New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Violent Cities

They're both a matter of free will. A person who doesn't want to donate through the church can leave the church. A person who doesn't want to donate through the nation can leave the nation. The difference is that the nation doesn't promise you'll be tortured for all eternity if you leave, whereas often the church insists that's exactly what will happen to someone who leaves them.



I feel charitable on Election Day, in November, when we, the People, CHOOSE who to elect, because I vote morally and help elect people who will work to make the state more charitable, even as I know that will mean higher taxes for me.



Yes, of course it is. I know I have a choice in the matter. I don't do it to buy myself a ticket to some sanctuary in the sky or to spare myself a one way trip to a lake of fire. I'm not serving myself the way a religious person would be with his so-called charity. I'm acting selflessly. And, yes, doing so has a positive impact on me as an individual, in the spiritual sense, even if it makes me poorer in the material sense.



Why? Just as you have no evidence that God exists, you also have no evidence that if God were to exist, he wouldn't have created magical flying dragons.



Of course. However, if I lived in a universe where there was no evidence that logic actually worked, I wouldn't.



Incorrect. Civilization dates back around 7300 years, with the first cities settled by Sumer. Judaism in anything like its current form dates to the Babylonian captivity, around 600 BCE. Even if you go way back to proto-Judaism with their mythological origins in the story of Moses who first received the Law from Yahweh, that would put Judaism's origin in Egypt's eighteenth or nineteenth dynasty. If you date the Exodus to Ramses the Great, around 1800 years had passed between Egypt's first Pharaoh and the start of Judaism. And Egypt's first Pharaoh wasn't even the beginning of their civilization. He was merely the person who united the Upper and Lower Nile kingdoms into a single kingdom. Meanwhile, Christianity dates back only about 2000 years.



So did Judaism -- according to their own myths, the righteous Abraham was willing to make a human sacrifice of his own kid.



The colonials and the English both thought they were enacting natural law.



Poorly. Yet another example of how things can turn out badly for those who have convinced themselves natural law dictates whatever rules they personally have settled on.



Quite well. The vast majority of them lived out unusually long and prosperous lives for their eras.


Agreed. You're a great example. But that's the point. Everyone THINKS he supports natural law.
Nope. God doesn't have a "Progressive Tithe Law." You give what you can. Is the IRS that understanding? That forgiving?

And furthermore, I wish my taxes were as light as tithing. I wish the IRS commissar was as merciful as my God. If taxes were as light and if we were more Christian SS, Medicare, and Obamacare would be history. Beats the hell out of jail. . . or hell.

And yes it was that way at one time. Google Texas Seed Bill and wrap your logic and stats around the outcome after the veto.

Your notions of God and faith are laughably antiquated. A lot has happened since the 14th century. Again, crack a book. Or better yet go to church on Sunday. See how modern it's all become since your days of the Inquisition and witch burnings.

Abraham dates back long before Moses. If that's not the dawn of civilization it's close enough.

And as a Triple 9er I'd expect you to have a better grasp of the story of Abraham. The Hebrew word for "sacrifice" is the same as "raise up." God was giving Abraham a dope slap and saying, "No dummy! Not sacrifice! Raise up! Kunta Kinte style! Give him to Me spiritually for life. Don't stab him!"

No. Kings lost their heads, revolutions were fought, and The Enlightenment was born. You're being willfully ignorant.

And the difference between those who follow Natural Law and those who give it lip service can be seen in the history of the victors and the vanquished. Again, you don't believe so you are blind.
 
Yes, I'm sure that even in mixed-income areas, interaction among the classes is limited by the usual dynamics of social circles and self-segregation. But it's still going to be more than when people are sitting 2 miles away from each other rather than 20 feet.
People live pretty damn close together in prison; still don't see a lot of mingling among different folks.
 
How many "charities" do you know besides the government that collect "contributions" at gunpoint?
Church charities are a good example. Many use terrorism to elicit "donations," by threatening their members with eternal torture if they don't comply.
 
Church charities are a good example. Many use terrorism to elicit "donations," by threatening their members with eternal torture if they don't comply.

Sorry, but that is perhaps one of the most ignorant statements in the annals of recorded history. I feel badly for you, and I pray you'll become wiser someday.
 
Nope. God doesn't have a "Progressive Tithe Law."

Neither of us has any reason to think God exists, much less to assert knowledge of what his laws might be. But, if we judge by churches, they can be a great deal less understanding than the IRS, since sometimes the punishment they promise isn't just a fine or jail time but eternal torture.

