New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Surreal....

No -- I am attempting to have a reasonable discussion of how we can address your safety concerns while addressing the rights of gun owners. These need not be mutually exclusive. So I say again, what compromise do you offer gun owners?

First, that's an absurdly broad question.

Second, there's little point in discussing policy with an indecisive person who waffles.
 
In that case, my decision is made. I don't want ANY new gun laws. Since we can't reach a reasonable compromise that guarantees my future rights, I stand against any new law. Decisive enough for you?
 
your future rights are not impinged in any way by a universal registration law and the closing of private sales loophole
 
your future rights are not impinged in any way by a universal registration law and the closing of private sales loophole

Well, I disagree, but registration is the first increment necessary toward banning, say, handguns, and taking just those away (since they serve "no sporting purpose" even though my brother has killed four deer with a handgun). As gun owners, we have learned that we cannnot trust our political opponents, Degs. I'd be happy to register my guns, if I though I could get a guarantee that registration is all that would ever be required. I can't get that, and feel compelled to fight every increment on those grounds if no others.
 
You are the one who for two years has argued that registration and licensing for the building of bombs, and large caliber artillery is not an infringement of the 2nd Amendment's permission of keeping and bearing these weapons. Furthermore Registration has no direct link to banning. As a result it is not an infringement since it does not limit your ability to keep and bear. Just because your brother has used a handgun to kill deer does not meant that is a utile argument. Many deer are killed by cars. That does not make cars utile in hunting deer. You are engaged in the logical fallacy of post hoc reasoning. That your brother used a handgun doesn't mean that's a handgun's utility. He could have used grenades made of Sarin. And yet Sarin is not only registered but licensed in a very limited manner for mfg and possession. Yet it still is an "arm".... bottom line, you are the one who has argued literally for years - that licensing is not an infringement, much less registration. You don't get to pick both sides of the fence
 
You are the one who for two years has argued that registration and licensing for the building of bombs, and large caliber artillery is not an infringement of the 2nd Amendment's permission of keeping and bearing these weapons. Furthermore Registration has no direct link to banning
.

That's simply laughable. Can you show me any juridisdiction in the world that has ever required registration without the registration being followed by the banning either all firearms or a class of firearms? Registration has to come first, so that the firearms can be located, and then banning can procede.

As a result it is not an infringement since it does not limit your ability to keep and bear. Just because your brother has used a handgun to kill deer does not meant that is a utile argument. Many deer are killed by cars. That does not make cars utile in hunting deer.

Yet that is precisely what my brother's Ruger .44 Magnum Blackhawk Hunter is designed for (as is a more standard .44 Magnum Blackhawk that I own). But they'd be lumped into a handgun ban all the same.

Yet it still is an "arm".... bottom line, you are the one who has argued literally for years - that licensing is not an infringement, much less registration. You don't get to pick both sides of the fence

I agree, it's not an infringement nor have I called it one here. I'm still opposed for the reasons already stated. It's the first stepping stone toward an infringement. I can name a city senator who wants "Mr. and Mrs. North America" to "send them all in." Why should I, as a gun owner, vote to make it easier for her?
 
That isn't what happened last time, Degs. Last time the GOP took over the House for the first time in 50 years.
What "last time"? The actual "last time" Conservatives
  • Lost the White House despite persistent high unemployment
  • lost Seats in the House
  • Lost Seats in the Senate
If you are referring to the last Off Year elections, that was a combination of a PR mistake on Obama's part that he has acknowledged and is showing every sign of having learned very well, and a "throw the bums out" protest vote. Meanwhile Currently the GOP Congress has worse numbers than Used Car Salesmen and Head Lice . The GOP is less popular than it was during the Clinton Impeachment http://thehill.com/blogs/blog-brief...unpopular-now-than-during-clinton-impeachment So I just don't see the equivilence

