New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

We All Know....

Would you cut defense spending? I doubt it.

So rather than throw out "cut spending," why don't you specify what you think is worth spending money on. Obviously, your focus is on cutting stuff that you don't approve of.

I have no problem with doing a drastic cut in defense spending. I am not opposed to reigning in spending generally. But I am also not opposed to asking the most wealthy who control 70% of the wealth to pay more in taxes. (I seriously doubt that you are in the top 1 or 2% in income. So rest assured that I am not out to raise YOUR taxes.

BTW, I pay plenty in taxes. If it were up to me, I would shift my contribution out of defense and into other government programs.

Well, the simple fact is that if you divide the Annual Federal Expenditures by the population, you will find that the Federal Government spends about 12,000 dollars per citizen.

That comes to about 35,000 dollars for each of the 114 million taxpayers.

So, in order for each citizen to pay his fair share, he would need to pay $12,000. Or if you just want to have the current number of taxpayers, each would have to pay $35,000.

One percent, or Ten percent or 20 percent of the income earning population cannot pay the expenses for 100% of total population no matter how much you tax them. That means, if spending isn't cut, and if entitlements and welfare programs, the main driver of our debt, aren't reformed in some way, the nation will go bankrupt.

Spending cuts, along with increasing the size of the revenue base, not tax increases that will shrink it, is the only way out. And that won't happen until the Democrats and Obama lose power. That I can guarantee you, because they will NEVER CUT GOVERNMENT SPENDING; it's how they buy votes.
 
So if 1% controls 90% of the wealth, should they not pay 90% of the taxes? Seems fair to me.

They don't. If 1% of income earners, (1.2 million people) controlled 90% of the wealth, the population would be literally going to the bathroom in a ditch.

Now under Obama's policies, that's exactly what will happen, and it will be much fewer than 1% controlling the little that's left. It will be only those that are employed by government. Just like in North Korea and Cuba.
 
How sorry does an individual have to be to want to tax elderly senior citizens, the disabled and the poverty striken for their last dime, but wants to give the rich a pass?

The federal deficit is over 1.2 trillion. There is simply no way to raise taxes on one ten or twenty percent at the top to pay for it.

That's why in Europe EVERYBODY PAYS through extremely high National sales taxes. And they are going bankrupt.

Your ideology is a failure. The best system is where everyone gets to keep the same percentage of their income, no matter how much their income is. It's called a flat tax with no deductions. A system that gives one man another mans earnings is the system that creates poverty, misery and bankruptcy.

Progressive taxes are the hallmark of communism, and we all know how that works out.
 
Would you cut defense spending? I doubt it.[/QUOTE

You could do away with the whole damn military and you wouldn't fix half the the problem.

And the Military is one of the few things that government does that is actually authorized it by the Constitution.

The fact is that the answer to our problem is real simple. More self sufficiency and less dependency. And that ain't going to happen with Democrats in power.

Which means a steady decline into collapse. It won't be long now, if Obama wins.
 
Do you have any example of a major nation that has achieved generalized prosperity without some form of progressive taxation?

Yes, ours before 1919. And I've got lots of examples of nations that have collapsed with a progressive tax system.
 
The bottom 50% of folks control 1.1% of the wealth, how much do you want to tax them Mr Scrooge? They already pay much more than 1% of total taxes paid, so how much more do you want to grind out of them? Just how Fascist are you?
 
Would you cut defense spending? I doubt it.[/QUOTE

You could do away with the whole damn military and you wouldn't fix half the the problem.

We could do away with well OVER half of the military and STILL have the best-funded military in the world. Let's say we cut 2/3 of the military budget. That would leave us spending about 2/3 more than the next-closest country. And it would mean about $475 billion in savings. That isn't going to erase the deficit single-handedly, to b e sure, but it would make a very large start. Combine that will letting Bush's tax cuts expire, and a return to normal economic growth, and you'll have the deficit eliminated in no time.

Fortunately, we don't have to think about this in a vacuum. We have fairly recent experience with turning record deficits into record surpluses. As you'll recall, the failed Reagan/Bush economic experiment left America with the biggest budget deficits in its history, and, under Clinton's leadership, those had given way to huge budget surpluses in just six years. We know what things factored in. Military spending was held down, taxes were increased (especially on the wealthy), we avoided any bone-headed military quagmires abroad, and we kept the rate of domestic spending growth somewhat below the historically normal pace. What we didn't do is what the phony deficit hawks in the GOP call for: cutting taxes on the rich while treating the single-biggest area of discretionary spending as off-limits for cuts.
 
