New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Was Aikin Really Wrong?

Akin's verbal lapse has been blown out of proportion because he did something that is relatively common -- he used "legitimate" incorrectly to mean "actual." He's apologized multiple times for the error in ads that are running daily in Missouri (that aren't receiving much national attention, frankly.)

It's perfectly fine not to like the man for being anti-abortion if that's your reason for not liking him, but condemning him for saying that rape is a valid or acceptable behavior is distorting what he was attempting to say.

I'm not sure you understand what Degsme is saying. I can't speak for Degs, but what I see Degs discussing is WHO aside from Democrats have condemned Aiken and asked him to step down. That WHO are members of his own party, including Mitt Romney who suggested he should take the advice of others and abandon his bid for office.

The point is that members of Aiken's party know what he was trying to say even with his mistaken "choice of words", yet they have asked him to not run. Most people don't condemn him for his mistaken choice of words, but for his follow-up which still suggests rape can somehow be divided into lesser and higher degrees of suffering by minor or adult women who suffer it. The crime in the former being that a minor is deemed to not be old enough to make an informed consent to have sex with an adult who should be acting as a responsible adult, not a child seducer or rapist, the latter, bluntly being assault upon a woman with a specific description to it based on the type of assault.

I think the key thing to note in Aiken's follow up and other's similar positions is that mention of the women who suffer not only the rape, but the propect of having to carry the result of that rape around inside them, is absent from the statement. Apparently, women are less important than the pregnancy that would result. To be fair, in his apology he did say he feels for victims of rape and prays for them.

The disturbing part for most people aside from his use of the word "legitimate" and forgiving him or getting past that "wrong" word usage is what he intoned as if he believed it based on discussions with medical professionals, was that women may somehow magically do something like refuse sperm from a rapist or that their chances of getting pregnant are less in the instance of rape because of some "natural" defense system against getting pregnant when raped. That was perhaps the real choking point for most people as it demonstrated, yet again, a low level of informed intelligence coming from some people who are or will be making important decisions for America and Americans regardless of political party.

While Americans or humans should not expect those they elect to be superhumans or godlike examples of perfection, I believe most people are looking for representatives that are reasonably intelligent, maybe even above average, informed (or have a thrist for being so), practical, logical and representative of the mixing bowl America is, even if they have a slight slant toward the specific interests of their constituents, which is also a part of the design of a Congress of people who represent "the people" and their various wants and needs. Unfortunately, it appears we have forgotten that the United States of America is also present in formula and we have divided along two main party lines, neglecting the nation and compromise, in favor of asserting our brand of philosophy.

It's not unlike spouses spending so much time arguing about how to run the household and discipline their children, nothing gets done, but arguing. In the end, everyone loses.

I believe it was less about Aiken's ill chosen words, but about his statement regarding women's bodies shutting down on the chances of getting pregnant from rape. That's a tough one to retract and say words were chosen badly. It's probably the reason members of his own party have asked him to step aside.

I agree, I left the Republican Party when it was intoned that Republicans should support, partial truths, uninformed and unintelligent statements and policies, even blatant untruths (lies) in the interest of "winning". I don't mind people having different opinions on things like abortion, but things like suggesting women's bodies somehow 'deal' with rape by somehow naturally 'shutting down' their chances of getting pregnant following rape, is over the top in terms of the level of intelligence demonstrated.
 
Much ado has been made about Aikin's statements. And many many conservative political leaders have condemned what he has said. But frankly I'm not sure they were correct in doing so. Note I'm not advocating what Aikin said. Factually it is stupid, ignorant and demagogic.

That said, I think Aikin is acutally right. He "misspoke" to the extent that he said things he believed but which he knows to be politically toxic and not to be openly aired. I also think he is right that he actually DOES enjoy a lot of support from conservatives for these views. After all, Paul Ryan ONLY supports abortion to save the life of the woman. So fundamentally, Ryan actually DOES agree with what Aikin went on to say http://lybio.net/tag/todd-akin-victims-rarely-get-pregnant-transcription/

"There should be some punishment, but the punishment ought to be on the rapist and not attacking the child."
​
And this is 100% consistent with what Paul Ryan advocates. Its 100% of what social conservatives advocate.

