New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Syria

He wouldn't have needed to. His resignation could have stopped the effort to go to war in it's tracks and ended any hope of Bush winning in 2004.
Maybe so but at that point the die was cast, and the war was inevitable, no matter what Powell did od did not do.
 
Maybe so but at that point the die was cast, and the war was inevitable, no matter what Powell did od did not do.

I disagree. The invasion was the end of March. Powell spoke on Feb. 5th. If he had resigned at any time prior to that date the political advice Bush would have gotten from Rove would be to push harder for Saddam to step down. I think the political calculations were much greater than anyone knows. I base that on the timing. It would have been far better to wait a year and start the invasion in early 2004....but that would have been too close to the election for the outcome to be certain. Rove, I think, wanted enough time to build a case for the failure to have been someone else's fault.
 
Last edited:
I disagree. Powell spoke on Feb. 5th. If he had resigned at any time prior to that date the political advice Bush would have gotten from Rove would be to push harder for Saddam to step down. I think the political calculations were much greater than anyone knows. I base that on the timing. It would have been far better to wait a year and start the invasion in early 2004....but that would have been too close to the election for the outcome to be certain. Rove, I think, wanted enough time to build a case for the failure to have been someone else's fault.
But that war took more time for the administration to get our allies on board, and I believe Powell thought he could help the country more by being where he was, than abandoning ship. Plus he had bought into the WMD bologna.
 
I think what we have to consider are the possible avalanche of ulterior motives that probably go along with a retaliatory strike.

I have to say that I am outraged about the attacks but the definitive question of who actually committed these atrocities may be impossible to answer. In light of that the next question is what are the secondary justifications?

I am not sure there are any. Absent the use of chemical weapons I would stay as far away from this as possible. However i think doing nothing in response to the use of those weapons in a region where more then one group would like nothing more then to use said weapons on western targets sends a horrendous message.
 
Do you think that Powell knew that there were no WMD in IRAC.

I do think so. I was reasonably certain of that just from reading newspaper stories about the WMD in their entirety. It was clear that there was a conscious effort on someone's part to portray Iraq as having WMD that it didn't have, particularly a nuclear weapons program that could never have been hidden from the international intelligence community. All Powell would've had to do is ask a few questions, and any of the intelligence supporting a WMD program would've collapsed. He didn't because he wanted the war to proceed.
 
I disagree. The invasion was the end of March. Powell spoke on Feb. 5th. If he had resigned at any time prior to that date the political advice Bush would have gotten from Rove would be to push harder for Saddam to step down. I think the political calculations were much greater than anyone knows. I base that on the timing. It would have been far better to wait a year and start the invasion in early 2004....but that would have been too close to the election for the outcome to be certain. Rove, I think, wanted enough time to build a case for the failure to have been someone else's fault.

Surely electoral calculations helped decide the timing, but I think another part was the tug of war between a State Dept. that wanted overwhelming force and a Defense Dept. that wanted to rely more on a smaller army and more elite groups. I do think the war would've happened and there was nothing Powell, or Bush for that matter, really could've done to stop it short of leading a working-class revolution. It wasn't a war of choice on the part of American capitalism--it was necessary to the system's survival to start laying the groundwork for the hoped-for victory in WW3 by establishing control over Iraq.
 
Surely electoral calculations helped decide the timing, but I think another part was the tug of war between a State Dept. that wanted overwhelming force and a Defense Dept. that wanted to rely more on a smaller army and more elite groups. I do think the war would've happened and there was nothing Powell, or Bush for that matter, really could've done to stop it short of leading a working-class revolution. It wasn't a war of choice on the part of American capitalism--it was necessary to the system's survival to start laying the groundwork for the hoped-for victory in WW3 by establishing control over Iraq.

The state department wanted no war at all. Powell wanted to continue the search for a diplomatic solution. The defense department was split. The military wanted overwhelming force (See General Shinseki's testimony before the Senate) and people like Rumsfeld and Feith ridiculed Shinseki and went for tactics that would save money, but lose lives.

Anything that would have delayed the war would have resulted in an invasion in 2004...or maybe not at all. Nobody would have wanted to start a war in late April or later....too damned hot. One factor that may be more in favor of your opinion than mine is that it is also too hot to keep 150,000 troops in the desert waiting to start a year later.

WW3? Dude...try to stay on this planet for a bit.
 
The war was over and won when he left office.
How in hell did you come to the conclusion that the war was over and won. When baby George left office, the war was just starting. The opposition was collecting itself after their ranks were decimated by desert storm, but when they got it together, the war started all over again. No war is ever over until the arms are laid down, and a peace agreement is signed. George W. stood on that ship and took credit for a win, and it may have well been except we tried to cut off the snakes head, and all awake Americans knew that it was far from over. We have not yet learned how to fight a gorilla war, and the Gorillas are still there, hiding in there holes. That damn war was, and is still going on.
 
Back
Top