New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Tim Tebow......

Well you are correct in part that virtually all the discussion is about your post but mostly about how jerky it was.
Certainly there was no shortage of right-wingers who wanted to thread to be about their personal feelings for me. But that's fine -- it helped facilitate the political discussion about the issue I brought up.
 
Other people like myself did feel the need to school you on the manners you so obviously lack.

I don't recognize any rule of etiquette that says people shouldn't engage in political discussions in response to a post on a forum expressly dedicated to political discussions. If you want to create such a rule, good luck with it.
 
I applaud you for having reached a very important milestone in the understanding of modern American society.... The word Tribalism sums it up perhaps better than any other.
I will gladly join in a series of interchanges on this subject because I believe it is key to finding at least some partial answers to our currently troubled populous.

In particular I would like to explore how both sets of leaders ( not political but social ) are using this effect to their own selfish ends.

JO
I think this tribalist impulse has definitely been getting stronger, because it's pushing more and more into fields that weren't particularly political in the past. At this point, it seems like everything from celebrities to consumer outlets to TV shows to fashion choices, to types of food all come with a de facto tribal designation.

I'd wager good money, without even looking, that a poll would confirm, for example, that most NCIS viewers are conservative and most viewers of The Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt are liberal, just based on their cultural feel. Similarly, I'd wager that liberals are more likely to eat kale than conservatives, while conservatives are more likely to eat beef than liberals. Chick Fil A is one one side of the divide, Starbucks on the other. Michael Bay and Joss Whedon. Fox News and the Young Turks. Etc.

I don't know to what extend the leaders are using this, versus to what extent they're just responding to it. Perhaps, to some extent, it's just an outgrowth of the Internet, in that in the modern era it's much easier to micro-target everything to specific people now, rather than having to find a way to appeal to a broad swath of the populace. And maybe that encourages everyone--politicians, consumer products manufacturers, media outlets, etc., to take more of a "package identity" approach to ingratiating themselves with the target audience.... such that it's more about a personal branding exercise.
 
I don't recognize any rule of etiquette that says people shouldn't engage in political discussions in response to a post on a forum expressly dedicated to political discussions. If you want to create such a rule, good luck with it.

The rule of etiquette would be to allow the top poster to dictate the intention of the conversation. If they intended it be be lighthearted and feel good tripe, then that is what the thread should be, and it should roll off of the top page after a few people express goodwill. Those who do not intend to express goodwill, should politely -keep their opinions to themselves and if it spurs a topic they would like to discuss, start their own top post.

You can generally tell by whether or not the top poster intended to create a "discussion"
or just merely post something of interest - by whether or not they end the post requesting some sort of feedback and or discussion or pose a question relative to their post.

In a previous forum I moderated, we told posters merely to scroll on by when faced with posts like Zam's if you were unable to simply just be nice and lighthearted. You are very welcome by the way, for the lesson in etiquette. Perhaps you can use it at parties and social gatherings... what am I saying.... if you behave like this there.. such invitations are likely few and far between.
 
I think this tribalist impulse has definitely been getting stronger, because it's pushing more and more into fields that weren't particularly political in the past. At this point, it seems like everything from celebrities to consumer outlets to TV shows to fashion choices, to types of food all come with a de facto tribal designation.

I'd wager good money, without even looking, that a poll would confirm, for example, that most NCIS viewers are conservative and most viewers of The Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt are liberal, just based on their cultural feel. Similarly, I'd wager that liberals are more likely to eat kale than conservatives, while conservatives are more likely to eat beef than liberals. Chick Fil A is one one side of the divide, Starbucks on the other. Michael Bay and Joss Whedon. Fox News and the Young Turks. Etc.

I don't know to what extend the leaders are using this, versus to what extent they're just responding to it. Perhaps, to some extent, it's just an outgrowth of the Internet, in that in the modern era it's much easier to micro-target everything to specific people now, rather than having to find a way to appeal to a broad swath of the populace. And maybe that encourages everyone--politicians, consumer products manufacturers, media outlets, etc., to take more of a "package identity" approach to ingratiating themselves with the target audience.... such that it's more about a personal branding exercise.

Oh I agree that the internet was like finding a pot of gold for some of the crowd manipulators....what other medium can reach millions per key stroke? None really.

Yes, though I suspect the issue may run a bit deeper I think a very good place to start and a very, very good analogy is the Tribal analogy. It fits the general pattern of what is observable in the groupings, interactions and reactions of the general categories out there today.

I don't have any real proof on the matter but I suspect that large marketing companies are aware of this trend and no doubt pay out six figure salaries to the trained psychologists on staff who both recognize it and know how to use it for a specific purpose. It could be either good or bad I suppose but I tend to see any type of personal handle on the individual and/or group as too dangerous to be trusted to the hands of other people.

JO
 
Oh I agree that the internet was like finding a pot of gold for some of the crowd manipulators....what other medium can reach millions per key stroke? None really.

Yes, though I suspect the issue may run a bit deeper I think a very good place to start and a very, very good analogy is the Tribal analogy. It fits the general pattern of what is observable in the groupings, interactions and reactions of the general categories out there today.

