New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Title 18, U.S. code 597

The law includes food and water.


It takes forever to find due to the deliberate leanings of today's media....but....here goes


"This Code section shall not be construed to prohibit a poll officer ... from making available self-service water from an unattended receptacle to an elector waiting in line to vote."
 
It takes forever to find due to the deliberate leanings of today's media....but....here goes


"This Code section shall not be construed to prohibit a poll officer ... from making available self-service water from an unattended receptacle to an elector waiting in line to vote."

But doesn't require it....so it is optional.

Admit it...it is an idiotic rule.
 
But doesn't require it....so it is optional.

Admit it...it is an idiotic rule.
But it's not prohibited which is the point.

Poll workers are free to provide self-service water if they so choose. That is the truth of the matter. It is an untruth to say is that the provision of water is prohibited outright.

It is an idiotic argument I'll give you that. The back and forth is odd, and the positioning disingenuine considering the text of what I just shared
 
But it's not prohibited which is the point.

Poll workers are free to provide self-service water if they so choose. That is the truth of the matter. It is an untruth to say is that the provision of water is prohibited outright.

It is an idiotic argument I'll give you that. The back and forth is odd, and the positioning disingenuine considering the text of what I just shared

Is any poll worker considered an "officer"? Who will pay for the water?
 
Is any poll worker considered an "officer"? Who will pay for the water?
So the facts of the matter are presented, and now we need to parse further? It says that water can be provisioned by a poll worker. Not the media narrative that water is being refused all together and penalized under law. It is a penalty for persons affiliated with a political party to do so within a certain distance. Otherwise it says what it says
 
So the facts of the matter are presented, and now we need to parse further? It says that water can be provisioned by a poll worker. Not the media narrative that water is being refused all together and penalized under law. It is a penalty for persons affiliated with a political party to do so within a certain distance. Otherwise it says what it says

There is no mention of allowing a poll officer an expense account to furnish water. It says nothing at all about party affiliation. Are you assuming only democrats would hand out water or that republicans would change votes for a bottle of water?

Think for a minute. Clearly the republicans are trying to encourage people to go home and not vote by restricting voting, packing polling places in democratic areas and working to make standing in line more prohibitive by making it more uncomfortable.
 
Title 18, U.S. code 597


Existing federal law that makes it a crime to attempt to influence the vote with food or beverage. Much like the law just passed in georgia. Seems to me a codifying of an existing federal law at the state level nothing more.
To defend Georgia's new voter suppression law, even this water issue, means one believes Trump's Big Lie that Georgia was stolen from him.
 
There is no mention of allowing a poll officer an expense account to furnish water. It says nothing at all about party affiliation. Are you assuming only democrats would hand out water or that republicans would change votes for a bottle of water?

Think for a minute. Clearly the republicans are trying to encourage people to go home and not vote by restricting voting, packing polling places in democratic areas and working to make standing in line more prohibitive by making it more uncomfortable.
Laws are to now address expense accounts? I am assuming neither of them.

I think these are issues that can be resolved.
 
To defend Georgia's new voter suppression law, even this water issue, means one believes Trump's Big Lie that Georgia was stolen from him.

Nah. I don't believe that it was stolen from trump. I believe he lost fair n square.

Zzzzz. Thud
 
Nah. I don't believe that it was stolen from trump. I believe he lost fair n square.

Zzzzz. Thud
Georgia Republicans put that water proviso into their new anti-democracy voter suppression law......to fvck with voters. That you defend it is telling.
 
Georgia Republicans put that water proviso into their new anti-democracy voter suppression law......to fvck with voters. That you defend it is telling.

Read english much? It says what it says. Verbatim.

That you come cackling with your stupidity is telling..
 
Laws are to now address expense accounts? I am assuming neither of them.

I think these are issues that can be resolved.

If there is no money attached to provide water then you assume that poll officers will do so out of pocket?

Can you site a single case of anyone changing their vote in exchange for food or drink in the 2020 election? How about a case of people handing out water that was as a part of any effort to identify the free food or water as coming from a candidate or party?
 
If there is no money attached to provide water then you assume that poll officers will do so out of pocket?

Can you site a single case of anyone changing their vote in exchange for food or drink in the 2020 election? How about a case of people handing out water that was as a part of any effort to identify the free food or water as coming from a candidate or party?
I don't claim any such cases. So why do I need to cite one?

I claim there's no issue here other than shrieking by the left. I even provided you the relevant statement within the law that indicates that water is not being without and can be provided.
 
If there is no money attached to provide water then you assume that poll officers will do so out of pocket?

Can you site a single case of anyone changing their vote in exchange for food or drink in the 2020 election? How about a case of people handing out water that was as a part of any effort to identify the free food or water as coming from a candidate or party?
Better still, you claim withholding food and water prevents people from voting. Cite examples of persons turned away or otherwise removed from the poles because of a lack of food and water..

You're the one making the claim
 
So we agree on that, but you do seem to deny that Georgia is attempting to pull the next election their way.
I don't seem to do any such thing. What I do seem to do is provide factual reference to the law as it is written. is that the law states that poll workers can provide water is in fact true as it is written in the law itself.
You claim that the law specifically prevents the provision of water, which it does not, it explicitly prevents representatives of political parties from providing water within a certain distance of a polling place

it would be nice to see your references to persons being disenfranchised because there's not water at a polling place
 
Better still, you claim withholding food and water prevents people from voting. Cite examples of persons turned away or otherwise removed from the poles because of a lack of food and water..

You're the one making the claim

That can only be done by observing an election where it is illegal to hand out water or food...this is the first time I'm aware of that a law has been passed that will impact voters standing in long lines. Get back to me after the next Georgia election.
 
I don't seem to do any such thing. What I do seem to do is provide factual reference to the law as it is written. is that the law states that poll workers can provide water is in fact true as it is written in the law itself.
You claim that the law specifically prevents the provision of water, which it does not, it explicitly prevents representatives of political parties from providing water within a certain distance of a polling place

it would be nice to see your references to persons being disenfranchised because there's not water at a polling place

As long as we are paying attention to detail...the law says "Poll Officers". I don't know that poll workers would qualify. We also know that it states water "may" be provided, but doesn't offer a means by which that water may be paid for. It also says nothing at all about political parties donating water.

We frequently see references to New Black Panther member standing at a polling place with a night stick and claim that meant voter intimidation...and yet no voter came forward to say they were intimidated.

It would be nice to settle on a standard of acceptable evidence. Since people were handing out water to those in line, how would we find evidence of people leaving because they tired of waiting and had no access to water?
 
That can only be done by observing an election where it is illegal to hand out water or food...this is the first time I'm aware of that a law has been passed that will impact voters standing in long lines. Get back to me after the next Georgia election.
We're in a thread whose title references federal law that includes food and water as federal prohibition withing certain distances...

So, national is your scope....feel free to cite reference to instances
 
Georgia Republicans put that water proviso into their new anti-democracy voter suppression law......to fvck with voters. That you defend it is telling.

Water isn't mentioned in the water
"anything of value" IS
 

Attachments

  • 1617290062265.png
    1617290062265.png
    366.5 KB · Views: 1
Back
Top