New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Two Americas

Informative read, brings another aspect into the discussion ,unions, re low wages and slow economic activity.
------------
News Analysis
Our Economic Pickle
excerpt
Wages have fallen to a record low as a share of America’s gross domestic product. Until 1975, wages nearly always accounted for more than 50 percent of the nation’s G.D.P., but last year wages fell to a record low of 43.5 percent. Since 2001, when the wage share was 49 percent, there has been a steep slide.
says Lawrence Katz, a labor economist at Harvard. “What we’re seeing now is very disquieting.” For the great bulk of workers, labor’s shrinking share is even worse than the statistics show, when one considers that a sizable — and growing — chunk of overall wages goes to the top 1 percent
snip ----
“We went almost a century where the labor share was pretty stable and we shared prosperity,” says Lawrence Katz, a labor economist at Harvard. “What we’re seeing now is very disquieting.”
MANY economists say the stubbornly high jobless rate and the declining power of labor unions are also important factors behind the declining wage share, reducing the leverage of workers to demand higher wages. Unions represent just 7 percent of workers in corporate America, one-quarter the level in the 1960s.

“There are very few occupations or industries where unions are strong enough where they can set standards,” says Lawrence Mishel, president of the Economic Policy Institute. “There are no standards being set, so companies can push down on wages for all workers, union and nonunion alike.” When the Detroit automakers secure two-tier contracts, that enables them to pay new hires $16 an hour, far less than the $28 an hour earned by longtime workers. This also pushes down labor’s share.
Pamela Waldron, a cashier at a KFC restaurant in Manhattan, earns $7.75 an hour after eight years on the job and says she last received a raise in 2007. “Being here eight years, I think I should be getting more,” she said. “You can fight for a raise, but I don’t think you’re going to get it.”

It is often thought that college graduates can escape these unfortunate wage trends. But college graduates — hit by the bursting of the tech bubble in the late 1990s and then by the deep recession — have been hit hard, too. Seventy percent of the nation’s college grads have had their after-inflation hourly wages decline since 2000, according to the Economic Policy Institute, with the typical graduate experiencing a 3.1 percent decline.
Jared Bernstein, who served in the Obama administration as executive director of the White House Task Force on the Middle Class, said many steps should be taken to increase labor’s income share, including raising the minimum wage, pushing down the jobless rate, enacting laws that make it easier for workers to unionize and increasing wage subsidies for those on the bottom. He also said the federal government, in spending hundreds of billions on health care, might insist that providers pay home-care aides or lab technicians $20 an hour rather than $10. “There’s no reason why a lab technician with a few years of community college shouldn’t be able to find her way into some segment of the middle class,” he said.
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/13/s...ductivity-climbs-but-wages-stagnate.html?_r=0

Yeah, unions. That was the heart of the Clinton economic success story! Oops, wait - no it wasn't...
 
Raising the minimum wage doesn't increase economic activity. Any positive economic effects are offset by job losses due to the development of technology to replace low skill jobs:

http://workbench.cadenhead.org/news/2906/next-outsourced-job-fast-food-order-taker

http://money.cnn.com/2014/05/22/technology/innovation/fast-food-robot/

http://www.qsrmagazine.com/exclusives/burgers-design

Raising employment levels and driving up median incomes through more economic opportunity does, however, tend to raise the price of entry level workers.

In fact the increase in minimum wage has not resulted in a much of a change in available jobs...it really depends on how large the change is. My first job was .75 per hour....and there are still the same number of people doing the job at the movie theater where I worked in 1968....

We'll be hiring at minimum wage and do raises from there. Obviously there are limits to what people will pay for fast food and limits to what our cost can be to produce.

From one of your links:
White Castle is using its kiosks as an adjunct to customer service, instead of reducing labor at the Columbus store. It has the same number of employees (40) as before the kiosk install.

Government does not create economic opportunity. The economic policies of the Obama administration have been more about softening the impact of the Bush recession...although the Green energy policy has had a positive effect on jobs in Colorado. Lending GM and Chrysler money saved a million jobs...but that was only intended to get them past the short term cash crisis....not create new opportunities.
 
