New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Two Americas

How do reach the conclusion that employee turnover comes at basically no cost?

I can find nothing to support that assertion...


The following is a comprehensive checklist of items to include when calculating the cost of turnover in any organization. To determine the costs, have the hourly and weekly cost of fully loaded payroll costs (i.e. salary plus benefits) of the vacant position, the management staff, the recruitment staff and others as outlined below.

It should be noted that the costs of time and lost productivity are no less important or real than the costs associated with paying cash to vendors for services such as advertising or temporary staff. These are all very real costs to the employer.

These calculations will easily reach 150% of the employees annual compensation figure. The cost will be significantly higher (200% to 250% of annual compensation) for managerial and sales positions.

To put this into perspective, let's assume the average salary of employees in a given company is $50,000 per year. Taking the cost of turnover at 150% of salary, the cost of turnover is then $75,000 per employee who leaves the company. For the mid-sized company of 1,000 employees who has a 10% annual rate of turnover, the annual cost of turnover is $7.5 million!

Do you know any CEO who would not want to add $7.5 million to their revenue? And, by the way, most of that figure would be carried over to the profit line as well. What about the company with 10,000 employees? The cost of turnover equals $75 million!...


http://www.isquare.com/turnover.cfm


There are many more such articles disputing your cost.

Yes, because obviously the cost of replacing the Director of Sales in a mid-sized corporation is completely analogous to replacing a fast food order taker. Come on Craig, you are smart enough to come up with a more applicable counter argument. Again, if that is indeed the cost, are the fast food industry managers just too stupid to figure this out and raise wages on their own? Most of these fast food jobs have come down to dumping pre-measured ingredients into color coded containers and punching a certain button (also color coded) to get that item onto the tray. Do you really think it takes a lot of time and effort to replace those "skills?"
 
Actually, it was the turnover of his staff.

Minimal training/turnover costs?

Exactly!!! And he figured it out and made the adjustment without the government having to force him to. Do you think the average modern day management scientist employed by McDonalds is just too stupid to see what Ford saw?
 
Yes, because obviously the cost of replacing the Director of Sales in a mid-sized corporation is completely analogous to replacing a fast food order taker. Come on Craig, you are smart enough to come up with a more applicable counter argument. Again, if that is indeed the cost, are the fast food industry managers just too stupid to figure this out and raise wages on their own? Most of these fast food jobs have come down to dumping pre-measured ingredients into color coded containers and punching a certain button (also color coded) to get that item onto the tray. Do you really think it takes a lot of time and effort to replace those "skills?"

I believe it takes time to find employees no matter their station. I think it takes time to train employees, no matter the station.

A "sales manager" shouldn't need any training. They talk...and have tons of experience. One at that level should already be intimate with the company's products when they take on the job of director.

And...there is but one director, as opposed to a staff of perhaps 100 part timers...

Who am I to believe? The people in the business, or you?
 
Exactly!!! And he figured it out and made the adjustment without the government having to force him to. Do you think the average modern day management scientist employed by McDonalds is just too stupid to see what Ford saw?
Apparently they are, as they have yet to raise wages to keep training and turnover costs down.
 
cough cough...

Packhouse Meats, a restaurant that opened in Newport, Kentucky in January, doesn’t allow tipping. Instead, it pays its employees a decent wage.

Servers at the restaurant make a minimum wage of $10 an hour. But they can also make 20 percent of their sales in commission — which is based on sales volume, the quality of service, and a few other factors — if it’s higher than that wage. This means that, on average, the servers are making $15 an hour. “Ten dollars an hour becomes a safety net,” explained owner Bob Conway. “When you come in and it’s dead, or you’re working through the middle of the afternoon and we don’t really have any business,” that $10 might kick in...

http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2014/06/10/3446937/packhouse-meats-tips/

It's a different business model! In and Out pays above minimum wages voluntarily because they want to minimize turnover. Their business model is built on a more interactive process to produce a higher quality meal. Other chains build their model on keeping skill levels low to keep prices low and make money through higher volumes. This idea that you lefties get to make all the management decisions for every business in the US is precisely why the Obama "recovery" is so abjectly tepid.
 
It's a different business model! In and Out pays above minimum wages voluntarily because they want to minimize turnover. Their business model is built on a more interactive process to produce a higher quality meal. Other chains build their model on keeping skill levels low to keep prices low and make money through higher volumes. This idea that you lefties get to make all the management decisions for every business in the US is precisely why the Obama "recovery" is so abjectly tepid.
Yes...it is a different business model.

You asked for ONE restaurant...and I gave you two.
 
Or you have completely misunderestimated their training and turnover costs...
Or you have.

...Even cutting the turnover rate, which matches the industry average, by a few percentage points would reduce the millions of dollars the restaurant chain spends annually on training. McDonald's declined to divulge how much it spends on training new hires.

But King, in a dubious claim of distinction considering the high turnover rate, said, "We train more people than the U.S. Army."...

