New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Tom Brokaw

The former news anchor had this to say the other day:


I think that there’s something else that goes beyond the event that we’ve all been riveted by in the last week. We have to work a lot harder as a motivation here. What prompts a young man to come to this country and still feel alienated from it, to go back to Russia and do whatever he did—and I don’t think we’ve examined that enough? I mean, there was 24/7 coverage on television, a lot of newspaper print and so on, but we have got to look at the roots of all of this because it exists across the whole subcontinent, and the—and the Islamic world around the world. And I think we also have to examine the use of drones that the United States is involved—and there are a lot of civilians who are innocently killed in a drone attack in Pakistan, in Afghanistan, and in Iraq. And I can tell you having spent a lot of time over there, young people will come up to me on the streets and say, we love America, but if you harm one hair on the head of my sister, I will fight you forever and there is this enormous rage against what they see in that part of the world as a presumptuousness of the United States.


http://www.thenation.com/blog/17397...ia-cover-drone-warfare-factor-terror-attacks#



So, Mr. Brokaw is blaming Islamic rage on, at least in part, our use of drone warfare. This administration, of course, loves the drones. Is Brokaw right? Are drones part of the problem? Is our President doing the right thing or not?

I leave it to you.

I can tell you that if my daughter or wife were killed in a drone strike, it would radicalize me. Why should I expect any different from others?
 
I can tell you that if my daughter or wife were killed in a drone strike, it would radicalize me. Why should I expect any different from others?


That being the case, what do you think we should do about those drone strikes? What's the alternative?
 
Would you set up a backpack bomb next to an 8-year old child at a recreational event? I am curious as to just how conditional folks' humanity is...

Becoming "radicalized" is vague. What do you think would become morally acceptable to you? I am genuinely curious about this. And, if we turn it around, are we saying "it is only the fact that I have not been wronged that prevents me from X"?

Again, I'm not suggesting that we all go through life as Mary Poppins irrespective of what befalls us, but of what intentional, targeted atrocity are we capable? It seems to me that we are relegating morality to mere animalistic reflex - and worse.
 
If I have to explain that to you,and also why the Japanese were interred in the first place,it is clear you were not there,and are listening to revised history many times over.

In that period of time Japanese were hated with a passion,and they were not safe walking the streets. Do you think the Government locked those people up simply because they wanted to? If so,you do not know the attitude of the American people at that time.

When the 2 bombs went off,people cheered,not giving a thought to those who died! We only knew our men would come home safe!There would be no more Bataan Death marches by Japanese!

In my case,I only knew my Dad's group had won the war in Europe and he would not have to go fight the war in Japan!

Innocent people were killed in Iraq,just because a motley,little group,led by an ignorant bully wanted to attack!

You can spin it all you want,but we know better.
 
You avoid my question. Why did the Japaneses launch no terror attacks on this country after WWII?

I'm not spinning, I'm asking. You're not answering.
 
I think all of this stuff serves little purpose other than dilution of guilt. Again, I'm all for measured introspection/consideration of warmaking methods/targets. I am not in favor of explaining away atrocity.

One can't help wonder whether such introspection about disaffectation would occur had the bombers been the domestic 'anti-government teabaggers'. Do ya think pious observations and consideration of earlier life trauma would be in play?

Yeah - that's what I thought.
 
I think all of this stuff serves little purpose other than dilution of guilt. Again, I'm all for measured introspection/consideration of warmaking methods/targets. I am not in favor of explaining away atrocity.

One can't help wonder whether such introspection about disaffectation would occur had the bombers been the domestic 'anti-government teabaggers'. Do ya think pious observations and consideration of earlier life trauma would be in play?

Yeah - that's what I thought.



Great question. If they had been TEA Party members, would we be worried about what we did to make them angry? If not, why are these folks different?
 
Zam ,you try to win a war with the latest weapons. Drones are saving many of our young people's lives.

You cannot have it both ways,the same as what we had to do to end the big ones.I hear all the moans about innocents. I guess you just have to be there.twisted revisions do not cut it.

Brokaw may be a writer,but he never served .Just as I never served. We have to rely on those we elect,and right now I am truly glad we have a President in Office,who has us out of the lie of a war,and on the way out of the other.