So frankly the conservative leadership that is decrying Aikin's comments is being more than a touch dishonest and is clearly unwilling to stand by its principles.

Because this 'flap' is so close to the convention the RNC is perfectly willing to throw the guy under the bus to keep attention on Romney. With Romney, they're having to try and 'make a silk purse out of a sow's ear' and it's a big job. They've been going nuts trying to figure out how to deal with all of the Ron Paul supporters that they're afraid will screw up their convention.

The reality is that Aiken has a fairly long career under his belt and that means quite a few constituents. While I don't agree with him at all, I consider it pretty unfair for them to trash his whole career over what was a pretty poor choice of words. One screw-up shouldn't kill all those years of what had to be goodwill with enough people to keep him elected.

The RNC has shown their true colors in too many ways for me to ever want to believe them on anything.
 
Republicans have trouble with women voters. There are a host of cultural reasons for this, and abortion is only the most publicized of them. That is why a lot of Republican leaders are trying to get someone who used the words "legitimate rape" to drop out -- they don't want to be associated with the terminology, no matter how innocuous the intent of the statement.

Akin is right, there are some studies that show women's bodies producing higher acidity/stronger base environments that reject sperm in cases of forcible rape, but he was wrong to cite it as scientific fact as the studies are too limited in nature to be applied generally.
 
Republicans have trouble with women voters. There are a host of cultural reasons for this, and abortion is only the most publicized of them. That is why a lot of Republican leaders are trying to get someone who used the words "legitimate rape" to drop out -- they don't want to be associated with the terminology, no matter how innocuous the intent of the statement.

Akin is right, there are some studies that show women's bodies producing higher acidity/stronger base environments that reject sperm in cases of forcible rape, but he was wrong to cite it as scientific fact as the studies are too limited in nature to be applied generally.

I agree on both counts, since there are studies that debunk what Aiken tried to point to (still exposing his level of informed intelligence).
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...ve-a-higher-pregnancy-rates-than-other-women/


To the point of the top post, the way I understand it is that Degs was pointing out what you confirmed, that Republicans are political and hypocritical as a result, as much as they point to the same in their opposition. It appears behind admonishing the rhetoric, they don't oppose what Aiken said as much as they saw what he said, would do to them politically and then applied the admonishing rhetoric.
 
Republicans have trouble with women voters. There are a host of cultural reasons for this, and abortion is only the most publicized of them. That is why a lot of Republican leaders are trying to get someone who used the words "legitimate rape" to drop out -- they don't want to be associated with the terminology, no matter how innocuous the intent of the statement.

Akin is right, there are some studies that show women's bodies producing higher acidity/stronger base environments that reject sperm in cases of forcible rape, but he was wrong to cite it as scientific fact as the studies are too limited in nature to be applied generally.

LeRoy: So I guess now, instead of distinguishing between 'legitimate rape' and 'non-legitimate rape', we are being asked to distinguish between 'forcible rape' and 'non-forcible rape'. Would non-forcible rape be equivalent to 'consensual rape'? I.e., some woman tells some man that he can go ahead and rape her, it's OK with her? Or maybe it's when some man starts raping some woman, and after a few strokes, she suddenly changes her mind, as is a woman's prerogative, and is 'cool' with it? And maybe she is suddenly 'into it'? Is that your thinking on this?

There are NO scientific studies that suggest women's bodies reject sperm in the case of rape. This is Republican junk science. If there were any truth to such 'studies', the rape camps that were set up by the Serbians in Bosnia during the ethnic cleansing in the 1990s would not have been successful at all. [The Serbians were raping Muslim women, in concentration camp like setups, and impregnating them in large numbers, and then forcing them to carry those fetuses to term.] And, yes, there were actually Republicans in the 1990s who were outraged that the United States moved to stop that.

Maybe now we know why.
 
Right on the money there Degs. They did it in order to distance Toad from The Munster Boy. But we're not going to let them get away with it, because let's face it, he said NOTHING that the value voting teabagging contingency doesn't buy into lock, stock and barrel!
 
I feel largely the same about the Democratic Party.

