New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Tom Brokaw

I most always agree with you but

It was in reply to your posts about drones 'We have them,they are saving the lives of ours.End of story! war is hell on all!'

I feel we saved lives of ours with torture and I just wondered if you would agree with that. I agree war is hell though.


The other posters were saying, that our enemies will get drones,too.I said,"We have them and should use them." Fretting about our enemies getting new war weapons should not deter us from using drones to save lives now . They are the best option of a lot of bad options.
 
My take is that Tom Brokaw is either just waking up to what many people were talking about during talk of invading Iraq if not even before that, including discussion of our involvement in Vietnam or he's trying to suggest there is something new in what he is discussing and he is trying to equate himself to Christopher Columbus as the discoverer of what it could be that causes anyone to attack the United States.

How many times has the subject of our nation's hypocrisies been brought up on this board, much less in relation to terrorism, foreign or domestic?

Brokaw may simply be looking for a way to approach the subject that those who have yet to notice it or feel that revenge, retribution, pre-emptive "defense" invading other nations and proposing by force they become like us are effect means of reducing or diminishing attacks may not have realized, that instead of reducing or diminishing reasons why people may carry their anger to the highest levels, the induce that kind of behavior. By broaching the possibilities, whether Brokaw has long felt them, known them or not, he could be cracking open the minds of those who seem to feel our means of "responding" to terrorism may very well be the means that add fuel to the fire rather than help extinguish them.

Another way to look at it is as Arkady did with regard to how any one of us would feel were another nation to do to us, what we have done to some others were a group from the U.S. like Aryan Nation of the Ku Klux Klan kill people in their nation.

Like children, if you ask why some are fighting or wanting to attack one another, they'll tell you it's because the other hit them first. If you want to stop something, engaging in it is not stopping it.

From a practical standpoint, we need to create a defense and security system that will detect and diffuse those who find reasons to attack us, in their own mind or as some "retribution" for our actions, but it seems wise to discuss and then work on reducing ways we might be or are feeding the fires of why people want to attack us. We need to look at Vietnam, we need to look at our support of the Mujahideen in Aghanistan in their efforts to push the Soviet Union out of that country, we need to look at our weapons sales to various nations and our blind loyalty to nations that do things we would admonish other nations for. In other words we could maybe work on our integrity, credibility, hypocrisy and openly discuss our conundrums and dilemmas to the extent that discussion would let people know we are faced to no good choices and a conscious and aware that no matter what decisions we make they will be bad ones. We could even put the onus on those that present us with such dilemmas and choices and suggest the could help us eliminate a need to make such choices.

At the same time, we need to think about all the potential consequences of our actions and not only how in the short term they benefit us. Getting drunk or smoking crack, having sex, gambling, being wreckless in all manner of ways might feel good to us in the short term and we may get away without any negative consequences if we do them infrequently, but in the long term and by engaging frequently, the odds we are going to see a negative short or long term effect are increased.

Once again we see a practical reason why vanity and pride (pride on certain levels) fall in not only in the "sin" column, but the deadlist of the deadly sins column. Vanity and pride seem to rob us of an ability to see ourselves truly and accurately and tend to make us see ourselves as the epitome of all things good and perfect. It defies introspection and blocks humility and deference to anything else that might be greater, whether it be a god or simply a mathematical equation.

Businesses that don't engage in some form of introspection and reporting about themselves will not see areas within their business that are not performing well or where their products fall behind their competition's. They could "cook" their books and write rosy reports about themselves, but that won't prevent them from going under, for all the self-congratulating that might go on before reality hits.

Aircraft pilots check out there aircraft before taking them up. Lying to themselves about a flaw or a stress crack could mean not just their own demise, but the demise of many passengers.

Nationalism or a few successes tend to blind people to a need to be forever vigilant to check themselves and their own actions as much as they check others. Doing so seems to serve integrity, honesty, practicality, credibilty, justice, fairness and all manner of things humans seem to believe are virtues rather than the opposite. While it is always nice to hear about all the virtuous things we have done, we don't like to hear negative things. Not hearing them does not mean they go away. To deny them or delude ourselves that they don't exist only puts off doing something about them to reduce them or correct them and the longer we put off doing something about them the more they accumulate adding weight to the negative and making it more difficult to do something about them.