It doesn't matter if you think hunting is a utility or not. It matters if hunters think that it useful.
Nope. It only matters if a "Rational basis" can be demonstrated for the utility of hunting. If you cannot show a rational basis, then you have no leg to stand on to claim it as legal fact.... as for an Olympic target pistol - its a tool to practice the skill of killing at a distance. The "sportsmanship" aspect of it is rather silly and not protected by the 2nd amendment.
OK, now I remember the CA injuries -- and you have provided your own answer. The gun was roughly handled -- it fired because of incorrect human handling, not by itself. Guns don't fire spontaneously.
rough handling can always happen. It was not "incorrectly" handled. it was just handled without specific care. Now if it wasn't "inherently dangerous" then such "specific care" would not be necessary after all, the books inside that backpack were just as roughly handled and somehow posed on potential harm to the other classmantes. That you continue to argue that guns are not inherently dangerous while at the same time claiming they need special care in handling is about as oxymoronic as it gets.
 
Again whether or not other jurisdictions he banned firearms after requiring registration (btw Canada requires registration but has no general ban) is irrelevant to whether or not registration is an infringement. That totalitiarian regimes have used arrest warrants as they wish to does not make the USA's warrant process totalitarian or Unconstitutional. Its laughable to pretend something is what it is not. Now as to whether or not your brother's handgun was "designed for hunting" is irrelevant. The primary utility of that handgun is killing. period.
I agree, it's not an infringement nor have I called it one here.
Sure you did. at the start of the post. Because if it is not an infringement, you have no basis for objecting other than paranoia.
 
[
QUOTE=degsme;624169]What "last time"? The actual "last time" Conservatives
[*]Lost the White House despite persistent high unemployment
[*]lost Seats in the House
[*]Lost Seats in the Senate

I was referring to what happened after the passage of the Clinton-era assault weapons ban. I don't know what you'rre talking about.


Nope. It only matters if a "Rational basis" can be demonstrated for the utility of hunting. If you cannot show a rational basis, then you have no leg to stand on to claim it as legal fact.... as for an Olympic target pistol - its a tool to practice the skill of killing at a distance.

Can I go to the market and buy venison? Why, no I cannot. There's a rational basis for me to hunt deer, then. Ditto rabbit and a host of other game animals. And no, an Olympic pistol is not "to practice killing at a distance." It would be unsuitable for that role. It has one, and only one, function, to shoot targets as a small distance. It's useless for anything else.

The "sportsmanship" aspect of it is rather silly and not protected by the 2nd amendment. rough handling can always happen. It was not "incorrectly" handled. it was just handled without specific care.

Degs -- if it fired and hit something other than an intended target, it was incorrectly handled. Further "rough handling" will not set off a modern firearm. Without knowing more detail of the firearm in this case, I can't respond, but firearms don't just "go off." What you're describing is a human error that led to someone being wounded.
 
Again whether or not other jurisdictions he banned firearms after requiring registration (btw Canada requires registration but has no general ban) is irrelevant to whether or not registration is an infringement.

Canada first registered semiautos, and then banned them, except for M-1 Garands, the U.S. arm used during WWII, which has a fixed magazine and loads via an 8-round en bloc clip (look it up), and the owners of those were "guaranteed" they would never lose their ownership, although they were restricted to keeping them only at ranges where they could be used for competition. Then the government changed its mind, and those too were banned and confiscated. Canada banned pistols so extensively that one family, descended from one of Custer's surviving officers at the Little Big Horn, was forced to sell one of that officer's pistols that had been in the family for more than a century (it went to someone here in the U.S., via auction). If you hold up Canada as an example, you're providing a perfect example of why I will always oppose registration.

Now as to whether or not your brother's handgun was "designed for hunting" is irrelevant.

Then so is the fact that an AR-15 is "designed for combat" the sole difference being that the latter statement is untrue.

Because if it is not an infringement, you have no basis for objecting other than paranoia.

