New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Tom Brokaw

Those that support drones usage do so until one is used against the U.S....

Also the usage of act of terror is to counter the usage of drones by our country...

Now before the monkey crap start flying please note that I do not condone the usage of terror to counter our usage of drones, but it does not surprise me...

The killing of innocent people so we can kill one person will turn more people into terrorists against us...

I know the drone supporters will not care about the innocent lives lost and some enjoy seeing a Muslim killed, but then cry when something like Boston happen...

So if we continue the usage of drones then expect the rise of act of terror on our soil...

Again this is not a endorsement for the usage of terror but just fact that in war we're not immune from hostile attacks on our soil, and if you disagree then you live with you head in the sand...

War is hell, and as long as we fight the war on terror we will see the battle brought to us on our own soil...
 
Actually, BOTH of those things matter, but Arkady spoke of his specific, individual tether that would be severed should his wife or kid fall victim - hence my drill down question. I am curious as to how tenuous our respective commitment to civilization is as individuals. That's why I asked.

I'd agree that your question is a valid one as well. Killing children is killing children. While certainly one can make the case that actively targeting a child is different than "collaterally killing" one, the child is nonetheless dead - and the remaining population is aggrieved. What this triggers in terms of abandonment of decency probably does vary by individual. Not all folks in war zones become terrorists. Some become passive haters of another country, but don't act on it. Some become sympathetic to unrepentent terrorists, but do not directly commit such acts. Some join the fight, but attack conventional military targets. While still others avail themselves of any means and methods to bring devastation to the other side.

In any case, I don't much care for a morality that is defined by how wronged the actor was/is.
 
That being the case, what do you think we should do about those drone strikes? What's the alternative?

I think they should be minimized. I think they should be viewed as having an enormous, hidden, indirect cost that comes in the form of radicalizing the friends and relatives of victims, and their wider community, so that they only get used in situations where the direct benefits are enormous. They may still be appropriate for targeting senior leaders of terrorist organizations in settings where collateral damage is expected to be minimal. But, this shouldn't be a widespread campaign. It should be done only in truly extraordinary cases.

Peter Bergen has said that under Bush there was an American drone attack in Pakistan every 43 days, compared to every four days during the first two years of the Obama administration (I'm not sure what the rate has been since then). I'd say that even under Bush they were being used excessively, but under Obama we're talking about an order of magnitude difference.

If we can reduce drone strikes to the point where people can believe there really were extraordinary and compelling circumstances calling for each and every such strike, the indirect damage can be minimized. Sure, those closest to the victims are still likely to be filled with rage, but the wider communities are more likely to blame the targets for any collateral damage, rather than the US. But if these things are happening hundreds of times per year, it will be seen as indiscriminate --as an arrogant foreign power killing people on a hair trigger because there's little cost to themselves. And that will radicalize a lot more people than those closest to the people killed.
 
I generally agree (and I share your previously stated concerns about detached, remote warmaking). Anything that anaesthetizes an awful thing brings with it the risk of making that thing more palateable.
 
Would you set up a backpack bomb next to an 8-year old child at a recreational event? I am curious as to just how conditional folks' humanity is...

Becoming "radicalized" is vague. What do you think would become morally acceptable to you? I am genuinely curious about this. And, if we turn it around, are we saying "it is only the fact that I have not been wronged that prevents me from X"?

Again, I'm not suggesting that we all go through life as Mary Poppins irrespective of what befalls us, but of what intentional, targeted atrocity are we capable? It seems to me that we are relegating morality to mere animalistic reflex - and worse.

No. I'm pretty sure I'd be much more focused in my revenge than that. I'm not at all trying to excuse the targeting of civilians... and especially children. I consider it inexcusable. But, "inexcusable" and "inexplicable" are two different things. I think that if American actions radicalize significant segments of large communities, that will including plenty of people with the seeds for psychopathic and sociopathic behavior. If we do so, we can expect more frequent attacks.
 
I'm not as interested in what people think of us as much as I am killing innocent people even if the case is extraordinary.
 
Great question. If they had been TEA Party members, would we be worried about what we did to make them angry? If not, why are these folks different?

If communities where Tea Partiers are in the majority had been targeted by hundreds of drone strikes, killing thousands, in an attempt to kill a few right-wing terrorists hiding in their midst, and the result were an uptick in Tea Party terrorism, would you be surprised? I wouldn't.
 
