New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Wealth over work

No, of course not. But the historical record sure does support my own, personal experience. I saved money when dividends were treated as ordinary income. I save money now, when they aren’t. I don’t at all see how lowering the dividends tax rate was supposed to make me more eager to save. If anything, it could make me LESS eager to do so. My main purpose for saving is the desire to set myself up to have enough of an income stream to live off of comfortably, in retirement. If I have to factor in higher tax rates on dividends, interest, and capital gains, then I need to save more money to have the same after-tax income as if I can factor in a lower tax rate on dividends, interest, and capital gains. Right now, my savings rate is only as high as it is because I have a suspicion that dividends, interest, and capital gains taxes are likely to rise back up to more normal rates before I retire. If I could be convinced they’d definitely stay so low, I could cut back on saving while maintaining the same expected quality of life in retirement. So, for me, the relationship is the opposite of what the theory suggests it should be. Higher taxes on unearned income actually promote accumulation of wealth.

I will just say that after 15 years in financial services, that your approach is somewhat unique. Serious investors, and people who have intentions of growing and maximizing their wealth - approach it very differently. You are looking at this as retirement but when I say wealth building - I mean well beyond retirement.

Its not to have money to live off when you are no longer working but about bringing yourself into a whole other standard of living. And, there is a fair amount of speculation in that. And thus - people expect for that speculation - that they will reap a large reward - the tax ramifications of doing that then, and thus being taxed on a large percentage of that reward, definitely impacts how they save. But, I think the benefits of essentially offering the average person that opportunity and incentive to be somewhat speculative, results in people creating and having capital to use for new ventures as well as adjusting the mindset of the individual - so they approach saving with the idea of wealth building. And there are advantages of that to society. When people are focused on building wealth, and creating their own wealth and financial destiny it affects their spending, it prioritizes their spending and financial habits. They generate assets - which then they use on hard times, but most importantly they also develop habits to avoid the hard times.

It is difficult to describe well the stark difference between the financial health of a person who is working towards building his empire and the person who is just working and interested in having a comfortable life. But, if I had my preference, I would say everyone needs to focus on building wealth. Not saving for retirement but actually building wealth. Creating assets and utilizing those assets for more assets. And, I think that offering incentives like cheap tax rates - encourages people to do that. And, while they do help the rich stay rich, they also allow people who didn't start out rich, but who utilize the same principles to get rich - to then become rich themselves.

There is a very interesting book - Rich Dad, Poor Dad. I don't know if you have read it or not. But, the core focus is essentially, what does a Rich father have to offer to his children by way of looking at the world that a poor one does not, and how does lacking this financial understanding lock the poor child into the same subsistence/working class lifestyle from generation to generation. And, what is interesting is that your perspective, is very similar to the "poor dad". And, of course you are not poor but as a pretty well off individual - you have a very working class approach to finances. That is not a criticism. I fight the same battles with my husband. He has done very well for himself, and as a couple we do very well together, but he came from a decidedly working class background and his vision for what financial health and wealth are - is a decidedly working class - very conservative approach.

connie
 
The point is that capital gains are subject to a lower rate than income actually earned by labor.

good so earn more money by investing it so you can have more and donate to the extra to charity then take that deduction...but here is the real point capital gains taxes are higher income taxes...for the poor...didn't think that one through now did ya...
 
There is a very interesting book - Rich Dad, Poor Dad. I don't know if you have read it or not. But, the core focus is essentially, what does a Rich father have to offer to his children by way of looking at the world that a poor one does not, and how does lacking this financial understanding lock the poor child into the same subsistence/working class lifestyle from generation to generation. And, what is interesting is that your perspective, is very similar to the "poor dad". And, of course you are not poor but as a pretty well off individual - you have a very working class approach to finances. That is not a criticism. I fight the same battles with my husband. He has done very well for himself, and as a couple we do very well together, but he came from a decidedly working class background and his vision for what financial health and wealth are - is a decidedly working class - very conservative approach.

connie

Unfortunately I only get to like it once.....I left out the rest of your excellent post because as a "Rich dad Poor dad" fan..Kiyosaki makes great points...the reason you are not wealthy is a choice in this country...Arkady doesnt know this because his wealth comes from his wife...she earns it.
 
Unfortunately I only get to like it once.....I left out the rest of your excellent post because as a "Rich dad Poor dad" fan..Kiyosaki makes great points...the reason you are not wealthy is a choice in this country...Arkady doesnt know this because his wealth comes from his wife...she earns it.

Why do you make such accusations?
 
How would my not wanting to give you money for nothing demonstrate that the money was earned?