I understand that anyone that supports your theory suffers from Diminished Mental Capacity.
IOW you don't understand. Considering this is a BASIC TENET OF ECONOMICS


I'll tell you what else I understand, The free market, Capitalism, Individual Liberty and a Limited government that protects those things by arresting people who steal the prosperity of others is what made this country great, not Marxist wealth re-distribution
Um ALL societies engage in wealth redistribution. And the USA has from before its outset. BTW in a free market, who protects property and contractual "rights"?
 
Do you have any example of a major nation that has achieved generalized prosperity without some form of progressive taxation?
Yes, ours before 1919. And I've got lots of examples of nations that have collapsed with a progressive tax system.
Really? Name some that collapsed.

And you do realize that prior to 1919, France, Germany and England ALL had Per Capita GDP production and growth rates IN EXCESS OF THE USA right? That's independently verifiaible HISTORIC FACT.
 
We have fairly recent experience with turning record deficits into record surpluses. As you'll recall, the failed Reagan/Bush economic experiment left America with the biggest budget deficits in its history, and, under Clinton's leadership, those had given way to huge budget surpluses in just six years.

God, are you people superficial. The same old parrots without ever looking at facts.

Fact ,Clinton spent 19% of GDP, Obama is spending 25%. Obama has enlarged spending by 30% over what Clinton did. And Clinton actually cut capital gains taxes. Obama wants to raise them. along with another 400 billion in tax increases in Obama care. Under Obama's tax plan the rates would be much higher than Clinton's.

But I'll make you a deal----only raise taxes back to Clinton era rates if you cut spending back to Clinton era spending. That means doing away with Obamacare, reducing food stamps by half, reducing medicaid funding, unemployment payments and every other damn welfare program and regulatory policy that is driving this country into bankruptcy. You want to talk Clinton/Gingrich era tax and spend policy I'm more than happy to.

Brilliant. And cut the military in half; yep great idea, while China and Russia and Iran and North Korea are all building up theirs. The best way to prevent war is to have the strongest military in the world. You folks are a walking talking disaster.
 
God, are you people superficial. The same old parrots without ever looking at facts.

Fact ,Clinton spent 19% of GDP, Obama is spending 25%. Obama has enlarged spending by 30% over what Clinton did.
Yes when the economy crashes (ie GDP goes down) Government expenditure as a percent of GDP will go up. And since government programs are what jumpstarts an economy that increase will be even more yes and?

And Clinton actually cut capital gains taxes. Obama wants to raise them.
a
Yes the GOP Congress pushed through a Cap Gains tax cut in the latter years of the Clinton administration. And THERE WAS NO INCREASE IN CAPITAL INVESTEMENT IN THE ECONOMY, so raising Cap Gains Taxes IS A GOOD IDEA since

  • it does not REDUCE Cap Gains investment (unless magically it doesn't work the same in both directions)
  • It reduces the deficit.


Brilliant. And cut the military in half; yep great idea, while China and Russia and Iran and North Korea are all building up theirs.
You do realize that if you add up what China, Russia, Iran and North Korean TOGEHTER are spending. it is LESS THAN HALF of what the US is spending just on PENTAGON budget. That does not include NSA, CIA, Coast Guard, Veterans administration. If you count that, $400 Billion is only 1/3 of the Defense budget.


The best way to prevent war is to have the strongest military in the world. You folks are a walking talking disaster.
RIGHT.. So spending more than Russia, China, Iran and North Korea combined on the military is a "disaster"... FASCINATING.. kinda like calling addition "a commie plot".
 
You dodged the question. I didn't say that you could pay down the debt by only cutting defense. But defense is a major government expense. Would you be willing to cut defense? Or should my taxes - at whatever level - go to support a bloated military that I did not ask for. That is the tyranny of the hawks.

So would you cut defense to HELP cut the deficit? Or would you pledge to INCREASE defense spending like Romney and Ryan? If you vote to raise defense spending, you are not a true deficit hawk (ala Ron Paul).

Answer the question. No more dodging to non-defense and entitlement spending.

Would you cut defense spending? I doubt it.[/QUOTE

You could do away with the whole damn military and you wouldn't fix half the the problem.