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/...140540_1_restaurants-turnover-rate-karen-king
 
Yes...it is a different business model.

You asked for ONE restaurant...and I gave you two.

I never asked for anecdotes, that's for sure. One or two restaurants hardly "proves" that the managers of the fast food industry, who employ an army of management scientists to improve operations (and bottom lines) are just too stupid to see the piles of their money that keep walking out the back door every time some pimple faced 16 year old who is chronically late and calls off sick when his girlfriend's parents go out for the night up and quits on them.
 
Or you have.

...Even cutting the turnover rate, which matches the industry average, by a few percentage points would reduce the millions of dollars the restaurant chain spends annually on training. McDonald's declined to divulge how much it spends on training new hires.

But King, in a dubious claim of distinction considering the high turnover rate, said, "We train more people than the U.S. Army."...

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/...140540_1_restaurants-turnover-rate-karen-king

Yes, and so we get back to the Henry Ford argument where increasing the costs for every man hour, costing tens of millions of dollars, simply to reduce turnover costs by a few million a year is a good way to lose money. If the costs of turnover are sufficient to warrant higher wages, the fast food industry hardly needs your elbow in their back in order to increase the wages of their workers. Your entire argument defeats itself.
 
I never asked for anecdotes, that's for sure. One or two restaurants hardly "proves" that the managers of the fast food industry, who employ an army of management scientists to improve operations (and bottom lines) are just too stupid to see the piles of their money that keep walking out the back door every time some pimple faced 16 year old who is chronically late and calls off sick when his girlfriend's parents go out for the night up and quits on them.
Yes...you did ask for anecdotes...

If it were anything approaching $5000 do you really think not one restaurant owner in America would have figured that out by now and raised their pay scale?

At least two owners figured it out...

Right...a 16 year old walks out and hurts productivity. A new employee needs to be found...and trained.
 
Or you have.

...Even cutting the turnover rate, which matches the industry average, by a few percentage points would reduce the millions of dollars the restaurant chain spends annually on training. McDonald's declined to divulge how much it spends on training new hires.

But King, in a dubious claim of distinction considering the high turnover rate, said, "We train more people than the U.S. Army."...

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/...140540_1_restaurants-turnover-rate-karen-king

Despite rising wages, flexible schedules and even health insurance, the revolving door is turning faster than ever.

Oops, maybe you better head back over to the drawing board...
 
Yes, and so we get back to the Henry Ford argument where increasing the costs for every man hour, costing tens of millions of dollars, simply to reduce turnover costs by a few million a year is a good way to lose money. If the costs of turnover are sufficient to warrant higher wages, the fast food industry hardly needs your elbow in their back in order to increase the wages of their workers. Your entire argument defeats itself.
You posted the article trying to tell me it wasn't about purchasing power. I read the article and it said it was about the very high cost of turnover.

You don't seem to think it is about either.
 
There is plenty of research that supports the contention that increases in the minimum wage reduce the availability of entry level jobs. While you can also point to "research" that claims to support the counterfactual argument that it has no effect, most of those are rather flawed. No matter how bad you leftists hate the market, you simply cannot repeal the law of supply and demand. If you raise the cost of something, people will demand less of it. Period!

One anecdote doesn't eliminate the point of the articles I linked to - that unskilled labor will be replaced by technology, and the more expensive you make unskilled labor, the greater the propensity to replace it with technology. Your one White Castle example notwithstanding - it may be that they had an increase in business so they needed to shift the staffing from order taking to production, or that they plan on reducing the staffing over time by not replacing people who leave. It doesn't refute the point that the number of entry level jobs will be lower than it otherwise would have been if the minimum wage is raised.

And the fact remains that the current recovery was (and continues to be) the weakest on record, and the responsibility for that can be laid directly at the Obama Administration's anti-capitalist economic policies. And the reason we can do that? We saw the same sort of dragged out non-recovery during the 30's, when FDR was using the same big government, anti-market kinds of economic policies that Obama has employed.

Speaking of counter factual....What policies of Reagan's led to a recovery? He lowered taxes and raised federal spending....His stimulus program amounted to about $3 trillion and was mostly money spent on defense....he bought tanks, ships, planes....unemployment didn't recover for 6 years.

Hoover did nothing....and his unemployment rate grew to 25% from 1929 to 1933. What country can you point to in 1929 that came out of the depression earlier than the US did and without government policies much the same as FDR's? What was the result of Reagan's S&L deregulation? Hmmm....a recession! Massive theft as federal oversight was eliminated, made billions disapear.

Name one single policy of Obama's that is anti-capital or anti-market....You probably think that intervention to save GM is an example....Certainly the bond holders lost money...but then investing is always a risk. They'd have lost money if GM went chapter 7 as well. That would have put 1 million people out of work. Obama made use of capital to keep them alive by buying stock in the new GM. He didn't fix prices. He didn't guarantee their profits. You know who the people were who were most pissed about GM staying afloat? People who had bought naked swaps or sold their stock short. They bet that the company would fail and it didn't.