In your case it wouldn't demonstrate anything...for real people who use money to live from...they use it to feed their families ect...so if they invest...for their retirement...ect it's makes a difference ...they wont give it away....but it makes a point if your money in the bank is unearned...and that is wrong ...just give it to me...but the fact that you dont shows that you do take ownership in that money...thus it is earned at some level in your mind.
 
it is not an accusation...if you actually read what arkady posts you would know he is wealthy but not by his actions...or just a liar

Believe me...I read Arkady's posts. He claims to be a lawyer...and his writings support that claim. You simply make unsupported accusations against him in every post. I merely asked why.

On the other hand, you make few claims...and your writings also support that.
 
But you actually did earn that money...it's not unearned money...you invested or deposited...and your actions per that agreement with the bank or investor determines how much you earn...that money did just get up on it's own and walk into the bank hop into an account...you would have had to make a conscious decision to put it into the bank and let the bank use that money and put it to woprk and you get paid for that.

My suggestion if you don't like how banks work or more in point for you...if you don't understand how they work...don't invest...but your action and choices earned you that income...just like someone's choice to take a job earns income.
Earned or unearned, it should be taxed. The question is why money I get for investments should be treated better, for tax purposes, than money I get for doing actual productive labor.
 
Why do you make such accusations?
Just to set the record straight, I earn about $200k per year, and my wife earns about $100k. So our earned income comes about 2/3 from me. We also have investment income of a few tens of thousands of dollars per year. Neither of us has ever inherited any wealth, though my wife had her college education covered by her parents (before we were together), which was effectively a $100,000 gift. I covered my education almost entirely with work and loans, though my parents co-signed on some of the loans (however, they didn't help repay them).
 
Earned or unearned, it should be taxed. The question is why money I get for investments should be treated better, for tax purposes, than money I get for doing actual productive labor.


what do you mean treated better? ...Income should be taxed and the govt should be smarter..they tax in a way that drives away good customers...see manufacturing...your assertions are based on the ones who pay most in taxes need to pay more and dont realize that while attacking capital gains it affect the poor..

You didnt think this through
 
Earned or unearned, it should be taxed. The question is why money I get for investments should be treated better, for tax purposes, than money I get for doing actual productive labor.

I have no trouble believing that.

I'm with you...it is obvious that the wealthy have set the game up for their benefit. I laugh at the usual objections, but none make me laugh harder than the "already been taxed" silliness.
 
This entire thread (with a few exceptions!) is just another example of people desperately trying to justify that which they no for certain, even as they really haven't a a clue as to why and how they know it for certain!

Recently, Congressman Dave Camp (R,MI) threw a tax reform proposal on the GOP House table, for consideration. Of course it was far from perfect, but at least sufficiently serious as to call for honest and good faith political consideration.

The GOP shouted Camp's (GOP) proposal down, almost before it even left the gate.
 
Serious investors, and people who have intentions of growing and maximizing their wealth - approach it very differently.

I guess it's semantic, but I consider myself a serious investor. My wife and I invest around $100k per year, and our total investment portfolios are pushing up close to $1 million. Our total net worth is already over $1 million and I'm only 40.

Mostly that's vanilla investing in mutual funds, ETFs, and company stock, so I'm not a "serious investor" in the sense of some hedge fund investor with an eight-figure portfolio, but I take investing seriously and am good enough at it to have beaten the S&P 500 in 12 of the last 14 years. But, for me, it's not about trying to maximize weath building. It's about trying to acheive specific goals. I want my daughter to be able to go to college without having to take on debt the way I did. I want to be able to retire before age 60, with enough of an investment income to travel. I want to be able to upgrade to a bigger house in a few years without a mortgage. I'm not trying to maximize some number for the abstract purpose of having a big number. I'm trying to have enough money to finance specific future spending. And the higher taxes are, the more I have to save and invest to do that.

And, I think that offering incentives like cheap tax rates - encourages people to do that.
How so? I don't feel any more drawn towards abstract wealth accumulation today than I did in, say, 2000, when tax rates were considerably higher. Do you? If so, why?

And, while they do help the rich stay rich, they also allow people who didn't start out rich, but who utilize the same principles to get rich - to then become rich themselves.

Many forms of wealth are zero sum games. There is a fixed amount of real estate, a finite amount of fossil fuels, etc. Something that makes it easier for a rich person to acquire and keep vast land holdings makes it harder for everyone else to acquire land, because it takes some of that land out of circulation. Even labor itself functions, to a limited extent, as zero-sum: if I hire someone to be my full-time gardener, that's labor that's not available to anyone else to do anything more productive. So, it's quite possible for something that helps the rich stay rich to also impoverish others. Nobody else is allowed to hunt in the king's forest, after all. That said, I understand some aspects of the economy are not zero sum, and for those, helping one person to accumulate wealth doesn't impoverish others. But the zero-sum aspects of the game are important to acknowledge.