And the Military is one of the few things that government does that is actually authorized it by the Constitution.

The fact is that the answer to our problem is real simple. More self sufficiency and less dependency. And that ain't going to happen with Democrats in power.

Which means a steady decline into collapse. It won't be long now, if Obama wins.
 
Ever heard of an "arms race"? Could it be that the Russians and Chinese are increasing military spending to match our own out of control military spending?

God, are you people superficial. The same old parrots without ever looking at facts.

Fact ,Clinton spent 19% of GDP, Obama is spending 25%. Obama has enlarged spending by 30% over what Clinton did. And Clinton actually cut capital gains taxes. Obama wants to raise them. along with another 400 billion in tax increases in Obama care. Under Obama's tax plan the rates would be much higher than Clinton's.

But I'll make you a deal----only raise taxes back to Clinton era rates if you cut spending back to Clinton era spending. That means doing away with Obamacare, reducing food stamps by half, reducing medicaid funding, unemployment payments and every other damn welfare program and regulatory policy that is driving this country into bankruptcy. You want to talk Clinton/Gingrich era tax and spend policy I'm more than happy to.

Brilliant. And cut the military in half; yep great idea, while China and Russia and Iran and North Korea are all building up theirs. The best way to prevent war is to have the strongest military in the world. You folks are a walking talking disaster.
 
The best way to prevent war is to have the strongest military in the world.

How do I put this gently? Umm... that's such a self-evidently stupid statement that I'm embarrassed for you. Is that gentle enough?

Look, someone ALWAYS has the strongest military in the world, by definition. Every single war that has ever started did so at a time when someone had the strongest military in the world. That doesn't prevent war.

Regardless, the US could cut its military budget to 1/3 its current size and still have, by far, the strongest military in the world. What we have right now is overkill on top of overkill. It's far more than we need to deter open aggression against the US, and it's ineffectual at deterring terrorist attacks against us. In fact, you can argue it encourages such attacks, in that it tempts us to use that military in aggressive ways that, in turn, act as wonderful terrorist recruitment material.

As for your proposal to roll us back to Clinton era rates and also Clinton-era spending, I'm not sure you have the math straight in your head. Clinton-era tax rates would produce more tax revenues today than they did in the Clinton era, because the population is larger and the GDP is bigger. But, for the exact same reasons, the government would need to spend more money to provide the same level of service, today, as they provided in the Clinton era. So, a more mathematically meaningful proposal would be to try to move revenues and spending back to the same percentage of GDP as during the Clinton era.

In 2000, federal tax receipts were 20.6% of GDP, and outlays were 18.2% of GDP, leaving us with a 2.4% surplus. For FY 2012, receipts are 15.8% of GDP and outlays are 24.3% of GDP, for a deficit of 8.5%. So, we'd want to bump up taxes enough to collect another 4.8% of GDP, and we'd want to cut spending enough to drop it by 6.1% of GDP.

Of that 6.1% drop in spending, as a share of GDP, a big chunk would come from the military. In 2000, we spent 16.5% of GDP on that. In 2012, 18.9%. So, that leaves us another 3.7% to find in the budget. If we were content with merely balancing the budget, though (as opposed to creating a record surplus like we had in 2000), we'd only need to find 1.3% of GDP in spending cuts.

So, where, specifically, should we look to find that last roughly $200 billion in spending cuts, to get us to a balanced budget with distribution roughly in line with what we had under Clinton? I don't know. Some of what we spend more on, under Obama, are investments I think are in our long-term interest. For example, we spend a greater share of our GDP on energy conservation than under Clinton, but I'd hate to see that change, since it makes us more secure, and sets us up well to avoid harder economic choices in the future, when oil will doubtless be more expensive.

One thing we'd have in our favor, if we tried to implement this plan, is that we're currently spending extra on things that are linked to the business cycle, and that will naturally go down as the economy improves. For example, unemployment benefits are more expensive in times of high unemployment, as are food stamps and other forms of assistance to the poor. A lot of what happened in the Clinton era is that those kinds of expenses decreased naturally, merely as a result of people becoming more prosperous.