Your notions of God and faith are laughably antiquated.

Not antiquated, merely well-informed.

Abraham dates back long before Moses. If that's not the dawn of civilization it's close enough.

To an even greater degree than Moses, Abraham is a mythical figure who likely has little or no historical basis. If he existed, though, he existed in a time long before Judaism, since even the Jewish myth system ascribes to Moses the receipt of the Law. The Covenant predates that, but that's not a religion, it's just a promise of racism by Yahweh. Even if we ignored all that, though, and pretended that Abraham was an historical figure and that Judaism predated not only the codification during the Babylonian Captivity, but even the receipt of the Ten Commandments, still Abraham existed long after the dawn of civilization.

The Bible's genealogy says that Moses' mother was Jochebed, whose father was Levi, son of Jacob, son of Isaac, son of Abraham. Thus, Abraham was Moses' great, great great grandfather. Setting aside supernatural generation lengths, and ascribing the longest realistic average generation length of about 40 years, that puts Abraham just 200 years before Moses. Putting Moses as far back into the Egyptian history as is realistic, in the reign of Thutmoses II of the eighteenth dynasty, that puts Abraham around 1679 BCE, during the time of the fourteenth dynasty, in Egypt. Thirteen dynasties came and went in their civilization over the course of well over a thousand years before the time of Abraham. For example, by the time Abraham was born, the Great Pyramid of Giza would already have been well over 800 years old, and the reign of the great Pharaoh Djoser would already have been a thousand-year-old memory.

Even assuming that the Bible got the genealogy of Moses wrong, and that Abraham was significantly earlier (say around 450 years before Moses), that still puts him only around the year 2000 BCE. That would be over a thousand years after Narmer united Egypt, and centuries after the Xia Dynasty was formed in China, the Akkadians in Sumer, the city of Harappa was settled in Pakistan, civilization took hold in Peru, the Minoans set up their civilization, in the Aegean, etc. And civilization actually long predates even those milestones. The megalithic temples of Malta date to 3600 BCE, millenia before even a forgiving dating of Abraham would put his story.

The legendary figure of Abraham is "close enough" to the dawn of civilization in the same sense that you and I could be said to be "close enough" to the dawn of the Roman Empire. The dawn of civilization was already thousands of years past before the time in which later people set the story of Abraham.

And as a Triple 9er I'd expect you to have a better grasp of the story of Abraham.

I have a decent grasp. As someone with a lower IQ, I would expect you to struggle with the story, though.... and you do. But, it's not hard to understand the story. Yahweh tests Abraham by ordering him to kill his own son. Abraham passes by showing he's willing to do so. Yahweh is a pretty twisted god.

The Hebrew word for "sacrifice" is the same as "raise up." God was giving Abraham a dope slap and saying, "No dummy! Not sacrifice! Raise up! Kunta Kinte style! Give him to Me spiritually for life. Don't stab him!"

I doubt you'll find a single major translation in history that translates it that way. The Young's Literal Translation has it as "burnt offering." The King James version also has "burnt offering." So does the American standard version, and the Catholic bible, etc. Yes, the Hebrew עֹלָה literally means "that which goes up," but the same term is used again and again throughout the Bible to refer to burnt offerings (where something is killed then burnt so the smoke goes up to God or the gods). In these other places, God doesn't show up and say "no, dummy, not sacrifice, raise that [ram/dove/bullock/lamb/sheep, etc.] up and give it to me spiritually for life." Instead, in every other instance it's clear that what was intended is for the thing to be killed and burnt so the smoke could go up to God. So, it would be very weird if, in this one case, with no context clues to steer us in a new direction, the word meant something totally different. The only reason to even speculate in that direction is discomfort with the fact the story's deity orders human sacrifice.

In fact, the context clues are entirely inconsistent with your creative reinterpretation. When the angel of the Lord stops Abraham, he doesn't say anything to imply that Abraham misinterpreted the order. There's no "hey, dummy, here's what I meant." Quite to the contrary, the angel's words only make sense if you assume Abraham interpreted the order correctly and was being tested to see if he would murder his own child if God commanded it. He passed the test by showing that he was frightened enough by God to abandon his own sense of morality rather than risk angering Him: "Do not do the least thing to him. For now I know that you fear God, since you did not withhold from me your son, your only one." The story then goes on to say that because Abraham was willing to murder his kid, the angel promised that he would bless Abraham with multitudes of descendants, who will be powerful because of Abraham's obedience to God's will. None of that text makes any sense if we were to accept your reinterpretation of what the order was.

