I would like to understand what anyone's objection is to universal background checks for gun purchases.
Full disclosure: I don't own a gun and never have. However, I know several gun owners and I have no reservations about their owning them. Most (not all) of the gun owners I know well are current or former members of the military, and they all use their guns for target shooting and, in some cases, hunting. I imagine they keep guns for self-protection as well, but have never asked. One I know is active in the NRA and participates in ''first hunt' activities designed to help kids learn about gun safety and to experience a hunt, and once a year participates in a hunt specifically designed for disabled kids (in both cases, the 'kids' are at least teenaged and are accompanied by a parent/guardian). I say this only to point out I'm not a rabid anti-gun person. I would not hunt unless I needed to, but I respect that some people do enjoy it.
Well, there have been a number of replies to your top post so far, but really only one answer to your question: “We dare not let the camel's nose under the tent lest we set the stage for our guns being taken from us someday, somehow – and the gun violence we experience as a society is an unfortunate but to some extent an acceptable price to pay to maintain the status quo with respect to gun rights.” Other than that, we've heard nothing new, although we have seen a lot of side issues raised for whatever reason. It's clear enough that rhetorical gamesmanship is some folks' stock in trade.
In any case I've yet to hear anyone give another answer to your question either here or in any other venue, quite frankly. Thus, I suspect most folks don't have one.
Of course there's nothing wrong with that answer, necessarily. It's legitimate. But it does lead to other questions that seldom seem to be asked.
A few times in the past I've asked what it is about our current gun possession laws that are so sacred. The experiences of gun confiscation that occurred in England and Australia are often brought up as whispered tales of horrific oppression; something that must never,
never be allowed to happen here or else the American dream will be irretrievably lost, or something. I've asked folks to explain
exactly why those gun control regimes are so absolutely insufferable, particularly in light of the facts that those laws do appear to be effective in curbing gun violence, at least to some degree, and given that so far those other countries haven't become anything like totalitarian collectives. Nearly every answer I've ever gotten to that question has been cloaked in soaring rhetoric about fundamental rights, the occasional need to water the tree of liberty, and so on. Sometimes the answer has simply been an expression of naked, unadorned personal feelings and desires. Often enough, the answer manages to weave both those threads together. Long on passion, short on plausible details...
Of course there's nothing necessarily wrong with those answers either. But again they lead to further questions.
Just to be clear, I'm not advocating for the kinds of gun control laws enacted in England and Australia. I'm actually more in favor of stricter licensing, registration, and training requirements in preference to banning certain types of firearms. But neither do I see how those gun control regimes deprive anyone of a fundamental right to self defense or even of the opportunity for recreational firearms use. They do take some toys out of folks' toy box, it's true. And I can see why those who
really enjoy playing with those particular toys might object to that. But I don't see how they can defend their objections to such laws in terms of so-called inviolable rights – except by simple fiat. And simple fiat, of course, is invariably and precisely the argument they make, as if their interpretation of the Second Amendment is self-evident and beyond any reasonable challenge. “It's my right because the Constitution says so and because the Constitution says so, you can't take away my rights!”
Now, there is something wrong with that answer. It's circular. It's self-referential. It doesn't explain anything and it doesn't make a case for why any particular vision of “gun rights” should be respected. Ironically enough, in that sense it's likely to be a self-defeating position in the long run.
My not-so-original conclusion is that, like a number of other issues, “gun rights” have become a touchstone and a stand-in for a host of larger concerns related to ongoing social changes. Some people feel threatened; they feel as if they're losing control of “their” country. For these folks, “gun rights” have become a symbol of power preserved. (Of course it should go without saying that I'm not suggesting that
everyone who wants to maintain the status quo feels threatened by cultural changes. But I'll say it anyway lest anyone jump to that conclusion.)
It's sort of like the “Reagan revolution”, which was in fact kind of the opposite of a revolution. It's the last gasp of old ideas, power structures, and cultural shibboleths – a wave being ridden by true believers and profiteers alike. As it subsides, the monomaniacal fixation on the current definition of “gun rights” will flounder as well. Right now, the rabid opponents of universal background checks have the decided edge in turning out deeply-motivated voters. That won't last. The shifts in population demographics and political beliefs and voting patterns are pretty clearly under way.
In the meantime, I'd have a lot more respect for a lot of the self-avowed defenders of fundamental rights if they were more consistent in their defense. Given that on this very forum we've seen that many of the fiercest champions of gun rights are perfectly happy to abridge other's rights to, for example, freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of association, equal protection of the laws, and private, non-harmful sexual conduct, all ostensibly in the name of the greater good, one has to wonder why we should accept that those rights – arguably much more fundamental to a person's well being than the right to own a semi-automatic firearm – are negotiable while the right to bear arms is near absolute.
Cheers.