connieb
Senator
No, of course not. But the historical record sure does support my own, personal experience. I saved money when dividends were treated as ordinary income. I save money now, when they aren’t. I don’t at all see how lowering the dividends tax rate was supposed to make me more eager to save. If anything, it could make me LESS eager to do so. My main purpose for saving is the desire to set myself up to have enough of an income stream to live off of comfortably, in retirement. If I have to factor in higher tax rates on dividends, interest, and capital gains, then I need to save more money to have the same after-tax income as if I can factor in a lower tax rate on dividends, interest, and capital gains. Right now, my savings rate is only as high as it is because I have a suspicion that dividends, interest, and capital gains taxes are likely to rise back up to more normal rates before I retire. If I could be convinced they’d definitely stay so low, I could cut back on saving while maintaining the same expected quality of life in retirement. So, for me, the relationship is the opposite of what the theory suggests it should be. Higher taxes on unearned income actually promote accumulation of wealth.
I will just say that after 15 years in financial services, that your approach is somewhat unique. Serious investors, and people who have intentions of growing and maximizing their wealth - approach it very differently. You are looking at this as retirement but when I say wealth building - I mean well beyond retirement.
Its not to have money to live off when you are no longer working but about bringing yourself into a whole other standard of living. And, there is a fair amount of speculation in that. And thus - people expect for that speculation - that they will reap a large reward - the tax ramifications of doing that then, and thus being taxed on a large percentage of that reward, definitely impacts how they save. But, I think the benefits of essentially offering the average person that opportunity and incentive to be somewhat speculative, results in people creating and having capital to use for new ventures as well as adjusting the mindset of the individual - so they approach saving with the idea of wealth building. And there are advantages of that to society. When people are focused on building wealth, and creating their own wealth and financial destiny it affects their spending, it prioritizes their spending and financial habits. They generate assets - which then they use on hard times, but most importantly they also develop habits to avoid the hard times.
It is difficult to describe well the stark difference between the financial health of a person who is working towards building his empire and the person who is just working and interested in having a comfortable life. But, if I had my preference, I would say everyone needs to focus on building wealth. Not saving for retirement but actually building wealth. Creating assets and utilizing those assets for more assets. And, I think that offering incentives like cheap tax rates - encourages people to do that. And, while they do help the rich stay rich, they also allow people who didn't start out rich, but who utilize the same principles to get rich - to then become rich themselves.
There is a very interesting book - Rich Dad, Poor Dad. I don't know if you have read it or not. But, the core focus is essentially, what does a Rich father have to offer to his children by way of looking at the world that a poor one does not, and how does lacking this financial understanding lock the poor child into the same subsistence/working class lifestyle from generation to generation. And, what is interesting is that your perspective, is very similar to the "poor dad". And, of course you are not poor but as a pretty well off individual - you have a very working class approach to finances. That is not a criticism. I fight the same battles with my husband. He has done very well for himself, and as a couple we do very well together, but he came from a decidedly working class background and his vision for what financial health and wealth are - is a decidedly working class - very conservative approach.
connie