If we could go back,I would wish Bush had listened to Clarke and maybe stopped9/11. but we cannot.
 
The former news anchor had this to say the other day:


I think that there’s something else that goes beyond the event that we’ve all been riveted by in the last week. We have to work a lot harder as a motivation here. What prompts a young man to come to this country and still feel alienated from it, to go back to Russia and do whatever he did—and I don’t think we’ve examined that enough? I mean, there was 24/7 coverage on television, a lot of newspaper print and so on, but we have got to look at the roots of all of this because it exists across the whole subcontinent, and the—and the Islamic world around the world. And I think we also have to examine the use of drones that the United States is involved—and there are a lot of civilians who are innocently killed in a drone attack in Pakistan, in Afghanistan, and in Iraq. And I can tell you having spent a lot of time over there, young people will come up to me on the streets and say, we love America, but if you harm one hair on the head of my sister, I will fight you forever and there is this enormous rage against what they see in that part of the world as a presumptuousness of the United States.


http://www.thenation.com/blog/17397...ia-cover-drone-warfare-factor-terror-attacks#



So, Mr. Brokaw is blaming Islamic rage on, at least in part, our use of drone warfare. This administration, of course, loves the drones. Is Brokaw right? Are drones part of the problem? Is our President doing the right thing or not?

I leave it to you.

I have only said what you have said here out loud to my family but have thought it often most lately. Queenie has said it over and over and I thought at the time.....all's fair in love and war but I am not so sure anymore. I think it is good to look ourselves straight in the eye.
 
Zam ,yo try to win a war with the latest weapons. Drones are saving many of our young people's lives.

You cannot have it both ways,the same as what we had to do to end the big ones.I hear all the moans about innocents. I guess you just have to be there.twisted revisions do not cut it.

Brokaw may be a writer,but he never served .Just as I never served. We have to rely on those we elect,and right now I am truly glad we have a President in Office,who has us out of the lie of a war,and on the way out of the other.

If we could go back,I would wish Bush had listened to Clarke and maybe stopped9/11. but we cannot.



You're still avoiding my question. Why?
 
there isn't one, it's them or us and if a GI is saved in the process then damn fine by me.

Thanks,Bru! On this one we agree! It is too easy to worry about the other side getting them.

We have them,they are saving the lives of ours.End of story! war is hell on all!
 
Right on,Knot! Of course it is easy to pretend it is fine for the US to attack a country we had no fight with,but God forbid the families of the dead get angry with us! How dare they?
 
Great post Knot.

I think the alternative is easy, just get out of every war we are in over there and let them fight their own.
 
What's interesting here is that Brokaw is positing a direct connection between this administration's reliance on drones and the resulting creation of new terrorists. Predictably, the reaction from the PJ liberals, who are sworn to protect Chicago Jesus at any and all costs, is to completely avoid that subject and attack "the right". Just like the left crucified Bob Woodward when he dared to momentarily step off the plantation, thus it will be done with Brokaw as well. This is why we are where we are...
 
I have only said what you have said here out loud to my family but have thought it often most lately. Queenie has said it over and over and I thought at the time.....all's fair in love and war but I am not so sure anymore. I think it is good to look ourselves straight in the eye.

Yes,Lily,instead of that,"we can do no wrong attitude! Our leaders have done a lot of wrong in our name! Going to war on trumped up lies is just the latest!
 
Thanks,Bru! On this one we agree! It is too easy to worry about the other side getting them.

We have them,they are saving the lives of ours.End of story! war is hell on all!

But MaryAnne, Guantanamo saved a few lives, would you agree with that.
 
it doesn't matter what any particular individuals morality would allow them to do once "radicalized", but rather whether there's any moral difference between what we do with drones and assorted other means to "eight year olds" and what those who'd choose ro consider "8 year olds" to be acceptable collateral damage as we collectively do. One needn't be willing to put an eight year old on top of a bomb to hatch it/kill them specifically to accept them as collateral damage as we do.

You aren't a statist that thinks morality is left outside of the statist door, are you, where animalistic reflexes (a one-way "eye for an eye" thing/good for the goose, not for the gander thing) are the norm in this case as opposed to the exception?
 
Back
Top