I've heard complaints about being forced to give up MORE of their monies in order for di m/l ibs to provide more for their life-long victim-hood voter base, no doubt about that, but never about providing any assistance.

(Oh, and by the way, assistance and a living are 2 distinctly different things, that could also be something that is confusing you here, look into it, 'K?)

3/4 of those receiving cash benefits from the government (other than Social Security) are children. Only 1/2 of 1 percent of adults receive those benefits. The majority of people receiving these benefits live in a family where someone works. The majority exit the welfare rolls within 4 months.

Only 8 percent of those getting food stamps also get cash benefits. The MAXIMUM food stamp benefit is less than $2 per person per meal. 61 percent of those getting food stamps are children, elderly, or disabled. Another 20 percent work full-time. The majority of those getting food stamps are on the rolls for less than 10 months.

Life-long victimhood? Being handed a living? Hardly.
 
In fact the increase in minimum wage has not resulted in a much of a change in available jobs...it really depends on how large the change is. My first job was .75 per hour....and there are still the same number of people doing the job at the movie theater where I worked in 1968....

We'll be hiring at minimum wage and do raises from there. Obviously there are limits to what people will pay for fast food and limits to what our cost can be to produce.

From one of your links:
White Castle is using its kiosks as an adjunct to customer service, instead of reducing labor at the Columbus store. It has the same number of employees (40) as before the kiosk install.

Government does not create economic opportunity. The economic policies of the Obama administration have been more about softening the impact of the Bush recession...although the Green energy policy has had a positive effect on jobs in Colorado. Lending GM and Chrysler money saved a million jobs...but that was only intended to get them past the short term cash crisis....not create new opportunities.

There is plenty of research that supports the contention that increases in the minimum wage reduce the availability of entry level jobs. While you can also point to "research" that claims to support the counterfactual argument that it has no effect, most of those are rather flawed. No matter how bad you leftists hate the market, you simply cannot repeal the law of supply and demand. If you raise the cost of something, people will demand less of it. Period!

One anecdote doesn't eliminate the point of the articles I linked to - that unskilled labor will be replaced by technology, and the more expensive you make unskilled labor, the greater the propensity to replace it with technology. Your one White Castle example notwithstanding - it may be that they had an increase in business so they needed to shift the staffing from order taking to production, or that they plan on reducing the staffing over time by not replacing people who leave. It doesn't refute the point that the number of entry level jobs will be lower than it otherwise would have been if the minimum wage is raised.

And the fact remains that the current recovery was (and continues to be) the weakest on record, and the responsibility for that can be laid directly at the Obama Administration's anti-capitalist economic policies. And the reason we can do that? We saw the same sort of dragged out non-recovery during the 30's, when FDR was using the same big government, anti-market kinds of economic policies that Obama has employed.
 
There is plenty of research that supports the contention that increases in the minimum wage reduce the availability of entry level jobs. While you can also point to "research" that claims to support the counterfactual argument that it has no effect, most of those are rather flawed. No matter how bad you leftists hate the market, you simply cannot repeal the law of supply and demand. If you raise the cost of something, people will demand less of it. Period!

One anecdote doesn't eliminate the point of the articles I linked to - that unskilled labor will be replaced by technology, and the more expensive you make unskilled labor, the greater the propensity to replace it with technology. Your one White Castle example notwithstanding - it may be that they had an increase in business so they needed to shift the staffing from order taking to production, or that they plan on reducing the staffing over time by not replacing people who leave. It doesn't refute the point that the number of entry level jobs will be lower than it otherwise would have been if the minimum wage is raised.

And the fact remains that the current recovery was (and continues to be) the weakest on record, and the responsibility for that can be laid directly at the Obama Administration's anti-capitalist economic policies. And the reason we can do that? We saw the same sort of dragged out non-recovery during the 30's, when FDR was using the same big government, anti-market kinds of economic policies that Obama has employed.

Plenty of research, as well as real world scenarios, indicate the opposite.