You're being willfully ignorant.

No. I'm just a person who has studied history, which makes conversing with me a disorienting experience for you. You're so used to your little alternative histories being unchallenged, like the counter-textual read of the story of Abraham, that when someone brings real learning to the table, you have no idea what to do.
 
Last edited:
People live pretty damn close together in prison; still don't see a lot of mingling among different folks.
I haven't been to prison, so I couldn't say. I have, however, read a few prison narratives, and the authors disagreed with that statement. For example, I've read Piper Kerman's "Orange is the New Black," Solzhenitzen's "The Gulag Archipelago," and Jack London's "Pinched." One of the things that makes prison lit interesting is the way people are forced to interact across social lines that exist outside the prison.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but that is perhaps one of the most ignorant statements in the annals of recorded history. I feel badly for you, and I pray you'll become wiser someday.
You misspelled that word. It's not "ignorant," it's "observant."
 
Last edited:
You misspelled that word. It's not "ignorant," it's "observant."

I should not have said "ignorant".

I should have said "profoundly ignorant". That would have been more accurate by degree.

Sad, really.
 
Last edited:
Neither of us has any reason to think God exists, much less to assert knowledge of what his laws might be.
Laws according to faith and religion. It's the best we humans can do.

But, if we judge by churches, they can be a great deal less understanding than the IRS, since sometimes the punishment they promise isn't just a fine or jail time but eternal torture.
It doesn't take faith to realize you'll be in jail by gunpoint if necessary if you don't pay taxes. No church has ever damned a person for any reason. Grow up.

Not antiquated, merely well-informed.

. . .if you're Torquemada.

I have a decent grasp. As someone with a lower IQ, I would expect you to struggle with the story, though.... and you do. But, it's not hard to understand the story. Yahweh tests Abraham by ordering him to kill his own son. Abraham passes by showing he's willing to do so. Yahweh is a pretty twisted god.

My interpretation comes from Rabbi Daniel Lapin. You went through the trouble of discovering for yourself the dual context of the Hebrew word and you still cling to your ignorance. Rabbi Lapin is what you would call a "smart" person. So you should have no problem agreeing with him. If you don't, take it up with him. You are too close minded for me.
 
Laws according to faith and religion. It's the best we humans can do.

The right function of reason is the best we humans can do. Believing in things in the absence of evidence most certainly is not.

It doesn't take faith to realize you'll be in jail by gunpoint if necessary if you don't pay taxes.

Yes. I'll agree that a person doesn't have to be insane to realize that willful refusal to pay taxes while staying in the country is likely to wind up eventually with the person going to jail. By comparison, a certain kind of insanity is needed to believe, without a shred of evidence, that you need to follow your church's rules to avoid damnation. But, from the perspective of a person suffering from that kind of insanity (i.e., a religious person), the church is very much holding a gun do your head -- only the gun fires bullets composed of never-ending indescribable suffering.

My interpretation comes from Rabbi Daniel Lapin.

Lapin's not a very bright man, judging by his gibbering idiocy in the various media appearances I've seen from him. He's been amusingly called David Duke's favorite Jew. However, I don't know Lapin's writings well enough to say whether you're reading his stance on this particular question correctly. Regardless, I'd strongly recommend finding yourself a better guide. Lapin's a joke in Biblical scholarship circles: a political propagandist and media personality, not an actual scholar.

Anyway, the view you're professing is obviously at odds with the text. If you remove the standard "burnt offering" translation and substitute in the translation you suggest, the whole story is transformed into nonsense, since that would not be a test, turning the angel of the Lord's statements into bizarre non sequiturs in the story. If the angel responded the way you incorrectly thought he did (something along the lines of "no dummy, no sacrifice," you'd have a point. But he doesn't. I responds exactly as he would if he were rescinding an order that Abraham had correctly understood.
 
Regardless, I'd strongly recommend finding yourself a better guide. Lapin's a joke in Biblical scholarship circles: a political propagandist and media personality, not an actual scholar.

Not like the staff "scholars" you cite at Salon and Mother Jones. LOL.
 
The right function of reason is the best we humans can do. Believing in things in the absence of evidence most certainly is not.
Do you love your mom?

Prove it.


