New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Welfare Shaming?

connieb

Senator
Well, this Mayor would like to see it happen.

http://www.wgme.com/news/features/t...s-welfare-recipients-29251.shtml#.VgVdMNJVikp

I'll be honest, I don't know why they allow the amount of a person's pension to be posted online. That sounds ike quite the invasion. And, I will say this does too.

However, I know that people used to feel ashamed of using public benefits so they did not. Which kept those on the rolls down and made sure for the most part that only the most desperate used them. Now though with no social stigma it seems everyone who is "struggling" and may not be otherwise starving - use them. I have had a person tell me that they use them because it does raise their quality of life. Personally as a tax payer, I believe people should have clothes, warm places to sleep and food in their bellies... but freeing up room in your budget so you can live like you are "middle class" on my dime, isn't what I am willing to pay for. However, I am not willing to invade osmeone's privacy to get that done, even though I think that if people who were using benefits to give their budgets more wiggle room felt ashamed for doing so they would be less inclined to do so.
 
I'm torn on this one. I do know abuse is out there (on welfare benefits) but respect the rule of privacy (prefer to see we maintain that in our society). Overall, at times we've become pretty mean spirited (this includes me) and desensitized to these things and it's a concerning trend.
 
I work for a non-profit and we're forced to list our salaries in our 990 IRS filing and post it on our web site. I think posting what you get from the government is fair game in such an environment. And yes, that would include government salaries too...
 
I'm torn on this one. I do know abuse is out there (on welfare benefits) but respect the rule of privacy (prefer to see we maintain that in our society). Overall, at times we've become pretty mean spirited (this includes me) and desensitized to these things and it's a concerning trend.

I remember very vividly a class in college. It was a weekend class - so even though I was only 20 - most of the class were working adults trying to improve their careers. One woman in the class was on welfare and taking classes there via subisidies. She brought this up in discussions many times. She was also - just a rather annoying personality. Many of the other women in the class though - were taking these classes at night and on weekends on their own dimes while trying to work full -time jobs and raise families.

So, I don't remember how it came up but I distinctly remember her saying something about going to the movies basically because she had food stamps she could afford to take her kids to the movies. And, she was saying it in from the perspective of - see how this has benefited me - to have this. And, one of the other ladies, late 20's full time worker, two young kids, a husband that worked nights etc... said - Woman - I don't pay taxes and your food stamps and bust my ass here to get farther in my career - so you can gloat about going to the damn movies. I don't take my family to the movies because its expensive and we need that money in our budget for essentials - that YOU get paid by other people.

And, the conversation went on and on with welfare lady defending how even if you were poor you needed entertainment, etc and pretty much the rest of the class being pissed off at her and not buying it.

Being only 20 and not really too much of a taxpayer at the time, I had never really thought about it from that perspective. But, I agreed with worker lady. In the end I am happy to make sure people have essentials. But, I don't agree with paying for their essentials, so that they can take what money they do have, and pay for something they want.

connie
 
If government salaries are public record, why not welfare benefits? Shame can be a great motivator. Of course, the problem we run into is that many people, especially leftists, are shameless.
 
I remember very vividly a class in college. It was a weekend class - so even though I was only 20 - most of the class were working adults trying to improve their careers. One woman in the class was on welfare and taking classes there via subisidies. She brought this up in discussions many times. She was also - just a rather annoying personality. Many of the other women in the class though - were taking these classes at night and on weekends on their own dimes while trying to work full -time jobs and raise families.

So, I don't remember how it came up but I distinctly remember her saying something about going to the movies basically because she had food stamps she could afford to take her kids to the movies. And, she was saying it in from the perspective of - see how this has benefited me - to have this. And, one of the other ladies, late 20's full time worker, two young kids, a husband that worked nights etc... said - Woman - I don't pay taxes and your food stamps and bust my ass here to get farther in my career - so you can gloat about going to the damn movies. I don't take my family to the movies because its expensive and we need that money in our budget for essentials - that YOU get paid by other people.

And, the conversation went on and on with welfare lady defending how even if you were poor you needed entertainment, etc and pretty much the rest of the class being pissed off at her and not buying it.