I don't have any real proof on the matter but I suspect that large marketing companies are aware of this trend and no doubt pay out six figure salaries to the trained psychologists on staff who both recognize it and know how to use it for a specific purpose. It could be either good or bad I suppose but I tend to see any type of personal handle on the individual and/or group as too dangerous to be trusted to the hands of other people.

JO
I've had some involvement in marketing campaigns -- not directly in formulating them, but in doing agreements with marketing firms on behalf of other big corporations, and so I've had some exposure to the back-room talk behind the formulation of campaigns. Certainly a lot of thought goes into positioning the product, culturally.

For example, check out a John Deere tractor ad. They all have a certain look, and it's a look designed to resonate with the self-image of a certain demographic. Generally, there are vistas of big sky and amber fields of grain. There's some manly middle-aged dude in blue-jeans, a baseball cap, and a weathered, serious face. There are images soaked in Americana, and a country-tinged soundtrack. It needn't be that way. In theory they could take a page from some car companies and give us a vehicle sitting in a sterile setting where some lab-coated figure in glasses is pictured, emphasizing the engineering and precision of the machinery, etc. But it's about shouting out tribal affiliation, much more than selling the features of the product.

Or consider a Suburu ad. They often show an upscale-bohemian late-20s couple dressed in an L.L. Bean ensemble, driving to some pristine destination. They're aiming for a demographic I might call "New Hampshire Liberal" -- a non-urban, but well-to-do and educated white family. Again, they're not selling particular stats (horsepower, resale value, towing capacity), but instead shouting out a tribal designation. It's "you're our people!"
 
I've had some involvement in marketing campaigns -- not directly in formulating them, but in doing agreements with marketing firms on behalf of other big corporations, and so I've had some exposure to the back-room talk behind the formulation of campaigns. Certainly a lot of thought goes into positioning the product, culturally.

For example, check out a John Deere tractor ad. They all have a certain look, and it's a look designed to resonate with the self-image of a certain demographic. Generally, there are vistas of big sky and amber fields of grain. There's some manly middle-aged dude in blue-jeans, a baseball cap, and a weathered, serious face. There are images soaked in Americana, and a country-tinged soundtrack. It needn't be that way. In theory they could take a page from some car companies and give us a vehicle sitting in a sterile setting where some lab-coated figure in glasses is pictured, emphasizing the engineering and precision of the machinery, etc. But it's about shouting out tribal affiliation, much more than selling the features of the product.

Or consider a Suburu ad. They often show an upscale-bohemian late-20s couple dressed in an L.L. Bean ensemble, driving to some pristine destination. They're aiming for a demographic I might call "New Hampshire Liberal" -- a non-urban, but well-to-do and educated white family. Again, they're not selling particular stats (horsepower, resale value, towing capacity), but instead shouting out a tribal designation. It's "you're our people!"

This is called "virtue signaling". It explains why you regularly remind us where you live, what you drive, what you eat, and various other tenets of your weird weather-panic religion that you seem to think anyone who doesn't live in your (sustainably designed, meat-free, and centrally located) house might possibly care about.
 
This is called "virtue signaling". It explains why you regularly remind us where you live, what you drive, what you eat, and various other tenets of your weird weather-panic religion that you seem to think anyone who doesn't live in your (sustainably designed, meat-free, and centrally located) house might possibly care about.
As you'll recall, I remind you of those things because you routinely feign ignorance about them -- pretending that I said the only thing I do to fight climate change is have the help sort my recyclables. It's not about virtue signaling. It's about reminding you and the group that you're a shameless liar. I know it hurts your feelings to have that pointed out consistently, but since I really enjoy seeing your feelings hurt, don't expect me to stop.
 
As you'll recall, I remind you of those things because you routinely feign ignorance about them -- pretending that I said the only thing I do to fight climate change is have the help sort my recyclables. It's not about virtue signaling. It's about reminding you and the group that you're a shameless liar. I know it hurts your feelings to have that pointed out consistently, but since I really enjoy seeing your feelings hurt, don't expect me to stop.

Looking forward to your next spiritual enlightenment announcement! In the meantime, make sure to avoid procreation per St. Al's decree.
 
http://kaepernick7.com/
If you click on the million dollar pledge, you can see the donations by month, along with details about what the charity does, what the donation was earmarked for, and a link to the charity if you'd like to donate, too. It looks like you have to click on each month in turn to see the full list.
I think maybe one one of those orgs didn't shout and bleed social justice warrior snowflake.

Not real charities just loser scams.
 
I think maybe one one of those orgs didn't shout and bleed social justice warrior snowflake.

Not real charities just loser scams.
Certainly most of Kaepernick's charities were focused on fighting for social justice. The fact you imagine the cause of social justice isn't charitable is bizarre.
 
Certainly most of Kaepernick's charities were focused on fighting for social justice. The fact you imagine the cause of social justice isn't charitable is bizarre.
Calling them scams is accurate, sober, clear thinking. I'm not surprised you find clear thinking bizarre.
 
Back
Top