New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Two Facts

Zam, the fact is you DON'T pay Detroit teachers more, they get less than the rest of the teachers in Michigan. Let's understand that, unless you disagree and want to argue that issue with me.
 
You seem to be talking to yourself here, Doubter. Could you give us a clue by quotation or looking at the threaded view when you reply as to the identity of the poster you are talking to? I've read the other posts made directly to your top post and I can't tell who you are talking to.

Two variables with no demonstrated correlation. Yet, you still draw a conclusion. Hmm.
 
So what is the purpose of your post, Zam, if you don't have an answer? You say it's not a lambasting of Detroit teachers, but yet you do not seem to put forth what it is about. You comment about doubling the salaries of Detroit teachers has me wondering if you have some sort of fear this is something in the works, and so you have to stem the possibility of it. I know of no one who is suggesting, or even asking for the salaries of Detroit teachers to be doubled.

While part of the problem lies with the teachers, and part with the system, a large part lies with the students themselves. As I've already pointed out, this problem is all across the state of Michigan, and not just in Detroit. This problem is all across the country, and not just Michigan. So I really do not comprehend the purpose of bringing up teacher salaries in Detroit, especially since Detroit teachers salaries lags behind the rest of the state.
 
And for projects to be shovel ready, those in charge must stop dragging their feet, and digging their heels in. Across the country it seemed that those states that did not have shovel ready projects were Republican.
 
I think most people are aware of the vast differences between public and private schools, and no one reasonably expects them to work at the same level. That said, 7% is, I believe most would agree, atrocious for any institution, public or private. If we accept that, shame on us.

I think it is interesting to hear boards of directors of corporations, many of them CEOs and upper management of companies themselves, justify 7, even 8 figure compensation packages for the heads of their companies to investors. Somehow they are not only "well worth" the money, but if they would not pay the money, they would not get "the best" people for the job.

As far as proficiency levels go....and not just in one place in the U.S.?
http://www.studentsfirst.org/pages/the-stats

Yes, "shame on us". Your solution is what? Less money? Private schooling for everyone?
 
I think it is interesting to hear boards of directors of corporations, many of them CEOs and upper management of companies themselves, justify 7, even 8 figure compensation packages for the heads of their companies to investors. Somehow they are not only "well worth" the money, but if they would not pay the money, they would not get "the best" people for the job.

As far as proficiency levels go....and not just in one place in the U.S.?
http://www.studentsfirst.org/pages/the-stats

Yes, "shame on us". Your solution is what? Less money? Private schooling for everyone?



If private enterprise throws there money around foolishly, that's their business. If public taxpayer money is thrown around foolishly, however, that's our business.


As I have posted earlier in this thread, I don't have a perfect one-size-fit-all solution for the mess that is the Public School System in Detroit. It does seem obvious, however, that doing what we've been doing isn't producing good results. We may need to shake up the Status Quo there and try something different. Simply shrugging our shoulders and saying "Oh well, that's just too bad" isn't going to help.
 
If private enterprise throws there money around foolishly, that's their business. If public taxpayer money is thrown around foolishly, however, that's our business.


As I have posted earlier in this thread, I don't have a perfect one-size-fit-all solution for the mess that is the Public School System in Detroit. It does seem obvious, however, that doing what we've been doing isn't producing good results. We may need to shake up the Status Quo there and try something different. Simply shrugging our shoulders and saying "Oh well, that's just too bad" isn't going to help.

You might be different, but anyone that throws around money foolishly, regardless of it occurring in the private sector or in government, is MY business.

You might have noted and recall the discussion and debate about the government bailing out those "throwing around money foolishly" in the private sector who contributed to the failed economy. The notion that there are somehow separate "states", one being "government" and one being the "private sector" or "individuals" and "society" for the purposes of pitting them against one another or in competition with one another seems to demonstrate a lack of thought and understanding of the interrelationships between most anything in the world, least of all governments and the societies they govern, but are also represented and in some respects, governed by.

The most functional "government" "for the people" is one where people have the most choice in the say of their destiny. How many corporations or families run that way? Logistically it would be next to impossible for any population over a certain number to make use of direct direct democratic means to decide every law of their governance, thus a representative democracy comes in as a workable alternative. In the system we have, there is a mechanism for us to have a choice in who will represent us and as that representation flows to the highest body, the "majority" is reflected. Thus while we might vote for whom and what we desire to represent us, even be successful in electing someone who represents us in every way, that does not necessarily reflect or represent the greater body of representatives elected.