Some of the expense is military-related stuff that doesn't show up in the defense budget. For example, we went from spending $1.2 billion on "veterans education, training, and rehabilitation," in 2000, to spending $12.2 billion, in 2012, largely as a kind of echo-expense from our dive into militarism and warmongering under Bush. Total veterans benefits and services rose from $47 billion to $130 billion. I certainly wouldn't advocate we leave those vets out in the cold. But, if we start pulling back from our counter-productive militarism, those kinds of expenses should start to decline on their own -- if fewer of our boys are getting their parts blown off in Iraq, less taxpayer money will be needed to treat them in the future. That, alone, could account for a quarter of the remaining savings we need to find.

So, that's my version of this plan. We'd recreate the Clinton-era picture largely through a process of tax hikes, de-militarization, and then just natural improvements that would occur as a result of the economy continuing to grow, and our military restraint meaning less cost bleed into other areas of the budget. What do you have in mind? Where would you find the savings?
 
Of that 6.1% drop in spending, as a share of GDP, a big chunk would come from the military. In 2000, we spent 16.5% of GDP on that. In 2012, 18.9%. So, that leaves us another 3.7% to find in the budget. If we were content with merely balancing the budget, though (as opposed to creating a record surplus like we had in 2000), we'd only need to find 1.3% of GDP in spending cuts.

So, where, specifically, should we look to find that last roughly $200 billion in spending cuts, to get us to a balanced budget with distribution roughly in line with what we had under Clinton? I don't know.

Well its not as hard as that. First off, DoD Expenditures have- according to CONSERVATIVE ECONOMISTS like Barro http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States have a Fiscal Multipler of 0.5. That compares to say civilian government infrastructure spending of 1.5 and as much as 4.0 for social safetynt programs.

Here's the other part. PRivate Sector MIDDLE CLASS fiscal multplier is around 1.5 (Upper quintile is about 0.7) .

So for every $1 you cut from Defense Spending and instead let MIDDLE CLASS earners spend that, you get AN EXTRA $! in GDP growth. And since the Fed takes 20% of each $1 of GDP growth, that means a 6.1% cut in Gov Spend that comes from DEFENSE will actually INCREASE gov' Revenues by about 1%.

So simply by cutting defense more than civillian sector spend, you get yourself down to a 0.3% GDP deficit.


Now a 0.3% GDP Deficit, requires a GDP growth of 1.5% (remember gov gets 20% of each 1% of growth) to be "parity". And today GDP is growing at 2% and if the recovery finally catches on that will go to 4% - but lets stay at 2%.

At 2% GDP growth, Government Revenues grow at 0.4% per year. So if your revenues are growing at 0.4% and your year one deficit is 0.3% -- then OVER TIME you "grow out" of the defict as it becomes an every smaller portion of GDP and Revenues.
 
I believe when we're talking about Romney's tax plan we are talking about Federal Income taxes. Romney has no control over what the states charge their citizens.

Payroll Taxes, according to the Dumbocrats are actually 'contributions' to your retirement fund and health insurance for retirement.

That's only true if you take Social Security and Medicare spending out of the budget discussion. Which you have not done, nor does the Ryan/Romney tax plan. So that means you have to include FICA in who pays what taxes.

And not everyone pays those. No income people don't pay any federal taxes
True, but that's not 50% of the population. That's more like 6% of the population.

and a lot of low income people get the earned income tax credit which completely offsets any payroll taxes+ gives them a nice welfare payment.
Again that's not relevant since arguably the wealthy get subsidies for their lifestyles from the cops etc. You can have a discussion about whether that is the right way to SPEND our tax dollars, but you cannot say that they are not paying taxes.

Yep. The great Democratic party, with their war on poverty. Urban renewal, Housing projects and the welfare state where the Democrats rule over large exports of corpses from our inner cities.
Um actually poverty was on its way down UNTIL REAGAN started cutting those programs.

Thats simply a statistical FACT

You may want to live in a 3rd world Welfare state. I don't.
There are no 3rd World "welfare states" - 3rd World states are charactarized invarialbly by SMALL GOVERNMENTS of LIMITED effect.

So YOU may want a government that "you can drag to the bathtub and drown" - but I look at a place like Somalia and that to me is a bad model.

OTOH I look at a place like Germany, or Finland or Denmark - where there are HIGHER TAXES, HIGHER SERVICES, HIGHER SAFTEY NET...

and which outgrew USA from 2002-2007 by 35% and I wonder why YOU don't want to grow at that rate?
 
Back
Top