penalties for failure to comply with the law.

It's true that some lawbreaking gun nuts will still ignore the law, so we make them responsible for any murders, etc., caused by their guns.

Criminals will ignore the law, but that's beside the point. I sell you a gun -- we do the background check (currently not available to non-dealers), you give me the 4473, and I keep it. Then you go commit a murder with the gun.

How does the government know where you got it?
 
We already have a similar system for cars in place. VINs have basically eliminated the market for stolen cars. Stolen cars are now broken up in chop shops but not resold as whole. And that has reduced the market for stolen cars quite significantly. Do cars still get stolen? Sure, but more for joy rides and spur of the moment crimes. Same would apply to guns. But since guns would tend to be locked up in gun safes, that opportunistic theft thing would not happen.
 
Gun registration is necessary as part of making this work. Gun registration is not an Am 2 infringement.
 
Criminals will ignore the law, but that's beside the point. I sell you a gun -- we do the background check (currently not available to non-dealers), you give me the 4473, and I keep it. Then you go commit a murder with the gun.

How does the government know where you got it?

The background check should record the sale.

There are solutions to all the "problems" you concoct. You just don't like the solutions. You should just say that instead of pretending there are any such insurmountable problems.
 
The background check should record the sale.

There are solutions to all the "problems" you concoct. You just don't like the solutions. You should just say that instead of pretending there are any such insurmountable problems.

Under current U.S. law, the NICS system is banned from being used to create a registry. But notice how quick we've moved from "better background check" to "gun registration."

I for one will not support registration.
 
Gun registration is necessary as part of making this work. Gun registration is not an Am 2 infringement.

I disagree, but even if gun registration is not a 2nd Amendment violation, it is both currently illegal and a political non-starter.

Above you write, "We already have a similar system for cars in place. VINs have basically eliminated the market for stolen cars. Stolen cars are now broken up in chop shops but not resold as whole" which isn't true. There is a thriving market in the theft of whole cars for export. Further, there is a largish difference between the registration of a car and the registration of guns -- no one wants to ban my ownership of a car. I can provide you with the names of numerous legislators who want to ban either all of my gun collection or parts of it.
 
Under current U.S. law, the NICS system is banned from being used to create a registry. But notice how quick we've moved from "better background check" to "gun registration."

I for one will not support registration.

You either want solutions or you don't.

You clearly don't.
 
You either want solutions or you don't.

You clearly don't.

I don't want a "solution" that involves registration, because I regard registration as an incremental move toward a ban. Remember, when we started looking at "reasonable" gun laws, we were just talking about improving background checks -- but that increment wasn't enough and we had to go to registration. When registration isn't enough, what will we do?
 
I don't want a "solution" that involves registration, because I regard registration as an incremental move toward a ban. Remember, when we started looking at "reasonable" gun laws, we were just talking about improving background checks -- but that increment wasn't enough and we had to go to registration. When registration isn't enough, what will we do?

Until paranoid gun nuts get over this delusion about the government taking all their guns, the nation will remain screwed and the slaughters will continue uinabated.

People will die, and their loved ones will be shattered, because people like you have an irrational fear of registration and other reasonable gun laws.
 
Until paranoid gun nuts get over this delusion about the government taking all their guns, the nation will remain screwed and the slaughters will continue uinabated.

I'm not being delusional -- I can point to serving legislators who desire precisely that, in both houses of Congress. I'll fight every increment, because I've seen it play out in other countries. Each increment is just another increment toward a ban.

And you didn't answer the question -- what do we do when the registration you desire is in place, and there's another massacre? Holmes, the Aurora murderer, would have passed any background check, and could easily have registred his guns. So we have registration and there's another Holmes and another Aurora. What happens then? Will "it was registered, and we can't impinge further on gun owners" be on your lips?
 
I'm not being delusional -- I can point to serving legislators who desire precisely that, in both houses of Congress. I'll fight every increment, because I've seen it play out in other countries. Each increment is just another increment toward a ban.

And you didn't answer the question -- what do we do when the registration you desire is in place, and there's another massacre? Holmes, the Aurora murderer, would have passed any background check, and could easily have registred his guns. So we have registration and there's another Holmes and another Aurora. What happens then? Will "it was registered, and we can't impinge further on gun owners" be on your lips?

There is NO chance that the government is going to confiscate all guns. None. You really should shake off the brainwashing that convinced you to the contrary.

And no one contends that gun control laws will completely end all gun carnage. There are simply too many guns in our society. The objective is to reduce the massacres.

And it's absurd to say Holmes would have passed any competent background check. He was a raging schizophrenic who was kicked out of school he was so ill.
 
I'm not being delusional -- I can point to serving legislators who desire precisely that, in both houses of Congress. I'll fight every increment, because I've seen it play out in other countries. Each increment is just another increment toward a ban.

And you didn't answer the question -- what do we do when the registration you desire is in place, and there's another massacre? Holmes, the Aurora murderer, would have passed any background check, and could easily have registred his guns. So we have registration and there's another Holmes and another Aurora. What happens then? Will "it was registered, and we can't impinge further on gun owners" be on your lips?

James Holmes was under psychiatric treatment for several months prior to the massacre. It is not clear to me that he "would have passed any background check". If his psychiatrist had known of the arsenal that he was assembling, I would at least LIKE to think that several red flags would have gone up.
 
James Holmes was under psychiatric treatment for several months prior to the massacre. It is not clear to me that he "would have passed any background check". If his psychiatrist had known of the arsenal that he was assembling, I would at least LIKE to think that several red flags would have gone up.

Gun nuts can't accept such delays when buying their guns. They view the slaughter of little kids and others as the price worth paying for unrestricted guns. Of course, they would view it differently if their kids and loved ones were slaughtered, but they don't know the victims, so their basic attitude is "Screw 'em. I want my guns and I want them now!"
 
This is all political theater. If they were serious about gun control, they'd draft a constitutional amendment.

Can you imagine some president a century ago asking his vice president to "convene a task force" to grant women the right vote through extra-judicial means?
 
Um....put an end to it? Uh....well....yeah. AFTER they got caught and exposed! LOL!

Fast and Furious was an asinine program, just like the similar program under GWB.

That's why Holder and Obama put an end to it.

Any chance you can move on to a discussion of current events where there is actual disagreement?
 
Um....put an end to it? Uh....well....yeah. AFTER they got caught and exposed! LOL!

ATF had some loony ideas, Fast and Furious being one of them (along with the similar "gunwalking" program under GWB).

Obama and Holder didn't get "caught" as to programs that were not their doing. They disocovered them and ended them. Leading Pugs to screech like banshees.
 
This is all political theater. If they were serious about gun control, they'd draft a constitutional amendment.

Can you imagine some president a century ago asking his vice president to "convene a task force" to grant women the right vote through extra-judicial means?

Sure, sane people could draft a constitutional amendment designed to repeal or limit the 2nd Amendment, but sane people know it would never pass, and would therefore be a waste of time.

We leave such wasting of time to the Pugs, as with the 34th Republican bill in Congress calling for the repeal of "Obamacare."

:lol:
 
And the USAtty said there was insufficient evidence.

And who does that US Attorney work for?
 
Back
Top