This goes for the national debt, (regarding revenue to reduce it and cutting out unnecessary spending), it goes for how we use our military, it goes for maintaining and improving the infrastructure of our nation and it goes for support and promotion of innovation and alternatives any status quos that keep us mired in the past for the sake of protecting the profits of a few, at the expense of the many. It goes for how we use our power in the world and whether we use it wisely or in ways that could universally or regionally be seen as overstepping the bounds of moderation, justice, fairness and anyone's definition of "defense".

Certainly, if all institutions, organizations and businesses believed that all they need do it claim to be the best rather than actually follow up their claims with something to prove it, hours upon hours of time and money would need not be spent on meetings and reports regarding their own status and taking action based on what those meetings and reports reveal, positive or negative, about the direction of the activities of those institutions, organizations, businesses, etc.

Yes, the U.S. has done some great and exceptional things in its history and those could be said to make it exceptional, but it has also done some things that are far from great or exceptional and might even be considered shameful in its history. It can only get better by recognizing, acknowledging, admitting to, discussing and learning from our mistakes. Sweeping them under the rug because we don't like to hear them does nothing to make us a better nation and only compounds what we have swept under the rug. We can't very well ignore things then complain when they come back to haunt us or nag us.
 
The other posters were saying, that our enemies will get drones,too.I said,"We have them and should use them." Fretting about our enemies getting new war weapons should not deter us from using drones to save lives now . They are the best option of a lot of bad options.

I know we agree on a lot of things MaryAnne, this is not one of them. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you, when it comes to drones is one thing I don't believe we want happening to us any more than we want people dropping nuclear bombs on us claiming that they had to do it to "stop the killing".

If they are attacking us because we do things like use drones and we're using drones because they're attacking us for doing things like using drones, it becomes a circular reasoning and self perpetuating "war".
 
Zammy, why should there be Japanese terrorists? They lost the war but won the peace and own as much, if not more, of America as Americans do. You don't think that the owners of Honda, Toyota, and Nissan, don't laugh about how they have conquered America without firing a shot? Their only competition in the US are the Chinese, not Americans.


You speak of the Japanese as if they were monolithic. They are no more that than Muslims are.
 
I know we agree on a lot of things MaryAnne, this is not one of them. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you, when it comes to drones is one thing I don't believe we want happening to us any more than we want people dropping nuclear bombs on us claiming that they had to do it to "stop the killing".

If they are attacking us because we do things like use drones and we're using drones because they're attacking us for doing things like using drones, it becomes a circular reasoning and self perpetuating "war".

We have a choice, kill many more of our own,or end the war with drones that are selective.The old way is not working.The real solution is to get out,let them fight their own wars.
 
The younger brother made it clear the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan is the reason.

So,who is responsible for those 2 wars,Zam? One should have never been started! It was based on lies! How much hatred do you think all those needless deaths have caused?

what two wars were going on when we were attacked on 9-11 murdering 2,977 people?
 
that is. Not what I am suggesting,or saying!

I am saying,the wars provided hate on the part of those affected by the self serving Bush gang!

"Terrorism against America deserves to be praised because it was a response to injustice, aimed at forcing America to stop its support for Israel, which kills our people"


was that the cause of 9-11 or two wars that had not even started yet?

Are you people for real here?
 
They ARE for real.
Scary thought, huh.


"Terrorism against America deserves to be praised because it was a response to injustice, aimed at forcing America to stop its support for Israel, which kills our people"


was that the cause of 9-11 or two wars that had not even started yet?

Are you people for real here?
 
You speak of the Japanese as if they were monolithic. They are no more that than Muslims are.

Seriously?!? Japan is MUCH more 'monolithic' than the Muslims are. In fact, there is probably no society on Earth that is more 'monolithic' than Japan, at least if you are using the standard definition of the word. The Islamic civilization stretches from Morocco in the West all the way to Indonesia and the Philippines in the Far East, and encompasses a bewildering variety of ethnic groups, many of whom do not like each other very much----case in point being the LONG historical enmity between the Arabs and the Persians, which HELPS to account for the brutal and bloody war between Iraq and Iran in the 1980s. You have the very strict Islam of Saudi Arabia vs the much more relaxed form of Islam that tends to predominate in Indonesia. In contrast, Japan is essentially ONE ethnic group, with an overwhelmingly strong sense of nationality. Japanese society is MUCH less centered around religious beliefs than Islamic societies. They responded to their defeat in World War II by radically altering their worldview. They had thought themselves invincible, but since it was America that defeated them, they decided to respond by pretty much imitating us. American culture was immensely popular in Japan in the 1950s. When they saw Americans going nuts over hula-hoops, they did so as well. When surf rock music became popular in America in the early 1960s, it became the rage in Japan as well.