Anyway, we have stats about which countries have the greatest income mobility -- stats that show in which countries those born near the bottom of the income structure have the most chance to rise to the top. Needless to say, the US, with its policies built around serving the rich, isn't one of them. And even if you check all the recommended boxes for getting ahead in this country -- getting a good education, working hard, avoiding drugs and alcohol, etc,. it can be very hard to make progress when he very fact of your hard work gets you taxed more than someone with the same income who gets it passively, by way of an investment portfolio or inheritance.

you have a very working class approach to finances
I had a working class upbringing. My parents had no money other than what they earned through their own hard labor. No doubt they instilled those values in me, too. That, to me, is a noble thing. I have slight regard for those who live off the labor of others, whether it's an able-bodied person who chooses to sit around and collect welfare, or an able-bodied person who chooses to sit around and cash checks from the trust fund his parents set up.
 
what do you mean treated better? ...Income should be taxed and the govt should be smarter..they tax in a way that drives away good customers...see manufacturing...your assertions are based on the ones who pay most in taxes need to pay more and dont realize that while attacking capital gains it affect the poor..

You didnt think this through
What I mean is that currently capital gains are taxed at rate much lower than wages and other earned income, at least for higher earners. Right now, if a rich person earns an additional dollar of wealth as a salary, for doing actual productive labor, he pays 42.5% (income tax plus Medicare tax). If he gets the same dollar as a long-term capital gain, he pays 20%. He's paying over twice as much, for the same income, if he actually worked for it, than if it was simply the result of the appreciation of an asset.
 
This entire thread (with a few exceptions!) is just another example of people desperately trying to justify that which they no for certain, even as they really haven't a a clue as to why and how they know it for certain!

Recently, Congressman Dave Camp (R,MI) threw a tax reform proposal on the GOP House table, for consideration. Of course it was far from perfect, but at least sufficiently serious as to call for honest and good faith political consideration.

The GOP shouted Camp's (GOP) proposal down, almost before it even left the gate.
We've become so partisan that even non-partisan reforms become partisan the moment they're suggested. There's all sorts of non-partisan simplification and rationalizing that could be done in the tax code, but these days people just can't work together even on that neutral territory.
 
In your case it wouldn't demonstrate anything...for real people who use money to live from...they use it to feed their families ect...so if they invest...for their retirement...ect it's makes a difference ...they wont give it away....but it makes a point if your money in the bank is unearned...and that is wrong ...just give it to me...but the fact that you dont shows that you do take ownership in that money...thus it is earned at some level in your mind.
My ownership of money is unconnected with whether I earned it. If some eccentric millionaire dies and leaves me a fortune because he closed his eyes and picked my name out of a phone book, that money is mine, but that doesn't mean I earned it. What makes you think ownership proves that something was earned?
 
You said wealth was equal to the product of savings and production. If you don't like the $1million example, try another. My company produces $1 million of value, of which is saves $100,000. Now, according to your formula, that’s $100 BILLION of wealth.
.

How is that?

You PRODUCE $1M in value and SAVE $100k, your wealth is $100k.

If you MULTIPLY times 12 months, you have created $1.2M in wealth through production x savings.
 
Last edited:
My ownership of money is unconnected with whether I earned it. If some eccentric millionaire dies and leaves me a fortune because he closed his eyes and picked my name out of a phone book, that money is mine, but that doesn't mean I earned it. What makes you think ownership proves that something was earned?

The thing that gets me to laughing when these "conservatives" chime in on tax issues, is just how obsessed they are with issues of "fairness" as opposed to efficiency. Why shouldn't a zillionare's kid be able to inherent his zillions without paying taxes on it?.....Well.....because it wouldn't be "fair" for him to have to pay taxes.

But...I think they do this without even realizing what they're doing.
 
If that is true, why do we pay taxes on our interest income? And what about the many corporations that don't pay any tax on their income, in fact, many actually get money from the Government?
That is why everybody should pay a flat 15% Federal income tax. It is the fairest way to get around loop holes for big business and make sure all voters have skin in the game. It is unjust to hold 49% hostage and liable for the 47% of filers who don't pay into the system.
 
I guess it's semantic, but I consider myself a serious investor. My wife and I invest around $100k per year, and our total investment portfolios are pushing up close to $1 million. Our total net worth is already over $1 million and I'm only 40.