If you can think up a better system than the one we live under, then I imagine there are many many ears, willing to listen. Dictatorships being easier have been joked about as being true, for the dictators and all who agree with them, but in all societies, there are a variety of people all of whom want to control their own destinies and many of them conflict with one another, especially the larger the population. To be absolutely free of government and restriction on one's life from other humans, one must isolate themselves from anything that would connect them in any way to any cooperation between themselves and another human. Even then, nature (the environment) would govern their struggle to survive within it. While they might be "free" to fish every last fish out of a fertile fishing hole, they are aslo "free" to cooperate with nature and benefit from taking only what they need and leaving the fishing hole fertile so they do not need to move on seeking another to exploit and decimate. You can decide which is the more intelligent and "conservative" action.

I no more want to pay for a billionaire's lavish lifestyle while they whine about how much they have to pay the employees they hire that support their millionaire, billionaire lifestyle, than I want support someone who is capable of supporting themselves. That would be assuming they are paid by a millionaire of billionaire, what is reasonably sufficient for them to claim that are truly "supporting" themselves or their family, while their 7 and 8 figure "bosses" jet set themselves and their families around the world ''for fun" and "entertainment" all supported and paid for by the casts of thousands that some billionaires and millionaires claim "make too much".

If you don't like your government representatives, don't vote for them or leave the country. Just the same, if you don't like management reneging on what they agreed to pay you as part of a mutual employee, employer agreement (yes, that is different than buying people to own as property and free laborers for as long as one likes or even "buying" them as indentured laborers based on the obvious abuses that have been demonstrated)

A right to "strike" a corporate management is no less a means to "protest" than the same to "protest" the management of the nation by an opportunity to vote that management out if one dislikes it. People can quit their nation or quit their jobs also.

The challenge faced in both circumstances is finding a replacement.


With regard to the problems in Detroit and elsewhere, I don't know anyone who is saying "oh well, that's the way it is", therefore we don't need to do anything and proof of that is your complaint that people are asking for more money to do something more.
 
You might be different, but anyone that throws around money foolishly, regardless of it occurring in the private sector or in government, is MY business.

Fine. Feel free to let those CEOs and CFOs how you think money should be allocated. I'm sure they'll take it under advisement.
 
I think it is interesting to hear boards of directors of corporations, many of them CEOs and upper management of companies themselves, justify 7, even 8 figure compensation packages for the heads of their companies to investors. Somehow they are not only "well worth" the money, but if they would not pay the money, they would not get "the best" people for the job.

For ten years, from 1993 to 2003, William McDonough was the President of the New York branch of the Federal Reserve. He has said that there is NO justification in economic theory for the current level of CEO salaries. And he is right. Here are some of his comments on CEO pay:



CEOs and Corporate Greed

by William J. McDonough

William J. McDonough is chairman of the Public Company Accounting Board, which was created by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002. The board oversees the auditors of public companies to protect investors and the public interest. This article appeared in The Christian Century, June 15, 2004 pp.8-9. Copyright by the Christian Century Foundation; used by permission. Current articles and subscriptions information can be found at www.christiancentury.org. This material was prepared for Religion Online by Ted and Winnie Brock.

Ten years ago, even five years ago, the American market economy was the model for and the envy of the world. The marvelous flexibility of our economy, our belief that "change" is a good word, our constant striving for innovation were and are factors that make ours an economic system that can compete with -- and beat -- any other.

And yet, in the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, the Congress and the president created a law that was revolutionary in the changes it prescribed and the activities it proscribed in our capital markets. It ruled that officers, directors and auditors of publicly traded companies must tale new responsibility for the accuracy of the companies’ financial reports and face stiff penalties for failing to do so.

How could that have happened? I believe it happened because in the course of the 1990s, many American business leaders got confused and their moral compasses stopped working.

It is particularly sad that such confusion took place at a time when U.S. businesses were responding in a brilliant way to a very serious challenge. Globalization of the world economy became much more intense in the 1990s, and American companies lost pricing power. It is easy to see why a manufacturing firm in Chicago cannot increase prices if it has to compete with firms in Mexico, China, India and other countries with dramatically lower labor costs. But service firms discovered that they had the same problem. You cannot raise prices for, say, a call center in Naperville if you are competing with call centers in New Delhi. Only very local services, such as health care and legal services, have been immune from this globalization-driven loss of the ability to raise prices.

If you cannot raise prices, and if wage pressures are fairly intense because of the kind of tight labor market we had in the 1990s, the only way to fund the wage increases without reducing profits is to improve labor productivity.

U.S. businesses solved their problem of loss of pricing power but rising wages by investing in information technology to run their businesses more precisely. Investing in IT was just the beginning. The way of doing business also had to change.

Retail trade is an obvious example. In a modern store, you check out and each item’s bar code tells the clerk what it costs. More important, the same type of information system updates the inventory records and the order book when the inventory hits a level indicating that it is time to reorder. In contrast to an earlier era, you do not need clerks to keep inventory records and you do not need large warehouses (because we copied the Japanese just-in-time delivery system previously used only in manufacturing). Also, there is a saving on the cost of financing now-reduced inventories. These and similar systems not only financed higher wages for workers, but increased profits substantially.