If we were to drop a nuke on Mecca, as Tom Tancredo suggests we should do (in response to any more serious terrorist attacks), do NOT expect the Islamic world to react the same way the Japanese did when we dropped nukes on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
 
Are drones part of the problem? Yes. When innocents are killed in the waging of warfare, that is a problem, especially for the families of those innocents. When that killing comes from faceless attacks from the sky, silent, unpredictable, that is a bigger problem especially for those considered "collatoral damage." Does that mean we shouldn't use drones? What's the alternative - sending American military members to die? The administration you say "loves the drones" no doubt loves the ability to wage the war with less loss of American life. Are American lives more precious than non-American lives? The pacifist in me says we are all equal in our right to life; the realist in me says that the country that has the ability to wage war while simultaneously not putting its citizens in harms way will certainly do so.

What's sad is when we (the non-politicians, non-decision makers) lose the humanity to see that a young man who may profess to love America would fight to the death if he lost a family member to an American drone strike. It is human. Sadder still are those who cite out-of-context passages from the Qu'ran and behave as though there are not similar passages in the Bible that can be (and have been) cited to justify American genocide in the past. Sure the past seems far away when seen only in the context of our own short lives, but the past is a harbinger of the future.

A thoughtful and well-considered post, BobbyT. I salute you.
 
What's interesting here is that Brokaw is positing a direct connection between this administration's reliance on drones and the resulting creation of new terrorists. Predictably, the reaction from the PJ liberals, who are sworn to protect Chicago Jesus at any and all costs, is to completely avoid that subject and attack "the right". Just like the left crucified Bob Woodward when he dared to momentarily step off the plantation, thus it will be done with Brokaw as well. This is why we are where we are...

Q: Did the Bush administration use drones?

A: Why, yes. Yes, they did.
 
I think they should be minimized. I think they should be viewed as having an enormous, hidden, indirect cost that comes in the form of radicalizing the friends and relatives of victims, and their wider community, so that they only get used in situations where the direct benefits are enormous. They may still be appropriate for targeting senior leaders of terrorist organizations in settings where collateral damage is expected to be minimal. But, this shouldn't be a widespread campaign. It should be done only in truly extraordinary cases.

Peter Bergen has said that under Bush there was an American drone attack in Pakistan every 43 days, compared to every four days during the first two years of the Obama administration (I'm not sure what the rate has been since then). I'd say that even under Bush they were being used excessively, but under Obama we're talking about an order of magnitude difference.

If we can reduce drone strikes to the point where people can believe there really were extraordinary and compelling circumstances calling for each and every such strike, the indirect damage can be minimized. Sure, those closest to the victims are still likely to be filled with rage, but the wider communities are more likely to blame the targets for any collateral damage, rather than the US. But if these things are happening hundreds of times per year, it will be seen as indiscriminate --as an arrogant foreign power killing people on a hair trigger because there's little cost to themselves. And that will radicalize a lot more people than those closest to the people killed.

I agree with you on this, Arkady. I think our use of drones HAS been excessive, to the point of being counter-productive. We probably ARE creating more terrorists than we are killing.
 
It's a simple fact of nature, kill innocents and you create enemies. Whether it's the drones, or the so-called 'smart bombs', they're not any smarter than the human that puts them into action. And there is a high element of human error involved. So yes, I'd say drones are part of the problem, and I don't agree with them.
 
It's a simple fact of nature, kill innocents and you create enemies. Whether it's the drones, or the so-called 'smart bombs', they're not any smarter than the human that puts them into action. And there is a high element of human error involved. So yes, I'd say drones are part of the problem, and I don't agree with them.

Not to mention an element of psychological terror in the realization that one is hunted observed and then is injured or killed by remote control, a strange dichotomy to those who commit suicide as part of the process of their injuring or killing others.

One can only imagine drones over the skies of our nation, used to "take out" people, and occasionally taking out more than the people intentionally targeted. Imagine hunters using drones to take down game. Efficient, but so one sided, there seems something terribly wrong with it.

Unfortunately we have once again, opened Pandora's Box instead of suppressing escalation. I'm not sure how we're going to feel about it the first time drones are used against us, rather than "for" us. My feeling is that we'll more than likely feel the same way those in nations we have used drones to kill, feel and that won't be feeling good about them.
 
We have a choice, kill many more of our own,or end the war with drones that are selective.The old way is not working.The real solution is to get out,let them fight their own wars.