It is not paranoia to believe that people who have said they want to ban guns are people who have a desire to ban guns.
 
Yup but other firearms are not banned. And the AR 15 is designed for killing as well. both are designed for killing - yes and Its paranoia to believe that The Constitution won't apply to any future laws.
 
Yup but other firearms are not banned. And the AR 15 is designed for killing as well. both are designed for killing - yes and Its paranoia to believe that The Constitution won't apply to any future laws.

Degs, you just made my case for me. I asked you to describe a jurisdiction in which registration had not led to a ban on firearms or a ban on a class of firearms. Effectively, in saying Canada is good because "other firearms are not banned" you're saying banning a class of firearms is OK (in Canada's case it is essentially all semi-autos and most handguns). I disagree, and Canada does not make your case that registration does not lead to confiscation -- Canada registered, and then confiscated.


As for paranoia, n this forum people have said, to me, that the current interpretation of the Constitution is wrong and, to paraphrase, that "all we need is for one of the damn conservatives on SCOTUS to die so Obama can put someone sensible on and we can have real gun control." And if that happens, which guns would be easiest to eliminate -- registered guns or unregistered guns?
 
Yup... some may believe that. And sensible gun control could pass muster of a non-ideological gun fethisist court. You would not lose your rights. You might have a reduced access to some hobbies.
 
Yup... some may believe that. And sensible gun control could pass muster of a non-ideological gun fethisist court. You would not lose your rights. You might have a reduced access to some hobbies.

Ownership of firearms is not a hobby, Degs, it is a right. And you have yet to do what I asked -- show me a jurisdiction in which registration was put in place and confiscation did not follow.
 
Ownership of firearms is not a hobby, Degs, it is a right. And you have yet to do what I asked -- show me a jurisdiction in which registration was put in place and confiscation did not follow.

Does the United States count?

Yet we’ve also always had gun control. The Founding Fathers instituted gun laws so intrusive that, were they running for office today, the NRA would not endorse them. While they did not care to completely disarm the citizenry, the founding generation denied gun ownership to many people: not only slaves and free blacks, but law-abiding white men who refused to swear loyalty to the Revolution.


For those men who were allowed to own guns, the Founders had their own version of the “individual mandate” that has proved so controversial in President Obama’s health-care-reform law: they required the purchase of guns. A 1792 federal law mandated every eligible man to purchase a military-style gun and ammunition for his service in the citizen militia. Such men had to report for frequent musters—where their guns would be inspected and, yes, registered on public rolls.

http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2011/09/the-secret-history-of-guns/308608/



The problem for gun rights advocates is that, if you look at the language and custom at the time the Second Amendment was written, laws like the Militia Act of 1792 pop up. It required men between the ages of 18 and 45 to register themselves for militia service, and specified they have certain weapons such as a "good rifle." Similarly, a report from Philadelphia in 1823 showed that there were 12,678 rifles in private hands, indicating some records of who owned what.

"Systems akin to registration were quite common at the time of the framing of the Constitution and the time of the ratification of the Bill of Rights," says Dennis Henigan, vice president for law and policy at the Brady Campaign and author of the new book Lethal Logic. "Even before that the state militia statutes had the same kind of requirements, so they can track how well the militia was armed."


http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504383_162-5258192-504383.html
 
Does the United States count?

The United States has never required national registration, which is what Degs and I were discussing.



For those men who were allowed to own guns, the Founders had their own version of the “individual mandate” that has proved so controversial in President Obama’s health-care-reform law: they required the purchase of guns. A 1792 federal law mandated every eligible man to purchase a military-style gun and ammunition for his service in the citizen militia. Such men had to report for frequent musters—where their guns would be inspected and, yes, registered on public rolls.

