New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Was Aikin Really Wrong?

MaryAnne. I don't mince words.

As many know I survived the plague of ignorance , political lying and brainwashing some time ago on different continent.
I can spot that growing filth here as well .
The new GOP is a bunch of scumbags , lying swine , shameless Taliban -like , Maoist tactical totalitarian in nature POSs.
If tomorrow some like Reince or Ryan and ilk will meet their creator for a judgment, I will pop up champagne to celebrate a good riddance the Americans will get from this dangerous plague and demagogues

That is exactly what this breed that is now in control of the Republican party is and yet the followers have the nerve to act as if Dems are at fault.

At least most women have figured this out. Women are pretty smart at seeing who really wants control.

At first it was a sneak attack,but now the attacks are full fledged,right out in the open. Akin popped a boil.
Rush started picking,Akin popped it.
 
Unlike Claire McCaskill, I believe that working to protect the most vulnerable in our society is one of my most important responsibilities, and that includes protecting both the unborn and victims of sexual assault. We must move forward and work together to replace Claire McCaskill in the Senate.
But I can’t do this alone… I need your help.
**************************************
No mon,no fun,your Son.

Too bad,so sad,your Dad!
 
Nope... in ALL places that is not rape. Both are minors. It can only LEGALLY be rape if one of them is over 18.

I don't think you're correct on that, but I don't have time to research it today. What I believe to be true (having a dim memory of something I've read in the past) is that it could still be adjudicated as rape, but that the matter would be recorded as an offense by a minor and all records would be expunged once the alleged rapist had reached adulthood.

No you know that a person serving jail time CLAIMS that's what took place. That's very different

Not to the guy in jail -- it's his word against hers.



And as KAF pointed out - that is the REAL offensiveness of Aikin's statement. And that is precisely why the condemnation of the GOP leadership is so hypocritical since that is EXACTLY the position of their Vice Presidential nomineee and that of many others. And it is a call to violating the Constitutions prohibition against involuntary servitude by ignoring the rights of the woman who was raped.

The position that "life is life" is one I intentionally inserted because it IS in the Republican party platform at this point -- and it is by no means the scarce opinion (even among women) that one would hope it to be. It is, nonetheless, no the pro-life, anti-abortion stance that has lead to the current controversy. Akin was pro-life, anti-abortion and didn't believe in an exception for rape or incest throughout his entire campaign and has made no secret of that fact throughout his campaign.

So why, then, has his statement on a St. Louis talk show become national news? Because he used the word "legitimate" to mean "actual" and thereby juxtaposed the words "legitimate" and "rape" in a way that could be portrayed as though some rapes are an acceptable activity.

You should be appalled by this, Degs, as what he MEANT and what he legitimately said, don't parse the same. This is the same thing that you deplored in the Obama, "you didn't build that" kerfluffle. What Obama MEANT was that the individual businessman didn't build the infrastructure of the surrounding society. Unfortunately, what he SAID was "If you've got a successful business -- you didn't build that."

What Akin MEANT was (and I hasten to add the science behind this statement is sketchy -- it isn't nonexistent) that in cases of actual rape, women's bodies may throw up a defense mechanism that prevents pregnancy. What he said was "From what I understand from doctors [pregnancy from rape] is really rare. If its a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to shut that whole thing down."

There is some science to show that women's bodies do change their PH balance in cases of forcible rape in ways that reduce the chance of pregnancy -- and that's what Akin mean to say. But as with "you didn't build that" the wrong words used in the wrong order have done damage to his campaign.
 
no, its because he combined the illigetimate thing with his nonsense about the body's natural defenses. the combination of those two statements convinced most everyone that he was crazy.
 
no, its because he combined the illigetimate thing with his nonsense about the body's natural defenses. the combination of those two statements convinced most everyone that he was crazy.


Maybe so gabriel, but crazy people don't always view other crazy people as being crazy, do they?
 
no, its because he combined the illigetimate thing with his nonsense about the body's natural defenses. the combination of those two statements convinced most everyone that he was crazy.

Well -- now you're just being incomprehensible. First, he didn't combine any " illigetimate" thing with anything else. Secondly, there is at least some science supporting the views (it is far from an indisputable "happens every time" thing).
 
Don't see what's so hard on this one- pro-life is pro-life, no doubt. And unscientific stupidity as a rationale is simply no excuse. He should bow out for the embarrassing misstatement.
 
I don't think you're correct on that, but I don't have time to research it today. What I believe to be true (having a dim memory of something I've read in the past) is that it could still be adjudicated as rape, but that the matter would be recorded as an offense by a minor and all records would be expunged once the alleged rapist had reached adulthood.