I agree with getting out. The problem with the idea or suggestion that we save lives of our own by the use of drones negates itself if the use of drones causes or exacerbates attacks in retribution, upon our troops or citizens at home. Sure we don't put pilot at risks, but if drones piss people off and only add to their list of reasons to attack us and they do, we haven't really saved American lives, but possibly caused or risked more American deaths than what would be in manned aircraft. I when there is something human and closer to the target, there is more accountability. Oddly, my thought is that it is related to and goes back to why the founders of this nation feared standing militaries of professional soldiers and chose state's militias composed of citizen soldiers. Such militia are more closely connected to civilian life and their family, friends and neighbors on a much more local level than professional soldiers from some distant locale commanded by some central command. The thought is/was, citizen soldiers would be more likely to know and have some connection to those they might be ordered to fire upon and based on that would not be as easy to be used by those who would use usurped power for tyrannical purposes. While the practical side of drones is quite obvious, the remote nature of their control removes the human connection as well as the accountability connection. When there is little or no skin in the game, there seems less incentive to care about or feel accountable for what one is doing.

No one wants to put our service men and women in the line of fire if we do not have to, but if we are indirectly putting not just them, but civilians at a higher risk of attack in retribution, anger, or other reasons based on our use of drones, there really may not be a net savings of American lives, but perhaps the risk of a higher loss of American lives

We went to Iraq and Afghanistan because some people attacked us. Were all of America to be blamed for some Americans going to another nation and killing people of that nation for whatever reason, we would not be happy at all about it, especially if our nation was invaded with the militaries of other nation's based on the same. How many Americans beyond those killed on 9/11 have lost their lives in the pursuit of justice for that event? How many Iraqis, Afghanis, Pakistanis and people of other nations have lost their lives as a result of the military conflict and our insertion into their internal affairs?

Once again, handing people the ammunition with which to attack us by providing some evidence of what they use to hype hate and anger at us, is not saving lives, but putting more at risk of being lost. I think the idea behind turn the other cheek is to not feed the fires of escalation and tit for tat. One can disarm others by denying them the ammunition they need to keep firing. It's difficult to credibly accuse the U.S. of imperialistic acts if we are not acting imperialistic, it feeds the fire when we respond to attacks on us based on claims of our being imperialistic with imperialistic acts, such as invading Iraq unilaterally or using drones in nations where we might not have full permission to use them or in places that our use of them put civilians in further danger, either by the drones themselves and collateral damage or by placing them between a rock and a hard place, living side by side with enemies of the U.S. and being expected to cooperate with the U.S.. They cooperate with us and they are considered traitors to some in their nation, they don't cooperate with us and we consider them as siding with terrorists or enemy combatants with the U.S.. In addition, when we're operating in someone else's sovereign nation, do they have a right to defend themselves from foreign troops or things like drones used in their nation?

Yes, getting out may not stop attacks, but it more than likely will help starve the fires of reasons to attack us, if only to "defend" themselves in the manner we have "defended" ourselves, by going to their nations with our military, drones, et al.
 
It's a simple fact of nature, kill innocents and you create enemies. Whether it's the drones, or the so-called 'smart bombs', they're not any smarter than the human that puts them into action. And there is a high element of human error involved. So yes, I'd say drones are part of the problem, and I don't agree with them.

Yeah Wahbooz and we've seen how well an "eye for an eye" has worked between Israel and its neighbors, since the beginning of Israel's existence.

Apparently what was to be "clearly understood" in one of the largest declarations of support for "the establishment national home for the Jewish people" was either not clearly understood or purposefully ignored.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balfour_Declaration

And we have been drawn into and been included in the conflict that has ensued.
 
No, Knot,we went to Afghanistan because we were attacked,and that country was harboring those who attacked us.

We went to war with Iraq because a small group of Neocons led by Cheney and his thugs wanted to go to war.They lied, used every trick in the book to go.

President Obama pulled us out of that cess pool and is now trying to get us out of Afghanistan.

I despise all war and killing in our name,but if modern weapons get us out then I trust this President to do it the best way he can.
Sorry. I have no problem with you thinking different.
 
Doesn't Brokaw think that the invasions and 10+ year occupations of Afghanistan and Iraq might be a much greater factor in their motivation? Cons are more that happy, tho, to blame it on the drones only.

Cons have extremely short memories,Friday. Especially when remembering the actions they are responsible for,and those they cheered on!
 
Back
Top