I'm curious. Does that mean you won't vote or you'll be voting for the candidate that tells you what you want to hear??

The problem I have with our political system, although I don't know one better or exactly how to solve the problem, is that inherently, based on the system, politicians are produced, not because they are a breed of human being, but because of how those who will be voting for them select them.

How many people do you really think are going to choose someone that disagrees with them to a level that is intolerable??? They aren't, thus politics (political science) formulates "images" that are intended to attract people on several different levels. First, one has to appeal to individuals, then to specific groups, then the general "politics" of a state, a region and then the nation, all while trying to stick within their group's platform. Essentially it is a mix of acting, sports and warlike strategy rolled into one as well as inclusive of what each party might refer to as "little white lies" or "stretching the truth a little", not to mention, leaving out key parts of the story to alter the perception to the opposite of what it would be were the whole story told (partial truths). All designed to walk the edge of "acceptable" ethics, yet even that seems to have been stretched a bit. Kinda like playing a baseball game and allowing the opposing teams to change the rules to their advantage, leading to a never ending game where no one really wins in the end, even if one gains a hollow "win" because there weren't any rules or any rules adhered to that would define what the "game" they "won" was.

The third party issue is a valid one, but with some serious third party contenders in the past, the election results show that a third party without exceptional support, has less of a chance of succeeding than it does of drawing away from a candidate that is the second choice to those who vote for the third party. This presents a dilemma for many and I think is the reason we have found it difficult to break away from two main parties. The "Tea Party" is a party within a party, I would imagine in part, based on recognition of its chances were it to be a separate "third" party.

I think if the right person came along, like an FDR (regardless of what you or I or anyone might think of him) who had IMMENSE support over several elections and they ran as a third party candidate, then we might be able to break out of being stuck in the two party rut.

Until then, even with some third party candidates that are quite popular, those on the edge monitor and gauge the amount of support and possible chances those candidates have of tipping the scales. If those chances don't look promising, rather than divert a vote away from their second choice candidate, people are going to throw in where the likelyhood of winning is greater, even if it is, as seems to be the result of the level of politics and politicians in recent times, a vote to avoid the chances of having the worst prospect (in one's mind) win the election.

Whatever you decide, I do hope you plan on voting.

Best,
Knot
 
I can imagine him and Ryan discussing the various forms of rape over lunch.

Incestual rape: This is either forced or unforced rape. For instance, a brother could have sex with his sister and it could be consensual but then due to shame, the sister would claim rape. Or, the uncle or grandpa could do the same thing. Now if the dad does it though, it has to be rape but not of the forced kind, more of the loving paternal kind. Bottom line: the baby just wants to live so tough luck sister.

Statutory rape: Now we all know this is very subjective and before all these feminists got in control, we used to be able to pick up 13 year olds at the drive in and have a great time. Just look at Jerry Lee or Elvis for Chrissakes. Statutory rape is usually consensual. Bottom line: the baby will live, sorry sister.

Forced rape without signs of violence: We know that a woman who really does not want to be raped will fight back. All good women have a duty to their families and honor to fight to keep their womanhoods intact and away from those who would take their innocence. Even the Moslems believe this so it must be true. If you did not fight back, you enjoyed it ergo, have the kid.

Forced rape with lots of signs of violence: Now this is the tricky one because this is not the fault of the women for being so weak and unable to defend herself. But if she had been carrying a gun, she could have shot the rapist so we have no sympathy for her plight. Bottom line: the kid will be born and you will take care of it.

Legitimate rape v forcible rape: They are two ways to say the same thing. Only forced rape is legitimate, all the others are just artifacts of modern liberal trends.
 
They really don't GG, because as long as we are talking about some loonie toon crazy republicon candidate in Missouri, we aren't talking about Romney's secret tax returns and Ryan's plan to dismantle Medicare. NCM, DC, TD, and the other righties are doing a good job of keeping us off message and talking about what some moron said. I think the RNC planned it that way.
 
The reality is that Aiken has a fairly long career under his belt and that means quite a few constituents. While I don't agree with him at all, I consider it pretty unfair for them to trash his whole career over what was a pretty poor choice of words. One screw-up shouldn't kill all those years of what had to be goodwill with enough people to keep him elected.