Nope trap. Consensual sex among minors is not a crime.

No you know that a person serving jail time CLAIMS that's what took place. That's very different
Not to the guy in jail -- it's his word against hers.
Except its not. Because if it was simply heSaid/SheSaid then there is clear "reasonable doubt".... Sorry, your credulousness in some of these situations - particularly given that you are a reporter, still surprizes me.




The position that "life is life" is one I intentionally inserted because it IS in the Republican party platform at this point -- and it is by no means the scarce opinion (even among women) that one would hope it to be.

And that's precisely why the castigation of Aikin is so hypocritical. He just basically articulated the core Pro-Life position with a soupcon of conservative beliefs about women.

What Aikin meant and what he said DO parse the same. I find neither "appalling" in that this is the irrationality and ignorance of the logical and factual issues surrounding reproductive rights that I have come to find is part and parcel of the conservative position.

And yes - the science behind Aikin's statement IS non-existant. Its a classic case where he conflates multiple ideas he has heard somewhere but did not followup to think through. Statistically it is true that a woman, violently raped, is LESS likely to be impregnated than a normal case of unprotected sex. But that's mainly because violent rape is more about power than about sexual gratification. And thus a larger percentage of male rapists fail to ejaculate vaginally during rape than men during consensual sex.

But that's very different than "women's bodies having a way of shutting that down". Yes it is also true that at different times of a woman's fertility cycle vaginal and servical concitions can positively and adversely affect sperm motility. But that is a DIFFERENT biological issue. And no, women's bodies during rape do not have "defense mechanisms to throw up".. From an evolutionalry biological perspective, this is undesirable and would be selected against. Because the mating dance for humans prior to civilization was not one of chaste dating and then a preganancy inducing honeymoon. Rather it was sex invariably at the demand of, and on the schedule of the dominant male in the pack

Thus female reproduction would evolve to accomondate this and maximize fertility in such a circumstance.

That Aikin seems to have a clue as to his conflation of these to things is neithr appalling to me, nor shocking, nor unexpected. Frankly it is PRECISELY what I expect fom conservatives post Reagan's "Facts are Stupid Things" (yes I know that was a slip, but I'd argue it was freudian) anti-intellectualism that we have faced for 30 years.
 
Don't see what's so hard on this one- pro-life is pro-life, no doubt. And unscientific stupidity as a rationale is simply no excuse. He should bow out for the embarrassing misstatement.
Why? Particularly when that mis-statement represents the views of those conservatives that most support him
 
Well, one thing is certain after all this discourse... The Republicans have sewn up the Rapist vote.

.... And, yea, I guess they should be celebrating that.

...It may be the only demographics they win this fall.

And we know how Republicans LOVE to celebrate in the end zone with NO BALL.
 
Well, one thing is certain after all this discourse... The Republicans have sewn up the Rapist vote.

.... And, yea, I guess they should be celebrating that.

...It may be the only demographics they win this fall.

LeRoy: Oh, I don't know. They also had the pedophile vote locked up, after the big Ted Nugent endorsement.
 
Gallup has a long history of accuracy.

Hmm not so much. First off the MoE is 3 points

Secondly Gallup does NOT have a long history of accuracy here precisely BECAUSE of their "likely voter model".

http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/11/06/when-house-effects-become-bias/
Another example is Gallup, whose traditional likely voter model showed a 15-point Republican advantage on the generic ballot — much higher than most other pollsters. This estimate wound up doing quite poorly:
 
degsme;480053 [QUOTE said:
And that's precisely why the castigation of Aikin is so hypocritical. He just basically articulated the core Pro-Life position with a soupcon of conservative beliefs about women.

You are fundamentally wrong here. If anything, he may have approached the pro-life position with a soupcon of the religious right's view of women. Not all conservatives are members of the religious right, you know.
What Aikin meant and what he said DO parse the same.

I'm sorry, Degs, but they do not. I've seen the clip. If he had substituted the word "actual" for "legitimate" the nationwide condemnation would have been nonexistent.

I find neither "appalling" in that this is the irrationality and ignorance of the logical and factual issues surrounding reproductive rights that I have come to find is part and parcel of the conservative position.

I'm a conservative. In fact, according to you I'm a conservative ideologue. Do I share the views that are "part and parcel" of the conservative position? If I do not, and you know that I do not, then there is something askew with your view of the conservative position.

And yes - the science behind Aikin's statement IS non-existant.

Not true. It is not "non-existent." There have been studies showing this mechanism. That being the case, it is not true for every woman, every time -- which is why Akin's overall view is incorrect.