This was an effective response on the part of American business executives. They deserved credit for it. But it perhaps was a factor in their moral confusion. Pundits told them it was a new economic era, and the excitement went to their heads in a variety of ways.

Two things stand out: executive compensation and the drive for ever increasing and fully predictable quarterly profits.

In 1980, the average large-company chief executive officer made 40 times more than the average employee in his or her firm. Let’s assume that the multiple made sense because of the extra preparation, the risk-taking ability, and the leadership skills required of CEOs.

By 2000, the multiple of the average CEO’s pay over that of the average worker in the firm had risen, according to some studies, to 400 times. So in the course of 20 years, the multiple of CEO pay went up by a factor of ten. There is no economic theory, however farfetched, which can justify such an increase. In my view, it is also grotesquely immoral.

I should also note that I knew a lot of CEOs in 1980, and I can assure you that the CEOs of 2000 were not ten times better -- if any better at all.

Now let’s look at earnings performance. During the 1990s corporate America developed a habit of predicting quarterly earnings -- something accomplished by the people in the financial management of public companies guiding allegedly independent investment analysts to a consensus on how much the company would make in the next quarter. That morphed into a string of predictions of ever rising quarterly profits.

In this time of confusion, if a company achieved what it forecast, the CEO -- he or she making 400 times an employee’s income -- was truly a genius. If the forecast was missed by underperforming, the genius was regarded as a fool and his or her tenure was questioned by the pundits of the investment banking community and the financial press.

What was really going on in response to this self-created situation was that companies were cooking the books, with the help of outsiders such as lawyers, investment bankers, commercial bankers and, yes, accountants and auditors.

When the tech bubble broke in the second quarter of 2000 and the large market correction began, the half of American households invested in the stock market started to notice that their retirement plans and mutual funds were losing value. They were unhappy, but they were not sure whom to blame.

The ensuing scandals let them know whom to blame: corporate executives. Lest anybody think it was just Enron, WorldCom, HealthSouth and a few others, financial implosions were happening with sufficient rapidity to make the American citizenry very angry.

In a democracy, when voters get angry, they let their elected representatives know just how angry they are. Congress and the White House responded with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, passed by overwhelming majorities in both the Senate and the House of Representatives and signed by a president who called it the most important securities legislation since 1934.

Let us stop for a moment and ask ourselves why the Congress, the president and the American people did not decide that the scandals involved just a few bad apples in an otherwise healthy business community. The reason: the widespread executive greed and the cooking-the-books phenomenon. The people thought that the business leadership in general needed a sharp lesson.

My impression is that many business executives think this is a bad dream that will soon go away. They are wrong. The American people are still angry and the politicians know it, I am told by friends on the Hill that their mail runs very heavy indeed from constituents strongly protesting the continuing excesses of executive compensation.

What should we be doing? We need enough CEOs and their boards -- preferably those of the very strongest companies -- who will inform the world that they wish to be judged on performance over time, not just yesterday or tomorrow. Lots of people will argue that it will be impossible to judge performance over time -- and it may take a while before the markets will adjust to a new, more rational management approach -- but we must take the risk and move in that direction. Private business leaders will have to show the courage to do it.

Is there some compass that should guide us? I think there is. My friend Kofi Annan in accepting the Nobel Peace Prize pointed out that at the center of all of the great religions is each person’s responsibility for others. Such responsibility is at the very heart of the Torah. In Christianity, it is dramatized in the Gospel of Matthew when a Pharisee asks Jesus which is the greatest of the commandments. He answers that there are two: the first is that we should adore the Lord our God. The second, equal to the first, is that we must love our neighbors as ourselves.

Does a CEO making 400 or 500 times more than the average employee not consider fellow workers to be neighbors? When we think of the community around us, are not those less fortunate then we -- the homeless, the orphaned, the uneducated -- our neighbors? What, after all, is the biggest difference between a homeless person on a windy corner and you and me? My answer is that I was luckier. When I look at such a person I do not swell with pride, but think that "there but for the grace of God go I." That person is my neighbor.

If once a week, when we are at our place of worship, or just sitting and thinking, would we not be better people and better leaders if we examined ourselves this way? In the past week, has everything I have done been moral, as opposed to legal but just within the outer limits of the law? In the next week, will everything I do be morally sound? We do not need theologians to guide us. Simply knowing that we should love our neighbors as ourselves is sufficient guidance.
 
What is your definition of a 'private enterprise'? Because if you're referring to a publicly held company, then you are wrong. That is why there's a PCAOB.

but why do you consistently refer to Detroit, when the entire educational system is seeing a failing problem? You claim to not be bashing the Detroit teachers, but you go right back there, and even go so far as to say

We may need to shake up the Status Quo there and try something different.

if you're not trying to indirectly bash them.
 
Back
Top