The attempt to attribute outrage toward Akin's remarks to a "poor choice of words" is a pathetic red herring. It was not Akin's "choice of words" that offended the American people. It was the underlying beliefs that he expressed. It wouldn't make a damn which words he had chosen -- his beliefs remain the same.
 
If anyone thinks Todd Aikens is right that the offspring resulting from RAPE or INCEST are "gifts" they need to come over here and get yourself a deserved, long, hard Noogie to the top of your flat head.
 
Akin's verbal lapse has been blown out of proportion because he did something that is relatively common -- he used "legitimate" incorrectly to mean "actual." He's apologized multiple times for the error in ads that are running daily in Missouri (that aren't receiving much national attention, frankly.)

It's perfectly fine not to like the man for being anti-abortion if that's your reason for not liking him, but condemning him for saying that rape is a valid or acceptable behavior is distorting what he was attempting to say.

you can't spin this one. Todd Akin and Paul Ryan developed legislation redefining rape...forcible rape vs non-forcible rape. that is, legitimate rape vs illegitimate rape. they wanted to muddy the waters. shameful.

as Pres Obama said "rape is rape."
 
and got him in trouble from the GOP, because he revealed their Taliban core-anti-human , woman hating filth torturing good people of USA

Yuri,what you just posted is so true.

Democrats are called all kinds of names, but which party wants to go into your body and tell you what to do with it, when something happens you have no control over. A hideous crime that no woman should ever have to suffer through. And Cons want them to pay afterward,too.The crime is not bad enough.
 
you can't spin this one. Todd Akin and Paul Ryan developed legislation redefining rape...forcible rape vs non-forcible rape. that is, legitimate rape vs illegitimate rape. they wanted to muddy the waters. shameful.

as Pres Obama said "rape is rape."

Really? Rape is rape? What is it when it's a 16 year old boy and a 15 year old girl, and they've gotten drunk on their first-ever bottle of wine and had sex? In some places, that's rape. In others, it's not. What if it's a 23-year-old female teacher and a 17 year old male student? That's rape in most jurisdictions in the U.S.

Of course, those are "consensual" acts where there is doubt about the ability to give consent because of age, or intoxication or a combination thereof.

But what of what I think of as "morning after rape" -- the "victim" wakes up and yells rape? I know of one person who served jail time in such an incident.

The point is, there are multiple things the law defines as rape -- Obama is simply wrong if he said "rape is rape."

People who know my perspective within this forum know I'm in favor of abortion, I still want to make it clear that the upcoming example is not my own personal point of view.

If "rape is rape," then wouldn't it also be fair to say, "life is life," and that the progeny created via a rape has as much right to live as those created via consensual sexual activity?

The world is obviously a more complex place.
 
Yuri,what you just posted is so true.

Democrats are called all kinds of names, but which party wants to go into your body and tell you what to do with it, when something happens you have no control over. A hideous crime that no woman should ever have to suffer through. And Cons want them to pay afterward,too.The crime is not bad enough.

Oh, the party that outlawed public sale of foie gras in CA is a party that wants to tell me what to do with my body, as is the same party that wants labels of deteriorated lungs put on cigarette packs, and the party that wants more controls on what I eat in the name of obesity -- that would of course be the Democratic Party.

I'm pro-abortion. I don't buy into the religious right's stance, which has always struck me as fairly anti-sex (at least anti-sex-outside-marriage and as a non-celibate bachelor I have my own strong views on the subject). I believe in an exception for rape and incest -- but I also don't think that the point of view of the religious right comparable with the Taliban as Yuri opined.
 
If that were the point, the critics wouldn't keep emphasizing the words "legitimate rape." That has been the point, that somehow Akin thinks rape can be legitimate. There are many people so opposed to abortion that they aren't in favor of an exception for rape or incest (they're a minority, but they're not a particularly rare minority). It's the words "legitimate rape" that got him in trouble.

Not much of a minority there TD when your candidate for vice-president is one of them. Heck the dumbazz even tried to pass a bill that redefined rape so more criminals would get off and fewer abortions would be performed, even in cases of "rape". No wonder your guys are losing the female vote.
 
Back
Top