But MaryAnne, Guantanamo saved a few lives, would you agree with that.

Lily,not sure what that has to do with Drones, but Guantanamo needs to be closed down,and those left there given a trial or released. Is that what you are asking?
 
You avoid my question. Why did the Japaneses launch no terror attacks on this country after WWII?

I'm not spinning, I'm asking. You're not answering.


Yes,you are spinning.I answered why there were no terror attacks by Japanese.At that time in History Japanese would not have stood a chance. That is why they were interred.

In the war,many Germans had to cover the fact they were German. My Grandparents among them.Both from Hanover,Germany. My Grandfather was a successful farmer and carpenter. And they were white. Japanese could not hide.
 
well, as one who has long considered himself a citizen of the world first, and one who's trained in and had some practice at conflict resolution, I can say with confidence that one needn't make any moral judgments about the acts, etc, of like kind involved, but determining who the provocateur, etc, more often than not is, because the acknowledgement and acceptance of that plays an intregal role in the process of the just and proper assignment and apportioning of blame, and the same acknowledgement and acceptance of it by both parties that make the proposed resolutions to the conflict acceptable then to the parties involved. If the actions of the one party can be shown to have been unlikely but for those of the other, then that must be considered. If the bully doesn't want to get pounded into the dirt, then the solution for their plight is simple for the use of perhaps excessive force (making them guilty of that as even the law recognizes) on the part of their wouldbe victim -- quit bullying.

As long as we are droning in the form of "signature strikes" where we don't even know who the victims of them are, or droning those who come to rescue those bombed, and civilian losses of "eight year olds" occur, in the eyes of most of the world community we're gonna be seen as the bullies, leaving the cessation of our conduct of that kind as the first step towards a remedy for/resolution to the conflict it perpetuates.

It's not a question of who is more or less moral or guilty, but rather what behavior on whose part plays the greatest role in the perpetuation and increase of the threat to both parties. If you think drone use (or any military hardware use that results in such large civilian casualties) creates more terrorists than they can ever hope to kill, which side of this debate you fall on should be a no-brainer as a practical matter alone. That's why I've always thought it is as stupid as it is immoral.

That's the debate here, not the morality of either side, since they are both departing from it and always have.

have a good one -- gotta scoot
 
Lily,not sure what that has to do with Drones, but Guantanamo needs to be closed down,and those left there given a trial or released. Is that what you are asking?


I most always agree with you but

It was in reply to your posts about drones 'We have them,they are saving the lives of ours.End of story! war is hell on all!'

I feel we saved lives of ours with torture and I just wondered if you would agree with that. I agree war is hell though.
 
that is. Not what I am suggesting,or saying!

I am saying,the wars provided hate on the part of those affected by the self serving Bush gang!
 
that is. Not what I am suggesting,or saying!

I am saying,the wars provided hate on the part of those affected by the self serving Bush gang!

Can you at least try to be honest in admitting Obama has carried on and in some cases expanded virtually all the Bush-era foreign policies? Your denial kills your credibility. Trying to blame Boston on Bush just makes you look like a total ass...
 
You're still avoiding my question. Why?

Zammy, why should there be Japanese terrorists? They lost the war but won the peace and own as much, if not more, of America as Americans do. You don't think that the owners of Honda, Toyota, and Nissan, don't laugh about how they have conquered America without firing a shot? Their only competition in the US are the Chinese, not Americans.
 
Can you at least try to be honest in admitting Obama has carried on and in some cases expanded virtually all the Bush-era foreign policies? Your denial kills your credibility. Trying to blame Boston on Bush just makes you look like a total ass...

Trying to deny that Bush's policies had nothing to do with Boston is showing what a dumbass you are. Which administration allowed those two boys to come to America seeking "political asylum", who allowed them to stay even after their parents reurned to Russia? Hint...his name starts with B...
 
Trying to deny that Bush's policies had nothing to do with Boston is showing what a dumbass you are. Which administration allowed those two boys to come to America seeking "political asylum", who allowed them to stay even after their parents reurned to Russia? Hint...his name starts with B...

So you give no weight to the fact that Obama has continued all of these policies?
 
Back
Top