...Real world evidence also plays out this way. When economists looked at state-level minimum wage increases over two decades, they didn’t find any evidence to support the idea that they hurt jobs, even during times of high unemployment. Five other studies did similar analyses and found the same thing. States with higher minimum wages have also experienced above-average job growth.

While the majority of states have higher minimum wages than the federal floor of $7.25,none has gone so far as to raise it to $15 an hour. Some cities, such as Seattle, are experimenting with wages at that level, and others could follow...

http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2015/01/23/3615049/fast-food-15-minimum-wage/
 
Plenty of research, as well as real world scenarios, indicate the opposite.



...Real world evidence also plays out this way. When economists looked at state-level minimum wage increases over two decades, they didn’t find any evidence to support the idea that they hurt jobs, even during times of high unemployment. Five other studies did similar analyses and found the same thing. States with higher minimum wages have also experienced above-average job growth.

While the majority of states have higher minimum wages than the federal floor of $7.25,none has gone so far as to raise it to $15 an hour. Some cities, such as Seattle, are experimenting with wages at that level, and others could follow...

http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2015/01/23/3615049/fast-food-15-minimum-wage/

Think Progress? Well that settles it - they certainly would never use a biased argument. Oops, wait a minute - yes they would.

You simply cannot use state minimum wage increase effects as a proxy for what would happen in the event of a national increase. The fact of the matter is that the predominant users of minimum wage jobs are fast food joints. They typically use a standard (national) staffing model and require franchisees everywhere to follow it. If one or even a few states raise their minimum wage, the industry isn't going to put the effort and investment into reducing staffing that they will if the national minimum wage increases. Same goes for car wash equipment manufacturers, etc. So you will naturally get an inherent bias in favor of the counterfactual that it "has no measurable effect" in any study that looks only at state (or local) minimum wage increases and then extrapolates those findings to a national minimum wage increase.

In 2006 David Neumark and William Wascher published a comprehensive review of more than 100 minimum wage studies published since the 1990s.30 They found a wider range of estimates of the effects of the minimum wage on employment than the 1982 review by Brown, Gilroy, and Kohen. The 2006 review found that "although the wide range of estimates is striking, the oft-stated assertion that the new minimum wage research fails to support the traditional view that the minimum wage reduces the employment of low-wage workers is clearly incorrect. Indeed . . . the preponderance of the evidence points to disemployment effects."31

http://www.downsizinggovernment.org/labor/negative-effects-minimum-wage-laws#5
 
Think Progress? Well that settles it - they certainly would never use a biased argument. Oops, wait a minute - yes they would.

You simply cannot use state minimum wage increase effects as a proxy for what would happen in the event of a national increase. The fact of the matter is that the predominant users of minimum wage jobs are fast food joints. They typically use a standard (national) staffing model and require franchisees everywhere to follow it. If one or even a few states raise their minimum wage, the industry isn't going to put the effort and investment into reducing staffing that they will if the national minimum wage increases. Same goes for car wash equipment manufacturers, etc. So you will naturally get an inherent bias in favor of the counterfactual that it "has no measurable effect" in any study that looks only at state (or local) minimum wage increases and then extrapolates those findings to a national minimum wage increase.

In 2006 David Neumark and William Wascher published a comprehensive review of more than 100 minimum wage studies published since the 1990s.30 They found a wider range of estimates of the effects of the minimum wage on employment than the 1982 review by Brown, Gilroy, and Kohen. The 2006 review found that "although the wide range of estimates is striking, the oft-stated assertion that the new minimum wage research fails to support the traditional view that the minimum wage reduces the employment of low-wage workers is clearly incorrect. Indeed . . . the preponderance of the evidence points to disemployment effects."31

http://www.downsizinggovernment.org/labor/negative-effects-minimum-wage-laws#5

Nothing is as useless as an immediate attack on the source. Don't be so [Unwelcome language removed] lame.

Economists Robert Pollin and Jeannette Wicks-Lim of the University of Massachusetts-Amherst...
 
Think Progress? Well that settles it - they certainly would never use a biased argument. Oops, wait a minute - yes they would.

