New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SYG

SYG needs to be dumped. it's an insane and immoral law pushed by ALEC/NRA/GOP for no other reason than to increase paranoia so more folks will BUY guns.

we need to start suing concealed carriers for threatening our safety in the public domain. I can keep your gun out of my home and I should be able to be protected from your gun in public.
Just because I'm curious, how would you go about suing someone for carrying a concealed weapon?
 
Here is the SYG law. It cancels out manslaughter in terms of only looking at the fight or the moment you say you were in fear of your life and that is how it is applied in courts here. by people lodging therein at night.

A couple of questions Minnie...

Before the so-called SYG law -- a title you inserted and bolded which is a lie, it is correctly called Justifiable Use of Force as it was before -- anyway, before the Justifiable Use of Force law was revised there was also a law defining manslaughter, correct?

In paragraph 3), the revision you underlined, can you tell us where it cancels out what has been the law for decades if not a century or more?

Enough of this silliness....
 
Last edited:
Just because I'm curious, how would you go about suing someone for carrying a concealed weapon?

following an incident or threat of an incident, an accident where the gun went off, an actual gun fight, etc. in a public area.

I should enjoy the same privilege as a citizen in public to be protected from gun toters......as the Supreme Court is protected in banning guns on their premises.
 
so dems and cons alike are deranged gun nuts?

(careful, you may shatter the prevailing narrative....)

I don't think legislators who are beholden to the NRA solely for the $$ or fear of negative ads.......are necessarily gun nuts, but they sure don't deserve our respect.
 
following an incident or threat of an incident, an accident where the gun went off, an actual gun fight, etc. in a public area.

I should enjoy the same privilege as a citizen in public to be protected from gun toters......as the Supreme Court is protected in banning guns on their premises.

Can I sue you for attempting to deprive me of my civil right to bear arms? And also for any crime that occurs which could have been prevented by the victim being armed? And for invading my privacy? How would you know I was carrying without looking under my clothing? I should sue you for the right to look under your clothing, if that's the case.....:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
following an incident or threat of an incident, an accident where the gun went off, an actual gun fight, etc. in a public area.

I should enjoy the same privilege as a citizen in public to be protected from gun toters......as the Supreme Court is protected in banning guns on their premises.

You do realize how ridiculous that suggestion is, don't you?
 
In regard to the many stories since the jury decided the Zimmerman case, I wonder if everyone understands that SYG language was in the jury instructions as it is important. It was located under Manslaughter and it does cancel out manslaughter in that it forces the jury to only look at the fight. Manslaughter takes your actions pre-fight into account. We may as well remove manslaughter from choices to jury in murder cases as it can't be used in Florida. It is what it is but in the middle of all this I worry for all of us who do not carry guns. What do we do? What is left for innocent people walking to the store or going about any ordinary task and having the misfortune of someone thinking we look suspicious, or we are rude to take a parking space, or they just don't like our expression or skin color? What is the difference between a pedophile chasing our children and a strange man chasing our children in the night? What can you do when you are innocent and yet can't protect yourself from a man with a gun because if we do try to save our life we can be legally killed.

I think the bottom line is that guns enable people to push things until someone ends up dead rather than using common sense and try to avoid trouble. Trayvon's death should have shown us all that we are all in danger and we have lost our right to feel safe in our own communities because we just don't know who is packing and what his intentions are when he is displeased about something a normal person going about their daily tasks did, or looks like he did, or looks like he may do. But it is as legal to kill you or your children or grandchildren as it was to kill Trayvon. This SYG law is absolutely fearful and it allows the irresponsible behavior so an adult can confront the criminals living in their own minds and apply it to an innocent child walking home from a neighborhood store. Adults are suppose to be adults but I no longer know what that means now that we have armed people causing incidents as they act out and a kid ends up dead and our courts can't even save future children because to fight back when someone is chasing them is to be responsible. But if a stranger follows our children we tell them to run. We tell our children to fight back. We tell our children to NEVER go with a stranger. Trayvon is the exception because that child being followed by a stranger had no right to defend himself. He only had the legal right to be killed.

We can do better than this. Change that horrific law so everyone feels a little safer and not just armed men scrambling around at night inventing bad guys and acting out a Cowboy nightmare.


The SYG laws are an abomination in need of a repeal in every state they exist.
 
A couple of questions Minnie...

Before the so-called SYG law -- a title you inserted and bolded which is a lie, it is correctly called Justifiable Use of Force as it was before -- anyway, before the Justifiable Use of Force law was revised there was also a law defining manslaughter, correct?

In paragraph 3), the revision you underlined, can you tell us where it cancels out what has been the law for decades if not a century or more?

Enough of this silliness....

I have explained it quite enough. I think you are going to have to do a little research on what this subject. You are going to have to know about what the conflict is to understand the news regarding all of this.
 
You're right , we can do better than this, like address what's really happening on the streets

Black-on-black murder is at an all-time high. It was revealed that each year, roughly 7,000 blacks are murdered and 94 percent of the time the murderer is another black person.

According to a study conducted by the Bureau of Justice Statistics, between 1976 and 2011 there were 279,384 black murder victims, which means that 262,621 were murdered by other blacks, resulting in the 94 percent figure.
Even though blacks make-up only 13 percent of the nation’s population, they account for more than 50 percent of homicide victims.

When a Toppost is the subject of black on black crime or the rarer conversation of white on white let me know. That is an interesting different subject.
 
Count me among those who would argue that SYG was not part of the Zimmerman defense and not part of the judges instructions to the jury.

Yet we find that a juror repeatedly cited SYG as the reason Zimmerman was acquitted in an interview with Anderson Cooper. Further, there are many who argue that justifiable homicide automatically includes SYG even though Zimmerman waived his SYG hearing right months before the trial began.

My own personal opinion is that there might be two errors in this case.

One is that the jury might have applied the wrong law as juror B-37's interview would indicate.

The other possible error might be a failure on the part of the judge to indicate in her instructions to the jury that Zimmerman was required to retreat safely if possible in order to invoke self-defense. Had she done so, the jury would have recognized that justifiable homicide was not the same thing as SYG in a case where the defendant waived his SYG hearing.
 
the NRA has a hold on many Dems.

What a crock. The NRA doesn't "have a hold" on anyone. What it has is millions of voting members and non-members who vote in its favor, and it is good at turning out this grass-roots support in actual elections. That's called, by most people, "democracy in action." You simply don't like that these millions of voters don't share your viewpoint that they should be disarmed.
 
You're right , we can do better than this, like address what's really happening on the streets

Black-on-black murder is at an all-time high. It was revealed that each year, roughly 7,000 blacks are murdered and 94 percent of the time the murderer is another black person.

According to a study conducted by the Bureau of Justice Statistics, between 1976 and 2011 there were 279,384 black murder victims, which means that 262,621 were murdered by other blacks, resulting in the 94 percent figure.
Even though blacks make-up only 13 percent of the nation’s population, they account for more than 50 percent of homicide victims.

black-on-black homicide 94%.
white-on-white homicide 86%.

not much difference. we murder our own family, friends and acquaintances.
 
Back
Top