Lapin's a joke in Biblical scholarship circles:

Said the atheist who wouldn't know a biblical scholarship circle from a quilting circle.
 
I haven't been to prison, so I couldn't say. I have, however, read a few prison narratives, and the authors disagreed with that statement. For example, I've read Piper Kerman's "Orange is the New Black," Solzhenitzen's "The Gulag Archipelago," and Jack London's "Pinched." One of the things that makes prison lit interesting is the way people are forced to interact across social lines that exist outside the prison.
I haven't been to prison either, but I used to work with a former Corrections guy, and I used to drink socially with a guy named Dave, who did over 20 years for drugs. Prison in this country breaks down by race; nobody crosses the color lines...... not for long.
 
Do you love your mom?

Prove it.

I can't prove it to you, and thus you'd be unreasonable to be convinced that I do love my mom, absent some evidence by way of my behavior.

Said the atheist who wouldn't know a biblical scholarship circle from a quilting circle.

In my experience, atheists are very often better Biblical scholars than believers, since atheists actually read the religious texts with their minds engaged, the same way they would read a non-religious text, whereas believers often have an alternative way of engaging with certain material -- a way that they reserve just for the stuff that lines up with their superstitions. Even though they could be reasonably intelligent people in other contexts, when it comes to their special area of localized insanity, their brains become practically useless.
 
I can't prove it to you, and thus you'd be unreasonable to be convinced that I do love my mom, absent some evidence by way of my behavior.
Any behavior can be faked and therefore, cannot be considered evidence.

Welcome, atheist, to the world of faith.

Even though they could be reasonably intelligent people in other contexts, when it comes to their special area of localized insanity, their brains become practically useless.
Said the open minded atheist injecting no bias into his interpretations.
 
Any behavior can be faked and therefore, cannot be considered evidence.

Welcome, atheist, to the world of faith.

Inductive reasoning isn't faith. I'll give you two examples.

REASON: I flip a coin 100 times. It comes up heads 51 times and tails 49 times. I conclude, based on these results and based on what I've observed from coins generally, that the coin is fairly evenly weighted and I should expect approximately 50% of subsequent flips to come out each way.

FAITH: I flip a coin 100 times. It comes up heads 51 times and tails 49 times. I conclude, based on fairy tales I was fed as a child, that God dictates every outcome in the world, and that the reason it came out that way was because He willed it. Based on that, I conclude that I should have no expectation at all about how subsequent flips will tend to come out, except to the extent that I can influence them through prayer.

It's possible that the reasoning in the first case is wrong. For example, maybe the coin is weighted to come out heads 75% of the time, and tails just had an improbable run of luck. Or maybe there really is some invisible agent dictating outcomes, and I could flip a million subsequent tails consecutively. But, inductive reasoning allows me to infer the most likely possibility. And, in our everyday lives, we think that way all the time. We'd be paralyzed without it. In our everyday lives we do not, however, think the second way most of the time. We only do so in a few isolate areas of our lives -- little pockets of compartmentalized insanity. Some of us have simply recognized the silliness of that and closed those compartments.
 
Inductive reasoning isn't faith. I'll give you two examples.

REASON: I flip a coin 100 times. It comes up heads 51 times and tails 49 times. I conclude, based on these results and based on what I've observed from coins generally, that the coin is fairly evenly weighted and I should expect approximately 50% of subsequent flips to come out each way.

FAITH: I flip a coin 100 times. It comes up heads 51 times and tails 49 times. I conclude, based on fairy tales I was fed as a child, that God dictates every outcome in the world, and that the reason it came out that way was because He willed it. Based on that, I conclude that I should have no expectation at all about how subsequent flips will tend to come out, except to the extent that I can influence them through prayer.

It's possible that the reasoning in the first case is wrong. For example, maybe the coin is weighted to come out heads 75% of the time, and tails just had an improbable run of luck. Or maybe there really is some invisible agent dictating outcomes, and I could flip a million subsequent tails consecutively. But, inductive reasoning allows me to infer the most likely possibility. And, in our everyday lives, we think that way all the time. We'd be paralyzed without it. In our everyday lives we do not, however, think the second way most of the time. We only do so in a few isolate areas of our lives -- little pockets of compartmentalized insanity. Some of us have simply recognized the silliness of that and closed those compartments.

Your faulty "reasoning" is called the Gambler's Fallacy. It's been taking money from stupid people like you for centuries.
 
Back
Top