New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The first Amendment

Um this isn't the Tea Party Thread.

Your idea about 1st Amendment not applying to states is meaningless nonsense since Am 5's Due Process clause already provided that protection PRIOR to ratification of the 14th, but the 14th made it EXPLICIT via the "incorporation clause". So its been a bit of nonsense conservatives who don't understand how the Constitution works, have periodically trotted out since then.

Its been nonsense for coming onto 150 years.
 
are we so short of things to talk about that have something to do with the NOW, that we need to go back over what has been
shown to be a fact and try to figure a way around it so you can make a point that you agree with?

The govt should do nothing to promote or defend any religion, or stop any religion from promoting itself. For the govt to allow any religious activity to be a part of govt responsibility should not happen.
 
Let me ask the question in a different way.
Suppose a States (any State) legislators say in their constitution,
" The congress of the State shall make no laws governing the turning of right on a red signal"
The question is,
can cities make such laws one way or another?
 
are we so short of things to talk about that have something to do with the NOW, that we need to go back over what has been
shown to be a fact and try to figure a way around it so you can make a point that you agree with?

The govt should do nothing to promote or defend any religion, or stop any religion from promoting itself. For the govt to allow any religious activity to be a part of govt responsibility should not happen.[/QUOTE]

It doesnt say government.
It says CONGRESS, and BTW thats my whole point
 
Why not?
Congress shall not and will not pass a law one way or another.
Thats the point of the TP
And its wrong. Because that ignores the fact that Congress does have authority to say levy taxes. Which is a civic authority. And if your "religion" says that you should not pay taxes, then that is now in conflict. but because the Congressional authority to levy taxes or regulate commerce in other manners (under the Commerce Clause in Article 1) any such regulation that does not specifically address an institution of religion HOLDS SWAY.

In the case of laws like Obamacare applying to Catholic Hospitals, since no-one compells the HRCC to run a hospital AS A BUSINESS, then their freedom of religion is not impaired. They could - if they felt it was their faith's calling - run a hospital purely on a voluntary basis with no paid employees and no business contracts for any services. It would probably suck as a hospital but that's not a Constitutional problem.

IF OTOH the HRCC wants to gain the benefits and protections of running a business: the ability to hire employees, the ability to contract
for goods and services, the protections of CIVIC contract law - then they do so VOLUNTARILY. And that means a VOLUNTARY submission to ALL relevant civic regulations INCLUDING ones on healthcare provisions.

Notice that Obamacare provisions on healthcare insurance DO NOT extend to the healthcare that "Orders" provide for their members. Precisely because that IS an Am 1 violation.

Your arguements are rather ignorant of how the Constitution works.
 
Good question. Does the federal Constitution have overide of any state passed legislation? Let's take a look at US histroy.

Some states allowed slavery before 1860, not so much after 1865.

Some states had laws making segregation legal prior to 1964, not so much after that.

Some states had laws making interracial marriage illegal, not so much anymore.

Some cities ban certain types of guns without the proper permits, not really working that well.

I would say that any state that tries to ban or restrict those three basic tenents of freedom would find themselves before the US Supreme Court shortly.
 
For the govt to allow any religious activity to be a part of govt responsibility should not happen.[/

Is that your opinion, or is that somewhere within the constitution?

Remember,
Congress shall make no laws, one way or another
 
In other words,
Congress cannot make a law that restricts OR allows religion within a government entity.
Which leaves it up to the entity to allow or restrict.
 
May a TOWN or a STATE ban or restrict religion, freedom of speech.
and or the right to petition?

Typically, no state or local law can trump the US Constitution. However obvious measures can be taken...for instance, city ordinances saying no one can start a panic by yelling "Fire" in a movie theatre.
 
For the govt to allow any religious activity to be a part of govt responsibility should not happen.[/

Is that your opinion, or is that somewhere within the constitution?

Remember,
Congress shall make no laws, one way or another

Where is the phrase "one way or another" in the 1st Amendment? Maybe I missed it.
 
In other words,
Congress cannot make a law that restricts OR allows religion within a government entity.
Wrong.

It means Congress cannot pass a law who's intent is to restrict or enhance a particular religion. Congress can pass all manner of CIVIC laws under its other authorities. And if those laws restrict or enable religion (say vacation days during the Winter Solstice period) AS A SIDE EFFECT, there is no problem.

So if Congress passes a law that requires EMPLOYERS to cover abortions under their healthcare plans, then because doing business is not a religious requirement but rather a VOLUNTARY CHOICE, no religious 1st Amendment consequences attach... because it is RELIGION NEUTRAL.

So is for example a building code that requires sprinklers in public buildings that accomodate gatherings of more tha 15 people. Since it applies to ALL buildings, it also applies NEUTRALLY to religious buildings with no exemption for them.


This is really tiresome. This is old settled law
 
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

For debate only


Specifically,
CONGRESS shall make no law......(meaning one way or another)

Question. (only an example)

May a TOWN or a STATE ban or restrict religion, freedom of speech.
and or the right to petition?

The fourteenth amendment has been ruled to have made the first amendment applicable to towns and states, as well.
 
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

For debate only


Specifically,
CONGRESS shall make no law......(meaning one way or another)

Question. (only an example)

May a TOWN or a STATE ban or restrict religion, freedom of speech.
and or the right to petition?

Former Attorney General Ed Meese thought so. He thought it would be perfectly permissible for an individual STATE to have an offical religion. So the state of Utah, for instance, could make the Mormon religion mandatory for all of the citizens of that state.

Of course, Ed Meese was a grade-A knucklehead......
 
But wait...

So, we can stifle Islam by simply denying them permits to build mosques?

flooding concerns in Chicago... really? Do you know what a joke that is? The Lake never floods anything, and the river is so over engineered, it isn't even a river any more, it is a bloody canal... part of the IM canal. The only "flooding" concerns in Chicago are from heavy rains overwhelming the storm sewers.

"flooding concerns" is Chicago politics for "take your Islam elsewhere".
 
Where is Islam being stifled... ALL religious institutions were being prohibited by zoning from building in that spot. What it really was was a property tax and revenue tax issue. Yes and?
 
Its a lousy question Jammer. Supremacy clause makes the US Consititution the supreme law of the land.

Amendment 5's Due Process clause means Constitutional rights cannot be abrogated without Due Process..

QED Am 1 protections could not be abrogated by the States. And to clarify that Am 14's incorporation clause made that explicit.
 
Where is the phrase "one way or another" in the 1st Amendment? Maybe I missed it.

It isnt in the constitution.
What is in the constitution is the fact that congress "can make no law"
which means by any definition, they cannot make a law.
Any law, any way, anyhow, anywhere, and under no circumstaces, meaning they cannot make a law "one way 0r another"
 
It isnt in the constitution.
What is in the constitution is the fact that congress "can make no law"
which means by any definition, they cannot make a law.
Any law, any way, anyhow, anywhere, and under no circumstaces, meaning they cannot make a law "one way 0r another"

In other words,
they cannot pass a law that says you can pray in school, any more than they could pass a law that says, you CANT pray in school.
 
GG I'm surprised at you. First off the "yelling fire" is actually protected speech regardless of the rather badly argued speech case from the 20s that has since been superceded at least twice.

Secondly the issue isn't one of "trumping" the Constitution. Rather its a sophomoric attempt to limit Am 1s restrictions on government action to Congress. However it ignores that the Religious freedom right is clearly stated, and then protected by Am 5's due process right.

Dude I expected more of you
 
Back
Top