You simply cannot use state minimum wage increase effects as a proxy for what would happen in the event of a national increase. The fact of the matter is that the predominant users of minimum wage jobs are fast food joints. They typically use a standard (national) staffing model and require franchisees everywhere to follow it. If one or even a few states raise their minimum wage, the industry isn't going to put the effort and investment into reducing staffing that they will if the national minimum wage increases. Same goes for car wash equipment manufacturers, etc. So you will naturally get an inherent bias in favor of the counterfactual that it "has no measurable effect" in any study that looks only at state (or local) minimum wage increases and then extrapolates those findings to a national minimum wage increase.

In 2006 David Neumark and William Wascher published a comprehensive review of more than 100 minimum wage studies published since the 1990s.30 They found a wider range of estimates of the effects of the minimum wage on employment than the 1982 review by Brown, Gilroy, and Kohen. The 2006 review found that "although the wide range of estimates is striking, the oft-stated assertion that the new minimum wage research fails to support the traditional view that the minimum wage reduces the employment of low-wage workers is clearly incorrect. Indeed . . . the preponderance of the evidence points to disemployment effects."31

http://www.downsizinggovernment.org/labor/negative-effects-minimum-wage-laws#5


Here's the paper...Screech about the findings.

http://www.peri.umass.edu/fileadmin/pdf/working_papers/working_papers_351-400/WP373.pdf

http://www.peri.umass.edu/236/hash/6e68011c89cf49f210e4183f49b8f735/publication/643/
 
Last edited:
Nothing is as useless as an immediate attack on the source. Don't be so [Unwelcome language removed] lame.

Economists Robert Pollin and Jeannette Wicks-Lim of the University of Massachusetts-Amherst...

Wasn't "attacking" them. I merely observed that they would be looking for any study that supports their political position regardless of its inherent bias, is all. Boston or Berkley, whatever - all you are gonna find there is anti-capitalist biased research.
 
Wasn't "attacking" them. I merely observed that they would be looking for any study that supports their political position regardless of its inherent bias, is all. Boston or Berkley, whatever - all you are gonna find there is anti-capitalist biased research.

It was your first comment. It was entirely unworthy of you.

Your bias is not allowing you to read the paper.

Putting money into the hands of the workers is not anti capitalist.
 

If you accept their "set of reasonable assumptions" then bully for you. I don't. They assume a $4700 "cost" for every employee the fast food joint has to replace and use that to offset the higher wages (by assuming it will reduce turnover). I think that number is complete horse shit...
 
It was your first comment. It was entirely unworthy of you.

Your bias is not allowing you to read the paper.

Putting money into the hands of the workers is not anti capitalist.

It is when it is accomplished by the large fist of the federal government being jammed into the pockets of the small business owners.
 
If you accept their "set of reasonable assumptions" then bully for you. I don't. They assume a $4700 "cost" for every employee the fast food joint has to replace and use that to offset the higher wages (by assuming it will reduce turnover). I think that number is complete horse shit...

What do you think the number is?
 
It is when it is accomplished by the large fist of the federal government being jammed into the pockets of the small business owners.

Fast food is hardly "small business"...

More money in the hands of workers gives them more purchasing power which means more money for the "capitalists"...

Henry Ford knew this...you don't seem to.
 
What do you think the number is?

Less than $500. If it were anything approaching $5000 do you really think not one restaurant owner in America would have figured that out by now and raised their pay scale? It's a complete farce of an assumption, but just the sort of thing you would expect from left wing academic economists who have likely never seen the inside of a fast food joint (let alone had to meet its payroll).
 
Less than $500. If it were anything approaching $5000 do you really think not one restaurant owner in America would have figured that out by now and raised their pay scale? It's a complete farce of an assumption, but just the sort of thing you would expect from left wing academic economists who have likely never seen the inside of a fast food joint (let alone had to meet its payroll).

How do reach the conclusion that employee turnover comes at basically no cost?

I can find nothing to support that assertion...


The following is a comprehensive checklist of items to include when calculating the cost of turnover in any organization. To determine the costs, have the hourly and weekly cost of fully loaded payroll costs (i.e. salary plus benefits) of the vacant position, the management staff, the recruitment staff and others as outlined below.