But that's very different than "women's bodies having a way of shutting that down". Yes it is also true that at different times of a woman's fertility cycle vaginal and servical concitions can positively and adversely affect sperm motility.

Some women's bodies do have a way of shutting down, for lack of a better terminology, unwanted sperm. As I said, it isn't a universal phenomenon. Nor does it work every time -- but then, neither does Brevicon, Demulen, Desogen,Norinyl, or Ortho-Cept. I'm surprised that you don't know about this -- there is apparently a "rape response" that happens in a lot of women's bodies, affecting their body chemistry and reducing the chance of pregnancy.
 
Not much of a minority there TD when your candidate for vice-president is one of them. Heck the dumbazz even tried to pass a bill that redefined rape so more criminals would get off and fewer abortions would be performed, even in cases of "rape". No wonder your guys are losing the female vote.

You've made my point for me. The viewpoint is sufficiently common to not be controversial in some circles. It wasn't the fact that Akin held the view that was controversial -- it was merely the choice of words.
 
Not true. It is not "non-existent." There have been studies showing this mechanism. That being the case, it is not true for every woman, every time -- which is why Akin's overall view is incorrect.

Some women's bodies do have a way of shutting down, for lack of a better terminology, unwanted sperm. As I said, it isn't a universal phenomenon. Nor does it work every time -- but then, neither does Brevicon, Demulen, Desogen,Norinyl, or Ortho-Cept. I'm surprised that you don't know about this -- there is apparently a "rape response" that happens in a lot of women's bodies, affecting their body chemistry and reducing the chance of pregnancy.

LeRoy: Cite these studies. Simply claiming that "studies exist" is the favored method of junk science proponents everywhere. And they had better be a study from some peer-reviewed science journal, not some "I Had Bigfoot's Baby" story from The Weekly World News.

Again: if there were any truth to your claims, why did so many Muslim women get pregnant in those infamous 'rape camps' set up by the Serbs in Bosnia in the early 1990s? Maybe the 'sperm-rejection mechanism' doesn't work in Muslim women??
 
If anyone thinks Todd Aikens is right that the offspring resulting from RAPE or INCEST are "gifts" they need to come over here and get yourself a deserved, long, hard Noogie to the top of your flat head.

They need more,but that would be a start!:eek:)
 
Not all conservatives are members of the religious right. But the majority is both in the GOP and in the Tea Party http://pewresearch.org/pubs/1903/tea-party-movement-religion-social-issues-conservative-christian

And if Aikin had substituted Actual for Legitimate, he'd still be in the same kimchee he's in now. Well maybe the GOP establishment would have been a bit more wishy washy - but the noxiousness of his ideas would be unchanged.

You are a minority conservative in that you are amoral when it comes to religion, but you are anti-intellectioal and anti-science which is part of the problem here.

And yes - the science behind Aikin's statement IS non-existant.
Not true. It is not "non-existent." There have been studies showing this mechanism
"studies" done by biased organizations with an interest in the outcome that are not peer reviewed in major journals are not "science".

Some women's bodies do have a way of shutting down, for lack of a better terminology, unwanted sperm.
No, you are now conflating a THIRD issue - that of Immune reactions to sperm. And that's a DIFFERENT issue and is as common among rape as it is among consensual sex. And the frequency of it "working" is so vanishingly small that its not something you build policy on.

pH affects sperm motility, but primarily in a gender selective manner
Immune response does attack the sperm itself, but that's a random function of immune system interactions and NOT part of the reproductive system

And NEITHER is the decorrellated cause of slightly lower preganancy rates for violent rape victims vs. unprotexted consensual sex examples. THAT is driven more by the reduced rate of full ejaculation during rape vs. consensual sex.


YET - you and Mr. Aikin are CONFLATING these three DISTINCT phenomenon as one. As I said - anti-science conservativism.
 
Yes you do FEEL that way.

Yet when challenged for a factual basis of such feelings, you seem to keep coming up short and instead respond with strawmen.

Oh, please. If you want me to list the times that the Democratic Party has lied to me (as a voter) or to my representatives in Congress the list is too long. It isn't a strawman to say that, for example, Clinton promised a middle-class tax cut and then reversed himself. It isn't a strawman to say that Al Gore Jr., at the very least, exaggerated his role in the creation of the Internet. It isn't a strawman to point to four or five times in my lifetime that numerous members of the Democratic Party have said they wanted just this one piece of "common sense" gun control legislation, and that would be enough -- and then gone on to introduce more gun control in the next Congressional session (the most egregious of these being the 1986 Firearms Owners Protection Act).

I'm surfeit with perfidy on the part of Democrats that I can factually support -- my trust was lost via 30 + years of watching them in action.
 
Back
Top