This recession and the one in 1981 were the real impetus behind a permanent loss of jobs. I saw more outsourcing and offshorting then than in any time of my career. There was a huge push towards tech as a replacement for employees....If a change in minimum wages is gradual and incremental then there is far less of a change in the number of employees making minimum wage. I'm building a fast food restaurant....the first one will employ 30 to 35 people. As long as every other fast food outlet has to pay the same entry level rate then I'll still be competitive.

I'll agree that it is nuts to think that there is a career to be had for the average driver or cook at our restaurant.....For people to argue that they should make $35k or $40k is crazy....potential customers will simply stay home and cook their own dinner. Raising the rate from $7.25 to $9 over the next five years would not create a problem for us.
 
Speaking of counter factual....What policies of Reagan's led to a recovery? He lowered taxes and raised federal spending....His stimulus program amounted to about $3 trillion and was mostly money spent on defense....he bought tanks, ships, planes....unemployment didn't recover for 6 years.

Hoover did nothing....and his unemployment rate grew to 25% from 1929 to 1933. What country can you point to in 1929 that came out of the depression earlier than the US did and without government policies much the same as FDR's? What was the result of Reagan's S&L deregulation? Hmmm....a recession! Massive theft as federal oversight was eliminated, made billions disapear.

Name one single policy of Obama's that is anti-capital or anti-market....You probably think that intervention to save GM is an example....Certainly the bond holders lost money...but then investing is always a risk. They'd have lost money if GM went chapter 7 as well. That would have put 1 million people out of work. Obama made use of capital to keep them alive by buying stock in the new GM. He didn't fix prices. He didn't guarantee their profits. You know who the people were who were most pissed about GM staying afloat? People who had bought naked swaps or sold their stock short. They bet that the company would fail and it didn't.

This recession and the one in 1981 were the real impetus behind a permanent loss of jobs. I saw more outsourcing and offshorting then than in any time of my career. There was a huge push towards tech as a replacement for employees....If a change in minimum wages is gradual and incremental then there is far less of a change in the number of employees making minimum wage. I'm building a fast food restaurant....the first one will employ 30 to 35 people. As long as every other fast food outlet has to pay the same entry level rate then I'll still be competitive.

I'll agree that it is nuts to think that there is a career to be had for the average driver or cook at our restaurant.....For people to argue that they should make $35k or $40k is crazy....potential customers will simply stay home and cook their own dinner. Raising the rate from $7.25 to $9 over the next five years would not create a problem for us.

Your entire repertoire consists of Democrat talking points. You seem to believe that if a Republican does the same thing as a Democrat, the Democrat's efforts will succeed while the Republican's are doomed to failure, simply because of the letter that sits behind their name. That's not how it works. Reagan and Clinton both spoke of the detrimental economic effects of a big government, social welfare, demand focused approach, setting the stage for investors to view investments as being potentially more valuable in such a future environment. They both sought to rein in the exploding cost of entitlements and anti-market regulations, and also supported the central bank's strong currency policies. And in both instances we enjoyed robust economic growth, featuring widespread economic opportunity and rising median incomes. It doesn't matter that they were from different parties - they had similar policy agendas.

Raising the minimum wage isn't the problem. Clinton did so without detrimental effect, due to his market friendly economic policies. Doing so in a slow growing economy that isn't creating enough jobs is the problem. The left seems to believe their efforts to raise the costs of employing people, dealing with increased regulations and tax compliance is the way to build a strong economy. One look at the Reagan/Clinton economic model shows exactly how silly that viewpoint is.
 
Does employee turnover cost?

Sure it does. But it does not cost $4700 to replace an unskilled minimum wage worker. The cost is a function of the skill level required.

Frankly, the cost that is involved is also a function of the over regulation of labor markets and the complexity of the (federal, state and local) tax codes.
 
Yes...you did ask for anecdotes...

If it were anything approaching $5000 do you really think not one restaurant owner in America would have figured that out by now and raised their pay scale?

At least two owners figured it out...

Right...a 16 year old walks out and hurts productivity. A new employee needs to be found...and trained.

How much training is involved in hiring a kid for a low skill job? I can guarantee you it isn't $4700....
 
Sure it does. But it does not cost $4700 to replace an unskilled minimum wage worker. The cost is a function of the skill level required.

Frankly, the cost that is involved is also a function of the over regulation of labor markets and the complexity of the (federal, state and local) tax codes.

But it also does not cost $500. These economists...not me...came up with that figure. You've done nothing to prove it incorrect.

It seems to me it costs more to train an unskilled worker than skilled ones. The skilled one already have the skills.
 
How much training is involved in hiring a kid for a low skill job? I can guarantee you it isn't $4700....

Merely saying so isn't a convincing argument.

Again...that figure is not mine. You tossed out $500...and there is nothing to back that figure.

I am prone to believe the authors of the study over one known to be rather partisan on the other side of the coin...
 
Back
Top