It should be noted that the costs of time and lost productivity are no less important or real than the costs associated with paying cash to vendors for services such as advertising or temporary staff. These are all very real costs to the employer.

These calculations will easily reach 150% of the employees annual compensation figure. The cost will be significantly higher (200% to 250% of annual compensation) for managerial and sales positions.

To put this into perspective, let's assume the average salary of employees in a given company is $50,000 per year. Taking the cost of turnover at 150% of salary, the cost of turnover is then $75,000 per employee who leaves the company. For the mid-sized company of 1,000 employees who has a 10% annual rate of turnover, the annual cost of turnover is $7.5 million!

Do you know any CEO who would not want to add $7.5 million to their revenue? And, by the way, most of that figure would be carried over to the profit line as well. What about the company with 10,000 employees? The cost of turnover equals $75 million!...


http://www.isquare.com/turnover.cfm


There are many more such articles disputing your cost.
 
Fast food is hardly "small business"...

More money in the hands of workers gives them more purchasing power which means more money for the "capitalists"...

Henry Ford knew this...you don't seem to.

As we’ve seen the rise in the daily wage was from $2.25 to $5 (including the bonuses etc). Say 240 working days in the year and 14,000 workers and we get a rise in the pay bill of $9 1/4 million over the year. A Model T cost between $550 and $450 (depends on which year we’re talking about). 14,000 cars sold at that price gives us $7 3/4 million to $6 1/4 million in income to the company.

It should be obvious that paying the workforce an extra $9 million so that they can then buy $7 million’s worth of company production just isn’t a way to increase your profits. It’s a great way to increase your losses though.


http://www.forbes.com/sites/timwors...y-fords-5-a-day-wages-its-not-what-you-think/

I thought you were above using discredited memes to make debate points...
 
Less than $500. If it were anything approaching $5000 do you really think not one restaurant owner in America would have figured that out by now and raised their pay scale? It's a complete farce of an assumption, but just the sort of thing you would expect from left wing academic economists who have likely never seen the inside of a fast food joint (let alone had to meet its payroll).

cough cough

...Because of our low turnover, and the fact that people are really into their jobs, $15 an hour wasn't a big stretch," Parker says.

Parker says there are savings in not having to constantly train new hires, and his workers are empowered because they're given so much responsibility.



http://www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/20...oint-pays-15-an-hour-and-yes-its-making-money
 
Less than $500. If it were anything approaching $5000 do you really think not one restaurant owner in America would have figured that out by now and raised their pay scale? It's a complete farce of an assumption, but just the sort of thing you would expect from left wing academic economists who have likely never seen the inside of a fast food joint (let alone had to meet its payroll).
cough cough...

Packhouse Meats, a restaurant that opened in Newport, Kentucky in January, doesn’t allow tipping. Instead, it pays its employees a decent wage.

Servers at the restaurant make a minimum wage of $10 an hour. But they can also make 20 percent of their sales in commission — which is based on sales volume, the quality of service, and a few other factors — if it’s higher than that wage. This means that, on average, the servers are making $15 an hour. “Ten dollars an hour becomes a safety net,” explained owner Bob Conway. “When you come in and it’s dead, or you’re working through the middle of the afternoon and we don’t really have any business,” that $10 might kick in...

http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2014/06/10/3446937/packhouse-meats-tips/
 
As we’ve seen the rise in the daily wage was from $2.25 to $5 (including the bonuses etc). Say 240 working days in the year and 14,000 workers and we get a rise in the pay bill of $9 1/4 million over the year. A Model T cost between $550 and $450 (depends on which year we’re talking about). 14,000 cars sold at that price gives us $7 3/4 million to $6 1/4 million in income to the company.

It should be obvious that paying the workforce an extra $9 million so that they can then buy $7 million’s worth of company production just isn’t a way to increase your profits. It’s a great way to increase your losses though.


http://www.forbes.com/sites/timwors...y-fords-5-a-day-wages-its-not-what-you-think/

I thought you were above using discredited memes to make debate points...

Actually, it was the turnover of his staff.

Minimal training/turnover costs?
 
Back
Top