Yes, that was a provision of the Militia Act of 1792. You really see it as a gun control law? If so, I'm fine with it -- force me to buy and M-4 Carbine, the current weapon of U.S. forces, and I'll buy one (but it entails allowing me to have a legally owned fully-automatic weapon). But no, the Militia Act of 1792 did not require musters. That


The problem for gun rights advocates is that, if you look at the language and custom at the time the Second Amendment was written, laws like the Militia Act of 1792 pop up.

The problem for anti-gun advocates is that these laws requried the individual to own firearms, because the militia was seen as no different from the armed populace.

"Systems akin to registration were quite common at the time of the framing of the Constitution and the time of the ratification of the Bill of Rights," says Dennis Henigan, vice president for law and policy at the Brady Campaign and author of the new book Lethal Logic. "Even before that the state militia statutes had the same kind of requirements, so they can track how well the militia was armed."

These "registrations" were again, not at the national level. I think you have to remember also that the 13th Amendment would not be passed for another 89 years, and that the provisions of the Bill of Rights generally did not apply at the state level. Many of the states of the period had established churches, just for example. The federal government could not act to register or ban firearms (because of the 2nd Amendment), but the states could have done so. The states could also exercise prior restraint on newspapers, conduct searches and seizures without warrants, etc. If you want to return to that states-rights model, you'd be in the minority among those who otherwise favor stronger gun controls.
 
The United States has never required national registration, which is what Degs and I were discussing.





Yes, that was a provision of the Militia Act of 1792. You really see it as a gun control law? If so, I'm fine with it -- force me to buy and M-4 Carbine, the current weapon of U.S. forces, and I'll buy one (but it entails allowing me to have a legally owned fully-automatic weapon). But no, the Militia Act of 1792 did not require musters. That




The problem for anti-gun advocates is that these laws requried the individual to own firearms, because the militia was seen as no different from the armed populace.



These "registrations" were again, not at the national level. I think you have to remember also that the 13th Amendment would not be passed for another 89 years, and that the provisions of the Bill of Rights generally did not apply at the state level. Many of the states of the period had established churches, just for example. The federal government could not act to register or ban firearms (because of the 2nd Amendment), but the states could have done so. The states could also exercise prior restraint on newspapers, conduct searches and seizures without warrants, etc. If you want to return to that states-rights model, you'd be in the minority among those who otherwise favor stronger gun controls.

The US, according to these articles, required gun registration and that did not end up with gun confiscation. That was your contention...and it has been proven false.

show me a jurisdiction in which registration was put in place and confiscation did not follow.

States are jurisdictions; even if the states administered the program, guns were registered, and were not confiscated.
 
The US, according to these articles, required gun registration and that did not end up with gun confiscation. That was your contention...and it has been proven false.

show me a jurisdiction in which registration was put in place and confiscation did not follow.

States are jurisdictions; even if the states administered the program, guns were registered, and were not confiscated.

The militia act of 1792 didn't require registration. It required purchase. Proof of purchase, and proof that the law was not violated, was handled by state-level militia organizations, not via a federal registry.
 
The militia act of 1792 didn't require registration. It required purchase. Proof of purchase, and proof that the law was not violated, was handled by state-level militia organizations, not via a federal registry.

I find information that says registration was required. Arms were often held in arsenals...and as the articles state...musters were frequent...inspection and registration common. The reason was to know who was ready to fight...
 
I find information that says registration was required. Arms were often held in arsenals...and as the articles state...musters were frequent...inspection and registration common. The reason was to know who was ready to fight...

Arms held in Arsenals were not provided by individuals, but by the states. My knowledge in this area is pretty extensive, and musters were frequent -- in some states. Others were very lax, and it was this laxity that ultimately led to the law's repeal (well, modification, we still have a militia act in force today -- you are probably a member of the militia although you may not be aware of that fact).

But for all of these circumstances the key thing you are either missing or ignoring is that there was no registry at the federal level. There was, at the state level, no registry of other arms. An individual might own a rifle, a shotgun and a musket -- and only the last would have been on the militia rolls, if in fact the local militia kept such a record.
 
Back
Top