Being only 20 and not really too much of a taxpayer at the time, I had never really thought about it from that perspective. But, I agreed with worker lady. In the end I am happy to make sure people have essentials. But, I don't agree with paying for their essentials, so that they can take what money they do have, and pay for something they want.

connie


I agree on the misuse. I just wonder how far we should go into peoples private lives to shame or even destroy them (as activists tend to do to folks they do not like or have taken a stand against them/bakeries, etc.)?

It happens...
 
I work for a non-profit and we're forced to list our salaries in our 990 IRS filing and post it on our web site. I think posting what you get from the government is fair game in such an environment. And yes, that would include government salaries too...

I guess that's fair. I've never been on welfare, but I know people who have (are) and the ones I know sure don't like being on it and got off as fast as possible. I also know there are generations of people who are gaming the system (I'm from the New Orleans area) and it's bad.

Like I said, I'm torn on this because once it starts, where will it end?
 
I agree on the misuse. I just wonder how far we should go into peoples private lives to shame or even destroy them (as activists tend to do to folks they do not like or have taken a stand against them/bakeries, etc.)?

It happens...

Well, I have spoken out quite a bit about the way this trend of public shaming on social media has really taken off. People calling for others to lose their jobs for things that happen in their personal lives, etc. I have a REAL problem with that kind of behavior, so I am not really into the whole public shaming thing.

On the other hand, I can see the other side, where if they disclose other recipients of Gov't money - why not this, as well. But, I can see that stuff being misused so that is concerning.
 
Well, I have spoken out quite a bit about the way this trend of public shaming on social media has really taken off. People calling for others to lose their jobs for things that happen in their personal lives, etc. I have a REAL problem with that kind of behavior, so I am not really into the whole public shaming thing.

On the other hand, I can see the other side, where if they disclose other recipients of Gov't money - why not this, as well. But, I can see that stuff being misused so that is concerning.

Yep... agreed.
 
Rosebud (Wiki Citizen Kane)


Rich kids should be ashamed of living off an allowance in college. In general, they should be ashamed of the fact that their Daddies set them up their whole life with unearned money, positions, connections, and social influence. They have nothing of their own. They accomplished nothing on their own, including what they did after being set up in a position from where they could seem to do the rest on their own. Honest people would shame both the moochers on the bottom and those unjustly set above us.
 
In related news, left wing groups are claiming terms like taxpayer and citizen are demeaning to welfare recipients and illegal aliens.
 
Well, this Mayor would like to see it happen.

http://www.wgme.com/news/features/t...s-welfare-recipients-29251.shtml#.VgVdMNJVikp

I'll be honest, I don't know why they allow the amount of a person's pension to be posted online. That sounds ike quite the invasion. And, I will say this does too.

However, I know that people used to feel ashamed of using public benefits so they did not. Which kept those on the rolls down and made sure for the most part that only the most desperate used them. Now though with no social stigma it seems everyone who is "struggling" and may not be otherwise starving - use them. I have had a person tell me that they use them because it does raise their quality of life. Personally as a tax payer, I believe people should have clothes, warm places to sleep and food in their bellies... but freeing up room in your budget so you can live like you are "middle class" on my dime, isn't what I am willing to pay for. However, I am not willing to invade osmeone's privacy to get that done, even though I think that if people who were using benefits to give their budgets more wiggle room felt ashamed for doing so they would be less inclined to do so.


why it's posted...It's not the individuals money to lefty it's what they allow the pensioner to have...being so generous!
 
Rosebud (Wiki Citizen Kane)


Rich kids should be ashamed of living off an allowance in college. In general, they should be ashamed of the fact that their Daddies set them up their whole life with unearned money, positions, connections, and social influence. They have nothing of their own. They accomplished nothing on their own, including what they did after being set up in a position from where they could seem to do the rest on their own. Honest people would shame both the moochers on the bottom and those unjustly set above us.


Ok sage of main street....why?..who theF*ck are you to tell someone what to do with their money...oh because you segregated them as rich???? Hahahahaha real funny...how about I decide what you can do with your money.....maybe what they are doing...as you put it...well lets look further:

Daddies set them up their whole life with unearned money, positions, connections, and social influence.


What are you saying women aren't capable of doing this?
...because you just did. Why not include women in your post?....btw are you talking about the House the Clintons(Bill) bought for Chelsea?...5mil...and what has she done?

Maybe if more people did this it would create hundreds of thousands of job openings that wont need to be filled by these people rather those who really need to work...ever thought of that...before you went on your hate rant?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top