Mostly that's vanilla investing in mutual funds, ETFs, and company stock, so I'm not a "serious investor" in the sense of some hedge fund investor with an eight-figure portfolio, but I take investing seriously and am good enough at it to have beaten the S&P 500 in 12 of the last 14 years. But, for me, it's not about trying to maximize weath building. It's about trying to acheive specific goals. I want my daughter to be able to go to college without having to take on debt the way I did. I want to be able to retire before age 60, with enough of an investment income to travel. I want to be able to upgrade to a bigger house in a few years without a mortgage. I'm not trying to maximize some number for the abstract purpose of having a big number. I'm trying to have enough money to finance specific future spending. And the higher taxes are, the more I have to save and invest to do that.


How so? I don't feel any more drawn towards abstract wealth accumulation today than I did in, say, 2000, when tax rates were considerably higher. Do you? If so, why?



Many forms of wealth are zero sum games. There is a fixed amount of real estate, a finite amount of fossil fuels, etc. Something that makes it easier for a rich person to acquire and keep vast land holdings makes it harder for everyone else to acquire land, because it takes some of that land out of circulation. Even labor itself functions, to a limited extent, as zero-sum: if I hire someone to be my full-time gardener, that's labor that's not available to anyone else to do anything more productive. So, it's quite possible for something that helps the rich stay rich to also impoverish others. Nobody else is allowed to hunt in the king's forest, after all. That said, I understand some aspects of the economy are not zero sum, and for those, helping one person to accumulate wealth doesn't impoverish others. But the zero-sum aspects of the game are important to acknowledge.

Anyway, we have stats about which countries have the greatest income mobility -- stats that show in which countries those born near the bottom of the income structure have the most chance to rise to the top. Needless to say, the US, with its policies built around serving the rich, isn't one of them. And even if you check all the recommended boxes for getting ahead in this country -- getting a good education, working hard, avoiding drugs and alcohol, etc,. it can be very hard to make progress when he very fact of your hard work gets you taxed more than someone with the same income who gets it passively, by way of an investment portfolio or inheritance.


I had a working class upbringing. My parents had no money other than what they earned through their own hard labor. No doubt they instilled those values in me, too. That, to me, is a noble thing. I have slight regard for those who live off the labor of others, whether it's an able-bodied person who chooses to sit around and collect welfare, or an able-bodied person who chooses to sit around and cash checks from the trust fund his parents set up.

I do not believe wealth building is a zero sum game. Yes, on the surface land held by some means its not available to all adn causes a temporary shortage, but the economy and the world is always in flux, and it is not as if anything is ever permanently removed from the market.

Additionally, being a serious investor has more do to do with your approach to investing, and less about the actual dollars you have invested. You can be a serious investor on $10,00 if that 10K is material to your overall net worth and you are approaching your investements with the intent to grow them.

I do certainly feel more drawn to wealth building when the relative tax rates are low. And, so are others. For one thing - stocks - are only one of the vehicles which deliver capital gains tax rates. Real estate and other assets purchased for investment purposes are also subject to capital gains. So, if you are focusing your attention only to stocks and not other capital assets you are missing a lot of the big picture. But, going back to a change in behavior, back when there was an extra huge tax credit for going out and investing in equipment and machinery - it was wildly popular with small to midsized businesses. and many clients went out and purchased machinery for their business because they could write the whole thing off in one year, instead of over time. And, that equipment is a capital asset - that is an aspect of wealth building. But, I completely agree with your point that you do not get the same type of change of focus in investing when you are only thinking of investing as stocks and bonds.

Again - back to the stats.... Arkady, the stats mean nothing without understanding the underlying sociological factors. Yes, it is difficult - wealthbuidling wise to go from the lowest to the highest in America. But, a large part of that is relative to our social safetynet which puts limits on the wealth you can have and still be eligible for benefits. So, if having money in teh bank disqualfies you from benefits and services you need - you are not going to try to keep any money in the bank. A simple comparison without acknowledging and adjusting for constraints like that - is meaningless. Even among middle class people the discouragements to wealth build are built into the system - for instance, you will likely qualify for less student aid for your kids if you are sitting on some net worth. But, does the average person want to liquidate their net worth to send their kid to school? Of course not, so then they are ither encouraged to save for the college alone - as opposed to building wealth, or they are not encouraged to build ti. Same with collecting SS - your SS is not necessarily taxable. But, if you you exceed a certain amount of AGI - your SS becomes taxable for income tax purposes. So, the incentives to not build wealth for many - are more appealing right now than building wealth.

As far as the working class attitude - you are essentially saying that what you support as economic policy has something to do with your own personal biases. In general, I don't think that makes good policy. I think good policy is based on what will encourage the most people to accumulate what they can and take the strain off of public resources. It being "right" or moral - has nothing to do with it.

connie
 
Back
Top